Why Tom Steyer couldn't buy his way onto the debate stage

By Ben Mitchell, Zak Hudak

/ CBS News

Biden campaigns in South Carolina

Tom Steyer's campaign was confident he would make it into the September debate. With the help of a nearly $5 million online advertising blitz, the billionaire presidential candidate had scooped up the necessary 130,000 unique donors in just over a month, meeting the Democratic National Committee's donor threshold to qualify.

But he also had to meet the polling requirement. As the party's deadline approached, Steyer had notched the necessary 2% in three qualifying polls, meaning he needed just one more to make it into the debate. The campaign hoped for another in an early primary state, where Steyer had spent more than $8 million on TV ads in six weeks, according to Advertising Analytics — more than any candidate, including President Donald Trump.

That poll never materialized.

The campaign vented that there hadn't been a qualifying poll in Nevada, where Steyer spent $1.7 million and finished fifth in one survey that wasn't approved by the DNC. But several political strategists offered another possible reason Steyer's strategy came up short: No amount of paid media can match the influence of actual coverage, referred to in media parlance as "earned media."

"Advertising you pay for can increase your name recognition, but unless people are hearing about you from third parties like earned media that are reinforcing a real narrative, then it's not really going to go anywhere," said Robby Mook, campaign manager for Hillary Clinton's 2016 presidential run.

It can't be said that Steyer's failure to make the debate is just because of a lack of earned media. He also lacks the breakout charisma little-known candidates usually need to be successful, and his resumé — Exeter, Yale, Wall Street, hedge funds — would be an awkward fit for a party that's become more populist and progressive in recent years.

"There's nothing he's offered in an ad that has given people reason to abandon another candidate and support him," said one veteran Democratic strategist. "I don't know there's one he could have come up with. I don't think that it's just that they're missing the message."

But Steyer is still indicative of how the proliferation of political news outlets and the exponential growth of earned media opportunities have diluted the influence of paid media like television ads on primary voters.

"Never before in the history of mankind has there been so much earned media, especially as it relates to politics," said Terry Sullivan, the campaign manager for Marco Rubio's 2016 presidential run. "It used to be there was that ad and maybe for every 10 ads, there was one TV story on that candidate. Now, there's 10 TV stories for every one ad."

Sullivan said it was clear that paid media was losing its power when Barack Obama first won the presidency. In the 2016 election, Mr. Trump enjoyed about $5 billion worth of free media coverage during the election, according to analytics firm mediaQuant.

With nearly wall-to-wall media coverage that began with his trip down the escalator at Trump Tower to announce his presidential campaign, Mr. Trump rose in the polls. Despite outspending Mr. Trump on paid ads by more than $48 million, according to Advertising Analytics, the Rubio campaign was never able to catch up.

"Earned media is like a snowball if you do it right," said Scott Tranter, the former director of data science for the Rubio campaign. "Whether it's good bad or indifferent, it's going to be what propels you in the polls."

Even when the coverage of then-candidate Trump was negative, his poll numbers continued to climb.

"Donald Trump had gotten more earned media in the state of Iowa than we could have bought had we used all the money Rubio raised the end of his campaign," said Tranter. "Even though it was all bad earned media, at the end of December 2015 he was the leader in Iowa. We didn't have enough money to buy paid media to counteract it."

According to some strategists, while paid ads are still potent in a general election and for candidates down-ballot, their ability to drive a message is handicapped in a presidential primary contest.

"In these primaries, the Democrats are communicating on issues where there's very little difference between the candidates," said Democratic strategist Jesse Ferguson.

"The biggest factor for primary voters is whom they see as the right antidote to Trump and proving you're that answer is something you have to show people. You can't tell them. It's not something where you're going to run a silver bullet ad that suddenly catapults you to the nomination."

Earned media, strategists say, also carries more weight with voters because it isn't coming from a campaign or political group.

"People are massively skeptical of political advertising, period, full stop," Mook said. "The credibility plummets the second they hear those words, 'I approve this message.' It poisons the well immediately."

Strategists point out that the goal of the primary candidates right now is to qualify for the debates, which is among the more valuable forms of earned media a campaign can secure. Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, who has spent the most on advertising in the field other than Steyer, dropped out of the race after failing to qualify for the September debate.

Meanwhile, on Thursday Steyer was continuing his campaign in a push to qualify for the October debate, vying for headlines and news alerts with the release of his tax returns.

Asked if the Steyer campaign would be angling for more earned television appearances, press secretary Alberto Lammers laughed and said, "In order to get there, we'd have to get invited."

Adam Brewster contributed to this report.

First published on August 30, 2019 / 12:27 PM

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Dorian expected to be "extremely dangerous" as it heads for U.S.

The hurricane, already a Category 2, could be a Category 4 with 140 mph winds when it makes landfall, likely over Florida, forecasters say

updated 5M ago Hurricane Dorian approaches the coast of Florida PAKISTAN-INDIA-KASHMIR-KHAN

Pakistan warns of "genocide" as India is accused of torture in Kashmir

PM Imran Khan says Pakistan's "armed forces are ready" to respond if India launches attack to distract from alleged torture of civilians in Kashmir

2H ago PAKISTAN-INDIA-KASHMIR-KHAN Uganda Ebola Outbreak

Ebola kills girl in Uganda as outbreak death toll nears 3,000

Death of Congolese girl flagged as likely Ebola case at border checkpoint highlights risk of outbreak's spread as deaths near 3,000

4H ago Uganda Ebola Outbreak dead-staghorn-coral.png

Australia downgrades outlook for Great Barrier Reef over warming

Government agency changes health prognosis for world's biggest reef from "poor" to "very poor" as world's oceans warm up

6H ago dead-staghorn-coral.png FILE PHOTO: Demonstration demanding Hong Kong's leaders to step down and withdraw the extradition bill in Hong Kong

Hong Kong protest leaders arrested as police ban massive rally

Organizers cancel plans for demo as police refuse to allow it, saying they want to avoid any violence as fears mount of a military crackdown

4H ago FILE PHOTO: Demonstration demanding Hong Kong's leaders to step down and withdraw the extradition bill in Hong Kong Tom Steyer

Why Tom Steyer couldn't buy his way onto the debate stage

A massive ad blitz wasn't enough to get the billionaire activist into the September Democratic debate

4M ago Tom Steyer SWITZERLAND-ECONOMY-DIPLOMACY-POLITICS-DAVOS-SUMMIT

Billionaire Jack Ma says AI will lead to a 12-hour workweek

Alibaba founder predicts AI advancements will mean shorter workweeks for people — that might not be good news

8M ago SWITZERLAND-ECONOMY-DIPLOMACY-POLITICS-DAVOS-SUMMIT ryan-russell.jpg

NFL player Ryan Russell comes out as bisexual

In addition to his personal essay on ESPN, Russell also posted a photo of himself with his boyfriend on Instagram

18M ago ryan-russell.jpg 0830-ctm-ohioteenskilled-battiste.jpg

Police trying to determine if homeowner was justified in killing teens

Families of two teenagers demanding answers after homeowner kills Javier Harrison and Devin Henderson

1H ago 0830-ctm-ohioteenskilled-battiste.jpg doj-getty.jpg

Suspect arrested for plotting NYC attack in the name of ISIS

Sources say he was planning an attack in the New York City borough of Queens

1H ago doj-getty.jpg Tom Steyer

Why Tom Steyer couldn't buy his way onto the debate stage

A massive ad blitz wasn't enough to get the billionaire activist into the September Democratic debate

4M ago Tom Steyer nfa-werner-juul-investigation-needs-tracks-and-gfx-frame-325.jpg

Juul being investigated for role in teen vaping

Attorneys general in Illinois and Washington, D.C. are looking into how the company's vaping device became so popular with teens

2H ago nfa-werner-juul-investigation-needs-tracks-and-gfx-frame-325.jpg Trump Holds a Meeting with Members of his Cabinet

Preview: James Mattis on serving an "unusual president"

In his first TV interview since leaving the Trump Administration, the former secretary of defense urges caution, saying the rabid nature of politics today "could tear this country apart"

2H ago Trump Holds a Meeting with Members of his Cabinet 0830-ctm-bidenbacklash-garrett.jpg

Joe Biden unapologetic after reportedly mistelling military story

Joe Biden tells the story methodically and with great passion, but reportedly gets almost every key detail wrong. Biden says the essence of the story is true.

3H ago 0830-ctm-bidenbacklash-garrett.jpg FRANCE-HISTORY-WWII-DDAY-ANNIVERSARY

Trump looks to mental institutions as solution to gun violence

Mental health experts say that won't solve the gun violence crisis

3H ago FRANCE-HISTORY-WWII-DDAY-ANNIVERSARY 0830-facebooklive-fandango-1923614-640x360.jpg

Entertainment

What to watch in theaters this Fall with Fadango

Hollywood hopes some of the big Fall movie releases will boost box office sales after a slow summer. Adriana Diaz is in the Toyota Green Room with Erik Davis, managing editor of Fandango, to discuss the movies worth watching this fall.

updated 8M ago 08:29 0830-facebooklive-fandango-1923614-640x360.jpg screen-shot-2019-08-29-at-3-20-02-pm.png

Alex Trebek says his chemo is over

The "Jeopardy!" host also revealed another personal tidbit: who he would like to play him in a biopic

14H ago screen-shot-2019-08-29-at-3-20-02-pm.png Jessi Combs

Racer and TV personality dies trying to break speed record

It's unclear what led to the crash, which is under investigation

21H ago Jessi Combs 2015 American Music Awards - Arrivals

"Shark Tank" star involved in boat accident that left two dead

O'Leary issued a statement saying he was a passenger on the boat that crashed into another watercraft Saturday night

Aug 29 2015 American Music Awards - Arrivals screen-shot-2019-08-28-at-8-58-00-pm.png

Chanel Beauty hires first openly transgender model

"I am the first openly trans person to work for the house of Chanel, and I am deeply humbled and proud to represent my community," Teddy Quinlivan said

Aug 28 screen-shot-2019-08-28-at-8-58-00-pm.png SWITZERLAND-ECONOMY-DIPLOMACY-POLITICS-DAVOS-SUMMIT

Billionaire Jack Ma says AI will lead to a 12-hour workweek

Alibaba founder predicts AI advancements will mean shorter workweeks for people — that might not be good news

8M ago SWITZERLAND-ECONOMY-DIPLOMACY-POLITICS-DAVOS-SUMMIT 0829-ctm-ringprivacyconcerns-yuccas-1922791-640x360.jpg

Ring security system's work with police raises privacy concerns

The Amazon-owned doorbell camera company says more than 400 law enforcement agencies use its "Neighborhood Watch" program, giving police potential access to customers' videos

Aug 29 0829-ctm-ringprivacyconcerns-yuccas-1922791-640x360.jpg Mark Zuckerberg

Facebook tightens rules for political ads, but loopholes remain

Company says it will confirm the identity of organizations that buy ads related to social and political issues

Aug 28 Mark Zuckerberg apple-siri-620x442.jpg

Apple apologizes for workers who listened to Siri recordings

The tech giant said it will still listen to Siri recordings, but only if consumers give permission

Aug 28 apple-siri-620x442.jpg Amy Klobuchar

Klobuchar blasts Trump's handling of renewable fuels industry

The EPA granted 31 small refinery exemption waivers, meaning they don't have to comply with federally mandated levels of biofuels blended into gasoline

Aug 28 Amy Klobuchar Texas Oil Companies Work To Adapt To Falling Oil Prices

Who are the biggest U.S. methane emitters?

Trump administration's move to weaken pollution rules is a missed opportunity to tackle a solvable climate problem

1H ago Texas Oil Companies Work To Adapt To Falling Oil Prices dead-staghorn-coral.png

Australia downgrades outlook for Great Barrier Reef over warming

Government agency changes health prognosis for world's biggest reef from "poor" to "very poor" as world's oceans warm up

6H ago dead-staghorn-coral.png DNA and genetics research concept. Hand is holding glowing DNA molecule in hand.

Is there a "gay gene"? Major new study says no

There's no such thing as a single gene that drives a person's sexual behavior, according to the largest study ever done on the subject

15H ago DNA and genetics research concept. Hand is holding glowing DNA molecule in hand. Hurricane Dorian leaves the Caribbean Sea and tracks toward the Florida coast in this NOAA satellite image taken at 10:20 a.m. ET August 29, 2019.

Kennedy Space Center bracing for Hurricane Dorian

NASA is hauling a massive launch gantry off the launch pad to avoid the threat of hurricane winds

14H ago Hurricane Dorian leaves the Caribbean Sea and tracks toward the Florida coast in this NOAA satellite image taken at 10:20 a.m. ET August 29, 2019. arctic-tern-in-flight-sherri-obrien-promo.jpg

Nature up close: Masters of long-distance flight

Arctic terns fly further than any other animal on Earth, and during the course of their lives may travel 1.5 million miles

22H ago arctic-tern-in-flight-sherri-obrien-promo.jpg nfa-werner-juul-investigation-needs-tracks-and-gfx-frame-325.jpg

Juul being investigated for role in teen vaping

Attorneys general in Illinois and Washington, D.C. are looking into how the company's vaping device became so popular with teens

2H ago nfa-werner-juul-investigation-needs-tracks-and-gfx-frame-325.jpg Uganda Ebola Outbreak

Ebola kills girl in Uganda as outbreak death toll nears 3,000

Death of Congolese girl flagged as likely Ebola case at border checkpoint highlights risk of outbreak's spread as deaths near 3,000

4H ago Uganda Ebola Outbreak 0830-ctm-vapedectors-dokoupil.jpg

High school students doubt efforts to reduce teen vaping will work

Three New Jersey high school students spoke with "CBS This Morning" about whether new measures to curb teen vaping would actually work

1H ago 0830-ctm-vapedectors-dokoupil.jpg DNA and genetics research concept. Hand is holding glowing DNA molecule in hand.

Is there a "gay gene"? Major new study says no

There's no such thing as a single gene that drives a person's sexual behavior, according to the largest study ever done on the subject

15H ago DNA and genetics research concept. Hand is holding glowing DNA molecule in hand. young-person-vaping.jpg

Milwaukee urges residents to stop vaping immediately

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention​ said 193 people in 22 states have contracted severe respiratory illnesses after vaping

17H ago young-person-vaping.jpg Texas Oil Companies Work To Adapt To Falling Oil Prices

Who are the biggest U.S. methane emitters?

Trump administration's move to weaken pollution rules is a missed opportunity to tackle a solvable climate problem

1H ago Texas Oil Companies Work To Adapt To Falling Oil Prices US-FIRE-CALIFORNIA-ENVIORNMENT-WEATHER

After fires, many California homeowners can't get insurance

Insurance companies are saying, "We're done with you," one resident says, while others face soaring costs

1H ago US-FIRE-CALIFORNIA-ENVIORNMENT-WEATHER Peloton Tread treadmill

Peloton's CEO said it makes money — not even close

Streaming fitness company has lost $450 million over the past three years alone, its IPO filing reveals

22H ago Peloton Tread treadmill sacklers-1810859-640x360.jpg

Where did the Sacklers shift cash from their opioid maker?

A web of trusts and companies, some located in tax havens, may complicate efforts to reach a financial settlement

updated 17M ago sacklers-1810859-640x360.jpg Bed Bath & Beyond To Expand

Bed Bath & Beyond hires Goldman Sachs to explore asset sales

Retailer, which has seen its growth slow and shares slide. faces pressure from investors to turn things around

18H ago Bed Bath & Beyond To Expand 0830-ctm-ohioteenskilled-battiste.jpg

Police trying to determine if homeowner was justified in killing teens

Families of two teenagers demanding answers after homeowner kills Javier Harrison and Devin Henderson

1H ago 0830-ctm-ohioteenskilled-battiste.jpg ap6608010465.jpg

America's deadliest mass shootings

These are the deadliest mass shootings in American history

Aug 5 40 photos ap6608010465.jpg doj-getty.jpg

Suspect arrested for plotting NYC attack in the name of ISIS

Sources say he was planning an attack in the New York City borough of Queens

1H ago doj-getty.jpg cbsn-fusion-teen-arrested-for-alleged-isis-terror-plot-in-queens-new-york-thumbnail-1923585-640x360.jpg

Teen arrested for alleged ISIS plot in Queens

A 19-year-old is expected to appear in federal court today in connection with an alleged terror plot. Officials say he was planning a knife attack inspired by ISIS. Jenna DeAngelis reports for CBSN New York.

updated 45M ago 01:33 cbsn-fusion-teen-arrested-for-alleged-isis-terror-plot-in-queens-new-york-thumbnail-1923585-640x360.jpg 5d6912222ec46-image.jpg

Simone Biles' brother charged with triple murder

Tevin Biles-Thomas was arrested in connection with a triple homicide at a party on New Year's Eve

2H ago 5d6912222ec46-image.jpg cbsn-fusion-president-trump-announces-the-u-s-space-command-is-open-as-part-of-an-approach-to-better-defend-american.jpg

Space

Trump launches U.S. Space Command

President Trump held a Rose Garden event to commemorate the establishment of the U.S. Space Command Thursday, as the president pushes for the creation of his sixth branch of the military, the Space Force. CBS News' Bofta Yimam reports.

14H ago 01:53 cbsn-fusion-president-trump-announces-the-u-s-space-command-is-open-as-part-of-an-approach-to-better-defend-american.jpg Hurricane Dorian leaves the Caribbean Sea and tracks toward the Florida coast in this NOAA satellite image taken at 10:20 a.m. ET August 29, 2019.

Kennedy Space Center bracing for Hurricane Dorian

NASA is hauling a massive launch gantry off the launch pad to avoid the threat of hurricane winds

14H ago Hurricane Dorian leaves the Caribbean Sea and tracks toward the Florida coast in this NOAA satellite image taken at 10:20 a.m. ET August 29, 2019. cbsn-fusion-trump-space-command-ceremony-2019-08-29-thumbnail-1923152-640x360.jpg

Trump establishes U.S. Space Command

President Trump marked the establishment of the U.S. Space Command in the Rose Garden, and unveiled its flag for the first time during a ceremony Thursday afternoon.

18H ago 03:49 cbsn-fusion-trump-space-command-ceremony-2019-08-29-thumbnail-1923152-640x360.jpg Trump

Trump marks establishment of U.S. Space Command

The president's "Space Force" must receive congressional approval

14H ago Trump 082719-hop1.jpg

SpaceX launches "Starhopper" test flight

The Starhopper is testing propulsion systems that will be used in SpaceX's planned heavy lift Starship spacecraft

Aug 27 082719-hop1.jpg Washington Redskins v New England Patriots

Highest-paid NFL players in 2019, ranked

These are the NFL superstars who earn the most cash this season

18H ago 50 photos Washington Redskins v New England Patriots ashleyfallisparents.jpg

Ashley Fallis death: A family's fight for justice

Was the Colorado mother's 2012 death a suicide, as her husband maintains, or was it murder, as her parents insist?

Aug 24 15 photos ashleyfallisparents.jpg intro-slide.jpg

World's most polluted cities

Air pollution can cause serious health problems for people who are exposed to it, even for just a few minutes

Aug 23 51 photos intro-slide.jpg Fire in an area of the Amazon rainforest near Humaita, Brazil

Pictures from the Amazon rainforest fires

A record number of fires have devastated the Amazon rainforest in Brazil and neighboring countries

Aug 22 30 photos Fire in an area of the Amazon rainforest near Humaita, Brazil corbett-1.jpg

Jason Corbett murder: A look at the evidence

In August 2015, former FBI agent Tom Martens and his daughter Molly Corbett admitted killing her Irish-born husband Jason Corbett, insisting they beat him in self-defense with a brick paver and a baseball bat because Jason was choking Molly and threatening to kill her

Aug 17 11 photos corbett-1.jpg cbsn-fusion-how-much-do-voters-care-about-bidens-gaffes-thumbnail-1923609-640x360.jpg

Popular

Do voters care about Biden's gaffes?

Joe Biden has made a string of verbal slip-ups on the campaign trail, but as CBS News' Caitlin Huey-Burns reports, many voters in South Carolina are unbothered. She told CBSN's Reena Ninan, some think his gaffes make him more endearing.

updated 20M ago 03:32 cbsn-fusion-how-much-do-voters-care-about-bidens-gaffes-thumbnail-1923609-640x360.jpg 0830-cbsn-nhk-elizabethwarrenvotes-1923590-640x360.jpg

Can Warren win Native American votes?

Democratic presidential candidate Elizabeth Warren has received criticism on the campaign trail from Native American groups. Rebecca Nagle, a Cherokee citizen, writer, and advocate, joined CBSN to discuss what she wants to hear from the senator.

updated 45M ago 06:42 0830-cbsn-nhk-elizabethwarrenvotes-1923590-640x360.jpg cbsn-fusion-teen-arrested-for-alleged-isis-terror-plot-in-queens-new-york-thumbnail-1923585-640x360.jpg

Teen arrested for alleged ISIS plot in Queens

A 19-year-old is expected to appear in federal court today in connection with an alleged terror plot. Officials say he was planning a knife attack inspired by ISIS. Jenna DeAngelis reports for CBSN New York.

updated 45M ago 01:33 cbsn-fusion-teen-arrested-for-alleged-isis-terror-plot-in-queens-new-york-thumbnail-1923585-640x360.jpg master-influencers-1920x1080-1917185-640x360.jpg

Kid influencers: Few rules, big money

Being a social media influencer is now considered one of the most popular career aspirations for millennials and Gen Z. But experts warn that regulations need to be put in place as younger and younger influencers share their lives on camera. This episode of CBSN Originals looks at the lives of three families whose kids are popular influencers on social media, while exploring some of the dangers implicit in the “kidfluencer” industry.

Aug 23 23:06 master-influencers-1920x1080-1917185-640x360.jpg

Hong Kong protest leaders arrested

Hong Kong pro-democracy protesters Joshua Wong and Anges Chow have been arrested and then released on bail. Both have vowed to continue fighting for freedom. This comes as the Chinese military moves more troops into the area. CBS News foreign correspondent Ramy Inocencio has the latest from Hong Kong.

updated 3M ago 02:34