Justice Department says Congress can't force IRS to provide Trump's tax returns

By Grace Segers

/ CBS News

DOJ backs keeping Trump's tax returns secret

The Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel released a memo Friday supporting the Treasury Department's position that Congress is not entitled to see President Trump's tax returns. Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin refused to comply with a House subpoena for Mr. Trump's federal tax returns in May, saying members of Congress did not have a "legitimate purpose" to review the returns.

The House Ways and Means Committee issued the subpoena for the president's tax returns to Mnuchin and IRS Commissioner Charles Rettig last Friday after Mnuchin denied the committee's initial request. Ways and Means Chairman Richard Neal says the committee is entitled to the returns under section 6103(f) of the IRS code, in order to conduct oversight and determine whether the IRS is enforcing laws.

Mnuchin argued that Congress doesn't have a "legitimate legislative purpose" in requesting the president's private tax information, and in its memo Friday the Office of Legal Counsel agreed.

Trending News

"Under the facts and circumstances, the Secretary of the Treasury reasonably and correctly concluded that the Committee's asserted interest in reviewing the Internal Revenue Service's audits of presidential returns was pretextual and that its true aim was to make the President's tax returns public, which is not a legitimate legislative purpose," the Office of Legal Counsel said in the memo.

Democrats in Congress have argued that viewing Mr. Trump's tax returns has legitimate legislative purpose in that it would reveal the financial dealings of the president and potential ethical issues. Neal threatened to sue the Treasury Department for refusing to respond to the subpoena.

However, while members of Congress may face an uphill battle in obtaining Mr. Trump's federal tax returns, they could have more luck with his New York state tax returns. The New York state legislature passed a measure in May to allow the leaders of the U.S. House Ways and Means Committee, the Senate Finance Committee or the Joint Committee on Taxation to access any New York state tax returns filed by elected officials and top appointed officials.

Paula Reid contributed to this report.

First published on June 14, 2019 / 5:48 PM

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Grace Segers

Grace Segers is a politics reporter for CBS News Digital.

DOJ says Congress can't force IRS to provide Trump's tax returns

The Justice Department says Congress does not have a "legitimate legislative purpose" for viewing the president's tax returns

17M ago

Italian director Franco Zeffirelli dies at 96

Zeffirelli died in Rome on Saturday, his son said

36M ago

Valedictorian rips school staff in graduation speech

"To my counselor, thank you for letting me fend for myself – you were always unavailable," Nataly Buhr said

1H ago

1 dead, 2 injured in shooting at Costco in California

The gunfire sent shoppers racing for the exits and ducking for cover

1H ago

The Dish: Chef Priya Krishna reveals her signature recipes

Including orange peel fish, and a drink she calls "Indian gatorade"

2H ago

DOJ says Congress can't force IRS to provide Trump's tax returns

The Justice Department says Congress does not have a "legitimate legislative purpose" for viewing the president's tax returns

17M ago

Hong Kong suspends controversial bill that sparked massive protests

Carrie Lam, Hong Kong's chief executive, said the government was backing down on the bill

2H ago

Ahead of World Elder Abuse Awareness Day, Feds take action

Government says "Grandparents Scheme" targeted at least 10 senior citizens and robbed them of at least $158,800

15H ago

The latest from the CBS News Election & Survey Unit

A recap of latest polls and data-driven studies from the CBS News Election & Survey Unit

17H ago

Ivanka Trump made $4 million from D.C. Trump Hotel last year

The first daughter's now-defunct clothing line also raked in more than $1 million in income, the White House disclosed

18H ago

Italian director Franco Zeffirelli dies at 96

Zeffirelli died in Rome on Saturday, his son said

36M ago

Hong Kong suspends controversial bill that sparked massive protests

Carrie Lam, Hong Kong's chief executive, said the government was backing down on the bill

2H ago

40,000-year-old wolf's head found in Siberia permafrost

Ice Age beast was between the ages of 2 and 4 when it died and was preserved in the permafrost

18H ago

U.S. intel: Iran tried to pick up crews from tankers

Crew of a merchant ship that came to the rescue of one of the attacked tankers said he "felt like he had no choice but to comply with Iranian demands"

18H ago

U.N. says Ebola outbreak still not a global emergency

Ebola outbreak has killed more than 1,400 people since it was declared in August, making it the second-deadliest in history

20H ago

Italian director Franco Zeffirelli dies at 96

Zeffirelli died in Rome on Saturday, his son said

36M ago

Highest-grossing movies of all time, ranked

What's the highest-grossing movie of all time? It might be one of your favorites

Jun 4 27 photos

Mavis Staples performs "We Get By"

Soul and gospel legend Mavis Staples has already won multiple Grammys. But she's not resting on her laurels: she's taking on tribute concerts, a tour, and a brand new album. Staples performs three songs off the new album, "We Get By."

1H ago 03:58

Mavis Staples performs "Change"

Soul and gospel legend Mavis Staples has already won multiple Grammys. But she's not resting on her laurels: she's taking on tribute concerts, a tour, and a brand new album. Staples performs three songs off the new album, "We Get By."

1H ago 03:19

Mavis Staples on singing at 80

Soul and gospel legend and multiple Grammy winner Mavis Staples is a member of the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame, and a Kennedy Center honoree. She’ll also be turning 80 next month. The Newport Folk Festival organized all-star birthday tributes in Nashville, Los Angeles, and at the Apollo Theater in New York, where she spoke with CBS’ Anthony Mason.

updated 58M ago 05:43

From deepfake to "cheap fake," it's hard to tell what's real online

Cybersecurity experts are concerned that because AI has never been cheaper or easier to use, deepfake videos will be deployed by a diverse set of hackers during the 2020 election

Jun 13

Instagram outage affected its homepage and mobile app

The photo and video sharing social media platform outage hit those on the East and West coasts Thursday

Jun 13

Bitcoin emits as much carbon as Las Vegas, researchers say

Computers that mine and process bitcoins use vast amounts of energy, troubling climate experts

Jun 13

House holds hearing on "deepfakes" and artificial intelligence

Lawmakers are concerned "deepfakes​" and other types of AI-generated synthetic data pose a threat to the U.S. election system

Jun 13

Robocall revenge: Meet the techies turning the tables on scammers

In a video that's received more than 2 million views, a man who calls himself "Jim Browning" infiltrates scammers in India

Jun 13

40,000-year-old wolf's head found in Siberia permafrost

Ice Age beast was between the ages of 2 and 4 when it died and was preserved in the permafrost

18H ago

Number of dolphin deaths triple in Gulf of Mexico

NOAA scientists say 98% of the dolphins that stranded themselves along the Gulf Coast have died

19H ago

NASA spots "Star Trek" Starfleet logo on Mars

Hopefully, it finds some aliens sporting Vulcan salutes next

20H ago

Nature up close: Wildlife and the story behind "Taco Bell's Cannon"

Judy Lehmberg explains how a misunderstanding by this classical musical newbie relates to imagery of animals on an unspoiled Earth

Jun 13

Earth approaching "meteor swarm" eyed in past impact

Scientists hope to study the Taurid meteor shower closely, in hopes of better predicting the risk of a future impact

Jun 12

Patients skipping prescriptions as prices rise

When Maryanne Perry lost her health insurance coverage, she discovered a $50 copay would jump to $1,000 a month

15H ago

King Arthur flour recall in multistate E. coli outbreak

The action involves more than 14,000 cases made by Archer Daniels Midland and sold by retailers including Walmart

18H ago

U.N. says Ebola outbreak still not a global emergency

Ebola outbreak has killed more than 1,400 people since it was declared in August, making it the second-deadliest in history

20H ago

Doctor risked career to protect moms and babies

Dr. Judy Robinson told "Whistleblower" she'd rather lose her job than look the other way

22H ago

Physician exposes dangerous practice involving high-risk pregnancies

An OB-GYN blew the whistle to protect mothers and their newborns — did profits come before the safety of patients?

Jun 14

Ivanka Trump made $4 million from D.C. Trump Hotel last year

The first daughter's now-defunct clothing line also raked in more than $1 million in income, the White House disclosed

18H ago

PetSmart's Chewy soars 59% in IPO

The online retailer has never turned a profit, but it's counting on Americans spending more money on their pets

18H ago

King Arthur flour recall in multistate E. coli outbreak

The action involves more than 14,000 cases made by Archer Daniels Midland and sold by retailers including Walmart

18H ago

Thousands of airline food workers to vote on strike threat

Union behind 11,000 caterers who service flights for American, Delta and United airlines is threatening job walkouts

19H ago

The U.S. minimum wage sets a record — for not rising

Despite a 10-year economic expansion and an 18% rise in the cost of living, the U.S. base pay hasn't budged since 2009

Jun 14

1 dead, 2 injured in shooting at Costco in California

The gunfire sent shoppers racing for the exits and ducking for cover

1H ago

Arkansas woman arrested in homicide of former state senator

Police have not yet said how former state Senator Linda Collins-Smith died

12H ago

Another American dies at Dominican resort

Another American has died at a resort in the Dominican Republic. According to family, Leyla Cox went on vacation to celebrate her birthday. Mola Lenghi has the latest.

12H ago 02:58

Five guilty of murder in mistaken identity slaying of Bronx teen

Lesandro "Junior" Guzman-Feliz was seen on video being dragged out of a store and attacked with knives

17H ago

Man arrested in 1986 slaying of girl walking home from school

Marc Karun's neighbors in Maine described his behavior as bizarre and say they aren't surprised by his arrest in the cold case

18H ago

NASA spots "Star Trek" Starfleet logo on Mars

Hopefully, it finds some aliens sporting Vulcan salutes next

20H ago

Earth approaching "meteor swarm" eyed in past impact

Scientists hope to study the Taurid meteor shower closely, in hopes of better predicting the risk of a future impact

Jun 12

SpaceX launches 3 Earth-observation satellites

The three Radarsat satellites will monitor resources and the effects of climate change across Canada

Jun 12

Jupiter's largest moons visible with binoculars in June

NASA has a message for space lovers this month: Look up

Jun 11

Unknown mass larger than Hawaii discovered on moon

Scientist think it could be leftover metal from a previous asteroid strike

Jun 11

Forbes: World's top 20 billionaires

Forbes has updated their billionaires list, detailing the richest people around the world.

Jun 13 21 photos

Tony Awards 2019: Red carpet looks from your favorite stars

See Broadway stars walk the red carpet at Radio City Music Hall in New York City at the 73rd Annual Tony Awards

Jun 9 39 photos

Jayme Closs case: Recently released evidence photos

At Jake Patterson's sentencing hearing, prosecutors showed a select few evidence photos to the court and asked that Patterson be sentenced to life in prison for the murders of Jayme Closs' parents and the 13-year-old's kidnapping

Jun 8 14 photos

Summer music 2019

It's summertime – time for music at festivals and venues across the country

Jun 8 42 photos

11 photos of former NICU babies show how far they've come

These babies proudly hold photos of their former selves to celebrate their amazing progress since graduating from the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit

Jun 5 11 photos

Popular

Mavis Staples performs "We Get By"

Soul and gospel legend Mavis Staples has already won multiple Grammys. But she's not resting on her laurels: she's taking on tribute concerts, a tour, and a brand new album. Staples performs three songs off the new album, "We Get By."

1H ago 03:58

Anthony Mason leaves "CTM Saturday"

"CBS This Morning Saturday" says goodbye to Anthony Mason, co-host of the broadcast, with a review of some of his best interviews. Mason will still appear during the week on "CBS This Morning"

updated 27M ago 05:39

Mavis Staples performs "Change"

Soul and gospel legend Mavis Staples has already won multiple Grammys. But she's not resting on her laurels: she's taking on tribute concerts, a tour, and a brand new album. Staples performs three songs off the new album, "We Get By."

1H ago 03:19

Mavis Staples on singing at 80

Soul and gospel legend and multiple Grammy winner Mavis Staples is a member of the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame, and a Kennedy Center honoree. She’ll also be turning 80 next month. The Newport Folk Festival organized all-star birthday tributes in Nashville, Los Angeles, and at the Apollo Theater in New York, where she spoke with CBS’ Anthony Mason.

updated 58M ago 05:43

Priya Krishna reveals her signature recipes

Priya Krishna was born and raised in Dallas, and loved the foods her mother prepared: traditional Indian recipes, but with a modern American twist. After becoming a food writer for major magazines and newspapers, Krishna decided to share these unique creations in her new cookbook, "Indian-ish: Recipes and Antics from a Modern American Family." The book has been named one of the best cookbooks of spring by The New York Times, Food and Wine, and other publications.

updated 58M ago 06:06