Supreme Court upholds "Peace Cross" on public land in Maryland

/ AP

A World War I memorial in the shape of a 40-foot-tall cross can continue to stand on public land in Maryland, the Supreme Court ruled Thursday.

The justices, in ruling 7-2 in favor of the backers of the cross, concluded that the nearly 100-year-old memorial's presence on a grassy highway median doesn't violate the First Amendment's establishment clause, which prohibits the government from favoring one religion over others. Two liberal justices — Justices Stephen Breyer and Elena Kagan — joined the court's five conservatives.

FILE: BLADENSBURG, MARYLAND – FEBRUARY 28: A 40-foot cross that honors 49 fallen World War I soldiers from Prince George's County stands at the busy intersection of Bladensberg and Annapolis roads and Baltimore Avenue February 28, 2019 in Bladensburg, Maryland. / Getty Images

The case had been closely watched because it involves the place of religious symbols in public life. Defenders of the cross, erected in 1925, in Bladensburg had argued that a ruling against them could doom of hundreds of war memorials that use crosses to commemorate soldiers who died.

Trending News

"The cross is undoubtedly a Christian symbol, but that fact should not blind us to everything else that the Bladensburg Cross has come to represent," Justice Samuel Alito wrote.

"For some, that monument is a symbolic resting place for ancestors who never returned home. For others, it is a place for the community to gather and honor all veterans and their sacrifices to our Nation. For others still, it is a historical landmark. For many of these people, destroying or defacing the Cross that has stood undisturbed for nearly a century would not be neutral and would not further the ideals of respect and tolerance embodied in the First Amendment. For all these reasons, the Cross does not offend the Constitution," he wrote.

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Justice Sonia Sotomayor dissented.

The cross' challengers included three area residents and the District of Columbia-based American Humanist Association, which includes atheists and agnostics. They argued that the cross, in a suburb near the nation's capital, should be moved to private property or modified into a nonreligious monument such as a slab or obelisk.

Defenders included the American Legion, which raised money to build the monument honoring area residents who died in World War I. Other backers included the Trump administration and Maryland officials who took over maintenance of the cross nearly 60 years ago to preserve it and address traffic safety concerns.

Maryland officials had argued that the cross, sometimes called the "Peace Cross," doesn't violate the Constitution because it has a secular purpose and meaning.

In the past, similar monuments have met with a mixed fate at the high court.

On the same day in 2005, for example, the court upheld a Ten Commandments monument on the grounds of the Texas Capitol while striking down Ten Commandments displays in Kentucky courthouses.

First published on June 20, 2019 / 10:54 AM

© 2019 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Constitutionality Of Memorial Cross For WWI Military Fallen  In Maryland Debated

Supreme Court upholds cross on public land in Maryland

The court concluded that the nearly 100-year-old memorial's presence doesn't violate the First Amendment's establishment clause

6M ago

How to watch USA vs. Sweden in Women's World Cup

The American Women's National Team looks for its third win in a row at the tournament

21M ago

Nancy Pelosi speaks to reporters amid escalating tensions with Iran

U.S. officials say Iran shot down an American spy drone over international waters over the Strait of Hormuz

updated 3M ago

Oil prices surge after Iran shoots down American spy drone

Rising friction between the U.S. and Iran is driving up the cost of crude around the world

28M ago

City pays $600,000 to hackers who seized its computer system

Cyberattack blocked 911 dispatchers from logging calls, as a growing number U.S. municipalities are taken hostage

37M ago

Supreme Court upholds cross on public land in Maryland

The court concluded that the nearly 100-year-old memorial's presence doesn't violate the First Amendment's establishment clause

6M ago

Nancy Pelosi speaks to reporters amid escalating tensions with Iran

U.S. officials say Iran shot down an American spy drone over international waters over the Strait of Hormuz

updated 3M ago

Biden slams Trump's Iran policy as a "self-inflicted disaster"

"By walking away from diplomacy, Trump has made military conflict more likely. Another war in the Middle East is the last thing we need" Biden said.

1H ago

Florida man arrested for slapping reporter's hand at Trump rally

Daniel Kestner is facing a battery charge for trying to slap the phone out of the hand of Orlando Sentinel reporter Michael Williams

3H ago

Homelessness crisis spurs recall effort against Los Angeles mayor

Figures released earlier this month showed a 16% jump in Los Angeles' homeless population over the last year, pegging it at 36,300

3H ago

Water runs out for millions in one of India's biggest cities

Reservoirs dry up after poor monsoon season, leaving residents, schools and businesses to tap dirty wells and pay for bottled water

updated 23M ago

After David Ortiz mistakenly shot, alleged motive comes to light

Police say the alleged mastermind in the shooting is a fugitive in the U.S.

1H ago

Biden slams Trump's Iran policy as a "self-inflicted disaster"

"By walking away from diplomacy, Trump has made military conflict more likely. Another war in the Middle East is the last thing we need" Biden said.

1H ago

Anger mounts as Hong Kong leader ignores protesters' ultimatum

Chinese-appointed Chief Executive Carrie Lam faces fresh groundswell of fury after ignoring demands to retract proposed extradition law

1H ago

Accused U.S. spy appeals to Trump as Russia denies his appeal

"Mr. President, we cannot keep America great unless we aggressively protect American citizens wherever they are," Paul Whelan says in Moscow court

2H ago

Unseen Freddie Mercury performance released

It was "recorded in a haze of late nights and fueled by 'fabulous food, vodka and Cristal Champagne,'" Mercury's friend said

2H ago

Highest-grossing movies of all time, ranked

What's the highest-grossing movie of all time? It might be one of your favorites

Jun 4 27 photos

Never-before-seen Freddie Mercury video

A never-before-seen video of Queen's longtime frontman, Freddie Mercury, was released overnight. The stripped-down version of the song "Time Waits For No One" was recorded in 1986.

1H ago 01:27

Janet Mock makes history with Netflix deal

Mock said she hopes the accomplishment, "will be a huge signal boost, industrywide, to empower people and equip them to tell their own stories"

10H ago

Key piece of evidence missing in Kevin Spacey case

The young man and his parents "have searched all the places where such a phone may have been stored. They have not found the phone," said attorney

11H ago

City pays $600,000 to hackers who seized its computer system

Cyberattack blocked 911 dispatchers from logging calls, as a growing number U.S. municipalities are taken hostage

37M ago

Workplace chat phenom Slack set to go public

"I'll Slack you" is a common phrase in a certain workplaces—and many are betting it'll become a dominant form of workplace collaboration

1H ago

Bitcoin price hits 1-year high on boost from Facebook's Libra plan

Cryptocurrency enthusiasts see Facebook's move into digital money as "the catalyst everyone's been looking for"

Jun 19

Why Facebook is minting its own currency

Social media company, no stranger to controversy, is diving into the brave new world of virtual money

Jun 18

Google commits $1 billion to ease housing crisis in the Bay Area

CEO Sundar Pichai said the internet company will pave the way for 20,000 new homes in the region over the next decade

19H ago

Water runs out for millions in one of India's biggest cities

Reservoirs dry up after poor monsoon season, leaving residents, schools and businesses to tap dirty wells and pay for bottled water

updated 23M ago

Spy satellites show glaciers losing ground to climate change

Declassified spy satellite photos lead scientists to some startling conclusions

20H ago

Hundreds of dead dolphins on Gulf Coast leave scientists perplexed

Almost 300 dead and dying dolphins have washed up on the shores of four Gulf Coast states – three times the usual number

Jun 19

Starving polar bear wanders into Siberian city looking for food

Hundreds of miles from where it should be hunting, emaciated bear seen poking around on industrial estate for food

Jun 19

Bear killed in Oregon after officials say it became too friendly

The bear had become "habituated" or accustomed to the area after people left food for it

Jun 18

Surprise medical bills: Congress aims to ease the pain

Millions of people, even those with solid coverage, can get hit with astronomical bills for out-of-network charges

1H ago

Study: 1 out of 6 hospital trips result in "surprise" medical bills

A report by the Kaiser Family Foundation finds that millions with solid coverage from large employers are exposed to "out-of-network" charges that can amount to thousands

4H ago

9/11 first responder who testified with Jon Stewart enters hospice

Retired NYPD detective Lou Alvarez tugged at hearts with his testimony on day before what was to be his 69th round of chemotherapy

4H ago

Driving while high: Offenders don't think they'll be arrested

AAA says in the last 30 days, almost 15 million drivers got behind the wheel within an hour of using marijuana

17H ago

Trump vows to cure cancer and eradicate AIDS

"We will push onward with new medical frontiers," President Trump said at his campaign kickoff rally

21H ago

Oil prices surge after Iran shoots down American spy drone

Rising friction between the U.S. and Iran is driving up the cost of crude around the world

28M ago

City pays $600,000 to hackers who seized its computer system

Cyberattack blocked 911 dispatchers from logging calls, as a growing number U.S. municipalities are taken hostage

37M ago

Workplace chat phenom Slack set to go public

"I'll Slack you" is a common phrase in a certain workplaces—and many are betting it'll become a dominant form of workplace collaboration

1H ago

Surprise medical bills: Congress aims to ease the pain

Millions of people, even those with solid coverage, can get hit with astronomical bills for out-of-network charges

1H ago

Fed wary of economic clouds, but leaves rates unchanged

Central bank officials say the economic outlook is increasingly uncertain — and signal their readiness to cut rates

14H ago

Witnesses: Navy SEAL killed prisoner, called him "ISIS dirtbag"

Gallagher has pleaded not guilty to murder and attempted murder stemming from his service in Iraq

38M ago

Inside the nationwide crime lab backlog

A growing backlog at crime labs nationwide is leaving victims waiting for justice. A recent government report found the backlog for DNA analysis increased almost 85 percent from 2011 through 2017. Mireya Villarreal reports.

2H ago 06:01

Father of murdered Alaska teen: "My daughter trusted these people"

Cynthia "Cee Cee" Hoffman was allegedly killed by a teen seeking a $9 million payment from an online stranger

3H ago

Father of murdered Alaska teen speaks out

An Alaska teenager is charged with murdering her best friend for a multimillion-dollar payday from a stranger she met online. Cynthia Hoffman was killed earlier this month. Police say a man posed online as a millionaire, then offered the suspect money to commit a murder and send him pictures of it. Jonathan Vigliotti reports.

2H ago 03:15

72 cops off duty over controversial posts

The Philadelphia Police Department has taken 72 officers off hte street because of social media posts described as racist, sexist, and violent. They were recently revealed by a watchdog group that reviewed thousands of posts from police officers around the country. Errol Barnett reports.

2H ago 02:53

NASA to land 1st woman on moon as part of Artemis mission

NASA's project aims to bring human beings back to the moon by 2024

Jun 16

NASA spots "Star Trek" Starfleet logo on Mars

Hopefully, it finds some aliens sporting Vulcan salutes next

Jun 14

Earth approaching "meteor swarm" eyed in past impact

Scientists hope to study the Taurid meteor shower closely, in hopes of better predicting the risk of a future impact

Jun 12

SpaceX launches 3 Earth-observation satellites

The three Radarsat satellites will monitor resources and the effects of climate change across Canada

Jun 12

Jupiter's largest moons visible with binoculars in June

NASA has a message for space lovers this month: Look up

Jun 11

Photographer Dave Engledow, the "World's Best Father"

He calls himself the "World's Best Father," and he's got the pictures of himself and his daughter, Alice, to prove it

Jun 16 16 photos

Forbes: World's top 20 billionaires

Forbes has updated their billionaires list, detailing the richest people around the world.

Jun 13 21 photos

Tony Awards 2019: Red carpet looks from your favorite stars

See Broadway stars walk the red carpet at Radio City Music Hall in New York City at the 73rd Annual Tony Awards

Jun 9 39 photos

Jayme Closs case: Recently released evidence photos

At Jake Patterson's sentencing hearing, prosecutors showed a select few evidence photos to the court and asked that Patterson be sentenced to life in prison for the murders of Jayme Closs' parents and the 13-year-old's kidnapping

Jun 8 14 photos

Summer music 2019

It's summertime – time for music at festivals and venues across the country

Jun 8 58 photos

Popular

Sneak peek: Defending DJ

Inside a family’s mission to restore their son’s reputation seven years after he was fatally shot by a police officer. CBS News special correspondent James Brown reports Saturday, June 22 at 10/9c on CBS.

20H ago 03:37

Retailers roll out rainbow merch for Pride

The value of the LGBTQ market is not lost on businesses trying to win over consumers during Pride Month.

updated 18M ago 01:15

Is Trump really "draining the swamp"?

President Trump promises he will "drain the swamp" if he's reelected, but many of his appointees have lobbying or corporate ties. CBS News White House reporter Kathryn Watson joined CBSN to discuss the president's promise.

updated 17M ago 06:36

Missouri abortion clinic license at stake

Missouri's last remaining abortion clinic, Planned Parenthood of St. Louis, says it will not comply with a new state requirement to conduct a second pelvic exam before an abortion. CBS News reporter Kate Smith joined CBSN with more on what's at stake.

updated 23M ago 04:54

Biden's segregationist senators controversy

Ahead of Congressman Jim Clyburn's "World Famous Fish Fry" in South Carolina, former Vice President Joe Biden's comments on his past working relationship with segregationist senators is dominating the conversation among 2020 candidates. CBSN political reporter Caitlin Huey-Burns joined CBSN with the latest.

updated 10M ago 06:20