A West Point cadet was sentenced to 21 years in prison for raping a sleeping classmate. Now, he's free to return to school.

By christina capatides

/ CBS News

In July 2016, U.S. Military Academy Cadet Jacob Whisenhunt was sentenced to 21 years in prison and discharged from the Army after being found guilty raping a female classmate as she slept in a nearby sleeping bag during Cadet Field Training at Camp Buckner. Whisenhunt's defense was that what transpired between him and the female cadet was consensual. But after a four-day trial, a jury of West Point faculty and staff found him guilty on three counts of sexual assault.

Now, an appeals court has thrown out Whisenhunt's conviction, vacating his sentence. And on Wednesday, the cadet returned to his class at West Point, according to the Associated Press.

The three male appellate military judges who overturned Whisenhunt's conviction ruled that circumstantial evidence backed up Whisenhunt's defense that the act was consensual, based on the fact that the woman — identified by the initials LM — did not struggle loudly enough to alert other cadets who were sleeping nearby.

Trending News

According to the Army Times, the female cadet testified that she froze when she woke up to discover Whisenhunt assaulting her, and remained in the fetal position for the duration of the intercourse. But the judges didn't seem to find that plausible.

"It is even harder to conclude beyond a reasonable doubt that appellant would anticipate that LM would not make any reflexive noise or movements upon being awakened, which would have alerted multiple others to his criminal activity," the ruling reads. "This is particularly true when there is no evidence that appellant threatened LM or took any steps, such as covering her mouth, to prevent an outcry."

In their ruling Monday, the judges also cited the fact that the female cadet could easily identify Whisenhunt as one of her classmates, and the fact that he did not attempt to clean up the semen he left behind in her sleeping bag, as reasons to believe it must have been consensual.

Whisenhunt "would have needed to anticipate that LM would not report his crimes at a later date, when the record is devoid of any evidence that LM could not identify him, that she was incapacitated, or that he had threatened or coerced her," the judges wrote. "Furthermore, appellant left his semen on LM's bivy cover, and there is no evidence that he tried to remove this evidence."

"A horrible message"

Former Air Force chief prosecutor, retired Col. Don Christensen, told CBS News the ruling sends "a horrible message."

"Their opinion is victim-blaming," he said. "It reads like something from decades ago. Their two bases for overturning the conviction — one was that the victim didn't act the way they wanted, and the other was that the accused surely wouldn't rape somebody that he knew, which shows that these three judges haven't got a clue when it comes to what sexual assault looks like. So, it's just going to send an incredibly bad message to the survivor community."

In May, a survey released by the Department of Defense revealed that sexual assault in the military had spiked nearly 40% since 2016 — with an estimated 20,500 service members experiencing some kind of "contact or penetrative sexual assault" in 2018. While those numbers are staggering, they may still only represent a fraction of the sexual assaults that actually occur in the U.S. military, given that only about 1 in 3 service members report their experience of sexual assault to a Defense Department authority.

Col. Christensen, who now serves as the president of Protect Our Defenders, an advocacy group with the mission of ending the epidemic of military rape, believes that this ruling will dissuade future victims from coming forward.

"Even now, when they do come forward, the odds of them getting a conviction are astronomically slim," he told CBS News. "You know, there were only 108 convictions last year in the military out of 7,000 reports, and so the numbers are against them. And then, when they actually do get a conviction, to have it overturned on such flimsy logic is just going to dissuade people from doing it. It's time for Congress to act on this; to be bold. They have been too slow to do anything really aggressive when it comes to sex assault in the military."

First published on June 6, 2019 / 6:42 PM

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Right Rail – Video Promo – Listing

A WWII-era veteran returns to the air

A World War II-era Douglas C-47 military transport plane dubbed "Miss Montana" had been parked in a museum for nearly two decades after a career transporting firefighters in Montana. Now, with its engines rebuilt and the fuselage restored to its early glory, it is joining other veteran airplanes that saw service on D-Day 75 years ago for a trip across the Atlantic, for an anniversary flight over the beaches of Normandy. Richard Schlesinger talks with those who got Miss Montana back in the air.

Jun 2 08:30

The bondage of bail

It's estimated that at least 60% of Americans in jail today – nearly a half-million – haven't been convicted of anything but are merely being held in pre-trial detention because they can't afford to make bail. What's worse, even people who are acquitted of charges may face years paying back their bail bond fees. Now, some states, like California, are moving to end their cash bail systems. Lee Cowan looks at the $2 billion-a-year private bail bond industry, and talks with the founder of the Bail Project, a non-profit that gives those in need bail without added fees, as well as the executive director of Equal Justice Under Law, dedicated to scrapping the cash bail system entirely.

Jun 2 09:31

Wood sculptor David Esterly

The delicate and expressive wood carvings of sculptor David Esterly may take months, even years, to create, conjured from the subtle neurological connections between the artist's brain and the hand. Faith Salie talks with Esterly, whose craft has placed him among the greatest wood workers, and who, at 75, is now facing the symptoms of ALS, also known as Lou Gehrig's disease.

Jun 2 05:40

Sunday Profile: Mindy Kaling

When she was a little kid, Mindy Kaling didn't see anyone on TV who looked like her, and yet she's built a career as a writer and actress who is remarkably relatable, whether it's her characters in the sitcoms "The Office" and "The Mindy Project," her bestselling books, or her new film "Late Night," which she wrote and stars in alongside Emma Thompson. Luke Burbank reports.

Jun 2 07:21

The Jonas Brothers: A little older, wiser, and happier than ever

The Jonas Brothers' "Sucker" has been rocking the airwaves as their first-ever #1 hit. But the brothers – Nick, Kevin and Joe – have traveled long paths, both together and solo, since coming onto the scene as teens nearly 15 years ago. Tracy Smith talks with the Jonas Brothers, each now married, about family ties and their decision to regroup, produce a new album ("Happiness Begins"), and head out on tour.

Jun 2 08:00

Rape conviction overturned, West Point cadet returns to campus

Judges' decision "is victim-blaming," said a former military chief prosecutor. "It reads like something from decades ago."

9M ago

Widow fights for husband's recognition as a D-Day hero

Waverly Woodson Jr. reportedly spent 30 hours giving CPR, removing bullets and performing amputations

10M ago

More rain could hit Louisiana after flooding turns deadly

A man drowned after his car stalled and sank on a flooded road

13M ago

Trump honors D-Day's fallen heroes

While marking the 75th anniversary of D-Day, President Trump honored the men who fought and died in Normandy. He also paid tribute to those who fought alongside Americans. Paula Reid reports.

updated 3M ago 01:58

Heroes of D-Day remembered

The D-Day invasion 75 years ago was the largest military operation by sea and air in history. Now, D-Day veterans are being honored for their heroism. Anthony Mason reports from Normandy.

updated 4M ago 04:05

Top headlines for June 6, 2019

Here's a look at the top stories making headlines on the "CBS Evening News."

updated 7M ago 01:12

D-Day: When the Allies turned the tide

The invasion of Nazi-held France on June 6, 1944 proved to be one of the most decisive campaigns of World War II

Jun 6, 2013 34 photos

Looking back at Tiananmen Square

Revisiting the 1989 pro-democracy movement in Beijing, and the Chinese military's bloody crackdown

Jun 4, 2014 34 photos

Notable deaths in 2019

A look back at the esteemed personalities who've left us this year, who touched us with their innovation, creativity and humanity

Jan 17 76 photos

New on Netflix, Hulu and Amazon

Shows and movies you'll want to stream soon

Apr 26 32 photos

Awe-inspiring reasons to love Planet Earth

On Earth Day it's time to stop and appreciate our planet

Apr 22, 2015 21 photos

Barbershop owner pays off seniors' debts so they can graduate

The reason several of the kids were in debt shocked the barbershop owner – she knew she had to do something

May 30

History teacher a "hero" to the veterans he's honored

Every year, John Corona brought in veterans to his school, so they can share their stories with the students

Apr 2

13-year-old buys his single mom a car

The mother of three said the last few weeks have been a struggle, so her son's gift was "the shock of her life"

Apr 2

Teen robotics team makes wheelchair for toddler

The family's insurance didn't cover the $20,000 wheelchair, so a group of high schoolers stepped in to help

Apr 2

Boy's lost stuffed animal found on mountain

The boy's mom thought his beloved Grover was gone forever — then a fellow mountain climber saw something blue sticking out of the snow

Apr 1

Community honors beloved mailman on his last day of work

One little girl dressed like him for career day at school – that's just how much this neighborhood loves him

May 28