North Carolina judge rejects state legislative district maps drawn for GOP advantage

/ AP

Significance of SCOTUS redistricting ruling

A North Carolina judicial panel rejected state legislative district maps Tuesday, saying legislators took extreme advantage in drawing voting districts to help elect a maximum number of Republican lawmakers. The judges gave lawmakers two weeks to try again.

The three-judge panel of state trial judges unanimously ruled that courts can step in to decide when partisan advantage goes so far it diminishes democracy. Their ruling comes after the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in June in a separate case involving North Carolina's congressional map that it's not the job of federal courts to decide if boundaries are politically unfair — though state courts could consider whether gerrymandering stands up under state laws and constitutions.

The state judges found that the way the majority-Republican General Assembly redrew legislative district maps in 2017 violated the rights of Democratic voters under the state constitution's equal protection and freedom of assembly clauses.

Trending News

"Partisan intent predominated over all other redistricting criteria resulting in extreme partisan gerrymandered legislative maps," the judges wrote. "The effect of these carefully crafted partisan maps is that, in all but the most unusual election scenarios, the Republican Party will control a majority of both chambers of the General Assembly. In other words, the court finds that in many election environments, it is the carefully crafted maps, and not the will of the voters, that dictate the election outcomes in a significant number of legislative districts and, ultimately, the majority control of the General Assembly."

Rep. David Lewis, a chief defendant in the case, declined to comment. Senate leader Phil Berger said senators would follow the court's instructions and adopt "a nonpartisan map," but his prepared statement didn't explicitly rule out a possible appeal.

The court gave lawmakers until Sept. 18 to again redraw maps to be used in next year's elections. The judges said they would appoint an outside referee to advise them in next steps, including drawing maps if lawmakers miss their Sept. 18 deadline.

The judges also raised the possibility they would postpone the state's March primary for legislature or other offices if they feel it's necessary.

Redistricting is the process of redrawing voting districts for state legislatures and Congress after every decennial census. Gerrymandering describes when the redistricting is slanted to give one political party a majority in as many districts as possible. North Carolina's legislative districts were redrawn in 2017 after a federal court determined they were an illegal gerrymander that sought to weaken the voting strength of minority voters.

But the group Common Cause and more than 30 registered Democratic voters sued, saying the 2017 districts were still so gerrymandered they unconstitutionally insulated Republicans from changes in voting behavior.

Lawyers for Republican state legislators argued there was no clear way for judges to know what kinds of map-making are unacceptable, since "redistricting is political because of what it is, not because of who does it." Any complaints about how districts were drawn would vanish if Democrats could lead some GOP voters to change their minds and voted with them, GOP lawyers said.

If state courts ultimately rule in favor of Democrats, they could order new district maps for next year's legislative elections. Lawmakers winning those elections will draw up maps after the 2020 census to last for the following decade, again influencing political power in the country's ninth-largest state.

The lawsuit contended that most of the 170 House and Senate districts drawn in 2017 violated the plaintiffs' free speech and association protections under the state constitution. It also said the boundaries violated a constitutional provision stating "all elections shall be free," because the maps are rigged to predetermine electoral outcomes and virtually ensure Republican control of the legislature.

The three-judge panel agreed Tuesday that part of the state constitution was violated.

The ruling appears to meet the request of plaintiffs by ordering that nearly half of state House districts and 21 of 50 Senate maps redrawn quickly, Common Cause NC spokesman Bryan Warner said.

The judges also imposed rules on a new round of redistricting. The new mapmaking must start from scratch, all map-drawing must occur at public hearings with computer screens visible to everyone and any consultants hired by lawmakers must be approved by the court.

Evidence introduced during the two-week trial in July included computer records created by Tom Hofeller, a now-dead GOP redistricting guru who helped draw the 2017 legislative maps. Those files, collected by Hofeller's estranged daughter after his death and shared with Common Cause, showed that Republican advantage was the overall objective of the latest redistricting.

Some of Hofeller's files were also used in separate litigation in New York challenging a plan by President Donald Trump's administration to include a citizenship question on the 2020 U.S. census.

The North Carolina lawsuit marks at least the eighth legal action challenging state election district maps since the current round of redistricting began in 2011. The lawsuits resulted in redrawing congressional lines in 2016 and legislative districts in 2017 — both to address racial bias.

First published on September 4, 2019 / 7:26 AM

© 2019 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Dorian leaves neighborhoods flattened and homes shredded in the Bahamas

The horrifying magnitude of the storm's destruction leaves parts of the island nation in ruins and underwater, in what the prime minister calls one of the the greatest national crises in Bahamian history

31M ago Aerial view shows devastation after hurricane Dorian hit the Abaco Islands in the Bahamas Unrest In Hong Kong During Anti-Government Protests

Hong Kong leader caves on key demand by protesters, but is it enough?

Beijing-appointed Chief Executive Carrie Lam will withdraw the extradition bill that sparked the anger, but protest leaders say it's too little, too late

updated 20M ago Unrest In Hong Kong During Anti-Government Protests

Dorian begins slow trek nudging U.S. coastline

Hurricane left "apocalyptic" damage in Bahamas, where death toll is expected to rise

1H ago  Prince Harry — Travalyst

Prince Harry launches travel sustainability initiative

While making the announcement, he also addressed the recent controversy over his and Meghan Markle's use of private jets last month

11H ago Prince Harry — Travalyst 0903-ctm-dorianbahamas-begnaud-1925436-640x360.jpg

Devastating images show Dorian ravaging the Bahamas

The deadly storm, which was stuck in place over the island nation, has been pounding the northern Bahamas for nearly two days

12H ago 0903-ctm-dorianbahamas-begnaud-1925436-640x360.jpg cbsn-fusion-north-carolina-congressional-map-redo-thumbnail-1478685-640x360.jpg

North Carolina judge rejects district maps drawn for GOP advantage

A panel says legislators took extreme advantage in drawing voting districts to help elect a maximum number of Republican lawmakers

14M ago cbsn-fusion-north-carolina-congressional-map-redo-thumbnail-1478685-640x360.jpg rtx1km3a.jpg

ACLU pushes House to oppose bill criminalizing domestic terrorism

The ACLU said the bill would unnecessarily expand authorities used by the Trump administration to target and discriminate against the very communities Congress hopes to protect

23M ago rtx1km3a.jpg US-ACCIDENT-BOAT

Man loses 5 family members in boat fire: "Complete nightmare"

"You want to hold onto that 1%. But at this point, my heart knows," Domenic Selga said after deadly boat fire

24M ago US-ACCIDENT-BOAT kayivey.jpg

Alabama governor will not step down over blackface skit

Ivey, 74, reiterated that she was wrong to appear in the skit over 50 years ago and that it does not reflect who she is today.

29M ago kayivey.jpg cbsnews-intelligence-matters-podcast-horizontal-620x350.jpg

Transcript: Kristin Wood on "Intelligence Matters"

In this episode of Intelligence Matters, host Michael Morell speaks with former CIA officer Kristin Wood about the process, substance and value of the agency's analytic work

1H ago cbsnews-intelligence-matters-podcast-horizontal-620x350.jpg cbsn-fusion-north-carolina-congressional-map-redo-thumbnail-1478685-640x360.jpg

North Carolina judge rejects district maps drawn for GOP advantage

A panel says legislators took extreme advantage in drawing voting districts to help elect a maximum number of Republican lawmakers

14M ago cbsn-fusion-north-carolina-congressional-map-redo-thumbnail-1478685-640x360.jpg rtx1km3a.jpg

ACLU pushes House to oppose bill criminalizing domestic terrorism

The ACLU said the bill would unnecessarily expand authorities used by the Trump administration to target and discriminate against the very communities Congress hopes to protect

23M ago rtx1km3a.jpg kayivey.jpg

Alabama governor will not step down over blackface skit

Ivey, 74, reiterated that she was wrong to appear in the skit over 50 years ago and that it does not reflect who she is today.

29M ago kayivey.jpg cbsnews-intelligence-matters-podcast-horizontal-620x350.jpg

Transcript: Kristin Wood on "Intelligence Matters"

In this episode of Intelligence Matters, host Michael Morell speaks with former CIA officer Kristin Wood about the process, substance and value of the agency's analytic work

1H ago cbsnews-intelligence-matters-podcast-horizontal-620x350.jpg harvard.jpg

Palestinian Harvard freshman kept out of U.S. allowed in, after all

He was denied entry at Boston's Logan Airport but is in U.S. now on student visa; administration staying mum on why he was blocked in first place

2H ago harvard.jpg Prince Harry — Travalyst

Prince Harry launches travel sustainability initiative

While making the announcement, he also addressed the recent controversy over his and Meghan Markle's use of private jets last month

11H ago Prince Harry — Travalyst untitled-collage.jpg

Ariana Grande sues Forever 21 over look-alike ads

Grande's $10 million lawsuit claims the clothing company ripped lyrics, color schemes and clothes from her "7 Rings" video

10H ago untitled-collage.jpg Premiere Of Warner Bros. Pictures' "Central Intelligence" - Arrivals

After Kevin Hart car crash, "The Rock" posts emotional message

"We have a lot more laughing to do together. Love you man. Stay strong," Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson wrote on Instagram

12H ago Premiere Of Warner Bros. Pictures' "Central Intelligence" - Arrivals deepfake-zao.jpg

App for movie fans raises specter of "deepfake" technology

Zao allows users to place themselves inside movie or TV scenes, to "become" famous actors, but experts warn of threats to privacy

18H ago deepfake-zao.jpg untitled-1.jpg

Justin Bieber opens up about fame, admits drug use

Bieber credits his wife, Hailey Baldwin, as one of the people who helped turn his life around

16H ago untitled-1.jpg US-INTERNET-FACEBOOK-DEMONSTRATION

Facebook tells Homeland Security: Don't create fake accounts

Federal agency lets employees create phony online accounts to monitor people trying to enter the U.S.

14H ago US-INTERNET-FACEBOOK-DEMONSTRATION A Facebook Like Button logo is seen at t

Facebook considers hiding "like" counts in news feed

Drive to amass huge support for a post, a cornerstone of the "influencer" economy, is linked to poor mental health

14H ago A Facebook Like Button logo is seen at t deepfake-zao.jpg

App for movie fans raises specter of "deepfake" technology

Zao allows users to place themselves inside movie or TV scenes, to "become" famous actors, but experts warn of threats to privacy

18H ago deepfake-zao.jpg FRANCE-US-INTERNET-SOCIAL-NETWORK-INSTAGRAM

Instagram could be biggest target for 2020 disinformation

A new NYU study says Instagram is an "ideal venue" for spreading false information in the next presidential race

14H ago FRANCE-US-INTERNET-SOCIAL-NETWORK-INSTAGRAM People walk past logos of Huawei in Huaian

Huawei claims U.S. threatened employees and attacked network

Chinese telecommunications company says the U.S. is "using every tool at its disposal" to disrupt its business

18H ago People walk past logos of Huawei in Huaian Prince Harry — Travalyst

Prince Harry launches travel sustainability initiative

While making the announcement, he also addressed the recent controversy over his and Meghan Markle's use of private jets last month

11H ago Prince Harry — Travalyst 0903-ctm-dorianbahamas-begnaud-1925436-640x360.jpg

Devastating images show Dorian ravaging the Bahamas

The deadly storm, which was stuck in place over the island nation, has been pounding the northern Bahamas for nearly two days

12H ago 0903-ctm-dorianbahamas-begnaud-1925436-640x360.jpg edijejuxyaat-90.jpg

Intense hurricanes like Dorian cause 1,000 times more damage

Research shows Category 5 hurricanes do exponentially greater damage – and we're seeing them much more frequently

17H ago edijejuxyaat-90.jpg 0830-labgrownmeat-doane.jpg

Inside the labs creating meat from stem cells

High-tech laboratories in Israel are pioneering slaughter-free meat created out of cells from farm animal tissues. It's real steak and real chicken, but no animals are hurt.

Aug 30 0830-labgrownmeat-doane.jpg Texas Oil Companies Work To Adapt To Falling Oil Prices

Who are the biggest U.S. methane emitters?

Trump administration's move to weaken pollution rules is a missed opportunity to tackle a solvable climate problem

Aug 30 Texas Oil Companies Work To Adapt To Falling Oil Prices teen-vaping.jpg

New laws aim to curb nicotine use among teens

This week, three states joined 10 others in enacting laws that raise the legal age to buy any tobacco products to 21

12H ago teen-vaping.jpg RH, Restoration Hardware Celebrates the Unveiling of RH Nashville, The Gallery at Green Hills

Hardware store recalls flammable robes, lead-tainted furniture

California retailer recalls two products in U.S. and Canada due to safety issues, according to federal safety agency

13H ago RH, Restoration Hardware Celebrates the Unveiling of RH Nashville, The Gallery at Green Hills ap-17046031152190.jpg

Purdue University: We're not Purdue Pharma, OK?

Same name, different Purdue: Indiana school finds it must distance itself from pharma company tied to opioid crisis

16H ago ap-17046031152190.jpg Fried food

Doctors say diet of fries and chips made teen "fussy eater" blind

British doctors cite case of boy in England to warn that poor nutrition can permanently damage vision, along with everything else

21H ago Fried food 0902-en-bariatricsurgery-lapook-1925336-640x360.jpg

How bariatric surgery helps with more than weight loss

In addition, people who had the surgery were 41% less likely to die from any cause during the study

Sep 2 0902-en-bariatricsurgery-lapook-1925336-640x360.jpg US-weather-hurricane

Florida hit by price gouging ahead of Hurricane Dorian

State's attorney general has received more than 2,400 reports of price gouging on everything from gas to water

15H ago US-weather-hurricane FILE PHOTO: A police officer stands next to a police cordon after a mass shooting at a Walmart in El Paso

Walmart asks customers not to openly carry guns, halts some ammo sales

After shootings at two stores, retailer will also stop selling some ammunition and completely exit handgun market

12H ago FILE PHOTO: A police officer stands next to a police cordon after a mass shooting at a Walmart in El Paso 11065890-10153410265453274-8734805804163590015-n.jpg

Dorian closes DisneyWorld, Legoland and other Florida tourist sites

Air travel halted in and out of Orlando as Sunshine State readies for tropical force winds and rain

13H ago 11065890-10153410265453274-8734805804163590015-n.jpg untitled-collage.jpg

Ariana Grande sues Forever 21 over look-alike ads

Grande's $10 million lawsuit claims the clothing company ripped lyrics, color schemes and clothes from her "7 Rings" video

10H ago untitled-collage.jpg Dow Jones Industrials Average Opens Slightly Higher, After Yesterday's Large Drop

Stocks drop on new signs of trouble in manufacturing

A measure of manufacturing activity last month fell to a 3-year low — and this was before tariffs went into effect

14H ago Dow Jones Industrials Average Opens Slightly Higher, After Yesterday's Large Drop meghan-mccain-the-view-abc.png

"The View" co-host Meghan McCain sounds off on gun control

"The View" co-host warned there could be "violence" if people's guns are taken away from them

9H ago meghan-mccain-the-view-abc.png ap6608010465.jpg

America's deadliest mass shootings

These are the deadliest mass shootings in American history

Aug 5 40 photos ap6608010465.jpg moa-incident-tribute-1.jpg

Boy back home months after being thrown from mall balcony

"We are so thankful, and we rejoice in the Lord's blessings to our family," his family said

11H ago moa-incident-tribute-1.jpg FILE PHOTO: A police officer stands next to a police cordon after a mass shooting at a Walmart in El Paso

Walmart halts some ammo sales, asks customers not to openly carry guns

After shootings at two stores, retailer will also stop selling some ammunition and completely exit handgun market

12H ago FILE PHOTO: A police officer stands next to a police cordon after a mass shooting at a Walmart in El Paso Odessa, Texas, mass shooting

Details emerge on how Texas gunman obtained weapon

The gunman had purchased his assault-style rifle from a private seller and skirted a federal background check

12H ago Odessa, Texas, mass shooting cbsn-fusion-president-trump-announces-the-u-s-space-command-is-open-as-part-of-an-approach-to-better-defend-american.jpg

Space

Trump launches U.S. Space Command

President Trump held a Rose Garden event to commemorate the establishment of the U.S. Space Command Thursday, as the president pushes for the creation of his sixth branch of the military, the Space Force. CBS News' Bofta Yimam reports.

Aug 29 01:53 cbsn-fusion-president-trump-announces-the-u-s-space-command-is-open-as-part-of-an-approach-to-better-defend-american.jpg Hurricane Dorian leaves the Caribbean Sea and tracks toward the Florida coast in this NOAA satellite image taken at 10:20 a.m. ET August 29, 2019.

Kennedy Space Center bracing for Hurricane Dorian

NASA is hauling a massive launch gantry off the launch pad to avoid the threat of hurricane winds

Aug 29 Hurricane Dorian leaves the Caribbean Sea and tracks toward the Florida coast in this NOAA satellite image taken at 10:20 a.m. ET August 29, 2019. cbsn-fusion-trump-space-command-ceremony-2019-08-29-thumbnail-1923152-640x360.jpg

Trump establishes U.S. Space Command

President Trump marked the establishment of the U.S. Space Command in the Rose Garden, and unveiled its flag for the first time during a ceremony Thursday afternoon.

Aug 29 03:49 cbsn-fusion-trump-space-command-ceremony-2019-08-29-thumbnail-1923152-640x360.jpg Trump

Trump marks establishment of U.S. Space Command

The president's "Space Force" must receive congressional approval

Aug 29 Trump 082719-hop1.jpg

SpaceX launches "Starhopper" test flight

The Starhopper is testing propulsion systems that will be used in SpaceX's planned heavy lift Starship spacecraft

Aug 27 082719-hop1.jpg Washington Redskins v New England Patriots

Highest-paid NFL players in 2019, ranked

These are the NFL superstars who earn the most cash this season

Aug 29 50 photos Washington Redskins v New England Patriots ashleyfallisparents.jpg

Ashley Fallis death: A family's fight for justice

Was the Colorado mother's 2012 death a suicide, as her husband maintains, or was it murder, as her parents insist?

Aug 24 15 photos ashleyfallisparents.jpg intro-slide.jpg

World's most polluted cities

Air pollution can cause serious health problems for people who are exposed to it, even for just a few minutes

Aug 23 51 photos intro-slide.jpg Fire in an area of the Amazon rainforest near Humaita, Brazil

Pictures from the Amazon rainforest fires

A record number of fires have devastated the Amazon rainforest in Brazil and neighboring countries

Aug 22 30 photos Fire in an area of the Amazon rainforest near Humaita, Brazil corbett-1.jpg

Jason Corbett murder: A look at the evidence

In August 2015, former FBI agent Tom Martens and his daughter Molly Corbett admitted killing her Irish-born husband Jason Corbett, insisting they beat him in self-defense with a brick paver and a baseball bat because Jason was choking Molly and threatening to kill her

Aug 17 11 photos corbett-1.jpg 0904-ctm-borderfundinglatest-tracy-1926191-640x360.jpg

Popular

Dems slam Trump's border wall funding plan

The Trump administration is diverting billions of dollars from military projects to pay for 175 miles of the president's border wall along the U.S.-Mexico border, a key campaign promise. There are 11 different wall projects, including new and replacement barriers. Ben Tracy reports.

updated 3M ago 01:11 0904-ctm-borderfundinglatest-tracy-1926191-640x360.jpg 0904-ctm-brexitdefeat-phillips-1926188-640x360.jpg

U.K. PM Boris Johnson faces Brexit rebellion

British politics are in chaos Wednesday morning after a stunning setback for Prime Minister Boris Johnson. Opposition lawmakers are trying to pass a law to stop Johnson from taking Britain out of the EU without an agreement. A so-called “no deal" Brexit could send shockwaves through world economies, including that of the U.S. Mark Phillips reports.

updated 4M ago 02:06 0904-ctm-brexitdefeat-phillips-1926188-640x360.jpg 0904-ctm-boatvictims-oliver-1926177-640x360.jpg

Man loses five family members in CA boat fire

The Coast Guard has suspended its search for survivors following a deadly boat fire off the coast of California. Newly-released video shows the vessel burning near Santa Barbara Monday morning. Meg Oliver spoke with a man who lost five members of his own family.

updated 11M ago 02:57 0904-ctm-boatvictims-oliver-1926177-640x360.jpg master-influencers-1920x1080-1917185-640x360.jpg

Kid influencers: Few rules, big money

Being a social media influencer is now considered one of the most popular career aspirations for millennials and Gen Z. But experts warn that regulations need to be put in place as younger and younger influencers share their lives on camera. This episode of CBSN Originals looks at the lives of three families whose kids are popular influencers on social media, while exploring some of the dangers implicit in the “kidfluencer” industry.

Aug 23 23:06 master-influencers-1920x1080-1917185-640x360.jpg 0904-ctm-doriancharleston-yuccas-1926169-640x360.jpg

Dorian threatens South Carolina's coast

Hurricane Dorian is jeopardizing South Carolina's crumbling coastline. When the tide starts rising along the coast, even on a normal day, the water goes over the sidewalk. Now, with Dorian on the way, all of the state's coast is under storm surge watches or warnings, and a high tide of more than 10 feet is projected for Thursday. Nearly 250,000 people have left, rather than face up to seven feet of storm surge. Jamie Yuccas reports.

updated 15M ago 01:29 0904-ctm-doriancharleston-yuccas-1926169-640x360.jpg