Trump wants to bring back mental institutions to address mass shootings

By Kathryn Watson

/ CBS News

Ex-fed: Trump "incorrect" on gun violence

President Trump says he wants to reopen mental institutions as a way to address mass shootings, an idea he pushed twice Thursday and has floated before.

The president's insistence that mental illness is the cause of mass shootings has disconcerted mental health professionals who insist that most people with mental illness are nonviolent. These experts also say people afflicted with mental illness are more likely to be the victims of violent crime than the perpetrator, and fear the president's language only further stigmatizes those struggling with mental health issues.

"I do want people to remember the words 'mental illness,'" the president told reporters on his way to a rally in New Hampshire Thursday afternoon, responding to a question about gun control.

Trending News

"These people are mentally ill and nobody talks about that. But these are mentally ill people, and people have to start thinking about it. I think we have to start building institutions again because, you know, if you look at the '60s and '70s, so many of these institutions were closed…But a lot of our conversation has to do with the fact that we have to open up institutions. We can't let these people be on the streets."

The president reiterated that thought at his rally hours later, insisting the U.S. "will be taking mentally deranged and dangerous people off of the streets." He didn't say exactly how that might happen.

"We are working very hard to make sure we keep guns out of the hands of insane people and those who are mentally sick and shouldn't have guns. But people have to remember however that there is a mental illness problem that has to be dealt with. It's not the gun that pulls the trigger, it's the person holding the gun," the president said to thunderous applause.

"Years ago many cities and states I remember so well closed mental institutions for budgetary reasons…We're going to have to give major consideration to building new facilities to those in need, we have to do it. And at the same time we will be taking mentally deranged and dangerous people off of the streets so we won't have to worry so much about that, a big problem. We don't have those institutions anymore and people can't get proper care."

Mr. Trump also floated opening new psychological institutions last year after the massacre at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Florida. At the time, the idea went nowhere.

"Part of the problem is we used to have mental institutions…where you take a sicko like this guy," the president said last year. "We're going to be talking seriously about opening mental health institutions again."

Although psychiatric hospitals still exist in the U.S., their numbers have declined precipitously in recent decades. This is do to a combination of factors, including laws that made it harder for the government to involuntarily commit people in many jurisdictions, as well as budget cuts at the state and local level.

Former FBI profiler Mary Ellen O'Toole contradicted Mr. Trump's assertion that mental health is a major factor in mass shootings. "Mental health is not the problem," she recently told CBS News chief Washington correspondent Major Garrett on CBS News' "The Takeout" podcast.

"My experience has been, that these are individuals that, if there is a mental health issue, they still are able to function very strategically, and in a very cold-blooded and callous manner. So, mental health is not the problem," O'Toole said. Fewer than 25% of mass shooters are clinically diagnosed with mental health issues, O'Toole added.

The National Alliance on Mental Illness estimates that roughly one in five adults in the U.S., or more than 46 million people, "experiences mental illness in a given year."

Grace Segers contributed to this report.

First published on August 16, 2019 / 10:20 AM

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Kathryn Watson

Kathryn Watson is a politics reporter for CBS News Digital.

kathryn-watson-220x140.png cbsn-fusion-china-is-eyeing-greenland-and-the-us-is-taking-note-thumbnail-1550716-640x360.jpg

Greenland rebuffs Trump, saying it's "not for sale"

"This is a complete and total catastrophe," a former U.S. ambassador to Denmark said

20M ago cbsn-fusion-china-is-eyeing-greenland-and-the-us-is-taking-note-thumbnail-1550716-640x360.jpg gettyimages-1156154777-594x594.jpg

Tlaib cancels Israel trip, citing "oppressive conditions"

"I can't allow the State of Israel to take away that light by humiliating me," Tlaib tweeted of her connections to the Palestinian people

44M ago gettyimages-1156154777-594x594.jpg fe9bc7b0-bfdd-11e9-8f25-9b5536624008-image-hires-162935.jpg

#BoycottMulan trends after comments by Disney star

#BoycottMulan is trending worldwide after "Mulan" star Liu Yifei voiced support for the police crackdown in Hong Kong

1H ago fe9bc7b0-bfdd-11e9-8f25-9b5536624008-image-hires-162935.jpg A view shows a passenger plane following an emergency landing near Moscow

Russian pilot says he felt no fear as he glided Airbus onto cornfield

"Shy" Ural Airlines pilot Damir Yusupov was lauded as hero for smooth emergency landing after birds choked both of his engines

2H ago A view shows a passenger plane following an emergency landing near Moscow A passenger walks to the First Class counter of Cathay Pacific Airways at Hong Kong Airport in Hong Kong

Cathay Pacific CEO resigns after pressure from Beijing

Rupert Hogg's resignation follows participation by some of the airline's employees in anti-government protests

2H ago A passenger walks to the First Class counter of Cathay Pacific Airways at Hong Kong Airport in Hong Kong ap-19228481224274.jpg

Trump says he wants to bring back mental institutions

The president thinks placing more people with mental illness in institutions will help solve America's gun violence problem

21M ago ap-19228481224274.jpg gettyimages-1156154777-594x594.jpg

Tlaib cancels Israel trip, citing "oppressive conditions"

"I can't allow the State of Israel to take away that light by humiliating me," Tlaib tweeted of her connections to the Palestinian people

44M ago gettyimages-1156154777-594x594.jpg nfa-diaz-mayor-panel-needs-tracks-and-gfx-frame-315.jpg

Mayors on recent mass shootings: "You lose trust in everything"

"It's a fraternity no one ever wanted to join," one mayor said. "There is no playbook"

1H ago nfa-diaz-mayor-panel-needs-tracks-and-gfx-frame-315.jpg plane-crash-today.png

Dale Earnhardt Jr. and family survive Tennessee plane crash

Dale Earnhardt Jr., his wife and baby daughter were unharmed when a jet ran off the end of the runway at Elizabethton Municipal Airport

1H ago plane-crash-today.png The General Electric logo is pictured on the General Electric offshore wind turbine plant in Montoir-de-Bretagne

GE faces allegations of accounting fraud "bigger than Enron"

Investigator Harry Markopolos, who warned regulators about Bernard Madoff, alleges GE engaged in a $38 billion fraud

1H ago The General Electric logo is pictured on the General Electric offshore wind turbine plant in Montoir-de-Bretagne cbsn-fusion-china-is-eyeing-greenland-and-the-us-is-taking-note-thumbnail-1550716-640x360.jpg

Greenland rebuffs Trump, saying it's "not for sale"

"This is a complete and total catastrophe," a former U.S. ambassador to Denmark said

20M ago cbsn-fusion-china-is-eyeing-greenland-and-the-us-is-taking-note-thumbnail-1550716-640x360.jpg ap-19228481224274.jpg

Trump says he wants to bring back mental institutions

The president thinks placing more people with mental illness in institutions will help solve America's gun violence problem

21M ago ap-19228481224274.jpg gettyimages-1156154777-594x594.jpg

Tlaib cancels Israel trip, citing "oppressive conditions"

"I can't allow the State of Israel to take away that light by humiliating me," Tlaib tweeted of her connections to the Palestinian people

44M ago gettyimages-1156154777-594x594.jpg nfa-diaz-mayor-panel-needs-tracks-and-gfx-frame-315.jpg

Mayors on recent mass shootings: "You lose trust in everything"

"It's a fraternity no one ever wanted to join," one mayor said. "There is no playbook"

1H ago nfa-diaz-mayor-panel-needs-tracks-and-gfx-frame-315.jpg Voters Go To Polls In Tight Georgia 6th District Congressional Race

Judge orders paper ballot backup plan for Georgia

The paper ballots will step in should the new voting system set to be in place by the presidential primary elections, falters

2H ago Voters Go To Polls In Tight Georgia 6th District Congressional Race plane-crash-today.png

Dale Earnhardt Jr. and family survive Tennessee plane crash

Dale Earnhardt Jr., his wife and baby daughter were unharmed when a jet ran off the end of the runway at Elizabethton Municipal Airport

1H ago plane-crash-today.png woodstock-cover-burk-uzzle-color-promo.jpg

Woodstock at 50, in the words, and music, of those who were there

A half-century after a mass of humanity converged on a farm in Bethel, N.Y. for three days of peace and music, musicians and concert-goers recall a unique moment for their generation

Aug 4 woodstock-cover-burk-uzzle-color-promo.jpg fe9bc7b0-bfdd-11e9-8f25-9b5536624008-image-hires-162935.jpg

#BoycottMulan trends after comments by Disney star

#BoycottMulan is trending worldwide after "Mulan" star Liu Yifei voiced support for the police crackdown in Hong Kong

1H ago fe9bc7b0-bfdd-11e9-8f25-9b5536624008-image-hires-162935.jpg 0816-ctm-carlossantana-1913232-640x360.jpg

Carlos Santana on what Woodstock can teach us

Carlos Santana is a global music icon. The guitarist and his band first topped the charts with “Evil Ways” off their self-titled debut in 1969. Fifty years ago this weekend, Santana took the stage at Woodstock in Bethel, New York. At the time, he was an unknown musician. He won over the massive crowd with his guitar riffs and his band's percussion. This year, he's celebrating that historic performance and the 20th anniversary of his Grammy Award-winning album "Supernatural," which includes the popular song, "Maria Maria." Santana joins "CBS This Morning" to discuss his performance at the iconic festival and what we can learn from Woodstock today.

1H ago 05:12 0816-ctm-carlossantana-1913232-640x360.jpg 0730-sunmo-amusementparks-1913246-640x360.jpg

Amusement parks

From the smells of fried sugar to stomach-churning rides, there is just something about amusement parks that brings out the kid in us. And is there anything more fun than a roller coaster ride? Faith Salie talks with Arthur Levine, a roller coaster critic, and amusement park historian Jim Futrell; and she visits the world's oldest amusement park, Denmark's Bakken, which opened in 1583.

updated 50M ago 04:18 0730-sunmo-amusementparks-1913246-640x360.jpg Two Women Dressed in Black and Crying at Funeral

Funeral homes now live streaming memorial services

Roughly 20% of funeral homes in U.S. offer an online option to grieving family and friends who can't attend the event

16H ago Two Women Dressed in Black and Crying at Funeral School Choice Utah

Overstock shares sink after CEO comments about "Deep State"

Investors are fleeing retailer Overstock after its CEO issued a bizarre statement about the "deep state" and "men in black"

21H ago School Choice Utah Facebook logo on broken cracked mobile phone screen

U.S. lawmaker joins international Facebook investigation

Rep. David Cicilline joins the International Grand Committee on Disinformation and "Fake News," as lawmakers from a dozen countries seek answers on election influencing

20H ago Facebook logo on broken cracked mobile phone screen Real Estate Upstart WeWork Releases Paperwork For Initial Public Offering

WeWork filed its IPO — now meet its We Double

A Wyoming company with a Chinese address and $441 in the bank seems poised to benefit from WeWork's buzzy IPO

Aug 14 Real Estate Upstart WeWork Releases Paperwork For Initial Public Offering 081419-dream3.jpg

Dream Chaser spaceplanes to launch on Vulcan rocket

Sierra Nevada Corp. picks ULA's Vulcan rocket to boost Dream Chaser spaceplanes into orbit

Aug 14 081419-dream3.jpg Western Greenland Hit By Unseasonably Warm Weather

Varnish and rubber found in Arctic snow, according to study

The study postulated that the pollutants were potentially carried via air

13H ago Western Greenland Hit By Unseasonably Warm Weather Western Greenland Hit By Unseasonably Warm Weather

July was the hottest month ever recorded on Earth

On the last day of the month alone, 11 billion tons of ice melted across Greenland — contributing to record low sea ice levels

18H ago Western Greenland Hit By Unseasonably Warm Weather president-theodore-roosevelt-glacier-point-yosemite-national-park-1903-loc.jpg

Nature up close: Theodore Roosevelt, the conservation president

The conservation movement in the U.S. dramatically advanced under the 26th president's watch, as he established 5 national parks, created the National Wildlife Refuge System and U.S. Forest Service, and oversaw the protection of 230,000,000 acres

21H ago president-theodore-roosevelt-glacier-point-yosemite-national-park-1903-loc.jpg my-post-49.png

12-year-old discovers apparent woolly mammoth tooth in Ohio

Jackson Hepner was taking photos with his family when he spotted the giant tooth along the edge of a creek

Aug 14 my-post-49.png Food and Farm Dehorning Cows

This university is banning beef to fight climate change

"Declaring a climate emergency cannot be empty words," the school's warden said

Aug 14 Food and Farm Dehorning Cows DRCONGO-HEALTH-EBOLA

Ebola outbreak spreads, claiming first victims in a new region

Government in Congo's previously unaffected South Kivu province says 1 person there has died and their child is being treated

2H ago DRCONGO-HEALTH-EBOLA Handout photo of an rtist's rendition of the U.S. Food and Drug Administration's (FDA) proposed cigarette packaging carrying graphic new health warnings

FDA wants to put graphic warnings on cigarette packs

In a move to amplify the health risks, images would show neck tumors, feet with amputated toes, and diseased lungs

14H ago Handout photo of an rtist's rendition of the U.S. Food and Drug Administration's (FDA) proposed cigarette packaging carrying graphic new health warnings Stress comes with the territory

Crying on the job? 8 in 10 workers say they've sobbed at work

Workplace weeping is a common experience, with almost half of workers blaming their boss or colleagues

Aug 15 Stress comes with the territory Rotem Amitai is seen in an undated photo provided by her family.

Flight attendant diagnosed with measles after N.Y. flight has died

El Al flight attendant Rotem Amitai was diagnosed with measles after flying from New York to Israel

Aug 14 Rotem Amitai is seen in an undated photo provided by her family. novartis

Brother scientists no longer at Novartis after drug scandal

Brian Kaspar and Allan Kaspar have left the drugmaker after the FDA said the company could face criminal penalties

Aug 14 novartis The General Electric logo is pictured on the General Electric offshore wind turbine plant in Montoir-de-Bretagne

GE faces allegations of accounting fraud "bigger than Enron"

Investigator Harry Markopolos, who warned regulators about Bernard Madoff, alleges GE engaged in a $38 billion fraud

1H ago The General Electric logo is pictured on the General Electric offshore wind turbine plant in Montoir-de-Bretagne Stock Market Graph next to a 1 dollar bill

Recession fears are back — should you be worried?

The longest economic expansion in U.S. history suddenly looks wobbly — but here's why it's too soon to freak

3H ago Stock Market Graph next to a 1 dollar bill Baseball player expression losing sucks

U.S. kids are quitting sports amid rising costs, inequality

Youth sports participation is rising among richer families, as children lower down the ladder exit the field

22H ago Baseball player expression losing sucks istock16795721large.jpg

If black families had white wealth, economy would be $1.5 trillion bigger

The typical white family in America has 10 times as much as the typical black family—and that hurts everyone

19H ago istock16795721large.jpg A passenger walks to the First Class counter of Cathay Pacific Airways at Hong Kong Airport in Hong Kong

Cathay Pacific CEO resigns after pressure from Beijing

Rupert Hogg's resignation follows participation by some of the airline's employees in anti-government protests

2H ago A passenger walks to the First Class counter of Cathay Pacific Airways at Hong Kong Airport in Hong Kong ​A suspicious device that caused the evacuation of a New York City subway station is seen in a picture distributed by the New York Police Department Aug. 16, 2019.

Devices that caused NYC subway station evacuation deemed safe

New York subway station evacuation caused delays to multiple subway lines during morning commute

updated 1M ago ​A suspicious device that caused the evacuation of a New York City subway station is seen in a picture distributed by the New York Police Department Aug. 16, 2019. ap6608010465.jpg

America's deadliest mass shootings

These are the deadliest mass shootings in American history

Aug 5 40 photos ap6608010465.jpg 0816-ctm-krogergunlawsuit-duncan-1913172-640x360.jpg

Woman sues for gun ban in Kroger stores

The daughter of a man killed by a gunman targeting African Americans in a Kentucky supermarket is speaking out about her legal fight to change the store's gun policy. A gunman last October killed two people in a Kroger outside Louisville. The company does not prohibit customers from taking firearms inside stores. Jericka Duncan reports.

2H ago 04:19 0816-ctm-krogergunlawsuit-duncan-1913172-640x360.jpg 0816-ctm-hollywoodripper-maher-1913147-640x360.jpg

"Hollywood Ripper" could face death penalty

The man known as the Hollywood Ripper could now face the death penalty after being convicted in two Los Angeles-area murders. On Thursday a jury found 43-year-old Michael Gargiulo guilty of stabbing two women to death and attempting to kill a third. Maureen Maher reports.

2H ago 03:26 0816-ctm-hollywoodripper-maher-1913147-640x360.jpg 0816-ctm-phillyshooting-duncan-1913121-640x360.jpg

Commissioner details violent Philly standoff

Pennsylvania's governor says he'll announce executive actions on gun control Friday, after a gunman wounded six officers in a shootout in Philadelphia. Police say Maurice Hill had an assault rifle and fired more than 100 shots at officers. Jericka Duncan reports.

2H ago 03:00 0816-ctm-phillyshooting-duncan-1913121-640x360.jpg cbsn-fusion-milky-way-black-hole-emits-mysterious-light-flare-thumbnail-1912999-640x360.jpg

Space

Milky Way black hole emits mysterious light flare

Scientists spot a flare of light coming from a black hole in the Milky Way. Syracuse University physics professor Duncan Brown explains to CBSN how the mysterious event may have occurred.

13H ago 06:27 cbsn-fusion-milky-way-black-hole-emits-mysterious-light-flare-thumbnail-1912999-640x360.jpg 081419-dream3.jpg

Dream Chaser spaceplanes to launch on Vulcan rocket

Sierra Nevada Corp. picks ULA's Vulcan rocket to boost Dream Chaser spaceplanes into orbit

Aug 14 081419-dream3.jpg The supermassive black hole located 26,000 light years from Earth in the center of the Milky Way.

Our galaxy's black hole suddenly flashed a bright light

Scientists called the flashes "unprecedented"

13H ago The supermassive black hole located 26,000 light years from Earth in the center of the Milky Way. US-astronomy-meteor-Perseid

How to watch the Perseid meteor shower peak Monday night

Anyone trying to watch the Perseid meteor shower should try to stay away from bright city lights

Aug 12 US-astronomy-meteor-Perseid ebbdvtjx4aacxou.jpg

A meteor large enough to see from Earth just hit Jupiter

The rare moment was captured with nothing more than a backyard telescope in Texas

Aug 9 ebbdvtjx4aacxou.jpg Ashley Ellerin, left, Tricia Pacaccio, center, and Maria Bruno.

Michael Gargiulo case: Stabbing deaths of three women linked to suspected serial killer

Investigators link murders of Tricia Pacaccio, Ashley Ellerin and Maria Bruno to same suspect: Michael Gargiulo

13H ago 13 photos Ashley Ellerin, left, Tricia Pacaccio, center, and Maria Bruno.  1slide-the-worst-movies-of-2019-ranked.jpg

The worst movies of 2019

The worst films of the year star big name actors, including Keanu Reeves, Anne Hathaway, and Chris Hemsworth.

Aug 9 51 photos 1slide-the-worst-movies-of-2019-ranked.jpg jake-barlow-oddities-and-curiosities-expo-39.jpg

The Oddities & Curiosities Expo

A traveling exhibition of gothic and occult art, sideshow performers, and bizarre specimens stopped outside Chicago, where CBS News photographer Jake Barlow took in the odd sights

Jul 22 24 photos jake-barlow-oddities-and-curiosities-expo-39.jpg gettyimages-486106944.jpg

New York's Central Park

America's first major landscaped public park, the 840-acre park in Manhattan welcomes more than 37 million visitors every year

Jul 21 25 photos gettyimages-486106944.jpg Charles Manson

Manson Family murders: The terrifying story in pictures

A look at the cult slayings that shocked – and scared – America

Jul 3 44 photos Charles Manson cbsn-fusion-nypd-bomb-squad-clears-fulton-street-station-thumbnail-1913283-640x360.jpg

Popular

NYPD bomb squad investigates packages

Three suspicious packages have been cleared by the NYPD after they were found in a Manhattan subway station this morning. Jarrod Bernstein, a former counterterrorism official for the Obama administration and former New York City emergency management spokesperson, joined CBSN for more.

updated 3M ago 07:39 cbsn-fusion-nypd-bomb-squad-clears-fulton-street-station-thumbnail-1913283-640x360.jpg 0816-ctm-grandmaroadtrip-1913239-640x360.jpg

Grandma Joy's epic road trip

A grandmother is nearly halfway through a road trip to visit every national park in the U.S. Joy Ryan, known as Grandma Joy, is 89 years old. She's from a small town in Ohio and until four years ago, had never seen a mountain or an ocean. But all that has changed thanks to her grandson. Chip Reid reports.

1H ago 03:28 0816-ctm-grandmaroadtrip-1913239-640x360.jpg 0816-ctm-carlossantana-1913232-640x360.jpg

Carlos Santana on what Woodstock can teach us

Carlos Santana is a global music icon. The guitarist and his band first topped the charts with “Evil Ways” off their self-titled debut in 1969. Fifty years ago this weekend, Santana took the stage at Woodstock in Bethel, New York. At the time, he was an unknown musician. He won over the massive crowd with his guitar riffs and his band's percussion. This year, he's celebrating that historic performance and the 20th anniversary of his Grammy Award-winning album "Supernatural," which includes the popular song, "Maria Maria." Santana joins "CBS This Morning" to discuss his performance at the iconic festival and what we can learn from Woodstock today.

1H ago 05:12 0816-ctm-carlossantana-1913232-640x360.jpg master-farming-climate-1920x1080notyt-1898130-640x360.jpg

A climate reckoning in the heartland

A historic flood in March 2019 left much of America's heartland under water. Grain farmers already struggling to bounce back from the Chinese trade war must now grapple with the realities of climate change that threaten to change the future of farming forever. Now, some farmers are implementing practices that could potentially reverse the effects of climate change – and provide a bigger profit. In this CBSN Originals documentary, Adam Yamaguchi travels to Nebraska, where he meets two farmers on different paths, both determined to pass their legacies on to the next generation.

Jul 26 23:07 master-farming-climate-1920x1080notyt-1898130-640x360.jpg 0816-ctm-mayorspanel-1913217-640x360.jpg

Mayors call for action after mass shootings

When gun violence erupts in America, the local mayor is often first to comfort families and try to heal the community. There have been more than 35,000 incidents of gun violence so far this year, blamed for more than 9,200 deaths. Of those, 261 are considered mass shootings. Adriana Diaz spoke to four mayors, one of whom had to respond to a massacre less than two weeks ago. They're part of a growing bipartisan chorus of local politicians pushing Congress to take action on guns.

1H ago 06:32 0816-ctm-mayorspanel-1913217-640x360.jpg