LGBT advocates fear Brett Kavanaugh's votes on gay-rights issues

/ AP

Kavanaugh's confirmation process

Gay-rights supporters who thronged the Supreme Court plaza after justices declared same-sex marriage a constitutional right expect to have little to celebrate if Brett Kavanaugh replaces Justice Anthony Kennedy, the author of all the court's major gay-rights rulings.

None of Kavanaugh's roughly 300 opinions as an appellate judge deals directly with LGBT issues, but his approach to judging leads some scholars and activists to believe he is unlikely to echo Kennedy's votes.

Still, they said Kavanaugh might be reluctant to overrule the landmark 2015 same-sex marriage decision, even if he might have voted against it in the first instance.

Trending News

While LGBT advocates sound alarms about Kavanaugh, opponents of same-sex marriage are applauding his nomination, though not necessarily focusing on its potential impact on gay rights.

The Family Research Council, a major Christian conservative advocacy group, lauded Kavanaugh's rulings on religious freedom and "long and praiseworthy history of judging as an originalist," a term that means interpreting the Constitution as it was understood when written. The council describes homosexuality as "unnatural" and "harmful."

The high court is likely to confront a range of LGBT issues, perhaps as early as the coming term. These could include President Donald Trump's ban on transgender people in the military and whether federal civil rights laws banning discrimination in the workplace and education cover sexual orientation and gender identity. The justices also might be asked to decide an issue they passed over last term: whether businesses can invoke religious objections to refuse service to gay people.

At Kavanaugh's 2006 confirmation hearing for his current post as an appellate judge — before the Supreme Court ruling that legalized same-sex marriage nationwide — he was asked whether he had a view on the definition of marriage and whether courts or legislatures should establish it. Kavanaugh didn't say, instead responding to a part of the question about judicial restraint.

"Throughout our history, we've seen that some of the worst moments in the Supreme Court history have been moments of judicial activism, where courts have imposed their own policy preferences" instead of interpreting the law, he said.

With sparse evidence about Kavanaugh's views on LGBT matters, observers are parsing his record for clues to how he might vote.

"I think there's very little mystery here about how he is likely to view those issues," said Shannon Minter of the National Center for Lesbian Rights. "He has an extremely conservative judicial record, and it's highly likely he would be a consistently negative vote on any issue affecting LGBT people."

Dale Carpenter, an expert on LGBT issues at Southern Methodist University, said he considers Kavanaugh a careful and thoughtful judge. "I don't think he is going to be a knee-jerk judge in any direction, and I don't think he is anti-LGBT," Carpenter said.

Carpenter said Kavanaugh also is "a judicial conservative and he's a textualist" who probably would be hesitant to expand the reach of civil rights laws, including protections barring workplace discrimination on the basis of sex, that do not specifically mention sexual orientation or gender identity. Federal appeals courts in Chicago and New York have recently ruled that bias against gay people is sex discrimination under Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act.

"He might see it as a very aggressive judicial decision to expand what have been seen to be the limits of Title VII protection, absent congressional action. But it's not unthinkable," Carpenter said.

Similarly, Kavanaugh's opinions and writings in favor of presidential authority suggest he could uphold Trump's ban on transgender people in the military, which has been blocked by lower courts, Carpenter said.

LGBT advocates point to two recent opinions Kavanaugh wrote on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit to highlight other concerns.

Last year, Kavanaugh dissented from a ruling that ultimately allowed a 17-year-old immigrant in federal custody to obtain an abortion.

If Kavanaugh were to form a court majority for overturning the landmark Roe v. Wade decision on abortion and the right to privacy, "that would have implications including on LGBTQ cases that were built upon that legal theory," said Sarah Warbelow, legal director of the Human Rights Campaign.

Sharon McGowan, legal director of Lambda Legal, noted that Kavanaugh's dissent said his colleagues were creating "a new right" for the teen. "That is a move that has historically been used whenever LGBT people are trying to access a right that has been accessed for other people," McGowan said.

Gay-rights advocates believe another Kavanaugh dissent — from a 2015 ruling against a challenge to the Affordable Care Act's requirements for contraceptive coverage — could signal how he might view arguments for religious exemptions from anti-discrimination laws. He said that requiring religious organizations to submit a form objecting to paying for the coverage "substantially burdened" the free exercise of religion.

"One of the primary battlegrounds for both LGBTQ rights and reproductive rights will be around religious exemptions, an area where we have already seen Judge Kavanaugh favor those seeking exceptions over those who are being denied services," GLAAD President Sarah Kate Ellis wrote in an email.

Kavanaugh subscribes to the view that courts should find in the Constitution rights that are not expressly mentioned only if they are rooted in history and tradition. This helps explain why Carpenter and other legal scholars believe Kavanaugh probably would not have been a vote for same-sex marriage on the Supreme Court.

But now that same-sex marriage is the law of the land, it probably is safe, said Douglas Kmiec, a Pepperdine University professor of constitutional law, who served in both Republican and Democratic administrations. "It would be extremely surprising if Judge Kavanaugh were to see the judiciary as capable of disavowing" Kennedy's opinion that is anchored in human dignity, Kmiec said.

Carpenter held out the prospect that Kavanaugh could surprise LGBT advocates.

"Judges are capable of surprising us. There was nothing in Kennedy's history to suggest he'd be anything like he was," he said.

First published on July 19, 2018 / 6:35 AM

© 2018 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Kroger recalls frozen berries over hepatitis A fears

Frozen fruit with freezer life of two years is recall target at nearly 2,800 stores after an FDA public health alert

7M ago

Anthony Bourdain's friends declare June 25 "Bourdain Day"

On what would've been his 63rd birthday, Anthony Bourdain's friends want fans to celebrate him

14M ago

Billy Porter's gown made from "Kinky Boots" curtain

"This is for female empowerment, that's a uterus," Porter said about the embellishment on the back of the dress

53M ago

JUUL pledges $7.5 million to research impact of e-cigarettes

E-cigarette use among teens has been called "an epidemic" by the FDA

1H ago

Abortion laws are "bad for business," nearly 200 CEOs say

Jack Dorsey and Diane von Furstenberg among chief executives saying reproductive equality needed for business growth

1H ago

Why former Defense Secretary Ash Carter wouldn't work for Trump

"It's not politics, it's personal conduct," Carter defended on "CBS This Morning" on Monday

3H ago

Trump threatens tariffs if Mexico deal falls through

"If for any reason the approval is not forthcoming, Tariffs will be reinstated!" Trump tweeted

2H ago

California clears way to provide health care to some immigrants

Low-income adults between the ages of 19 and 25 living in California illegally would be eligible for California's Medicaid program,

5H ago

Democrats descend on Iowa to take on Trump

Although there were so many Democratic candidates in Iowa that they couldn't avoid each other, the frontrunner in the state was not among them

12H ago

Senators hope to force vote on arms sales to Saudi Arabia

Senators have been introducing legislation aimed at blocking the sale of weapons to the kingdom, in opposition of the Trump administration's Saudi policy

16H ago

Outrage after investigative journalist beaten, detained in Russia

In a show of rare solidarity, Russia's three major newspapers put out nearly identical front pages to support detained journalist Ivan Golunov

4H ago

3 get life in prison for raping and murdering 8-year-old girl

Prosecutors plan to seek death penalty for three convicted men, including a police officer

1H ago

Video shows Red Sox icon David Ortiz being ambushed and shot

Police say Ortiz was shot at "nearly point-blank range" at nightclub; the gunman was captured and beaten

2H ago

Senators hope to force vote on arms sales to Saudi Arabia

Senators have been introducing legislation aimed at blocking the sale of weapons to the kingdom, in opposition of the Trump administration's Saudi policy

16H ago

Massive protests in Hong Kong over Chinese extradition bill

Hong Kong's Legislative Council plans to vote Wednesday on the bill

9H ago

Anthony Bourdain's friends declare June 25 "Bourdain Day"

On what would've been his 63rd birthday, Anthony Bourdain's friends want fans to celebrate him

14M ago

Highest-grossing movies of all time, ranked

What's the highest-grossing movie of all time? It might be one of your favorites

Jun 4 27 photos

Billy Porter's gown made from "Kinky Boots" curtain

"This is for female empowerment, that's a uterus," Porter said about the embellishment on the back of the dress

53M ago

Tonys 2019: "Hadestown" the big winner

Here's a full list of winners from the 73rd Annual Tony Awards

2H ago

"Handmaid's Tale" star Elisabeth Moss: "I'm not a dark person"

The actress and producer of the critically-acclaimed drama says the show's message is that women united are stronger and can affect change

3H ago

Leader of worker protests at Google quits, citing "retaliation"

YouTube marketing manager departs after a dozen years with Google, citing "public flogging, shunning and stress"

Jun 7

NASA to allow private astronauts on space station

NASA's plan could make way for visits by private-sector astronauts to the International Space Station as early as next year

Jun 7

Uber to offer helicopter taxi service in NYC

Uber Copter will take select "members" on an 8-minute flight to or from Wall St. and JFK Airport — for a $200-to-$225 price

Jun 7

Beyond Meat stock price soars ever higher after first earnings as public company

Market experts warn the vegan meat company's sky-high stock price — up 350% since its IPO last month — is hard to justify

Jun 6

FCC allows automatic blocking of robocalls

Phone companies can now block robocalls by default, but they are permitted to charge you for the service

Jun 6

Nature up close: Grizzlies and black bears

Judy Lehmberg on the bears of Yellowstone National Park

23H ago

NASA to allow private astronauts on space station

NASA's plan could make way for visits by private-sector astronauts to the International Space Station as early as next year

Jun 7

24,000 pounds of garbage removed from Mount Everest

Among the 11 tons of recovered trash from the 45-day project are food wrappers, cans, bottles and empty oxygen cylinders.

Jun 6

Dog owners may be stressing out their pets, study suggests

Researchers on border collies and Shetland sheepdogs, and examined coritsol levels in the hair follicles of both the pet and its owner

Jun 6

Trump administration plans to expand hunting and fishing access

The plan seeks to increase access hunting and fishing access across 1.4 million acres of protected federal lands.

Jun 6

Kroger recalls frozen berries over hepatitis A fears

Frozen fruit with freezer life of two years is recall target at nearly 2,800 stores after an FDA public health alert

7M ago

JUUL pledges $7.5 million to research impact of e-cigarettes

E-cigarette use among teens has been called "an epidemic" by the FDA

1H ago

Death of Granger Smith's son puts spotlight on drownings

Drownings are the leading cause of unintentional deaths of children ages 1 to 4

Jun 7

On National Doughnut Day, some Dunkin' Donuts customers warned of hepatitis A infection

Health officials say an infectious worker at a Dunkin' Donuts may have exposed customers to the disease

Jun 7

FDA finds asbestos in more cosmetics from Claire's Stores

Federal agency warns consumers to steer clear of additional products, saying tests detected cancer-causing mineral

Jun 7

Kroger recalls frozen berries over hepatitis A fears

Frozen fruit with freezer life of two years is recall target at nearly 2,800 stores after an FDA public health alert

7M ago

Abortion laws are "bad for business," nearly 200 CEOs say

Jack Dorsey and Diane von Furstenberg among chief executives saying reproductive equality needed for business growth

1H ago

Raytheon, United Technologies to merge, creating defense giant

The merger will create a company bigger than Lockheed Martin and Northrop Grumman, with sales of about $74 billion

3H ago

Trump threatens tariffs if Mexico deal falls through

"If for any reason the approval is not forthcoming, Tariffs will be reinstated!" Trump tweeted

2H ago

Mega Millions $530 million winning ticket sold in San Diego

If the winner chooses the cash option, they will walk away with about $345 million before taxes

Jun 8

Crime

David Ortiz shot in Dominican Republic

David Ortiz, the longtime baseball slugger better known as "Big Papi" is in stable condition with a gunshot wound. The retired Boston Red Sox star was shot at the Dial Bar & Lounge Sunday night in his hometown of Santo Domingo in the Dominican Republic. Two other people were also wounded. Police say the gunman is in custody and several people were detained in connection with the shooting. David Begnaud reports.

3H ago 03:16

Jayme Closs: Hometown Hero

CBS News journalists explore the courage of Wisconsin teenager Jayme Closs, held captive for 88 days before escaping, and how she and her community have bonded to help her heal

Jun 8

Etan Patz case: 1979 disappearance of NYC boy continues to haunt investigators

"48 Hours" goes inside the painstaking investigation through the eyes of those who have spent more than three decades trying to find the 6-year-old boy and to bring closure to his heartbroken parents

Jun 8

5th suspect arrested in bus assault

A fifth teenager has been arrested in connection with the brutal attack of a lesbian couple in London. One of the victims shares her story for the first time with Imtiaz Tyab.

19H ago 02:08

Lesbian couple speaks out after bus attack in London

Police in London have arrested five suspects, aged 15 to 18, on suspicion of robbery and an aggravated hate crime

Jun 8

Trump criticizes NASA moon plans he approved

In a tweet, the president disparaged NASA's moon mission plan that his administration had endorsed

Jun 7

NASA to allow private astronauts on space station

NASA's plan could make way for visits by private-sector astronauts to the International Space Station as early as next year

Jun 7

NASA opening access to space station

CBS News space consultant Bill Harwood joins CBSN to discuss NASA's announcement that commercial astronauts will be allowed to travel to the International Space Station starting next year.

Jun 7 06:04

Jupiter's largest moons will be visible this month

NASA has a message for space lovers this month: Look up

Jun 5

NASA taps 3 companies for moon missions

If all goes well, the landers will touch down on the moon in 2020 and 2021

May 31

Tony Awards 2019: Red carpet looks from your favorite stars

See Broadway stars walk the red carpet at Radio City Music Hall in New York City at the 73rd Annual Tony Awards

15H ago 39 photos

Jayme Closs case: Recently released evidence photos

At Jake Patterson's sentencing hearing, prosecutors showed a select few evidence photos to the court and asked that Patterson be sentenced to life in prison for the murders of Jayme Closs' parents and the 13-year-old's kidnapping

Jun 8 14 photos

Summer music 2019

It's summertime – time for music at festivals and venues across the country

Jun 8 35 photos

11 photos of former NICU babies show how far they've come

These babies proudly hold photos of their former selves to celebrate their amazing progress since graduating from the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit

Jun 5 11 photos

Evidence photos in the disappearance of Jodi Huisentruit

Jodi Huisentruit, the morning news anchor at Iowa's KIMT-TV was reported missing on June 27, 1995. Mason City Police are still at work trying to solve this case 23 years later.

Jun 1 26 photos

Popular

Alexis Ohanian on congressional tech hearings

Reddit co-founder and venture capitalist Alexis Ohanian says "we've waited too long" to have conversations about technology that's already used widely in our society. He spoke with CBSN about the upcoming congressional hearings that are meant to explore possible antitrust violations by Facebook, Google, Amazon, and Apple.

updated 4M ago 02:24

Alexis Ohanian pushes for paternity leave

Reddit co-founder and venture capitalist Alexis Ohanian talks to CBSN about his partnership with Dove Men+Care aimed at making paid paternity leave a standard in the United States.

updated 4M ago 08:29

Private prison businesses make big money

Despite the decline in the number of people being incarcerated, private prison companies are making money by providing services to inmates with almost no government oversight. Axios reporter Stef Kight joined CBSN AM to discuss when the trend began and how lawmakers are looking to correct the system.

updated 15M ago 06:45

Google CEO defends YouTube amid scandals

The CEO of Google, which owns YouTube, is speaking out about a series of recent controversies over misinformation and hate speech on the site. In a new interview with Axios on HBO, Sundar Pichai said YouTube is working hard to improve. Axios media reporter Sara Fischer joins CBSN to discuss.

1H ago 05:44

"Handmaid's Tale" star Elisabeth Moss

The critically acclaimed drama, "The Handmaid's Tale," is back for its third season. The Hulu show made history when it won the Emmy for best drama series in 2017, the first streaming program to take home the top prize. Elisabeth Moss is the star and executive producer of the series. "CBS This Morning" co-host Gayle King sits down with Moss to talk about the impact of the groundbreaking show and her decades-long career.

2H ago 06:11