Prosecutor removed from case of Navy SEAL charged with war crimes

/ CBS/AP

Navy SEAL released pending trial

San Diego — A military judge took the rare step Monday of removing a prosecutor accused of misconduct from the war crimes case of a decorated Navy SEAL.

Capt. Aaron Rugh ordered the lead prosecutor removed from the case of Special Operations Chief Edward Gallagher after defense lawyers accused the prosecution of spying on their emails, according to the ruling.

The defense asked Rugh to dismiss the case or remove prosecutors because of the surreptitious effort to track defense emails without court approval in an effort to find the source of news leaks.

Trending News

Rugh said it was not in his power to determine if Cmdr. Christopher Czaplak violated ethical or professional rules, but the potential for a probe into those actions required that he be removed from the prosecution.

Czaplak received word of the ruling during a deposition while questioning an Iraqi general who is a witness in the case, defense lawyer Tim Parlatore said.

Czaplak left in the middle of the testimony being recorded on video in San Diego for use at the trial. He did not return to the courtroom.

Parlatore said it was a step in the right direction.

"There's no way he should be allowed to continue on this case," Parlatore said. "We're still hopeful the entire case will be dismissed."

Rugh said he would rule on whether to dismiss murder and attempted murder counts against Gallagher by the end of Wednesday.

Gary Solis, a former Marine Corps prosecutor and military judge who teaches law at Georgetown, said he's never heard of anything like this, saying Czaplak's decision to track defense attorneys' emails was "contrary to legal ethics and common sense."

"Unprecedented is too tame a description for what he did," said Solis, who applauded the ruling. "Unwise is overly optimistic … His conduct has been entirely inappropriate."

A Marine Corps lawyer, Capt. Conor McMahon, assigned to the case will not be removed, Rugh said.

But it's not clear if McMahon will stay on the prosecution team. McMahon's commanders ordered him to stop participating in the case last week and he didn't appear at hearings on Thursday and Friday.

The Navy would not say if he would remain on the team.

Czaplak will be replaced with another attorney from the Navy, spokesman Brian O'Rourke said.

"Chief Petty Officer Gallagher is entitled to a fair trial and the Navy is committed to upholding that principle," O'Rourke said.

Last week, Rugh unexpectedly released Gallagher from custody as a remedy for interference by prosecutors in the middle of a hearing that also included accusations they withheld evidence from the defense.

The removal of Czaplak could delay the trial scheduled to start June 10.

Republicans in Congress have rallied in support of Gallagher, saying he has been mistreated. President Donald Trump, who intervened to move Gallagher to better confinement, has considered dismissing the charges.

Gallagher pleaded not guilty to murder in the death of an injured teenage militant in Iraq in 2017 and to attempted murder for picking off two civilians from a sniper's perch.

It is extremely unusual for a military judge to remove the prosecution or dismiss a case only days before the start of a trial. The military justice system has gotten few war crime convictions and been criticized for being ineffective.

At hearings last week, Rugh indicated he was misled about the investigation into news leaks.

He said investigators told him privately they planned to embed code in what he believed to be a court document to help them find the source of leaks. But the judge said he didn't have the power to authorize such a tactic and wasn't told they planned to target emails sent to the defense lawyers or a journalist.

Rugh also said he believed Czaplak was working with federal prosecutors and his approval was not necessary.

Rugh received a letter Friday from the U.S. attorney's office in San Diego, saying they had not approved or coordinated the tracking, Parlatore said.

Evidence at the hearings showed prosecutors enlisted a Naval Criminal Investigative Service intelligence specialist to conduct criminal background checks on three civilian lawyers and a Navy Times journalist who has broken several stories based on leaked documents.

Parlatore, who was among the three lawyers investigated, accused prosecutors of a "rogue, relentless, and unlawful cyber campaign" that may have violated attorney-client privilege and hurt his client's ability to get a fair trial.

Czaplak downplayed the move, saying the embedded code recorded nothing more than what marketers use to find out where and when messages were opened by recipients.

Another prosecutor, Lt. Scott McDonald said the effort only gathered data, such as internet protocol addresses, and did not snoop on the content of emails or require a search warrant.

"Even if there was some intrusion" in violation of attorney client-privilege, it didn't rise to the level to dismiss the case, McDonald said.

Czaplak said the tracking ended May 10 after he was confronted by Parlatore who discovered the code in an unusual logo of an American flag with a bald eagle perched on the scales of justice beneath the prosecutor's signature.

Several experts testified that the code couldn't generally be used to identify a specific person or capture content.

Gallagher, who was a platoon leader, has pleaded not guilty to murder in the death of an injured teenage militant in Iraq in 2017 and attempted murder for allegedly picking off civilians from a sniper's perch.

His platoon supervisor, Lt. Jacob Portier, is fighting charges of conduct unbecoming an officer for allegedly conducting Gallagher's re-enlistment ceremony next to the militant's corpse.

Efforts to get the case thrown out come as President Trump considers pardoning several service members accused of war crimes, including Gallagher, who faces trial June 10.

One of Gallagher's civilian defense attorneys, Marc Mukasey, is also a personal lawyer for the president, the Reuters news service notes.

Gallagher could face life in prison if he's convicted of all the charges, including murder, attempted murder and obstructing justice, Reuters points out.

Gallagher says fellow SEALS testifying against him — several after being granted immunity — are disgruntled subordinates who made up allegations in an effort to get him stripped of his command, Reuters adds.

First published on June 4, 2019 / 2:36 AM

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Prosecutor removed from case of Navy SEAL charged with war crimes

Edward Gallagher's lawyers accused prosecutor of spying on their emails; Gallagher is charged with murdering injured teen militant in Iraq in 2017

5M ago

New "Lion King" trailer reveals Beyoncé's voice as Nala

Just can't wait to hear Beyoncé's take on Nala? Be prepared

2H ago

Charles Manson follower Leslie Van Houten denied parole again

Van Houten was 19 when she and other cult members stabbed to death wealthy Los Angeles grocer Leno LaBianca and his wife, Rosemary

4H ago

Gator crashes picnic date and eats bowl of guacamole

"He annihilated an entire block of cheese. Gobbled it down, lickety-split. The salami didn't stand a chance," woman said of the alligator that ruined her date

5H ago

House passes long-delayed $19.1 billion disaster aid bill

The bill's passage was delayed during Congress' recent recess by three dissenting Republican congressmen

7H ago

House passes long-delayed $19.1 billion disaster aid bill

The bill's passage was delayed during Congress' recent recess by three dissenting Republican congressmen

7H ago

Feds take aim at tech giants with antitrust probes

Lawmakers launched a bipartisan probe into monopoly in the tech industry, while the Trump administration is investigating companies like Google and Facebook

6H ago

House to vote to hold Barr, McGahn in contempt next week

The House Judiciary Committee voted earlier this month to hold him in contempt of Congress for failing to comply with its subpoenas related to the Mueller report

5H ago

Dems threaten contempt vote for Barr and Ross in 2020 Census probe

A recent court filing alleged that a Republican gerrymandering strategist played a role in the administration's decision to add a citizenship question on the Census

5H ago

Jimmy Carter is now a tenured professor — finally

The 94-year-old ex-president lectures on religion, public health, political science and history

9H ago

Prosecutor removed from case of Navy SEAL charged with war crimes

Edward Gallagher's lawyers accused prosecutor of spying on their emails; Gallagher is charged with murdering injured teen militant in Iraq in 2017

5M ago

900-year-old chess piece discovered in family's drawer

The chess piece was in possession by a family in Scotland for 55 years before they found out its value; it could fetch $1.26 million at an upcoming auction

3H ago

USS Lincoln conducts training amid tensions with Iran

The carrier was specifically sent to the Arabian Sea in response to threats from Iran

8H ago

McCain and Obama used to taunt Trump in UK

An anti-Brexit group is responsible for the unique displays of dissatisfaction

9H ago

How accurate is HBO's "Chernobyl"?

A new mini-series brings to life the story of the 1986 nuclear disaster

10H ago

New "Lion King" trailer reveals Beyoncé's voice as Nala

Just can't wait to hear Beyoncé's take on Nala? Be prepared

2H ago

Highest-grossing movies of all time, ranked

What's the highest-grossing movie of all time? It might be one of your favorites

May 20 27 photos

AMC threatens to pull "The Walking Dead" out of Georgia

It joins a slew of media and entertainment companies threatening to exit after the state passed a new anti-abortion law

8H ago

Does Jeopardy! champ James Holzhauer lose today?

Holzhauer is just $58,000 shy of Ken Jennings' record of $2.52 million in winnings for the TV trivia show

8H ago

Jay-Z becomes 1st billionaire hip-hop artist

Jay-Z grew up in the Marcy housing projects of Brooklyn. Now he owns three homes and multiple business adding up to a billion-dollar fortune

2H ago

Feds take aim at tech giants with antitrust probes

Lawmakers launched a bipartisan probe into monopoly in the tech industry, while the Trump administration is investigating companies like Google and Facebook

6H ago

Tim Cook: Apple is "moving privacy protections forward"

Apple revealed new privacy features Monday at its annual Worldwide Developers Conference

7H ago

Electronic Entertainment Expo (E3) 2019 Preview

The Electronic Entertainment Expo (E3) — the video game industry's biggest event — starts next week

8H ago

Apple announces iTunes replacement, iOS 13 updates

The tech giant is holding its annual conference where it announced some major changes concerning user privacy — and showcased one very expensive computer

10H ago

Apple announces it's getting rid of iTunes

iTunes can't compete with streaming services like the company's own Apple Music and Spotify

6H ago

NASA taps 3 companies for moon missions

If all goes well, the landers will touch down on the moon in 2020 and 2021

May 31

Energy Department calls natural gas "freedom gas" in press release

The release isn't the first time the department has associated "freedom" with natural gas

May 29

Thousands of puffins die as climate warms

Mass mortality events are becoming bigger and more frequent in "a changing world"

May 29

Cosmonauts honor spacewalk pioneer on eve of 85th birthday

Cosmonauts dedicate spacewalk to Alexey Leonov, who carried out the first spacewalk in 1965

May 29

Why this year's tornado season is in overdrive

For the year so far, we are closing in on 1,000 tornado reports across the nation

May 29

U.S. looks to help more cancer patients access experimental drugs

Food and Drug Administration announced a project to have the agency become the middleman between patients and drug companies

3H ago

Drug extends lives of young breast cancer patients

The drug Kisqali (ribociclib) is already approved by the FDA, and new research shows it helps some breast cancer patients live longer

13H ago

Data for 12 million Quest patients may have been exposed

Blood-testing company hack compromised people's Social Security numbers, financial data and medical information

6H ago

States target Georgia's film business after abortion ban

Competing states seek to capitalize on filmmakers' intentions to pull billions of production dollars from Georgia over heartbeat law

May 31

Missouri's last remaining abortion clinic will stay open

Planned Parenthood of St. Louis would have been forced to stop providing abortion by the end of Friday

May 31

Tim Cook: Apple is "moving privacy protections forward"

Apple revealed new privacy features Monday at its annual Worldwide Developers Conference

7H ago

AMC threatens to pull "The Walking Dead" out of Georgia

It joins a slew of media and entertainment companies threatening to exit after the state passed a new anti-abortion law

8H ago

As more tariffs loom, experts warn consumers to brace for impact

Companies from Chipotle to Walmart are warning of higher prices for consumers amid trade feuds with China and Mexico

8H ago

Carnival agrees to pay $20 million for pollution violations

Carnival cruise ships continued to pollute the oceans despite a previous criminal conviction aimed at curbing similar conduct

7H ago

Does Jeopardy! champ James Holzhauer lose today?

Holzhauer is just $58,000 shy of Ken Jennings' record of $2.52 million in winnings for the TV trivia show

8H ago

Charles Manson follower Leslie Van Houten denied parole again

Van Houten was 19 when she and other cult members stabbed to death wealthy Los Angeles grocer Leno LaBianca and his wife, Rosemary

4H ago

Dallas PD taps FBI for help after 2nd transgender woman killed

Chynal Lindsey's murder comes just two weeks after the killing of Muhlaysia Booker

7H ago

Virginia Beach survivors describe shooting

New details are emerging about the 12 people who were shot and killed at a municipal building in Virginia Beach. Survivors said active shooter training may have saved lives. Jeff Pegues reports.

7H ago 02:19

Virginia Beach shooting survivors say training helped save lives

One survivor said victim Keith Cox directed several people to hide in an office

8H ago

Man sentenced for Mall of America attack

The man accused of throwing a 5-year-old boy over a balcony at the Mall of America, seriously injuring the child, was sentenced today to 19 years in prison. CBS News' Marc Liverman reports.

8H ago 01:27

NASA taps 3 companies for moon missions

If all goes well, the landers will touch down on the moon in 2020 and 2021

May 31

Cosmonauts honor spacewalk pioneer on eve of 85th birthday

Cosmonauts dedicate spacewalk to Alexey Leonov, who carried out the first spacewalk in 1965

May 29

SpaceX readying crew ship for flight by end of year

SpaceX, working through a Crew Dragon failure probe, is protecting possible end-of-year flight

May 28

NASA awards contract for future moon station

NASA is moving ahead with plans to send astronauts back to the moon by 2024

May 23

SpaceX pins high hopes on Starlink satellites

SpaceX plans multiple Starlink launches in 2019 to build out space-based internet network

May 23

Evidence photos in the disappearance of Jodi Huisentruit

Jodi Huisentruit, the morning news anchor at Iowa's KIMT-TV was reported missing on June 27, 1995. Mason City Police are still at work trying to solve this case 23 years later.

Jun 1 26 photos

Horrifying photos of Chernobyl and its aftermath

HBO's drama provided a devastating look at the worst nuclear accident of the 20th century. Now see what really happened.

May 31 39 photos

Memorial Day 2019: America honors the fallen

Remembering the sacrifices made by service members in our nation's wars

May 27 37 photos

John & Jacque: A tale of love and war

A look at John Needham, Jacque Villagomez and the events that led to her death

May 25 14 photos

Highest-grossing movies of all time, ranked

What's the highest-grossing movie of all time? It might be one of your favorites

May 20 27 photos

Popular

1989: Man stops tank in Tiananmen Square

A CBS News team covering the 1989 protests in Beijing recorded a man stopping a Chinese tank in Tiananmen Square. This image would become one of the most iconic of all time. Here is Richard Roth's original report for the "CBS Evening News" from that night.

2H ago 01:09

Jay-Z named hip-hop's 1st billionaire

Jay-Z just joined an elite club of entertainers who have hit billionaire status — and he's the first hip-hop artist to do so. Forbes says the rapper's art, real estate, liquor and other investments, along with his entertainment industry earnings, have accumulated into "a fortune that conservatively totals $1 billion."

2H ago 00:29

Elaine Chao's family business ties scrutinized

New reporting from The New York Times is taking a look at Transportation Secretary Elaine Chao's connections to China, through her family business. New York Times investigative reporter Eric Lipton joins CBSN's Elaine Quijano to discuss.

3H ago 08:08

Apple showcases new privacy features

Apple hosted its annual Worldwide Developers Conference and this year's major theme was privacy. The tech giant announced some new features aimed at protecting user data. Dan Howley, tech editor for Yahoo Finance, joins CBSN to discuss what Apple is doing differently and what it means for its customers.

3H ago 08:07

6/3/19: Red and Blue

President Trump makes state visit to the UK; Kushner on Trump's birtherism push

3H ago 46:35