Judge rules that terror watchlist violates constitutional rights

/ AP

The government's watchlist of more than 1 million people identified as "known or suspected terrorists" violates the constitutional rights of those placed on it, a federal judge ruled Wednesday.

The ruling from U.S. District Judge Anthony Trenga grants summary judgment to nearly two dozen Muslim U.S. citizens who had challenged the watchlist with the help of a Muslim civil-rights group, the Council on American-Islamic Relations.

But the judge is seeking additional legal briefs before deciding what remedy to impose.

Trending News

The plaintiffs said they were wrongly placed on the list and that the government's process for adding names is overbroad and riddled with errors.

The watchlist is disseminated to a variety of governmental departments, foreign governments and police agencies.

The FBI declined comment on the ruling Wednesday. In court, the FBI's lawyers argued that the difficulties suffered by the plaintiffs pale in comparison to the government's interests in combatting terrorism.

Gadeir Abbas, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, called the ruling a victory. He said he will be asking the judge to severely curtail how the government compiles and uses its list.

"Innocent people should be beyond the reach of the watchlist system," Abbas said. "We think that's what the Constitution requires."

Abbas said that while there has been significant litigation over the no-fly list, which forced the government to improve the process for people seeking to clear their name from the list, he said Trenga's ruling is the first to broadly attack the government's use of the watchlist. Trenga also wrote in his 31-page ruling that the case "presents unsettled issues."

Ultimately, Trenga ruled that the travel difficulties faced by plaintiffs — who say they were handcuffed at border crossings and frequently subjected to invasive secondary searches at airports — are significant, and that they have a right to due process when their constitutional rights are infringed.

He also said the concerns about erroneous placement on the list are legitimate.

"There is no evidence, or contention, that any of these plaintiffs satisfy the definition of a 'known terrorist," Trenga wrote. And the alternate standard for placement — that of a "suspected terrorist" — can easily be triggered by innocent conduct that is misconstrued, he said.

The watchlist, also known as the Terrorist Screening Database, is maintained by the FBI and shared with a variety of federal agencies. Customs officers have access to the list to check people coming into the country at border crossings, and aviation officials use the database to help form the no-fly list, which is a much smaller subset of the broader watchlist.

The watchlist has grown significantly over the years. As of June 2017, approximately 1.16 million people were included on the watchlist, according to government documents filed in the lawsuit. In 2013, the number was only 680,000. The vast majority are foreigners, but according to the government, there are roughly 4,600 U.S. citizens and lawful permanent residents on the watchlist as of 2017.

Abbas argued at a court hearing earlier this year that the intrusions imposed on those listed are all for naught and that the list is worthless in terms of preventing terrorism. He noted that Omar Mateen, the man who shot and killed 49 people at an Orlando nightclub in 2016, was at one time on the list but was later removed from it. Others who have committed terrorist acts have never even been included on the watchlist.

The suit was filed in 2016, and has exposed previously unknown details about the list and how it is disseminated. In particular, government lawyers acknowledged after years of denials that more than 500 private entities are given access to the list. Government lawyers describe those private agencies as "law enforcement adjacent" and include university police forces, and security forces and hospitals, railroads and even animal-welfare organizations.

Abbas said the revelations about the government's actions have come after years of dismissive responses from government officials who accused CAIR and others of paranoia, and that people are now paying more attention to the civil-rights implications of watchlisting.

Earlier this year, the House of Representatives adopted a proposal from Democratic Minnesota Rep. Ilhan Omar that would force President Donald Trump's administration to disclose details about how it shares the watchlist with foreign countries.

First published on September 5, 2019 / 7:39 AM

© 2019 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

11 migrant parents separated from kids can return to U.S.: Judge

The federal judge found that some of the migrants might have been forced into authorizing their deportation, so they should be let back into the U.S. so they can reunite with their children

2H ago Boy Separated from Mother By Zero Tolerance Border Policy Welcomed Home In Guatemala forian-5a-090519.jpg

Reinvigorated Dorian lashing coasts of North and South Carolina

It's a Category 3 storm again and could bring hurricane conditions including dangerous storm surges to the area today

updated 23M ago forian-5a-090519.jpg Bahamas Relief Effort Begins in Wake of Dorian Destruction

"Everything is gone": Survivors describe horrors of facing Hurricane Dorian

"CBS Evening News" anchor Norah O'Donnell spoke with survivors, who described the horrors of facing Dorian

12H ago Bahamas Relief Effort Begins in Wake of Dorian Destruction Britain — Brexit

Boris Johnson suffers Brexit vote defeat

Members of Parliament are terrified of a so-called "no-deal Brexit," fearing it would cause chaos and even food shortages

12H ago Britain — Brexit APTOPIX Britain Brexit

What comes next with Brexit? Here's why no one knows

If all the talk of political rebellions, possible elections, and shutting down Parliament has your head spinning, you're not alone

16H ago APTOPIX Britain Brexit en0608vancleave.jpg

Judge rules that terror watchlist violates constitutional rights

Plaintiffs said they were wrongly placed on the list and that the government's process for adding names is overbroad and riddled with errors

12M ago en0608vancleave.jpg Police Chokehold-Death

NYPD arrests plunge since cop fired for chokehold death

The trend points to a possible slowdown amid a heated response to the firing from the officers' union

30M ago Police Chokehold-Death Kevin Hart

911 call from Kevin Hart car crash released: "He's hurting"

It remains unclear how the accident will affect Hart, who has emerged from his roots in standup comedy to become one a major Hollywood star

1H ago Kevin Hart Boy Separated from Mother By Zero Tolerance Border Policy Welcomed Home In Guatemala

11 migrant parents separated from kids can return to U.S.: Judge

The federal judge found that some of the migrants might have been forced into authorizing their deportation, so they should be let back into the U.S. so they can reunite with their children

2H ago Boy Separated from Mother By Zero Tolerance Border Policy Welcomed Home In Guatemala forian-5a-090519.jpg

Reinvigorated Dorian lashing coasts of North and South Carolina

It's a Category 3 storm again and could bring hurricane conditions including dangerous storm surges to the area today

updated 23M ago forian-5a-090519.jpg en0608vancleave.jpg

Judge rules that terror watchlist violates constitutional rights

Plaintiffs said they were wrongly placed on the list and that the government's process for adding names is overbroad and riddled with errors

12M ago en0608vancleave.jpg Boy Separated from Mother By Zero Tolerance Border Policy Welcomed Home In Guatemala

11 migrant parents separated from kids can return to U.S.: Judge

The federal judge found that some of the migrants might have been forced into authorizing their deportation, so they should be let back into the U.S. so they can reunite with their children

2H ago Boy Separated from Mother By Zero Tolerance Border Policy Welcomed Home In Guatemala Trump

Trump displays seemingly edited map of Dorian's projected path

Trump is claiming ignorance Wednesday after a map of Hurricane Dorian's projected path appeared to be altered with a black pen

9H ago Trump House Judiciary Committee Votes On Subpoena For Full Mueller Report

GOP Representative Jim Sensenbrenner to retire

The second-longest serving current member of the House became the 15th GOP lawmaker to announce he won't run for re-election in 2020. Representatives Susan Davis and Bill Flores also announced their retirement

10H ago House Judiciary Committee Votes On Subpoena For Full Mueller Report The Late Show with Stephen Colbert

Biden defends gaffes on Colbert, jokingly calls him Jimmy Kimmel

"Any gaffe that I have made — and I've made gaffes like every politician I know has — have been not about the substance of issue," Biden said

9H ago The Late Show with Stephen Colbert FILE PHOTO: Opera singer Placido Domingo sits during an event at the Manhattan School of Music in New York

Several more women accuse Placido Domingo of sexual harassment

The Associated Press says a spokeswoman for the opera legend disputes the allegations, which follow similar ones reported by the AP last month

3H ago FILE PHOTO: Opera singer Placido Domingo sits during an event at the Manhattan School of Music in New York Mac Miller

Man arrested in connection to Mac Miller's death

Cameron James Pettit, 28, was taken into custody and has been charged with one count of distribution of a controlled substance

9H ago Mac Miller The Late Show with Stephen Colbert

Biden defends gaffes on Colbert, jokingly calls him Jimmy Kimmel

"Any gaffe that I have made — and I've made gaffes like every politician I know has — have been not about the substance of issue," Biden said

9H ago The Late Show with Stephen Colbert gettyimages-598763578.jpg

Twitter moves to foil hackers after Chloe Grace Moretz's feed hijacked

A tweet from the Hollywood actress's account claimed to reveal Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey's Social Security number

14H ago gettyimages-598763578.jpg Premiere Of Weinstein Company "Vicky Cristina Barcelona" - Arrivals

Scarlet Johansson says she believes Woody Allen

"I see Woody whenever I can, and I have had a lot of conversations with him about it," Johansson said

16H ago Premiere Of Weinstein Company "Vicky Cristina Barcelona" - Arrivals Little baby girl fastened with security belt in safety car seat.

Carmakers to add alerts to prevent child heatstroke deaths

Automakers agree to install technology by 2025 to remind people to retrieve children from a vehicle's back seat

13H ago Little baby girl fastened with security belt in safety car seat. gettyimages-598763578.jpg

Twitter moves to foil hackers after Chloe Grace Moretz's feed hijacked

A tweet from the Hollywood actress's account claimed to reveal Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey's Social Security number

14H ago gettyimages-598763578.jpg US-LAWS-ABORTION

Need birth control? Planned Parenthood has an app for that

In 27 states, Planned Parenthood patients will be able to purchase birth control options through a new mobile app

17H ago US-LAWS-ABORTION phishing

Ransomware attacks on rise — and small towns are in crosshairs

"We see them because attackers see that they're successful," said one cybersecurity pro of spike in municipal hacks

18H ago phishing FRANCE-INTERNET-TECHNOLOGY-LEWEB12

Google fined $170 million for violating kids' privacy on YouTube

Video platform illegally harvested children's online data without getting their parents' consent, FTC says

13H ago FRANCE-INTERNET-TECHNOLOGY-LEWEB12 0904-ctm-dorianandclimate-berardelli-1926258-640x360.jpg

Is climate change making hurricanes more powerful?

"Almost all the research shows that in the future, hurricanes are likely to get more intense," meteorologist Jeff Berardelli says

18H ago 0904-ctm-dorianandclimate-berardelli-1926258-640x360.jpg Greenpeace Protests Outside DNC Headquarters Urging The Party To Hold A Climate Change Debate

Where the 2020 candidates stand on climate change

Many of the Democratic candidates will be defending their climate plans in six-hour town hall event Wednesday

19H ago Greenpeace Protests Outside DNC Headquarters Urging The Party To Hold A Climate Change Debate Prince Harry — Travalyst

Prince Harry launches travel sustainability initiative

While making the announcement, he also addressed the recent controversy over his and Meghan Markle's use of private jets last month

Sep 3 Prince Harry — Travalyst 0903-ctm-dorianbahamas-begnaud-1925436-640x360.jpg

Devastating images show Dorian ravaging the Bahamas

The deadly storm, which was stuck in place over the island nation, has been pounding the northern Bahamas for nearly two days

Sep 3 0903-ctm-dorianbahamas-begnaud-1925436-640x360.jpg edijejuxyaat-90.jpg

Intense hurricanes like Dorian cause 1,000 times more damage

Research shows Category 5 hurricanes do exponentially greater damage – and we're seeing them much more frequently

Sep 3 edijejuxyaat-90.jpg US-LAWS-ABORTION

Need birth control? Planned Parenthood has an app for that

In 27 states, Planned Parenthood patients will be able to purchase birth control options through a new mobile app

17H ago US-LAWS-ABORTION craig-oxycontin-lawsuit-3-2017-3-29.jpg

Purdue Pharma prepping for a bankruptcy, report says

Lawyers for opioid peddler Purdue Pharma have documents in works for a Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing, Reuters reports

16H ago craig-oxycontin-lawsuit-3-2017-3-29.jpg vaping-closeup-620.jpg

Michigan becomes first state to ban flavored e-cigarettes

Governor Gretchen Whitmer accuses e-cigarette companies of using sweet flavors to hook young people on nicotine

20H ago vaping-closeup-620.jpg istock-181397947.jpg

Breaking bad habits of sugary sodas and junk food

New studies find diets consisting mainly of junk foods and sugar-sweetened soft drinks can have devastating, even deadly, health impacts

20H ago istock-181397947.jpg teen-vaping.jpg

Oregon death from lung illness may be linked to vaping

Oregon health officials say they are investigating the death of a person who had severe respiratory illness after using an e-cigarette

21H ago teen-vaping.jpg 22 Dead And 26 Injured In Mass Shooting At Shopping Center In El Paso

Family sues Walmart after both parents were shot in El Paso attack

Lawsuit alleges the retailer failed to protect customers — father remains hospitalized in critical condition

13H ago 22 Dead And 26 Injured In Mass Shooting At Shopping Center In El Paso FRANCE-INTERNET-TECHNOLOGY-LEWEB12

Google fined $170M for violating kids' privacy on YouTube

Video platform illegally harvested children's online data without getting their parents' consent, FTC says

13H ago FRANCE-INTERNET-TECHNOLOGY-LEWEB12 phishing

Ransomware attacks on rise — and small towns are in crosshairs

"We see them because attackers see that they're successful," said one cybersecurity pro of spike in municipal hacks

18H ago phishing craig-oxycontin-lawsuit-3-2017-3-29.jpg

Purdue Pharma prepping for a bankruptcy, report says

Lawyers for opioid peddler Purdue Pharma have documents in works for a Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing, Reuters reports

16H ago craig-oxycontin-lawsuit-3-2017-3-29.jpg 4-ways-walmart-is-courting-millennials-5d643cfbd18735000164ffe5-1-aug-26-2019-20-13-28-poster.jpg

Will Walmart's new ammo policy reduce guns on the street?

Because most firearms sales stem from thousands of small gun shops or gun shows, Walmart's impact is unclear

22H ago 4-ways-walmart-is-courting-millennials-5d643cfbd18735000164ffe5-1-aug-26-2019-20-13-28-poster.jpg billy-jack-crutsinger-horizontal.png

Texas man gives 4 minute statement before execution

Billy Jack Crutsinger, 64, received a lethal injection Wednesday evening at the state penitentiary in Huntsville

9H ago billy-jack-crutsinger-horizontal.png ap6608010465.jpg

America's deadliest mass shootings

These are the deadliest mass shootings in American history

Aug 5 40 photos ap6608010465.jpg Mac Miller

Man arrested in connection to Mac Miller's death

Cameron James Pettit, 28, was taken into custody and has been charged with one count of distribution of a controlled substance

9H ago Mac Miller cbsn-fusion-cameron-james-pettit-arrested-mac-miller-death-today-2019-09-04-thumbnail-1927073-640x360.jpg

Man arrested in Mac Miller's death

Cameron James Pettit, 28, is in custody Wednesday on federal charges. Pettit allegedly sold counterfeit pharmaceutical narcotics containing fentanyl to rapper Mac Miller two days before he died of a drug overdose last year. CBSN's Elaine Quijano has more.

10H ago 00:42 cbsn-fusion-cameron-james-pettit-arrested-mac-miller-death-today-2019-09-04-thumbnail-1927073-640x360.jpg cbsn-fusion-greg-craig-not-guilty-lying-to-department-of-justice-2019-09-04-thumbnail-1927090-640x360.jpg

Greg Craig found not guilty of lying to DOJ

Greg Craig, a prominent Democratic attorney and former White House counsel, was found not guilty of lying to the Justice Department about work he had done on behalf of Ukraine in 2012. A federal jury in Washington acquitted Craig after less than four hours of deliberation Wednesday.

10H ago 01:00 cbsn-fusion-greg-craig-not-guilty-lying-to-department-of-justice-2019-09-04-thumbnail-1927090-640x360.jpg cbsn-fusion-president-trump-announces-the-u-s-space-command-is-open-as-part-of-an-approach-to-better-defend-american.jpg

Space

Trump launches U.S. Space Command

President Trump held a Rose Garden event to commemorate the establishment of the U.S. Space Command Thursday, as the president pushes for the creation of his sixth branch of the military, the Space Force. CBS News' Bofta Yimam reports.

Aug 29 01:53 cbsn-fusion-president-trump-announces-the-u-s-space-command-is-open-as-part-of-an-approach-to-better-defend-american.jpg Hurricane Dorian leaves the Caribbean Sea and tracks toward the Florida coast in this NOAA satellite image taken at 10:20 a.m. ET August 29, 2019.

Kennedy Space Center bracing for Hurricane Dorian

NASA is hauling a massive launch gantry off the launch pad to avoid the threat of hurricane winds

Aug 29 Hurricane Dorian leaves the Caribbean Sea and tracks toward the Florida coast in this NOAA satellite image taken at 10:20 a.m. ET August 29, 2019. cbsn-fusion-trump-space-command-ceremony-2019-08-29-thumbnail-1923152-640x360.jpg

Trump establishes U.S. Space Command

President Trump marked the establishment of the U.S. Space Command in the Rose Garden, and unveiled its flag for the first time during a ceremony Thursday afternoon.

Aug 29 03:49 cbsn-fusion-trump-space-command-ceremony-2019-08-29-thumbnail-1923152-640x360.jpg Trump

Trump marks establishment of U.S. Space Command

The president's "Space Force" must receive congressional approval

Aug 29 Trump 082719-hop1.jpg

SpaceX launches "Starhopper" test flight

The Starhopper is testing propulsion systems that will be used in SpaceX's planned heavy lift Starship spacecraft

Aug 27 082719-hop1.jpg Washington Redskins v New England Patriots

Highest-paid NFL players in 2019, ranked

These are the NFL superstars who earn the most cash this season

Aug 29 50 photos Washington Redskins v New England Patriots ashleyfallisparents.jpg

Ashley Fallis death: A family's fight for justice

Was the Colorado mother's 2012 death a suicide, as her husband maintains, or was it murder, as her parents insist?

Aug 24 15 photos ashleyfallisparents.jpg intro-slide.jpg

World's most polluted cities

Air pollution can cause serious health problems for people who are exposed to it, even for just a few minutes

Aug 23 51 photos intro-slide.jpg Fire in an area of the Amazon rainforest near Humaita, Brazil

Pictures from the Amazon rainforest fires

A record number of fires have devastated the Amazon rainforest in Brazil and neighboring countries

Aug 22 30 photos Fire in an area of the Amazon rainforest near Humaita, Brazil corbett-1.jpg

Jason Corbett murder: A look at the evidence

In August 2015, former FBI agent Tom Martens and his daughter Molly Corbett admitted killing her Irish-born husband Jason Corbett, insisting they beat him in self-defense with a brick paver and a baseball bat because Jason was choking Molly and threatening to kill her

Aug 17 11 photos corbett-1.jpg mcdowell-sneakpeek-1428191-640x360.jpg

Popular

Sneak peek: Storm of Suspicion

"48 Hours" goes behind the scenes with investigators as they search for a mother of two who vanished just before Hurricane Harvey hit. Correspondent Maureen Maher investigates. Watch Saturday, September 7 at 9/8c on CBS.

14H ago 03:39 mcdowell-sneakpeek-1428191-640x360.jpg 0905-ctm-doriansearch-battiste-1927217-640x360.jpg

Man searches for son lost in Dorian

The race is on to find survivors in the Bahamas, after Hurricane Dorian flattened some of the islands. The monster storm battered the area for 48 hours, and thousands of people remain unaccounted for. CBS News spoke with one man who was separated from his young son when the hurricane hit his home on Abaco Island. Nikki Battiste reports.

updated 3M ago 03:02 0905-ctm-doriansearch-battiste-1927217-640x360.jpg 0905-ctm-bahamasaftermath-odonnell-1927203-640x360.jpg

Aerial view shows devastation in the Bahamas

CBS News got an exclusive look with the U.S. Coast Guard at the damage in the Bahamas from the air. “CBS Evening News” anchor Norah O’Donnell also met Robert and Phyllis Cornea, who are seeking refuge in Nassau. The couple say the Category 5 storm destroyed their home in Abaco, the island they lived on for more than 50 years.

updated 20M ago 01:49 0905-ctm-bahamasaftermath-odonnell-1927203-640x360.jpg master-influencers-1920x1080-1917185-640x360.jpg

Kid influencers: Few rules, big money

Being a social media influencer is now considered one of the most popular career aspirations for millennials and Gen Z. But experts warn that regulations need to be put in place as younger and younger influencers share their lives on camera. This episode of CBSN Originals looks at the lives of three families whose kids are popular influencers on social media, while exploring some of the dangers implicit in the “kidfluencer” industry.

Aug 23 23:06 master-influencers-1920x1080-1917185-640x360.jpg 0905-ctm-trumpweatherreport-tracy-1927211-640x360.jpg

Trump stands by inaccurate claim about Dorian

President Trump is at the center of a hurricane controversy Thursday morning, as he stands by his inaccurate claim about the states threatened by Hurricane Dorian. At a briefing Wednesday, the president displayed a forecast map that appeared to be altered with a black line showing Dorian possibly striking Alabama, backing a claim he previously made on Twitter. Ben Tracy reports.

updated 20M ago 01:44 0905-ctm-trumpweatherreport-tracy-1927211-640x360.jpg