Game over: Middle-class and poor kids are ditching youth sports

By Aimee Picchi

/ MoneyWatch

Income inequality is hurting youth sports

From Little League to the ubiquitous suburban soccer field, youth sports in the U.S. have long been considered an important part of growing up. But the rising cost of playing sports, coupled with rising economic inequality, is increasingly leading poor and even middle-class families to hang up their cleats.

That trend is being fueled by the growth in "pay-to-play" sports, which is making organized athletics prohibitively expensive for many households. Participation in sports among families earning less than $75,000 has dropped since 2011, according to The Aspen Institute's Project Play.

By contrast, children from better off families are participating in ever great numbers. About 7 of 10 children from families that earn more than $100,000 play sports, compared with 3 in 10 from families earning less than $25,000, the non-profit think tank found in a 2018 report.

Trending News

The typical American family spends about $700 per year on their child's sports activities, but some parents shell out as much as $35,000 annually to pay for lessons, camps, school sports fees, equipment, travel and more, according to Project Play. Even public schools are increasingly charging for sports due to budget cuts, data from the Rand Corporation shows.

Families earning $50,000 or less — or middle- and lower-income households — cited cost as the top reason their kids don't participate in organized sports, the Rand study noted.

The biggest predictor of sport participation is the parents' income. Only 27.5 percent of children from homes with incomes under $25,000 a year play sports compared to the 45.5 percent of kids from homes with incomes greater than $100,000 a year, via @AspenInstitute pic.twitter.com/w7cGSoCccE

— Dr. Lynne Kenney (@DrLynneKenney) August 12, 2019

"We have a system that is based on the concept of 'up or out,' like we have in a lot of corporate America, except it's not merit-based," said Tom Farrey, executive director of The Aspen Institute's Sports & Society program. "It's disproportionately based on whether you come from a family with money or if you are that child who is simply an early bloomer."

Winning the college game

This represents a massive shift within a single generation, Farrey said. In earlier decades, children played in local team sports, rarely traveling outside their local areas for games.

But that's changed, he said, partly due to the pressure from college-minded families to help their children earn athletic scholarships and admission to elite colleges. To make sure their children stand out, they are opening up their wallets for lessons, camps, expensive club teams that travel for tournaments and more.

"Youth sports has been transformed by the chase for the athletic scholarship and the preferential admission to highly selective colleges," he said. "A recruited athlete has a greater advantage than a legacy or a minority or any other population."

That change in the environment for youth sports was evident in the college admissions scandal that tarnished actresses Lori Loughlin and Felicity Huffman as well as dozens of other parents. Some parents spent millions to bribe college athletics officials, who then offered their children a spot on a college team — securing them admission to Yale and other prestigious schools. In some cases, the students didn't even play the sport.

Kids are dropping out of youth sports at an alarming rate. That’s why @AspenInstSports started #DontRetireKid. There needs to be a sports system that’s for all kids, regardless of zip code or talent. https://t.co/DuWzALbPtx pic.twitter.com/qtDSpB7V8D

— The Aspen Institute (@AspenInstitute) August 6, 2019

Of course, most families are simply spending money to further their children's athletic abilities, often with the goal of securing a college scholarship. One in 5 parents with a kid in sports believe it will lead to a college athletic scholarship. That's almost certainly wishful thinking: Only 1 in 10 young people who play sports ever get a sports scholarship, a recent TD Ameritrade study found.

"When you have that kind of system, parents start spending a lot of money," Farrey said. "That's where you get them on the right club teams, hiring private trainers and doing whatever it takes — buying them the $300 special bat — to have them succeed at sports."

He added, "It effectively pushes aside a lot of kids on the lower end of the income distribution."

Pubic school losing out

Some public schools are adding pay-to-play fees due to shrinking or stagnant sports budgets. In some cases, it's due to caps on property taxes that's making it tougher to find resources for schools or financial struggles.

That pattern can be seen in Ohio, where families in one school district may pay up to $1,000 to enroll their kids in sports, while a family in a nearby district may pay nothing, according to the Dayton Daily News. Some schools charge sports fees because it helps them avoid making cuts; others pared back the charges in order to increase sports participation, the paper noted.

Here is more evidence of how we are pricing poor kids out of sports. Sports are one of the best ways for young people develop the character and grit skills it takes to succeed in life.

National Youth Sport Survey — The Aspen Institute Project Play https://t.co/u6FlMrgExC

— Jon Husted (@JonHusted) August 7, 2019

Meanwhile, poor students face a host of issues that wealthier children don't that can deter them from playing sports, said Mara Mazza of the Kings County Tennis League, a non-profit that teaches tennis to low-income children in Brooklyn. "There are a variety of reasons why kids don't participate in sports. Some of it is access, some of it is transportation and some of it is safety," she said.

The bigger picture, according to the Aspen Institute's Farrey: Middle-class and poor children who can't afford to play sports may be at a distinct disadvantage compared with kids from affluent families.

"The research shows physically active kids are less likely to be obese, more likely to get a college degree, less likely to suffer chronic illnesses including cancer and more likely to be active as adults, and twice as likely to have active children," he said. "Everyone will pay price if we don't get them off the couch."

First published on August 15, 2019 / 9:49 AM

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc.. All Rights Reserved.

Hong Kong protests: How did we get here?

CBS News Asia correspondent Ramy Inocencio explains what brought the pro-democracy protesters onto the streets, and what could come next

50M ago cbsn-fusion-hong-kong-protesters-fear-military-crackdown-after-violence-at-airport-demonstrations-thumbnail.jpg Traders work on the floor at the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) in New York

Stocks whipsaw amid recession fears, China's threat

Investors brace themselves after Wednesday's 800-point plunge amid recession signals and China's threats on trade war

1H ago Traders work on the floor at the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) in New York INDIA-POLITICS-INDEPENDENCE DAY

Pakistan says troops killed as India PM keeps mum on Kashmir crackdown

Narendra Modi danced around his move to scrap Kashmir's semi-autonomy and cut its 8 million inhabitants off from the world in his Independence Day speech

updated 14M ago INDIA-POLITICS-INDEPENDENCE DAY SPAIN-BRITAIN-SYRIA-IRAN-DIPLOMACY-CONFLICT

U.S. moves to seize Iranian tanker ahead of expected release

Top judge in British territory reportedly said the Grace 1 "would have sailed" if not for the last minute U.S. intervention

3H ago SPAIN-BRITAIN-SYRIA-IRAN-DIPLOMACY-CONFLICT dsc-0192.jpg

Advocates say "Remain in Mexico" turns migrants into "marketable commodity"

The U.S. is keeping most asylum seekers on the other side of the border in Mexico — where advocates say they can't help them

3H ago dsc-0192.jpg bunker.jpg

Child porn fugitive found hiding in underground bunker

Jeremiah Button's jury trial was just two weeks away when he disappeared in early 2016

6M ago bunker.jpg jane-pauley-at-the-ponte-vecchio-in-florence-promo.jpg

This Week: "A Sunday Morning in Florence" (August 18)

Jane Pauley hosts a special broadcast of the Emmy-winning Sunday morning news program from Tuscany, sharing stories on all things Italian – art and design, traditions and culture, fashion, food, music, entertainment, history and human interest

10M ago jane-pauley-at-the-ponte-vecchio-in-florence-promo.jpg Baseball player expression losing sucks

U.S. kids are quitting sports amid rising costs, inequality

Youth sports participation is rising among richer families, as children lower down the ladder exit the field

11M ago Baseball player expression losing sucks 0815-ctm-mpuflowerpower-diaz-1912463-640x360.jpg

"It's doing something good": Two women brighten lives of seniors with memory loss

The Bloomington, Minnesota, pair rearrange up to nearly a thousand bouquets a month, with 150 volunteers working five days a week

30M ago 0815-ctm-mpuflowerpower-diaz-1912463-640x360.jpg APTOPIX Gunman Firing at Police

Philadelphia suspect in custody after hourslong standoff

Police had initially responded around 5 p.m. on a narcotics warrant and things "went awry almost immediately," Commissioner Richard Ross said

45M ago APTOPIX Gunman Firing at Police rtx1i06o.jpg

Trump rule would let some businesses bar LGBT workers

The move comes as a reversal after Trump vowed to maintain Obama-era protections during his first month in office

57M ago rtx1i06o.jpg Traders work on the floor at the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) in New York

Stocks whipsaw amid recession fears, China's threat

Investors brace themselves after Wednesday's 800-point plunge amid recession signals and China's threats on trade war

1H ago Traders work on the floor at the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) in New York US-CRIME-SHOOTING-TOLL

Beto O'Rourke delivering first speech after El Paso shooting

Beto O'Rourke has been absent from the campaign trail in the wake of the deadly shooting in El Paso, Texas

1H ago US-CRIME-SHOOTING-TOLL Donald Trump

Trump to kick off New Hampshire campaign with Thursday visit

After barely losing New Hampshire in 2016, the president looks to flip the Granite State next year

1H ago Donald Trump dsc-0192.jpg

Advocates say "Remain in Mexico" turns migrants into "marketable commodity"

The U.S. is keeping most asylum seekers on the other side of the border in Mexico — where advocates say they can't help them

3H ago dsc-0192.jpg Houston Astros v Cleveland Indians

MLB player becomes American citizen years after escaping Cuba

Because of America's relationship with Cuba, Puig had to be smuggled into the country through Mexico

17H ago Houston Astros v Cleveland Indians woodstock-cover-burk-uzzle-color-promo.jpg

Woodstock at 50, in the words, and music, of those who were there

A half-century after a mass of humanity converged on a farm in Bethel, N.Y. for three days of peace and music, musicians and concert-goers recall a unique moment for their generation

Aug 4 woodstock-cover-burk-uzzle-color-promo.jpg Todd Chrisley, Julie Chrisley

Reality TV stars plead not guilty to tax evasion charges

Todd Chrisley posted on Instagram on Monday a denial of any wrongdoing and alleged a former employee was "stealing from us big time"

17H ago Todd Chrisley, Julie Chrisley taylorswift-uplift-1911917-640x360.jpg

Taylor Swift sends fan $6,000 for tuition

Taylor Swift just surprised a fan from Canada by sending her more than $6,000 for tuition and rent after reading about her family struggles in a Tumblr post.

20H ago 01:06 taylorswift-uplift-1911917-640x360.jpg 0814-ctm-jadapinkettsmith-1911716-640x360.jpg

Jada Pinkett Smith speaks to 20-year-old self

Actress Jada Pinkett Smith is the creator of “Red Table Talk,” a show that streams on Facebook Watch. On “Red Table Talk,” Pinkett Smith, her daughter Willow, and her mother Adrienne Banfield-Norris have raw conversations on provocative issues from marriage to mental health. She’ll also soon return to the big screen in the action movie “Angel has Fallen,” alongside Gerard Butler. Pinkett Smith joined “CBS This Morning” Wednesday to discuss those projects and more.

Aug 14 06:55 0814-ctm-jadapinkettsmith-1911716-640x360.jpg Real Estate Upstart WeWork Releases Paperwork For Initial Public Offering

WeWork filed its IPO — now meet its We Double

A Wyoming company with a Chinese address and $441 in the bank seems poised to benefit from WeWork's buzzy IPO

15H ago Real Estate Upstart WeWork Releases Paperwork For Initial Public Offering 081419-dream3.jpg

Dream Chaser spaceplanes to launch on Vulcan rocket

Sierra Nevada Corp. picks ULA's Vulcan rocket to boost Dream Chaser spaceplanes into orbit

15H ago 081419-dream3.jpg FRANCE-US-INTERNET-TECHNOLOGY

Facebook contractors listened to Messenger chats

Facebook said it's ended the practice of having contractors listen to and transcribe the recordings

19H ago FRANCE-US-INTERNET-TECHNOLOGY untitled-collage-1.jpg

Teen tweets from LG smart fridge, goes viral

15-year-old Dorothy figured out how to tweet from a Nintendo DS, a Wii and her fridge

21H ago untitled-collage-1.jpg rtx2z6n2.jpg

Apple lifted by delay in U.S. tariffs on China

With the tech company set to roll out its latest iPhones in September, higher levies on Chinese imports would hurt

Aug 13 rtx2z6n2.jpg my-post-49.png

12-year-old discovers apparent woolly mammoth tooth in Ohio

Jackson Hepner was taking photos with his family when he spotted the giant tooth along the edge of a creek

10H ago my-post-49.png Food and Farm Dehorning Cows

This university is banning beef to fight climate change

"Declaring a climate emergency cannot be empty words," the school's warden said

15H ago Food and Farm Dehorning Cows 0814-ctm-babyrhino-blackstone-1911720-640x360.jpg

The fight to save the northern white rhino

The last remaining members of the species are a mother and daughter that live under 24-hour armed guard in Kenya – but two rhinos thousands of miles away could offer hope

23H ago 0814-ctm-babyrhino-blackstone-1911720-640x360.jpg The supermassive black hole located 26,000 light years from Earth in the center of the Milky Way.

Our galaxy's black hole suddenly flashed a bright light

Scientists called the flashes "unprecedented"

18H ago The supermassive black hole located 26,000 light years from Earth in the center of the Milky Way. US-astronomy-meteor-Perseid

How to watch the Perseid meteor shower peak Monday night

Anyone trying to watch the Perseid meteor shower should try to stay away from bright city lights

Aug 12 US-astronomy-meteor-Perseid Stress comes with the territory

Crying on the job? 8 in 10 workers say they've sobbed at work

Workplace weeping is a common experience, with almost half of workers blaming their boss or colleagues

1H ago Stress comes with the territory Rotem Amitai is seen in an undated photo provided by her family.

Flight attendant diagnosed with measles after N.Y. flight has died

El Al flight attendant Rotem Amitai was diagnosed with measles after flying from New York to Israel

10H ago Rotem Amitai is seen in an undated photo provided by her family. novartis

Brother scientists no longer at Novartis after drug scandal

Brian Kaspar and Allan Kaspar have left the drugmaker after the FDA said the company could face criminal penalties

16H ago novartis 0814-ctm-dementia-narula.jpg

Tips for lowering blood pressure, which may cut dementia risk

A study in the Journal of the American Medical Association has found a link between high blood pressure and dementia

Aug 14 0814-ctm-dementia-narula.jpg Teens vaping

New warnings of link between lung disease in teens and e-cigarettes

Minnesota became the third state where serious injuries linked to e-cigarettes were reported in the last month

Aug 14 Teens vaping Baseball player expression losing sucks

U.S. kids are quitting sports amid rising costs, inequality

Youth sports participation is rising among richer families, as children lower down the ladder exit the field

11M ago Baseball player expression losing sucks US-stocks-market

Dow down 800 points after bond markets flash recession warning

Major stock indexes tumble around 3% after yields on Treasury bonds inverted — a signal the U.S. economy is slowing

16H ago US-stocks-market Traders work on the floor at the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) in New York

Stocks whipsaw amid recession fears, China's threat

Investors brace themselves after Wednesday's 800-point plunge amid recession signals and China's threats on trade war

1H ago Traders work on the floor at the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) in New York Real Estate Upstart WeWork Releases Paperwork For Initial Public Offering

WeWork filed its IPO — now meet its We Double

A Wyoming company with a Chinese address and $441 in the bank seems poised to benefit from WeWork's buzzy IPO

15H ago Real Estate Upstart WeWork Releases Paperwork For Initial Public Offering Stress comes with the territory

Crying on the job? 8 in 10 workers say they've sobbed at work

Workplace weeping is a common experience, with almost half of workers blaming their boss or colleagues

1H ago Stress comes with the territory bunker.jpg

Child porn fugitive found hiding in underground bunker

Jeremiah Button's jury trial was just two weeks away when he disappeared in early 2016

6M ago bunker.jpg ap6608010465.jpg

America's deadliest mass shootings

These are the deadliest mass shootings in American history

Aug 5 40 photos ap6608010465.jpg APTOPIX Gunman Firing at Police

Philadelphia suspect in custody after hourslong standoff

Police had initially responded around 5 p.m. on a narcotics warrant and things "went awry almost immediately," Commissioner Richard Ross said

45M ago APTOPIX Gunman Firing at Police 0815-ctm-phillycopsshot-duncan-1912334-640x360.jpg

Armed standoff paralyzes PA neighborhood

A standoff in a Philadelphia neighborhood is over after the man accused of wounding six police officers and shooting repeatedly at others surrendered overnight. Maurice Hill, 36, walked out of the home where he had barricaded himself, holding his hands in the air. Police say Hill first opened fire when officers came to the house with a warrant. Two officers and three hostages were trapped inside for about five hours until a SWAT team rescued them. Jericka Duncan reports.

2H ago 03:49 0815-ctm-phillycopsshot-duncan-1912334-640x360.jpg FILE PHOTO: A Oregon District resident stands at a memorial for those killed during Sunday morning's a mass shooting in Dayton

Dayton shooter's parents apologize for "insensitive" obituary

Obituary Connor Betts' parents posted on funeral home website didn't mention the shooting or his sister, one of those he shot to death

3H ago FILE PHOTO: A Oregon District resident stands at a memorial for those killed during Sunday morning's a mass shooting in Dayton 081419-dream3.jpg

Dream Chaser spaceplanes to launch on Vulcan rocket

Sierra Nevada Corp. picks ULA's Vulcan rocket to boost Dream Chaser spaceplanes into orbit

15H ago 081419-dream3.jpg The supermassive black hole located 26,000 light years from Earth in the center of the Milky Way.

Our galaxy's black hole suddenly flashed a bright light

Scientists called the flashes "unprecedented"

18H ago The supermassive black hole located 26,000 light years from Earth in the center of the Milky Way. US-astronomy-meteor-Perseid

How to watch the Perseid meteor shower peak Monday night

Anyone trying to watch the Perseid meteor shower should try to stay away from bright city lights

Aug 12 US-astronomy-meteor-Perseid ebbdvtjx4aacxou.jpg

A meteor large enough to see from Earth just hit Jupiter

The rare moment was captured with nothing more than a backyard telescope in Texas

Aug 9 ebbdvtjx4aacxou.jpg cbsn-fusion-saturn-rings-disappearing-nasa-2019-08-06-thumbnail-1906783-640x360.jpg

Saturn's rings are disappearing

NASA's Cassini spacecraft ended its historic exploration of Saturn in 2017 and, slowly but surely, scientists are learning more about the ringed planet. Data from the 13-year mission helped scientists determine Saturn's rings are much newer than the planet itself — and they're disappearing.

Aug 6 00:42 cbsn-fusion-saturn-rings-disappearing-nasa-2019-08-06-thumbnail-1906783-640x360.jpg 1slide-the-worst-movies-of-2019-ranked.jpg

The worst movies of 2019

The worst films of the year star big name actors, including Keanu Reeves, Anne Hathaway, and Chris Hemsworth.

Aug 9 51 photos 1slide-the-worst-movies-of-2019-ranked.jpg jake-barlow-oddities-and-curiosities-expo-39.jpg

The Oddities & Curiosities Expo

A traveling exhibition of gothic and occult art, sideshow performers, and bizarre specimens stopped outside Chicago, where CBS News photographer Jake Barlow took in the odd sights

Jul 22 24 photos jake-barlow-oddities-and-curiosities-expo-39.jpg gettyimages-486106944.jpg

New York's Central Park

America's first major landscaped public park, the 840-acre park in Manhattan welcomes more than 37 million visitors every year

Jul 21 25 photos gettyimages-486106944.jpg Charles Manson

Manson Family murders: The terrifying story in pictures

A look at the cult slayings that shocked – and scared – America

Jul 3 44 photos Charles Manson star-trek.jpg

New on Netflix, Hulu and Amazon

Shows and movies you'll want to stream soon

Jun 24 30 photos star-trek.jpg 0814-cbsn-sponsored-vxv-smallbusinessspotlight-1911837-640x360.jpg

Popular

Calligrapher embraces tech to grow business

In our Small Business Spotlight – Joanna Krupnick used Instagram to promote her old-fashioned designs and launch a new business.

22H ago 03:17 0814-cbsn-sponsored-vxv-smallbusinessspotlight-1911837-640x360.jpg 0815-cbsn-iranuscoalition-tyv-new-1912492-640x360.jpg

Inside Strait of Hormuz as Iran tensions rise

The U.S. is trying to build an international coalition to counter Iran's influence in the Middle East, especially in the Strait of Hormuz. The White House says it wants to protect oil tankers and shipping routes in the region. Imtiaz Tyab is the only U.S. network correspondent to gain access to Iran's territorial waters since the recent spike in tensions, and he joins CBSN with a closer look.

updated 13M ago 01:55 0815-cbsn-iranuscoalition-tyv-new-1912492-640x360.jpg 0815-ctm-mpuflowerpower-diaz-1912463-640x360.jpg

The subtle power of a bouquet of flowers

In this installment of our ongoing series, A More Perfect Union, we meet two childhood friends are turning recycled bouquets into moments of joy in Minnesota. Adriana Diaz reports.

updated 30M ago 04:01 0815-ctm-mpuflowerpower-diaz-1912463-640x360.jpg master-farming-climate-1920x1080notyt-1898130-640x360.jpg

A climate reckoning in the heartland

A historic flood in March 2019 left much of America's heartland under water. Grain farmers already struggling to bounce back from the Chinese trade war must now grapple with the realities of climate change that threaten to change the future of farming forever. Now, some farmers are implementing practices that could potentially reverse the effects of climate change – and provide a bigger profit. In this CBSN Originals documentary, Adam Yamaguchi travels to Nebraska, where he meets two farmers on different paths, both determined to pass their legacies on to the next generation.

Jul 26 23:07 master-farming-climate-1920x1080notyt-1898130-640x360.jpg 0815-ctm-tarellavinmccraneyqa-1912458-640x360.jpg

"Moonlight" screenwriter talks new OWN series

Tarell Alvin McCraney is a playwright, professor and co-writer of the Oscar-winning screenplay for “Moonlight.” McCraney is turning to television for his new project,"David Makes Man," about a 14-year-old prodigy handling the pressures of an elite education and the dangers of his Miami neighborhood. McCraney joins "CBS This Morning" to discuss how he drew on his own Florida childhood for "David Makes Man."

updated 16M ago 07:06 0815-ctm-tarellavinmccraneyqa-1912458-640x360.jpg