Legal experts question arrest of ex-deputy who didn't confront Parkland shooter

/ AP

The case against former Parkland deputy

The arrest of a Florida sheriff's deputy for not confronting the gunman in the Parkland school massacre represents a highly unusual use of the law — and a legally dubious one, in the opinion of some experts. Scot Peterson, 56, appeared in court Wednesday on 11 charges, including negligence and child neglect for not entering the building during the rampage last year at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School that left 17 people dead.

In court papers, prosecutors said five people were killed and four others wounded after Peterson took up his position, gun drawn, but did not go inside. Nikolas Cruz, 20, faces the death penalty if convicted in the Valentine's Day bloodshed.

President Donald Trump and others have branded Peterson a coward. But can Broward County prosecutors prove his hesitation to act amounts to a crime?

Trending News

Legal experts are not so sure and suggested prosecutors may have overreached.

Scot Peterson pictured in a mugshot released June 4, 2019. Broward County Sheriff's Office

"This is a unique prosecution, pushing the bounds of criminal liability," said David O. Markus, a prominent Miami defense attorney not involved in the case. "While elected prosecutors many times bow to the court of public opinion, our justice system demands that a case like this be tested in a court of law. Legally, this is a tough one for the prosecution."

Michael Grieco, a defense attorney and state legislator from Miami Beach who is also not involved in the case, agreed that prosecutors face an uphill climb.

"Although as a father, legislator and human being, I believe that there is no societal defense to cowardice, the law has consistently and recently held that there is no constitutional duty for police to protect us from harm," Grieco said. "The decision to criminally charge Mr. Peterson, although popular in the court of public opinion, will likely not hold water once formally challenged."

New surveillance video shows deputy outside during Parkland school massacre

Instances in which law enforcement officers are accused of mishandling a situation are often dealt with not with criminal charges but with lawsuits seeking damages. Several have already been filed against Peterson.

The negligence charge brought by prosecutors accuses Peterson of "reckless indifference" or "careless disregard" for others. Child neglect involves a failure to protect someone under 18 from "abuse, neglect or exploitation."

Peterson's lawyer, Joseph DiRuzzo, said the charges should be dismissed because Peterson did not legally have a duty to care for the students, as would be the case for someone dealing directly with children, such as a nurse or day care staffer.

"Mr. Peterson cannot reasonably be prosecuted because he was not a 'caregiver,' which is defined as a parent, adult household member or other person responsible for a child's welfare," DiRuzzo said. "Mr. Peterson was not criminally negligent in his actions, as no police officer has ever been prosecuted for his or her actions in responding to an active shooter incident."

Investigators, prosecutors and victims' family members tell a different story. Prosecutors noted in court papers that Peterson was trained to confront an armed assailant and, as the school's resource officer, was the only armed person on campus who could have limited or stopped the carnage in a timely way.

"He could have and would have saved lives. So he has to deal with that for the rest of his life," said Lori Alhadeff, whose 14-year-old daughter Alyssa was killed.

Parkland parents demand prison time for officer charged for failing to confront gunman

Florida Department of Law Enforcement Commissioner Rick Swearingen, whose agency conducted a 14-month investigation into Peterson's conduct that included interviews with 184 witnesses and a review of many hours of surveillance video, said: "There can be no excuse for his complete inaction and no question that his inaction cost lives."

Bail was set at $102,000 for Peterson, who was fired Tuesday as a deputy though he had already retired. He said nothing at the hearing Wednesday and did not enter a plea. In news interviews, he has defended his actions as justified amid the chaos that day.

"I believed there was a sniper. So in my mind, I'm thinking to myself there's possibly, maybe, somebody up there shooting out. But I didn't think they were shooting at kids," Peterson said on NBC's "Today" show. "I thought they were shooting out at the building. Outside."

Peterson faces a maximum sentence of nearly 100 years in prison if convicted on all counts, a combination of felonies and misdemeanors. Other than Cruz, who is set to go to trial early next year, he is the only person charged with a crime despite a well-documented litany of failures by authorities before and during the massacre.

"There has only ever been one person to blame — Nikolas Cruz," Peterson's lawyer said.

Shooting at high school in Parkland, Florida
Shooting at high school in Parkland, Florida 34 photos

First published on June 5, 2019 / 3:42 PM

© 2019 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

mugshot-crop.jpg Shooting at high school in Parkland, Florida

Legal experts question ex-deputy's arrest over Parkland inaction

Scot Peterson was criminally charged for failing to confront a school shooter, but prosecutors may have an uphill battle

8M ago

Pence meets with top Mexican diplomat as tariff deadline nears

The tariffs go into effect Monday if President Trump isn't satisfied with Mexico's progress

26M ago

How to watch the 2019 Belmont Stakes

The 151st running of the Belmont Stakes takes place this Saturday

26M ago

YouTube plans to ban thousands of extremist videos

The announcement comes just a day after the platform said that racist and homophobic slurs against a Vox journalist do not violate its harassment policies

37M ago

Walmart CEO: Congress should hike federal minimum wage

Doug McMillon tells shareholders — and presidential candidate Bernie Sanders — that $7.25 an hour clearly is "too low"

38M ago

Pence meets with top Mexican diplomat as tariff deadline nears

The tariffs go into effect Monday if President Trump isn't satisfied with Mexico's progress

26M ago

Walmart CEO: Congress should hike federal minimum wage

Doug McMillon tells shareholders — and presidential candidate Bernie Sanders — that $7.25 an hour clearly is "too low"

38M ago

Tlaib tears up while reading death threat at white supremacy hearing

Tlaib broke down at the haring after recalling a threat her office received

39M ago

Trump administration ends federal fetal tissue research

The policy changes won't affect privately funded research

1H ago

Border apprehensions of families and children continue to skyrocket

U.S. authorities apprehended more than 84,000 families and 11,000 unaccompanied children near the U.S.-Mexico border last month

1H ago

Cristiano Ronaldo rape lawsuit dropped in Nevada, federal suit remains active

The lawsuit stems from a 2009 encounter between a soccer star and woman in Las Vegas

1H ago

Border apprehensions of families and children continue to skyrocket

U.S. authorities apprehended more than 84,000 families and 11,000 unaccompanied children near the U.S.-Mexico border last month

1H ago

How CBS News Radio reported D-Day from the front lines

"Everything they did was new. The American people received updates on the war live every night"

2H ago

How to watch D-Day 75th anniversary coverage

Anthony Mason will lead CBS News' live coverage of events marking that historic day

2H ago

U.S. nixes educational, recreational activities for migrant children

The agency in charge of taking care of minors said it is running out of funds to continue housing migrant children detained by the U.S. near the southern border

2H ago

Wajahat Ali makes the case for having kids — even in his darkest hour

Just hours before Wajahat Ali was to give a TED Talk about why more people should be having children, he got the kind of news every parent dreads

updated 48M ago

Highest-grossing movies of all time, ranked

What's the highest-grossing movie of all time? It might be one of your favorites

Jun 4 27 photos

"Twilight Zone" episode exposes America's "dirty little secret"

Actress Sanaa Lathan told CBSN she cried when she first read the script of her "Twilight Zone" episode

3H ago

How to watch the 2019 Country Music Television Awards

The 2019 CMT Awards will be live from Nashville, hosted by Little Big Town

6H ago

Sephora closing for diversity training after singer's tweet

SZA wasn't the only celebrity who had a bad experience with Sephora – Leslie Jones also tweeted about the company, too

7H ago

YouTube plans to ban thousands of extremist videos

The announcement comes just a day after the platform said that racist and homophobic slurs against a Vox journalist do not violate its harassment policies

37M ago

Facial recognition technology ramps up, but lacks "checks and balances"

For the first time in the United States, some schools could start using facial recognition technology for security

7H ago

Tim Cook on tariffs, immigration and spending too much time on our phones

The Apple CEO sat down with incoming "CBS Evening News" anchor Norah O'Donnell

21H ago

Cryptocurrency whiz behind $4.5 million lunch with Buffett

The entrepreneur sees an opportunity "for mutual understanding and knowledge transfer" over lunch with Buffett

21H ago

Tim Cook: "We should all be concerned" about fake news

"I worry that the fake news is not under control," Apple CEO Tim Cook told CBS News' Norah O'Donnell

Jun 4

Air pollution kills 100,000 Indian children every year, study says

Report by New Delhi-based NGO blasts government inaction on pollution and renewable energy, blames air pollution for 12.5 percent of all deaths

4H ago

Civilization faces "existential risk" from climate change, report warns

New report forecasts widespread societal breakdown set off by the migration of billions of people fleeing climate extremes

22H ago

NASA taps 3 companies for moon missions

If all goes well, the landers will touch down on the moon in 2020 and 2021

May 31

Energy Department calls natural gas "freedom gas" in press release

The release isn't the first time the department has associated "freedom" with natural gas

May 29

Thousands of puffins die as climate warms

Mass mortality events are becoming bigger and more frequent in "a changing world"

May 29

Wajahat Ali makes the case for having kids — even in his darkest hour

Just hours before Wajahat Ali was to give a TED Talk about why more people should be having children, he got the kind of news every parent dreads

updated 48M ago

Oakland becomes second U.S. city to legalize "magic mushrooms"

The vote makes the investigation and arrest of adults who grow, possess and use the substances as one of the lowest priorities for police.

1H ago

Beverly Hills first U.S. city to ban tobacco sales

The city council unanimously approved a ban on tobacco sales with exemptions for hotels and cigar lounges

3H ago

Why "Desperate Housewives" star is talking about anal cancer

"Mostly I want to talk about it because I know there are people who are ashamed"

7H ago

Opioid claims tarnish Johnson & Johnson's family-friendly image

Known for evoking "childhood and babies," J&J now faces fire in a case alleging it played a role in the opioid crisis

22H ago

YouTube plans to ban thousands of extremist videos

The announcement comes just a day after the platform said that racist and homophobic slurs against a Vox journalist do not violate its harassment policies

37M ago

Walmart CEO: Congress should hike federal minimum wage

Doug McMillon tells shareholders — and presidential candidate Bernie Sanders — that $7.25 an hour clearly is "too low"

38M ago

Pearl Street Caviar aims to popularize pricey delicacy

Craig Page is working to change caviar's image and cost as a food for the 1% so it it can be enjoyed by the 99%

1H ago

Bernie Sanders tells shareholders Walmart pays "starvation wages"

The senator and Democratic presidential candidate addressed Walmart shareholders Wednesday to advocate for higher wages for its workers

2H ago

Beverly Hills first U.S. city to ban tobacco sales

The city council unanimously approved a ban on tobacco sales with exemptions for hotels and cigar lounges

3H ago

Legal experts question ex-deputy's arrest over Parkland inaction

Scot Peterson was criminally charged for failing to confront a school shooter, but prosecutors may have an uphill battle

8M ago

Cristiano Ronaldo rape lawsuit dropped in Nevada, federal suit remains active

The lawsuit stems from a 2009 encounter between a soccer star and woman in Las Vegas

1H ago

Cardinal denies mishandling abuse report

Catholic Church Cardinal Daniel DiNardo is accused of allowing a priest to be reassigned after a report the priest had an inappropriate sexual relationship with an adult parishioner. Associated Press reporter Nicole Winfield joins CBSN from Rome to discuss the accusation and the fallout.

updated 24M ago 04:47

Alabama considering chemical castration for child molesters

Alabama lawmakers have passed a bill that would require pedophiles to undergo chemical castration as a condition of their parole

1H ago

Deputy charged after staying outside during Parkland shooting

Scot Peterson, 56, faces child neglect, culpable negligence and perjury charges

3H ago

NASA taps 3 companies for moon missions

If all goes well, the landers will touch down on the moon in 2020 and 2021

May 31

Cosmonauts honor spacewalk pioneer on eve of 85th birthday

Cosmonauts dedicate spacewalk to Alexey Leonov, who carried out the first spacewalk in 1965

May 29

SpaceX readying crew ship for flight by end of year

SpaceX, working through a Crew Dragon failure probe, is protecting possible end-of-year flight

May 28

NASA awards contract for future moon station

NASA is moving ahead with plans to send astronauts back to the moon by 2024

May 23

SpaceX pins high hopes on Starlink satellites

SpaceX plans multiple Starlink launches in 2019 to build out space-based internet network

May 23

Evidence photos in the disappearance of Jodi Huisentruit

Jodi Huisentruit, the morning news anchor at Iowa's KIMT-TV was reported missing on June 27, 1995. Mason City Police are still at work trying to solve this case 23 years later.

Jun 1 26 photos

Horrifying photos of Chernobyl and its aftermath

HBO's drama provided a devastating look at the worst nuclear accident of the 20th century. Now see what really happened.

May 31 39 photos

Memorial Day 2019: America honors the fallen

Remembering the sacrifices made by service members in our nation's wars

May 27 37 photos

John & Jacque: A tale of love and war

A look at John Needham, Jacque Villagomez and the events that led to her death

May 25 14 photos

Highest-grossing movies of all time, ranked

What's the highest-grossing movie of all time? It might be one of your favorites

Jun 4 27 photos

Popular

The case against former Parkland deputy

Former Florida Deputy Scot Peterson made his first court appearance Wednesday after being arrested Tuesday. He's facing 11 charges including negligence for his inaction during the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School shooting in 2018. Attorney Jesse Weber joined CBSN to discuss the charges Peterson is facing.

updated 6M ago 06:14

Rep. Tlaib breaks down in tears over threats

The freshman congresswoman, who is Muslim, got very emotional while reading a threat her office had received during a hearing on Capitol Hill.

updated 24M ago 02:14

Sneak peek: The Lost Boy

More than three decades after 6-year-old Etan Patz went missing, police found a surprising suspect. "48 Hours"' and correspondent Richard Schlesinger go inside the investigation. Is the haunting case really over? Watch Saturday, June 8 at 9/8c on CBS

updated 58M ago 03:24

Cardinal denies mishandling abuse report

Catholic Church Cardinal Daniel DiNardo is accused of allowing a priest to be reassigned after a report the priest had an inappropriate sexual relationship with an adult parishioner. Associated Press reporter Nicole Winfield joins CBSN from Rome to discuss the accusation and the fallout.

updated 24M ago 04:47

Biden on abortion and the Hyde Amendment

Former Vice President Joe Biden's presidential campaign says he still supports the Hyde Amendment, a policy that bans federal funding for abortion. CBSN political reporter Caitlin Huey Burns explains how his stance may be a factor with Democratic primary voters.

1H ago 08:24