Navy SEAL killed young prisoner and called him "ISIS dirtbag," witnesses testify

/ AP

Navy SEAL released pending trial

San Diego—A decorated Navy SEAL suddenly plunged a knife into the neck of a wounded young Islamic State prisoner, killing him, and later scoffed that he was "just an ISIS dirtbag," former comrades testified at a war crimes trial.

Dylan Dille and Craig Miller took the stand Wednesday at the San Diego court-martial of Special Operations Chief Edward Gallagher, who has pleaded not guilty to murder and attempted murder stemming from his 2017 tour of duty in Iraq.

More former SEALs were expected to testify on Thursday in a case that has drawn the attention of President Donald Trump and revealed a rare rift in the typically tight-knit elite special forces. Testifying on the second day of trial, Dille said when a radio call announced the prisoner was wounded on May 3, 2017, Gallagher replied: "Don't touch him, he's all mine."

Navy Special Operations Chief Edward Gallagher hugs his wife, Andrea Gallagher, after leaving a military courtroom on Naval Base San Diego on May 30, 2019; the decorated Navy SEAL is facing a murder trial in the death of an ISIS prisoner was freed from custody after a military judge cited interference by prosecutors Julie Watson / AP

The captive was on the hood of a Humvee fading in an out of consciousness with only a minor leg wound visible when Iraqi forces delivered him to a SEAL compound in Mosul. Dille said he was not the grizzled warrior he expected to find.

Trending News

"He looked about 12 years old," Dille said. "He had a wrist watch around his bicep. He was rail thin."

Gallagher, a trained medic, began treating the boy's injuries. When he applied pressure to his leg wound, the boy shot up in pain.

Miller, a then-Special Warfare Operator 1st Class who has since been promoted to chief, said he put his foot on the boy's chest to keep him down. Miller briefly stepped away and said when he returned he saw Gallagher unexpectedly plunge a knife twice into the boy's neck "right here on the right side in the jugular vein," he said tapping the spot above the collar of his dress whites.

Blood spurted out and another SEAL jumped back and grabbed his medical bag, Miller said. Defense lawyers say Gallagher treated the prisoner for a collapsed lung suffered in a blast from an air strike. He made an incision in his throat to insert a tube to clear the airway.

They claim that disgruntled sailors fabricated the murder accusations because he was a demanding platoon leader and they didn't want him promoted. Miller said he immediately reported the stabbing to an officer, but didn't pursue a more formal complaint until months after returning from deployment.

He acknowledged he never took photos of the enemy's wounds or tried to document the incident. No corpse was ever recovered, no autopsy was performed and no forensic evidence was gathered.

Navy SEAL Murder Case
This undated selfie provided by Andrea Gallagher shows her husband, U.S. Navy SEAL Edward Gallagher, who has been charged with allegedly killing an Islamic State prisoner in his care and attempted murder for the shootings of two Iraq civilians in 2017. Edward Gallagher / AP

Miller struggled with recalling details from that day. He didn't remember the platoon flying a drone over the dead body — not even after seeing video in court that showed him smiling nearby. After the boy died, Gallagher's re-enlistment ceremony was conducted next to the corpse. Miller and other troops were in photos of the event.

Later that day, Dille said Gallagher confronted him and other senior enlisted men and said he knew they were upset with what happened.

"This was just an ISIS dirtbag," Dille said Gallagher told the group.

Defense lawyer Tim Parlatore questioned why Dille never confronted Gallagher or reported him to superiors until after deployment. Parlatore also accused Dille, Miller and other officers who discussed concerns about Gallagher in a chat room of coordinating a campaign to oust Gallagher.

"My truth is watertight, Mr. Parlatore," Dille said.

Dille also said that he also believed Gallagher had fired at Iraqi civilians from a sniper's position several times, including an instance on June 18, 2017, when an old man was shot by the Tigris River. Dille was also a sniper and was near Gallagher during the shootings but didn't see him pull the trigger.

After hearing a gunshot coming from Gallagher's position and seeing the old man fall, Dille said he looked through his scope and saw the man bleeding through his white clothing. He said Gallagher then radioed that he thought he had missed the old man.

Defense lawyer Marc Mukasey objected to the testimony, saying descriptions of the alleged shootings were "wildly vague."

Gallagher, who served eight tours of duty and earned two Bronze Stars for valor, was in the courtroom in his dress uniform with a chest full of medals. His wife, parents and brother also attended. His family has lobbied intensely for his freedom, claiming he was being treated unfairly.

Congressional Republicans took up his cause and prevailed on Trump to release Gallagher from the brig into better conditions in a military hospital. Trump also is reportedly considering a pardon for Gallagher. A judge released Gallagher from custody last month after prosecutors violated his constitutional rights by tracking defense attorney emails in an effort to find who leaked court documents to reporters.

First published on June 20, 2019 / 10:22 AM

© 2019 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

APTOPIX Navy SEAL Murder Case Navy SEAL Murder Case

City pays $600,000 to hackers who seized its computer system

Cyberattack blocked 911 dispatchers from logging calls, as a growing number U.S. municipalities are taken hostage

7M ago

Witnesses: Navy SEAL killed prisoner, called him "ISIS dirtbag"

Gallagher has pleaded not guilty to murder and attempted murder stemming from his service in Iraq

8M ago

Workplace chat phenom Slack set to go public

"I'll Slack you" is a common phrase in a certain workplaces—and many are betting it'll become a dominant form of workplace collaboration

32M ago

Biden slams Trump's Iran policy as a "self-inflicted disaster"

"By walking away from diplomacy, Trump has made military conflict more likely. Another war in the Middle East is the last thing we need" Biden said.

52M ago

How to watch the 2019 NBA draft

On Thursday night the top college basketball players will be selected by NBA teams

1H ago

Biden slams Trump's Iran policy as a "self-inflicted disaster"

"By walking away from diplomacy, Trump has made military conflict more likely. Another war in the Middle East is the last thing we need" Biden said.

52M ago

Florida man arrested for slapping reporter's hand at Trump rally

Daniel Kestner is facing a battery charge for trying to slap the phone out of the hand of Orlando Sentinel reporter Michael Williams

3H ago

Homelessness crisis spurs recall effort against Los Angeles mayor

Figures released earlier this month showed a 16% jump in Los Angeles' homeless population over the last year, pegging it at 36,300

3H ago

Officer-involved shooting remains Buttigieg's biggest 2020 challenge

The shooting forces Buttigieg to navigate the dual roles of mayor and candidate at a critical time for both his campaign and the city

3H ago

Study: 1 out of 6 hospital trips result in "surprise" medical bills

A report by the Kaiser Family Foundation finds that millions with solid coverage from large employers are exposed to "out-of-network" charges that can amount to thousands

3H ago

Water runs out for millions in one of India's biggest cities

Reservoirs dry up after poor monsoon season, leaving residents, schools and businesses to tap dirty wells and pay for bottled water

9M ago

After David Ortiz mistakenly shot, alleged motive comes to light

Police say the alleged mastermind in the shooting is a fugitive in the U.S.

updated 42M ago

Biden slams Trump's Iran policy as a "self-inflicted disaster"

"By walking away from diplomacy, Trump has made military conflict more likely. Another war in the Middle East is the last thing we need" Biden said.

52M ago

Anger mounts as Hong Kong leader ignores protesters' ultimatum

Chinese-appointed Chief Executive Carrie Lam faces fresh groundswell of fury after ignoring demands to retract proposed extradition law

1H ago

Accused U.S. spy appeals to Trump as Russia denies his appeal

"Mr. President, we cannot keep America great unless we aggressively protect American citizens wherever they are," Paul Whelan says in Moscow court

2H ago

Unseen Freddie Mercury performance released

It was "recorded in a haze of late nights and fueled by 'fabulous food, vodka and Cristal Champagne,'" Mercury's friend said

1H ago

Highest-grossing movies of all time, ranked

What's the highest-grossing movie of all time? It might be one of your favorites

Jun 4 27 photos

Never-before-seen Freddie Mercury video

A never-before-seen video of Queen's longtime frontman, Freddie Mercury, was released overnight. The stripped-down version of the song "Time Waits For No One" was recorded in 1986.

updated 38M ago 01:27

Janet Mock makes history with Netflix deal

Mock said she hopes the accomplishment, "will be a huge signal boost, industrywide, to empower people and equip them to tell their own stories"

10H ago

Key piece of evidence missing in Kevin Spacey case

The young man and his parents "have searched all the places where such a phone may have been stored. They have not found the phone," said attorney

11H ago

City pays $600,000 to hackers who seized its computer system

Cyberattack blocked 911 dispatchers from logging calls, as a growing number U.S. municipalities are taken hostage

7M ago

Workplace chat phenom Slack set to go public

"I'll Slack you" is a common phrase in a certain workplaces—and many are betting it'll become a dominant form of workplace collaboration

32M ago

Bitcoin price hits 1-year high on boost from Facebook's Libra plan

Cryptocurrency enthusiasts see Facebook's move into digital money as "the catalyst everyone's been looking for"

Jun 19

Why Facebook is minting its own currency

Social media company, no stranger to controversy, is diving into the brave new world of virtual money

Jun 18

Google commits $1 billion to ease housing crisis in the Bay Area

CEO Sundar Pichai said the internet company will pave the way for 20,000 new homes in the region over the next decade

18H ago

Water runs out for millions in one of India's biggest cities

Reservoirs dry up after poor monsoon season, leaving residents, schools and businesses to tap dirty wells and pay for bottled water

9M ago

Spy satellites show glaciers losing ground to climate change

Declassified spy satellite photos lead scientists to some startling conclusions

20H ago

Hundreds of dead dolphins on Gulf Coast leave scientists perplexed

Almost 300 dead and dying dolphins have washed up on the shores of four Gulf Coast states – three times the usual number

Jun 19

Starving polar bear wanders into Siberian city looking for food

Hundreds of miles from where it should be hunting, emaciated bear seen poking around on industrial estate for food

Jun 19

Bear killed in Oregon after officials say it became too friendly

The bear had become "habituated" or accustomed to the area after people left food for it

Jun 18

Surprise medical bills: Congress aims to ease the pain

Millions of people, even those with solid coverage, can get hit with astronomical bills for out-of-network charges

1H ago

Study: 1 out of 6 hospital trips result in "surprise" medical bills

A report by the Kaiser Family Foundation finds that millions with solid coverage from large employers are exposed to "out-of-network" charges that can amount to thousands

3H ago

9/11 first responder who testified with Jon Stewart enters hospice

Retired NYPD detective Lou Alvarez tugged at hearts with his testimony on day before what was to be his 69th round of chemotherapy

3H ago

Driving while high: Offenders don't think they'll be arrested

AAA says in the last 30 days, almost 15 million drivers got behind the wheel within an hour of using marijuana

16H ago

Trump vows to cure cancer and eradicate AIDS

"We will push onward with new medical frontiers," President Trump said at his campaign kickoff rally

21H ago

City pays $600,000 to hackers who seized its computer system

Cyberattack blocked 911 dispatchers from logging calls, as a growing number U.S. municipalities are taken hostage

7M ago

Workplace chat phenom Slack set to go public

"I'll Slack you" is a common phrase in a certain workplaces—and many are betting it'll become a dominant form of workplace collaboration

32M ago

Surprise medical bills: Congress aims to ease the pain

Millions of people, even those with solid coverage, can get hit with astronomical bills for out-of-network charges

1H ago

Fed wary of economic clouds, but leaves rates unchanged

Central bank officials say the economic outlook is increasingly uncertain — and signal their readiness to cut rates

14H ago

Harassment allegations slide since Harvey Weinstein accused

The number of highly publicized accusations of sexual assault or misconduct is down sharply, "#MeToo Index" shows

15H ago

Witnesses: Navy SEAL killed prisoner, called him "ISIS dirtbag"

Gallagher has pleaded not guilty to murder and attempted murder stemming from his service in Iraq

8M ago

Inside the nationwide crime lab backlog

A growing backlog at crime labs nationwide is leaving victims waiting for justice. A recent government report found the backlog for DNA analysis increased almost 85 percent from 2011 through 2017. Mireya Villarreal reports.

1H ago 06:01

Father of murdered Alaska teen: "My daughter trusted these people"

Cynthia "Cee Cee" Hoffman was allegedly killed by a teen seeking a $9 million payment from an online stranger

2H ago

Father of murdered Alaska teen speaks out

An Alaska teenager is charged with murdering her best friend for a multimillion-dollar payday from a stranger she met online. Cynthia Hoffman was killed earlier this month. Police say a man posed online as a millionaire, then offered the suspect money to commit a murder and send him pictures of it. Jonathan Vigliotti reports.

1H ago 03:15

72 cops off duty over controversial posts

The Philadelphia Police Department has taken 72 officers off hte street because of social media posts described as racist, sexist, and violent. They were recently revealed by a watchdog group that reviewed thousands of posts from police officers around the country. Errol Barnett reports.

2H ago 02:53

NASA to land 1st woman on moon as part of Artemis mission

NASA's project aims to bring human beings back to the moon by 2024

Jun 16

NASA spots "Star Trek" Starfleet logo on Mars

Hopefully, it finds some aliens sporting Vulcan salutes next

Jun 14

Earth approaching "meteor swarm" eyed in past impact

Scientists hope to study the Taurid meteor shower closely, in hopes of better predicting the risk of a future impact

Jun 12

SpaceX launches 3 Earth-observation satellites

The three Radarsat satellites will monitor resources and the effects of climate change across Canada

Jun 12

Jupiter's largest moons visible with binoculars in June

NASA has a message for space lovers this month: Look up

Jun 11

Photographer Dave Engledow, the "World's Best Father"

He calls himself the "World's Best Father," and he's got the pictures of himself and his daughter, Alice, to prove it

Jun 16 16 photos

Forbes: World's top 20 billionaires

Forbes has updated their billionaires list, detailing the richest people around the world.

Jun 13 21 photos

Tony Awards 2019: Red carpet looks from your favorite stars

See Broadway stars walk the red carpet at Radio City Music Hall in New York City at the 73rd Annual Tony Awards

Jun 9 39 photos

Jayme Closs case: Recently released evidence photos

At Jake Patterson's sentencing hearing, prosecutors showed a select few evidence photos to the court and asked that Patterson be sentenced to life in prison for the murders of Jayme Closs' parents and the 13-year-old's kidnapping

Jun 8 14 photos

Summer music 2019

It's summertime – time for music at festivals and venues across the country

Jun 8 58 photos

Popular

Sneak peek: Defending DJ

Inside a family’s mission to restore their son’s reputation seven years after he was fatally shot by a police officer. CBS News special correspondent James Brown reports Saturday, June 22 at 10/9c on CBS.

19H ago 03:37

Abortion clinic license at stake

Missouri's last remaining abortion clinic, Planned Parenthood of St. Louis, says it will not comply with a new state requirement to conduct a second pelvic exam before an abortion. CBS News reporter Kate Smith joined CBSN with more on what's at stake.

updated 22M ago 04:54

Innovative program combines coding and dance

Our series, A More Perfect Union, aims to show that what unites us as Americans is far greater than what divides us. In this installment, we introduce you to a corporate executive who spends his Saturdays teaching technology with a twist. Jericka Duncan stopped by for a lesson.

updated 38M ago 05:14

How to get good sleep during long summer days

Friday is the Summer Solstice, the day we get more sunlight than any other day of the year. But all that light can throw off your circadian rhythm, which controls sleep patterns. Dr. Tara Narula joins "CBS This Morning" to discuss the best ways to make sure you're getting enough sleep each night.

updated 38M ago 04:39

Celebrating high school grads who enlist

It's high school graduation season, when many schools celebrate the colleges their students plan to attend. But some districts are also honoring graduates who decided to enlist in the military. Vladimir Duthiers has the story of a group that’s honored high schoolers heading into uniform for a decade.

updated 19M ago 02:56