Judge orders paper ballot contingency plan for Georgia elections

/ AP

Hacking accusations rattle Georgia governor race

If Georgia election officials fail to meet the tight timeline they've set to implement an entirely new voting system, they'll have to quickly pivot to hand-marked paper ballots for the March presidential primaries.

That's according to a Thursday ruling by U.S. District Judge Amy Totenberg.

Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger last week certified a new voting system and said it will be in place by the March 24 presidential primary elections, just over seven months away. The chief information officer for Raffensperger's office, Meritt Beaver, acknowledged during a court hearing last month that the implementation schedule is "tight."

Trending News

The state's $106 million contract with Denver-based Dominion Voting Systems includes new touchscreen voting machines that print a paper record with a code that's read by a scanner.

Raffensperger said in an emailed statement Thursday that his office is "already moving full steam ahead" to implement the new system.

It's set to replace the outdated election management system and paperless voting machines that Georgia has used since 2002. Election integrity advocates and individual voters sued in 2017 alleging that the touchscreen voting are unsecure and vulnerable to hacking.

They had asked Totenberg to order an immediate switch to hand-marked paper ballots, noting that special and municipal elections are scheduled before March. The judge declined, citing concerns about the state's capacity to make an interim switch to hand-marked paper ballots while also working to implement a new system.

But she made it clear it's not acceptable for the state to use the old system as a backup if the new system isn't in place in time.

"Georgia's current voting equipment, software, election and voter databases, are antiquated, seriously flawed, and vulnerable to failure, breach, contamination, and attack," she wrote.

Instead, she ordered election officials to develop a contingency plan that includes using hand-marked paper ballots. She ordered a pilot of that contingency plan during elections this November.

Totenberg noted that some dates and details about the implementation have been a "moving target," and that the state has already scaled back a planned pilot program and postponed some deadlines.

This "slippage" gave her concerns about the state's ability to effectively handle the "mammoth undertaking" of procuring, testing and installing the equipment in all 159 counties, as well as installing a new election management, ballot building and voter registration system, she wrote.

Jennifer Doran, elections supervisor for Morgan County, said she's pretty confident the state will meet the deadlines, but she said, "It's better to have a contingency already in place in case it doesn't happen."

Totenberg's ruling applies only to Georgia, but at least parts of eight other states still use paperless balloting. Using voter registration and turnout data, the Brennan Center for Justice at NYU School of Law estimated in a report this week that as many as 12% of voters, or around 16 million people in the U.S., will vote on paperless equipment in November 2020.

The plaintiffs in this lawsuit have said the new machines have many of the same vulnerabilities as the old ones. They also worry that the portion of the printed record that's read by the scanner is a QR code, not human-readable text, meaning voters have to trust that the code accurately reflects their selections.

Totenberg called the legislation providing for a new system "an essential step forward out of the quagmire, even if just to terminate use of an antiquated vulnerable voting system."

"The wisdom or legal conformity of the Secretary of State's selection of a new vendor's particular ballot system though is not the question now before the Court," she wrote, adding in a footnote that a report last year from the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine recommends the use of paper ballots because of the vulnerabilities of electronic systems.

Perhaps alluding to legal challenges of the new system promised by plaintiffs, Totenberg quoted baseball legend Yogi Berra, writing: "The past may here be prologue anew — it may be 'like déjà vu all over again.'"

The state, she wrote, has "previously minimized, erased, or dodged the issues underlying this case." In her 153-page order, Totenberg recounted the history of the case and related actions, or inaction, by the state "to ensure transparency for the future."

Both sides saw victory in Totenberg's order.

″(W)e are pleased the Court endorsed the policy decisions of the state's elected officials to move to a new paper ballot voting system in time for the 2020 elections while not disrupting the 2019 elections," Raffensperger said in an emailed statement. "These activist plaintiffs continue fruitlessly attempting to force their preferred policy outcomes on Georgia voters without success."

Marilyn Marks, executive director of the Coalition for Good Governance, one of the plaintiffs in the case, wrote in an email that it was important that Totenberg "recognized Plaintiffs concerns about the State's plan to move to another form of electronic voting — electronic ballot marking devices." The voters' right to accountable elections requires hand-marked paper ballots counted by optical scanners with thorough audits, she wrote.

David Cross, a lawyer representing several Georgia voters in the case, called the ruling a "big win for all Georgia voters and those working across the country to secure elections and protect the right to vote."

The integrity of Georgia's voting system was heavily scrutinized during last year's midterm election, in which Republican Brian Kemp, the state's top election official at the time, narrowly defeated Democrat Stacey Abrams to become governor.

Totenberg also ordered state officials to develop a plan by Jan. 3 to address errors and discrepancies in the state's voter registration database. Election officials are also instructed to provide each precinct with a paper backup of its voter registration list.WEB: Judge orders paper ballot contingency plan for Georgia elections

First published on August 16, 2019 / 7:50 AM

© 2019 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Ebola outbreak spreads, claiming first victims in a new region

Government in Congo's previously unaffected South Kivu province says 1 person there has died and their child is being treated

0M ago DRCONGO-HEALTH-EBOLA U.S. Rep. Rashida Tlaib listens to a comment from a constituent during a town hall-style meeting in Inkster, Michigan, Aug. 15, 2019.

Israel to let Rep. Tlaib pay humanitarian visit to grandmother

Government says day after rejecting joint trip by U.S. Democratic Reps. that Tlaib promised "not to promote boycotts" on visit to West Bank

updated 45M ago U.S. Rep. Rashida Tlaib listens to a comment from a constituent during a town hall-style meeting in Inkster, Michigan, Aug. 15, 2019. KCNA picture of North Korean leader Kim Jong Un guiding the test firing of a new weapon

North Korea launches more projectiles, rejects new talks with South

South Korean and Japanese officials say the apparent short-range missiles posed no immediate threat, but they came hours after a firm rebuke from the Kim regime

3H ago KCNA picture of North Korean leader Kim Jong Un guiding the test firing of a new weapon Western Greenland Hit By Unseasonably Warm Weather

Varnish and rubber found in Arctic snow, according to study

The study postulated that the pollutants were potentially carried via air

10H ago Western Greenland Hit By Unseasonably Warm Weather Conor McGregor

Conor McGregor seen in video sucker-punching man in bar

The older man appeared unfazed after the retired MMA fighter attacked — and it was all captured on surveillance video

12H ago Conor McGregor breaking-news-v6.jpg

New York subway station evacuated over suspicious packages

New York subway station evacuation caused delays to multiple subway lines during morning commute

5M ago breaking-news-v6.jpg Voters Go To Polls In Tight Georgia 6th District Congressional Race

Judge orders paper ballot backup plan for Georgia

The paper ballots will step in should the new voting system set to be in place by the presidential primary elections, falters

20M ago Voters Go To Polls In Tight Georgia 6th District Congressional Race 0816-ctm-krogergunlawsuit-duncan-1913172-640x360.jpg

Woman sues for gun ban in Kroger grocery stores after father's murder

"You don't need a gun to buy groceries," her attorney said

27M ago 0816-ctm-krogergunlawsuit-duncan-1913172-640x360.jpg Stock Market Graph next to a 1 dollar bill

Recession fears are back — should you be worried?

The longest economic expansion in U.S. history suddenly looks wobbly — but here's why it's too soon to freak

59M ago Stock Market Graph next to a 1 dollar bill Ohio Shooting

Dayton gunman had drugs and alcohol in his system, coroner says

Connor Betts was hit by at least two dozen police bullets through gaps in his body armor, coroner adds; judge keeps friend who bought him the armor jailed

1H ago Ohio Shooting Voters Go To Polls In Tight Georgia 6th District Congressional Race

Judge orders paper ballot backup plan for Georgia

The paper ballots will step in should the new voting system set to be in place by the presidential primary elections, falters

20M ago Voters Go To Polls In Tight Georgia 6th District Congressional Race U.S. Rep. Rashida Tlaib listens to a comment from a constituent during a town hall-style meeting in Inkster, Michigan, Aug. 15, 2019.

Israel to let Rep. Tlaib pay humanitarian visit to grandmother

Government says day after rejecting joint trip by U.S. Democratic Reps. that Tlaib promised "not to promote boycotts" on visit to West Bank

updated 45M ago U.S. Rep. Rashida Tlaib listens to a comment from a constituent during a town hall-style meeting in Inkster, Michigan, Aug. 15, 2019. img-4642.jpg

Disguises, gadgets and Cold War spying with CIA's ex-disguise chief

On "The Takeout," Jonna Mendez describes how the CIA uses disguise to protect both operatives and assets

2H ago img-4642.jpg US-NAACP-HARRIS

Kamala Harris woos Iowans with message for the middle class

Harris makes her pitch across Iowa this week amid flagging poll numbers, hoping to regain lost ground on tour in her new campaign bus

11H ago US-NAACP-HARRIS UPDATED trail-markers-graphic-presidential-4.jpg

2020 Daily Trail Markers: Dems rally to Tlaib, Omar over Israel ban

Trump tweeted that the Israeli government "would show great weakness" if it allowed Reps. Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib into the country

12H ago UPDATED trail-markers-graphic-presidential-4.jpg alien.jpg

"Storm Area 51" now becoming "Alien Stock" music festival

Before you ask who is performing, the answer is: who knows?

16H ago alien.jpg woodstock-cover-burk-uzzle-color-promo.jpg

Woodstock at 50, in the words, and music, of those who were there

A half-century after a mass of humanity converged on a farm in Bethel, N.Y. for three days of peace and music, musicians and concert-goers recall a unique moment for their generation

Aug 4 woodstock-cover-burk-uzzle-color-promo.jpg Houston Astros v Cleveland Indians

MLB player becomes American citizen years after escaping Cuba

Because of America's relationship with Cuba, Puig had to be smuggled into the country through Mexico

Aug 14 Houston Astros v Cleveland Indians Todd Chrisley, Julie Chrisley

Reality TV stars plead not guilty to tax evasion charges

Todd Chrisley posted on Instagram on Monday a denial of any wrongdoing and alleged a former employee was "stealing from us big time"

Aug 14 Todd Chrisley, Julie Chrisley taylorswift-uplift-1911917-640x360.jpg

Taylor Swift sends fan $6,000 for tuition

Taylor Swift just surprised a fan from Canada by sending her more than $6,000 for tuition and rent after reading about her family struggles in a Tumblr post.

Aug 14 01:06 taylorswift-uplift-1911917-640x360.jpg Two Women Dressed in Black and Crying at Funeral

Funeral homes now live streaming memorial services

Roughly 20% of funeral homes in U.S. offer an online option to grieving family and friends who can't attend the event

14H ago Two Women Dressed in Black and Crying at Funeral School Choice Utah

Overstock shares sink after CEO comments about "Deep State"

Investors are fleeing retailer Overstock after its CEO issued a bizarre statement about the "deep state" and "men in black"

18H ago School Choice Utah Facebook logo on broken cracked mobile phone screen

U.S. lawmaker joins international Facebook investigation

Rep. David Cicilline joins the International Grand Committee on Disinformation and "Fake News," as lawmakers from a dozen countries seek answers on election influencing

18H ago Facebook logo on broken cracked mobile phone screen Real Estate Upstart WeWork Releases Paperwork For Initial Public Offering

WeWork filed its IPO — now meet its We Double

A Wyoming company with a Chinese address and $441 in the bank seems poised to benefit from WeWork's buzzy IPO

Aug 14 Real Estate Upstart WeWork Releases Paperwork For Initial Public Offering 081419-dream3.jpg

Dream Chaser spaceplanes to launch on Vulcan rocket

Sierra Nevada Corp. picks ULA's Vulcan rocket to boost Dream Chaser spaceplanes into orbit

Aug 14 081419-dream3.jpg Western Greenland Hit By Unseasonably Warm Weather

Varnish and rubber found in Arctic snow, according to study

The study postulated that the pollutants were potentially carried via air

10H ago Western Greenland Hit By Unseasonably Warm Weather Western Greenland Hit By Unseasonably Warm Weather

July was the hottest month ever recorded on Earth

On the last day of the month alone, 11 billion tons of ice melted across Greenland — contributing to record low sea ice levels

16H ago Western Greenland Hit By Unseasonably Warm Weather president-theodore-roosevelt-glacier-point-yosemite-national-park-1903-loc.jpg

Nature up close: Theodore Roosevelt, the conservation president

The conservation movement in the U.S. dramatically advanced under the 26th president's watch, as he established 5 national parks, created the National Wildlife Refuge System and U.S. Forest Service, and oversaw the protection of 230,000,000 acres

19H ago president-theodore-roosevelt-glacier-point-yosemite-national-park-1903-loc.jpg my-post-49.png

12-year-old discovers apparent woolly mammoth tooth in Ohio

Jackson Hepner was taking photos with his family when he spotted the giant tooth along the edge of a creek

Aug 14 my-post-49.png Food and Farm Dehorning Cows

This university is banning beef to fight climate change

"Declaring a climate emergency cannot be empty words," the school's warden said

Aug 14 Food and Farm Dehorning Cows DRCONGO-HEALTH-EBOLA

Ebola outbreak spreads, claiming first victims in a new region

Government in Congo's previously unaffected South Kivu province says 1 person there has died and their child is being treated

0M ago DRCONGO-HEALTH-EBOLA Handout photo of an rtist's rendition of the U.S. Food and Drug Administration's (FDA) proposed cigarette packaging carrying graphic new health warnings

FDA wants to put graphic warnings on cigarette packs

In a move to amplify the health risks, images would show neck tumors, feet with amputated toes and diseased lungs

12H ago Handout photo of an rtist's rendition of the U.S. Food and Drug Administration's (FDA) proposed cigarette packaging carrying graphic new health warnings Stress comes with the territory

Crying on the job? 8 in 10 workers say they've sobbed at work

Workplace weeping is a common experience, with almost half of workers blaming their boss or colleagues

23H ago Stress comes with the territory Rotem Amitai is seen in an undated photo provided by her family.

Flight attendant diagnosed with measles after N.Y. flight has died

El Al flight attendant Rotem Amitai was diagnosed with measles after flying from New York to Israel

Aug 14 Rotem Amitai is seen in an undated photo provided by her family. novartis

Brother scientists no longer at Novartis after drug scandal

Brian Kaspar and Allan Kaspar have left the drugmaker after the FDA said the company could face criminal penalties

Aug 14 novartis 0816-ctm-krogergunlawsuit-duncan-1913172-640x360.jpg

Woman sues for gun ban in Kroger grocery stores after father's murder

"You don't need a gun to buy groceries," her attorney said

27M ago 0816-ctm-krogergunlawsuit-duncan-1913172-640x360.jpg Stock Market Graph next to a 1 dollar bill

Recession fears are back — should you be worried?

The longest economic expansion in U.S. history suddenly looks wobbly — but here's why it's too soon to freak

59M ago Stock Market Graph next to a 1 dollar bill Baseball player expression losing sucks

U.S. kids are quitting sports amid rising costs, inequality

Youth sports participation is rising among richer families, as children lower down the ladder exit the field

19H ago Baseball player expression losing sucks istock16795721large.jpg

If black families had white wealth, economy would be $1.5 trillion bigger

The typical white family in America has 10 times as much as the typical black family—and that hurts everyone

16H ago istock16795721large.jpg Two Women Dressed in Black and Crying at Funeral

Funeral homes now live streaming memorial services

Roughly 20% of funeral homes in U.S. offer an online option to grieving family and friends who can't attend the event

14H ago Two Women Dressed in Black and Crying at Funeral breaking-news-v6.jpg

New York subway station evacuated over suspicious packages

New York subway station evacuation caused delays to multiple subway lines during morning commute

5M ago breaking-news-v6.jpg ap6608010465.jpg

America's deadliest mass shootings

These are the deadliest mass shootings in American history

Aug 5 40 photos ap6608010465.jpg 0816-ctm-krogergunlawsuit-duncan-1913172-640x360.jpg

Woman sues for gun ban in Kroger stores

The daughter of a man killed by a gunman targeting African Americans in a Kentucky supermarket is speaking out about her legal fight to change the store's gun policy. A gunman last October killed two people in a Kroger outside Louisville. The company does not prohibit customers from taking firearms inside stores. Jericka Duncan reports.

updated 8M ago 04:19 0816-ctm-krogergunlawsuit-duncan-1913172-640x360.jpg 0816-ctm-hollywoodripper-maher-1913147-640x360.jpg

"Hollywood Ripper" could face death penalty

The man known as the Hollywood Ripper could now face the death penalty after being convicted in two Los Angeles-area murders. On Thursday a jury found 43-year-old Michael Gargiulo guilty of stabbing two women to death and attempting to kill a third. Maureen Maher reports.

updated 2M ago 03:26 0816-ctm-hollywoodripper-maher-1913147-640x360.jpg 0816-ctm-phillyshooting-duncan-1913121-640x360.jpg

Commissioner details violent Philly standoff

Pennsylvania's governor says he'll announce executive actions on gun control Friday, after a gunman wounded six officers in a shootout in Philadelphia. Police say Maurice Hill had an assault rifle and fired more than 100 shots at officers. Jericka Duncan reports.

updated 6M ago 03:00 0816-ctm-phillyshooting-duncan-1913121-640x360.jpg cbsn-fusion-milky-way-black-hole-emits-mysterious-light-flare-thumbnail-1912999-640x360.jpg

Space

Milky Way black hole emits mysterious light flare

Scientists spot a flare of light coming from a black hole in the Milky Way. Syracuse University physics professor Duncan Brown explains to CBSN how the mysterious event may have occurred.

10H ago 06:27 cbsn-fusion-milky-way-black-hole-emits-mysterious-light-flare-thumbnail-1912999-640x360.jpg 081419-dream3.jpg

Dream Chaser spaceplanes to launch on Vulcan rocket

Sierra Nevada Corp. picks ULA's Vulcan rocket to boost Dream Chaser spaceplanes into orbit

Aug 14 081419-dream3.jpg The supermassive black hole located 26,000 light years from Earth in the center of the Milky Way.

Our galaxy's black hole suddenly flashed a bright light

Scientists called the flashes "unprecedented"

10H ago The supermassive black hole located 26,000 light years from Earth in the center of the Milky Way. US-astronomy-meteor-Perseid

How to watch the Perseid meteor shower peak Monday night

Anyone trying to watch the Perseid meteor shower should try to stay away from bright city lights

Aug 12 US-astronomy-meteor-Perseid ebbdvtjx4aacxou.jpg

A meteor large enough to see from Earth just hit Jupiter

The rare moment was captured with nothing more than a backyard telescope in Texas

Aug 9 ebbdvtjx4aacxou.jpg Ashley Ellerin, left, Tricia Pacaccio, center, and Maria Bruno.

Michael Gargiulo case: Stabbing deaths of three women linked to suspected serial killer

Investigators link murders of Tricia Pacaccio, Ashley Ellerin and Maria Bruno to same suspect: Michael Gargiulo

11H ago 13 photos Ashley Ellerin, left, Tricia Pacaccio, center, and Maria Bruno.  1slide-the-worst-movies-of-2019-ranked.jpg

The worst movies of 2019

The worst films of the year star big name actors, including Keanu Reeves, Anne Hathaway, and Chris Hemsworth.

Aug 9 51 photos 1slide-the-worst-movies-of-2019-ranked.jpg jake-barlow-oddities-and-curiosities-expo-39.jpg

The Oddities & Curiosities Expo

A traveling exhibition of gothic and occult art, sideshow performers, and bizarre specimens stopped outside Chicago, where CBS News photographer Jake Barlow took in the odd sights

Jul 22 24 photos jake-barlow-oddities-and-curiosities-expo-39.jpg gettyimages-486106944.jpg

New York's Central Park

America's first major landscaped public park, the 840-acre park in Manhattan welcomes more than 37 million visitors every year

Jul 21 25 photos gettyimages-486106944.jpg Charles Manson

Manson Family murders: The terrifying story in pictures

A look at the cult slayings that shocked – and scared – America

Jul 3 44 photos Charles Manson 0816-ctm-krogergunlawsuit-duncan-1913172-640x360.jpg

Popular

Woman sues for gun ban in Kroger stores

The daughter of a man killed by a gunman targeting African Americans in a Kentucky supermarket is speaking out about her legal fight to change the store's gun policy. A gunman last October killed two people in a Kroger outside Louisville. The company does not prohibit customers from taking firearms inside stores. Jericka Duncan reports.

updated 8M ago 04:19 0816-ctm-krogergunlawsuit-duncan-1913172-640x360.jpg 0816-ctm-hollywoodripper-maher-1913147-640x360.jpg

"Hollywood Ripper" could face death penalty

The man known as the Hollywood Ripper could now face the death penalty after being convicted in two Los Angeles-area murders. On Thursday a jury found 43-year-old Michael Gargiulo guilty of stabbing two women to death and attempting to kill a third. Maureen Maher reports.

updated 2M ago 03:26 0816-ctm-hollywoodripper-maher-1913147-640x360.jpg 0816-ctm-phillyshooting-duncan-1913121-640x360.jpg

Commissioner details violent Philly standoff

Pennsylvania's governor says he'll announce executive actions on gun control Friday, after a gunman wounded six officers in a shootout in Philadelphia. Police say Maurice Hill had an assault rifle and fired more than 100 shots at officers. Jericka Duncan reports.

updated 6M ago 03:00 0816-ctm-phillyshooting-duncan-1913121-640x360.jpg master-farming-climate-1920x1080notyt-1898130-640x360.jpg

A climate reckoning in the heartland

A historic flood in March 2019 left much of America's heartland under water. Grain farmers already struggling to bounce back from the Chinese trade war must now grapple with the realities of climate change that threaten to change the future of farming forever. Now, some farmers are implementing practices that could potentially reverse the effects of climate change – and provide a bigger profit. In this CBSN Originals documentary, Adam Yamaguchi travels to Nebraska, where he meets two farmers on different paths, both determined to pass their legacies on to the next generation.

Jul 26 23:07 master-farming-climate-1920x1080notyt-1898130-640x360.jpg 0816-ctm-nypdsuicides-pegues-1913111-640x360.jpg

Ninth NYPD death by suicide this year

New York City’s police commissioner says there is a mental health emergency in his department after the ninth suicide by an officer this year. Officer Robert Echeverría took his own life on Wednesday. This came a day after another officer's suicide. Jeff Pegues reports.

updated 6M ago 03:02 0816-ctm-nypdsuicides-pegues-1913111-640x360.jpg