U.N. warns of global "groundswell" of hate speech

By Pamela Falk

/ CBS News

United Nations – Introducing a new "Action Plan" to combat hate speech, U.N. Secretary General Antonio Guterres warned Tuesday that the world is in danger of forgetting the lessons of the Holocaust. And he blamed the leaders of certain democracies as well as dictatorships for fueling the spread of hate speech around the world.

"In both liberal democracies and authoritarian regimes, some political leaders are bringing the hate-fueled ideas and language of these groups into the mainstream, normalizing them, coarsening the public discourse and weakening the social fabric," Guterres said.

Asked by CBS News to specify which countries' leaders he was referring to, he replied, "Some political leaders are, to a certain extent, mainstreaming what has been until now particularly the expression of extremist groups." Pressed on which ones, he would only say with a smile, "We have seen it in some recent electoral campaigns."

Trending News

Asked about it again during his press availability, Guterres said it was a "strategy" not to call any country out by name. Rather, he said he wanted to keep the focus on the substance of the issue.

U.N. Secretary General Antonio Guterres LISI NIESNER / REUTERS

"My objective today is not to name or shame any individual because unfortunately we are dealing with something that has spread … and we are facing a massive phenomenon."

The focus of the event, which also featured Under Secretary General Adama Dieng, special envoy for the prevention of genocide, was the resurgence of and spread of hate speech today.

The U.N. chief said that while hate speech has been around for a long time, it is now amplified by social media. He lamented what he called a "groundswell" of "xenophobia, racism and intolerance, violent misogyny, and also anti-Semitism and anti-Muslim hatred" in countries around the world.

"When the [U.N.] Charter was drafted," Guterres said, "the world had just witnessed genocide on an industrial scale. Hate speech had sown the seeds, building on millennia of scapegoating and discrimination against the Jews, and culminating in the Holocaust."

"Seventy-five years on," he said, "we are in danger of forgetting this lesson."

Over the years, he said, "hate speech has been a precursor to atrocity crimes, including genocide, from Rwanda to Bosnia to Cambodia."

Fighting hate speech at the U.N. and online

Dieng said the U.N.'s Action Plan aims to tackle hate speech from its root causes to its impact, and to develop "counter-narratives." He said the plan "never calls for restrictions of freedom of expression and opinion to address hate speech."

The European Union's U.N. Ambassador João Vale de Almeida told diplomats gathered: "Hate speech is spreading in all our societies and constitutes a threat to open, pluralist and democratic societies. "

He said the E.U. has enacted legislation to protect victims of crime and has a range of policy actions, including a "Code of Conduct" on countering illegal hate speech online, devised together with Facebook, Microsoft, Google (which owns YouTube), and Twitter, put into place in May 2016.

Some U.S. lawmakers believe that the U.S. is lagging behind, struggling with the debate over free speech, while countries like New Zealand and Great Britain are responding to extremist propaganda and misinformation online by imposing stricter regulations on big tech companies.

At the U.N. Tuesday, Courtney Nemroff, the Trump administration's deputy U.S. representative to the Economic and Social Council of the U.N., said, "The United States strongly agrees that the Plan of Action should not endorse limitations on freedom of speech, and that more speech, not less, is needed," adding that in the U.S. "our experience has taught us that speech restrictions do not work."

Nemroff also said, "Our strong belief in freedom of expression does not mean that we sit idly by as individuals and groups seek to spread toxic expressions of hatred," and added that all individuals should speak out against hate speech.

In March, less than two weeks after a white supremacist live-streamed his deadly attack on worshipers at two New Zealand mosques, Facebook announced that it was broadening its definition of banned hate speech and taking action against white nationalism and white separatism.

Facebook sets restrictions on livestreaming following deadly New Zealand attacks

But many critics have faulted big tech companies for not acting more aggressively to curtail the spread of extremist content on their platforms.

The U.N. Action Plan

U.N. Secretary General Guterres said the Action Plan aims to:

The U.N. chief was clear on the goal, if not precisely how it would be executed. "Hate speech is in itself an attack on tolerance, inclusion, diversity and the very essence of our human rights norms and principles," and "undermines social cohesion, erodes shared values, and can lay the foundation for violence," Guterres said.

First published on June 18, 2019 / 4:15 PM

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Pamela Falk

Pamela Falk is CBS News Foreign Affairs Analyst and an international lawyer, based at the United Nations.

R20 Austrian World Summit

U.N. warns of global "groundswell" of hate speech

U.N. Secretary General Antonio Guterres says the world is in danger of forgetting the lessons of the Holocaust

15M ago

White House knew of Shanahan domestic incident for months, officials say

Shanahan's expected nomination to become defense secretary was on track "even of this morning," an administration official told CBS News

34M ago

Former XFL star "He Hate Me" reported missing

Rod Smart's family is worried about his safety and well-being and the Lancaster County are investigating

49M ago

Why Facebook is minting its own currency

Social media company, no stranger to controversy, is diving into the brave new world of virtual money

51M ago

N.J. man found dead in Dominican hotel amid spate of mystery deaths

Joseph Allen's family says the 55-year-old traveled to the Dominican Republic frequently and was in good health

56M ago

White House knew of Shanahan domestic incident for months, officials say

Shanahan's expected nomination to become defense secretary was on track "even of this morning," an administration official told CBS News

34M ago

How Trump is doing on his original campaign promises

President Trump has had more than two years to realize his campaign promises. So, how is he doing?

1H ago

Gillibrand urges Congress to limit funds for migrant children shelters

Lawmakers are currently negotiating new funding for the agency which takes care of migrant children in U.S. custody

2H ago

Shanahan out as defense chief after reports of domestic incidents

Shanahan faced scrutiny over several domestic incidents involving members of his family several years ago

updated 49M ago

Trump: Millions in U.S. illegally to be deported starting next week

Tweets were posted on eve of formal announcement of re-election bid expected to have immigration as a central theme

3H ago

U.N. warns of global "groundswell" of hate speech

U.N. Secretary General Antonio Guterres says the world is in danger of forgetting the lessons of the Holocaust

15M ago

N.J. man found dead in Dominican hotel amid spate of mystery deaths

Joseph Allen's family says the 55-year-old traveled to the Dominican Republic frequently and was in good health

56M ago

Former European soccer boss detained amid World Cup probe

French police investigating whether corruption played a role in the stunning decision to award Qatar hosting duty for the 2022 World Cup

1H ago

Boeing announces first 737 Max deal since deadly crashes

International Airlines Group (IAG), the parent company of British Airways and other carriers, signed a letter of intent for 200 Boeing 737 aircraft

1H ago

Trump: Millions in U.S. illegally to be deported starting next week

Tweets were posted on eve of formal announcement of re-election bid expected to have immigration as a central theme

3H ago

Ruth Bader Ginsburg earns MTV Movie & TV Award

RBG had some tough competition in the category — including Serena Williams

3H ago

Highest-grossing movies of all time, ranked

What's the highest-grossing movie of all time? It might be one of your favorites

Jun 4 27 photos

How to be successful in an automated world

It's estimated in the next 15 to 20 years, 32 percent of jobs are likely to change significantly due to automation. Fourteen percent could be completely automated. Right now, 60 percent of adults do not have the right skills for emerging jobs. New York Times senior economic correspondent Neil Irwin has a new book called " How to Win in a Winner?Take?All World." He joins "CBS This Morning" with advice for how to succeed in this new economy.

6H ago 05:03

Remembering Gloria Vanderbilt

Friends and fans are saluting heiress, socialite and fashion pioneer Gloria Vanderbilt. She died Monday of advanced stomach cancer. Vanderbilt was 95, and had been well-known for nearly all of those years. Her son, Anderson Cooper, called her "an extraordinary woman who lived life on her own terms." Anthony Mason reports.

8H ago 02:56

Remembering Gloria Vanderbilt

Gloria Vanderbilt, the heiress and designer, has died at age 95. Vanderbilt's extraordinary life has been in the spotlight since she was a child. Maurice DuBois takes a look back at Vanderbilt's life and career.

20H ago 01:52

Why Facebook is minting its own currency

Social media company, no stranger to controversy, is diving into the brave new world of virtual money

51M ago

Google commits $1 billion to ease housing crisis in the Bay Area

CEO Sundar Pichai said the internet company will pave the way for 20,000 new homes in the region over the next decade

1H ago

Meet Facebook's Libra, a digital currency for the social network

The company is partnering with big names like Visa, Mastercard, Uber and Spotify to create a new global cryptocurrency

7H ago

U.S. continues battle against ex-CIA software engineer tied to WikiLeaks

Joshua Adam Schulte was indicted on 13 counts in 2018, including the illegal transmission of lawfully possessed national defense information as well as three charges related to child pornography

18H ago

Elon Musk says he's "deleted" his Twitter account

Musk's account is still listed as active, however, and he changed his display name to "Daddy DotCom" on Father's Day

Jun 17

Bear killed in Oregon after officials say it became too friendly

The bear had become "habituated" or accustomed to the area after people left food for it

5H ago

Sled dogs slog through meltwater on Greenland ice sheet

"Challenging conditions" for researchers collecting instruments used to measure sea ice brought on by "very warm conditions" in the Arctic

updated 48M ago

Why Stonehenge "waste material" may be "Holy Grail" for geologists

No one really knows how or why Stonehenge was created — but this cylinder of rock could provide some answers

1H ago

Warming waters may be changing shark migration patterns

An 8-year-old boy was bit by a shark in the third attack this season along the North Carolina coast

21H ago

Facebook and Tesla accused of hiding climate change risks

Investment group say hundreds of big companies are falling short when it comes to disclosing their environmental impact

20H ago

Study: Obesity rate falling for preschoolers who receive food aid

Obesity rates dropped steadily to about 14% in 2016 — the latest data available — from 16% in 2010, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reported

3H ago

Flesh-eating bacteria increasing on East Coast

The dangerous bacteria can infect wounds in your skin – and even the seafood you eat

6H ago

She had an abortion before Roe v. Wade. Now she's speaking out

"I felt so cheated, because I felt like I didn't have the opportunity, because it was illegal, to really think about how I was feeling about it," Carla Nordstrom told CBS News

16H ago

Pillsbury flour among recalled brands in multistate E. coli outbreak

Action by owner Hometown Food action involves about 4,620 cases of product tied to Archer Daniels Midland mill in Buffalo, New York

Jun 17

Study: Cosmetic products send kids to E.R. every 2 hours

The study was conducted by the Center for Injury Research at Nationwide Children's Hospital

Jun 17

Why Facebook is minting its own currency

Social media company, no stranger to controversy, is diving into the brave new world of virtual money

51M ago

Google commits $1 billion to ease housing crisis in the Bay Area

CEO Sundar Pichai said the internet company will pave the way for 20,000 new homes in the region over the next decade

1H ago

Boeing announces first 737 Max deal since deadly crashes

International Airlines Group (IAG), the parent company of British Airways and other carriers, signed a letter of intent for 200 Boeing 737 aircraft

1H ago

How to get married without breaking the bank

Last year, couples spent an average of nearly $34,000 tying the knot

2H ago

Child support payments vary wildly from state to state

Moving from Massachusetts to Vermont could lessen your monthly child support payment from $1,187 to $519

3H ago

Former European soccer boss detained amid World Cup probe

French police investigating whether corruption played a role in the stunning decision to award Qatar hosting duty for the 2022 World Cup

1H ago

16.5 tons of cocaine seized in massive drug bust

The drug bust is the largest in history in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, with a street value of more than $1 billion

updated 5M ago

Florida cop convicted of lesser charge in controversial shooting

Jonathan Aledda said he thought white autistic man had gun, his shot hit man's black caretaker, and video sparked uproar

9H ago

Man tries to smuggle 34 birds into U.S. in carry-on luggage

U.S. Attorney's office said Francis Gurahoo, 39, was traveling into the United States from Guyana on Sunday

16H ago

Man who shared New Zealand shooting video sentenced to 21 months

Philip Arps had earlier pleaded guilty to two counts of distributing the video of the massacre at a mosque in Christchurch

16H ago

NASA to land 1st woman on moon as part of Artemis mission

NASA's project aims to bring human beings back to the moon by 2024

Jun 16

NASA spots "Star Trek" Starfleet logo on Mars

Hopefully, it finds some aliens sporting Vulcan salutes next

Jun 14

Earth approaching "meteor swarm" eyed in past impact

Scientists hope to study the Taurid meteor shower closely, in hopes of better predicting the risk of a future impact

Jun 12

SpaceX launches 3 Earth-observation satellites

The three Radarsat satellites will monitor resources and the effects of climate change across Canada

Jun 12

Jupiter's largest moons visible with binoculars in June

NASA has a message for space lovers this month: Look up

Jun 11

Photographer Dave Engledow, the "World's Best Father"

He calls himself the "World's Best Father," and he's got the pictures of himself and his daughter, Alice, to prove it

Jun 16 16 photos

Forbes: World's top 20 billionaires

Forbes has updated their billionaires list, detailing the richest people around the world.

Jun 13 21 photos

Tony Awards 2019: Red carpet looks from your favorite stars

See Broadway stars walk the red carpet at Radio City Music Hall in New York City at the 73rd Annual Tony Awards

Jun 9 39 photos

Jayme Closs case: Recently released evidence photos

At Jake Patterson's sentencing hearing, prosecutors showed a select few evidence photos to the court and asked that Patterson be sentenced to life in prison for the murders of Jayme Closs' parents and the 13-year-old's kidnapping

Jun 8 14 photos

Summer music 2019

It's summertime – time for music at festivals and venues across the country

Jun 8 58 photos

Popular

Shanahan withdraws Defense Secy. nomination

Acting Defense Secretary Patrick Shanahan is withdrawing from the confirmation process after accusations of domestic violence by his ex-wife. Secretary of the Army Mark Esper will be taking his place. This comes as the Pentagon also announced it will be sending 1,000 more troops to the Middle East. CBS News national security correspondent David Martin joined CBSN with more.

updated 42M ago 10:31

Facebook unveils Libra cryptocurrency

Facebook is jumping into the cryptocurrency market. The company unveiled a new digital currency called Libra on Tuesday. It will be used on a blockchain-based system called Calibra, which will oversee security of users' financial data. CBS News contributor and Wired editor-in-chief Nicholas Thompson joins CBSN with details.

1H ago 04:07

Elaine Welteroth on memoir "More Than Enough"

Elaine Welteroth sat down with CBSN's Vladimir Duthiers to discuss her new book "More Than Enough."

2H ago 02:35

Pompeo on Iran: "President Trump does not want war"

Secretary of State Mike Pompeo spoke to reporters after the Trump administration announced 1,000 additional troops to the Middle East.

1H ago 08:02

Sandy Hook parent wins defamation lawsuit

The father of child killed in the massacre at Sandy Hook elementary school has won a defamation lawsuit. Lenny Pozner, whose 6-year-old son Noah died in the shooting, successfully sued the publishers of a book claiming the 2012 shooting didn't happen. Vladimir Duthiers has more.

1H ago 00:17