"Client 9": How Spitzer fell (or was pushed)

/ CBS

"It's a hard film to boil down," said director Alex Gibney of his new documentary on the very public fall from grace of New York's former governor who was outed for having used the services of call girls.

But the narrative of "Client 9: The Rise and Fall of Eliot Spitzer" is anything but straightforward, and its tawdriness is not limited to the pay-for-sex sense.

The film presents unsettling questions surrounding the case which exploded in March 2008 when Spitzer was named in The New York Times as having been a customer of the Emperors Club VIP escort service.

Trending News

For example:

Why was the FBI – which never investigates escort services – devoting considerable manpower and resources to tapping the phones of the Emperors Club? And why were details about its girls leaked to reporters, including their real names and home and work phone numbers?

Why was Spitzer the only client pursued by the feds for being a john, when other public figures (such as Louisiana's Republican Senator David Vitter, caught texting the D.C. Madam from the Senate Chamber) have gone untouched?

How did a notorious GOP dirty trickster learn about Spitzer's proclivities and allegedly inform the Justice Department, in a letter the feds say they never received?

Why did one of the many powerful enemies Spitzer had made during his investigation of Wall Street corruption admit to a CNBC reporter, when news of Spitzer's outing broke, that he already knew about it, and boasted that a witness had informed him of details?

It's all enough to make even the most un-conspiracy-minded go hmmmmmm. . . .

Spitzer certainly was a star ascendant when, as New York's Attorney General, he investigated bankers and investment fund managers. The "Sheriff of Wall Street" handily won election as Governor, with a vow to clean up corruption in Albany.

But he had a target on his back – and news of Spitzer's sex scandal not only brought rejoicing to Wall Street, it also stopped dead in its tracks investigations of abuses in Big Finance (which would, only months later, collapse spectacularly).

Gibney said his take on the story changed as he delved deeper into its issues – that it was not just about a prominent figure making a public fool of himself, but about the outside forces that may have contributed to the salacious spectacle.

"When I approached the film (and I think it was one of the reasons why Spitzer agreed to appear), it wasn't only going to be a film about the scandal – the rich irony of the Sheriff of Wall Street seeking comfort in an escort service. Yes, it was a rich irony, but it wasn't a unique irony. But there was something odd about the timing of it all."

And so Gibney dug in, joined by investigate journalist Peter Elkind (with whom he'd collaborated on "Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room").

Gibney said the only condition Spitzer made for agreeing to be interviewed was that the filmmakers share with him any new discoveries so that could comment. "But there was no deal about what we couldn't or couldn't use – we were going to use anything," Gibney said.

One of the most fascinating – and jaw-dropping – aspects of "Client 9" was how Gibney was able to get so many of Spitzer's enemies, whose actions carry the whiff of conspiracy, to talk on camera with such candor and glee. (Well, to be honest, the glee part was not so difficult to understand.)

Case in point: Kenneth Langone, cofounder of Home Depot and former director of the New York Stock Exchange. In 2003 he was prosecuted by Spitzer for approving a $140 million retirement package for then-Chairman of the NYSE Dick Grasso. Though the lawsuit was thrown out in court, Langone never forgave Spitzer.

In Gibney's film, Langone is forthright about his opinions of his adversary – even in the face of CNBC video in which Langone suggested he had an informant who witnessed Spitzer purchasing postal money orders used to pay for call girls.

"I think he wanted to dance on Spitzer's grave," Gibney said. "The degree of the enmity towards Spitzer, the vitriol, was so high that I just think he couldn't resist."

Gibney said the same thing goes for Hank Greenburg, the former head of AIG who was forced to resign after Spitzer began an investigation into fraud at AIG and the reinsurance firm Gen Re. "Hank Greenburg's office called me up the same day the project was announced," wanting to talk, Gibney said

Though Greenburg's lawyers prevented him from talking for some time, the exec was made available for the cameras, Gibney noted, once the statute of limitations passed for criminal prosecution on the Gen Re matter.

Coincidence? Hmmmmmmmmm . . .

GOP dirty trickster Roger Stone (who was a consultant to embattled New York Senate Majority Leader Joseph Bruno) boasted that he'd sent a letter to the FBI informing them of Spitzer's peccadilloes, which he claims was the impetus for the Federal investigation into the Emperors Club VIP.

The FBI insists they have no record of receiving any letter from Stone (and, conveniently, the copy of Stone's letter obtained by the filmmakers had the address and addressee redacted).

Yet federal investigators who interviewed the Emperors Club VIP's call girls and madam presented wiretap data and information that was exceedingly detailed. This was no truck stop bust.

In his zeal to find out more about the scandal, Gibney discovered that Ashley Dupre, the escort who was unmasked as the call girl Spitzer met at a Washington, D.C. hotel, turned out to be a bit player – she wasn't even the woman with whom Spitzer regularly consorted but was merely filling in that night.

That girl, working name "Angelina," agreed to speak but only if her face and voice were kept secret. And rather than fall back on the time-tested method of obscuring a witness' features and voice on camera – silhouetted in shadowing lighting, distorted voice – Gibney opted to have transcripts of "Angelina"'s interviews performed by an actress, full disclosure given.

Instead of presenting the working girl as a criminal, like a mob hit man, "Angelina" is seen as someone who speaks the truth about the escort industry, and as a victim who falls prey to government interrogators.

Gibney said he was unable to interview only three people he sought : Dupre; Spitzer's wife, Silda Wall Spitzer; and Michael Garcia, the former U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York who launched the investigation of Spitzer only to announce, many months later, that there were no prosecutable crimes.

"It is scary!" Gibney said of the reach of the Justice Department in the case. "On the one hand people can say, "Well, what difference does it make? I mean, he did what he did.' Yeah, but the investigation is really quite scary because you realize the power of the federal government. And they didn't do this to David Vitter; they just decided they were going to do it with Elliot Spitzer."

And what was Gibney's takeaway? "A greater understanding of the man himself, a greater understanding of the viciousness of the political blood sport, and then a rather textured understanding of how he was outed," he said.

"Client 9: The Rise and Fall of Eliot Spitzer" is now playing theatrically in several U.S. markets, and is also obtainable on VOD.

For more info:

"Client 9: The Rise and Fall of Eliot Spitzer" (Official website)

First published on November 13, 2010 / 1:18 PM

© 2010 CBS. All rights reserved.

Boeing 737 MAX 8

Consumers could see higher fares because of Boeing 737 woes

Global grounding of the aircraft is rippling through the travel sector and even denting the U.S. economy

28M ago Boeing 737 MAX 8 Election 2018 Mississippi

CBS News Eye on Trends: The latest from the CBS News Election & Survey Unit

A recap of latest polls and data-driven studies from the CBS News Election & Survey Unit

1H ago Election 2018 Mississippi donald-trump-china-flag.jpg

Trump's China trade tweets dampen already low expectations for talks

Mr. Trump claimed China is "praying" for him to lose in 2020 as stalled trade and tariff talks resume in Shanghai

1H ago donald-trump-china-flag.jpg American Bison Bull - Genetically Pure Specimen

17-year-old girl gored by bison in North Dakota

The bison were on either side of the trail when the 17-year-old walked between them, park officials say

1H ago American Bison Bull - Genetically Pure Specimen United States of America v Netherlands : Final - 2019 FIFA Women's World Cup France

U.S. women's soccer coach steps down after World Cup victory

"The opportunity to coach this team and work with these amazing women has been the honor of a lifetime," Ellis said

updated 47M ago United States of America v Netherlands : Final - 2019 FIFA Women's World Cup France Election 2018 Mississippi

CBS News Eye on Trends: The latest from the CBS News Election & Survey Unit

A recap of latest polls and data-driven studies from the CBS News Election & Survey Unit

1H ago Election 2018 Mississippi donald-trump-china-flag.jpg

Trump's China trade tweets dampen already low expectations for talks

Mr. Trump claimed China is "praying" for him to lose in 2020 as stalled trade and tariff talks resume in Shanghai

1H ago donald-trump-china-flag.jpg US-POLITICS-TRUMP

New law says Trump must release tax returns to be on Calif. primary ballot

California Gov. Gavin Newsom signed into law a bill that would demand that presidential candidates disclose five years of federal tax returns to be listed on the state's primary election ballot

1H ago US-POLITICS-TRUMP US-VOTE-DEMOCRATS-DEBATE

Democrats meet in Detroit for second debate — live updates

Ten Democrats running for president will make their pitch on immigration, the economy, abortion rights and more

updated 3M ago US-VOTE-DEMOCRATS-DEBATE paul.jpg

Rand Paul offers to send Ilhan Omar to Somalia

Rep. Ilhan Omar escaped Somalia's civil war as a child with her family

3H ago paul.jpg brazil-prison-riot-relatives.png

Relatives identifying victims of deadly prison riot in Brazil

Dozens of relatives of inmates killed during a riot in northern Brazil are gathering at a coroner's office Tuesday

1H ago brazil-prison-riot-relatives.png donald-trump-china-flag.jpg

Trump's China trade tweets dampen already low expectations for talks

Mr. Trump claimed China is "praying" for him to lose in 2020 as stalled trade and tariff talks resume in Shanghai

1H ago donald-trump-china-flag.jpg royalbay-archie.jpg

Prince Harry wants only 2 kids out of concern for the planet

"Two, maximum!" Prince Harry told Jane Goodall during a conversation about the future of the planet

1H ago royalbay-archie.jpg seesaw.jpg

Artist installs seesaws at U.S.-Mexico border wall

Kids in Sunland Park, New Mexico were able to seesaw with kids in Anapra, Mexico

5H ago seesaw.jpg cbsn-fusion-john-kelly-joins-board-of-detention-center-operator-thumbnail-1843094-640x360.jpg

Lawsuit seeks info on John Kelly's ties to company housing migrants

Lawsuit follows an exclusive CBS News report in May that the former White House chief of staff had joined the board of the nation's only for-profit company holding unaccompanied migrant kids

5H ago cbsn-fusion-john-kelly-joins-board-of-detention-center-operator-thumbnail-1843094-640x360.jpg royalbay-archie.jpg

Prince Harry wants only 2 kids out of concern for the planet

"Two, maximum!" Prince Harry told Jane Goodall during a conversation about the future of the planet

1H ago royalbay-archie.jpg screen-shot-2019-07-30-at-12-33-30-pm.png

Cardi B and Bernie Sanders meet to talk politics

Cardi B has often shared her love for American history and politics – and the urgency of getting young people to participate in the 2020 presidential election

4H ago screen-shot-2019-07-30-at-12-33-30-pm.png 3

New on Netflix, Hulu and Amazon

Shows and movies you'll want to stream soon

Jun 24 30 photos 3 A$AP Rocky

A$AP Rocky pleads not guilty to assault in Sweden

American rapper is accused of attacking a man on a Stockholm street, and even before the trial began he was backed by President Trump

2H ago A$AP Rocky Lil Nas X

Lil Nas X breaks Billboard record with "Old Town Road"

Breakthrough rapper's viral song "Old Town Road" overtook the Billboard record set by Mariah Carey's "One Sweet Day​" for most weeks at No. 1

Jul 29 Lil Nas X FILE PHOTO: Credit reporting company Equifax Inc. offices are pictured in Atlanta

Con artists already running fake Equifax settlement websites

Determining if you're among the 147 million Americans entitled to compensation for 2017 breach takes only seconds

5H ago FILE PHOTO: Credit reporting company Equifax Inc. offices are pictured in Atlanta Capital One Bank

Have a Capital One credit card? Take these 5 steps

If you're a Capital One customer, consider adding extra levels of security to keep scammers from misusing your data

3H ago Capital One Bank computer.jpg

Capital One data breach hits more than 100 million people

The hacker got information including credit scores and balances plus the Social Security numbers of about 140,000 customers

3H ago computer.jpg HONG KONG-UBER-TAXI-COURT

Uber lays off 400 people from its marketing team

Ride-hailing company blames its losses partly on costly promotions to attract riders and drivers

Jul 29 HONG KONG-UBER-TAXI-COURT Fortnite World Cup Finals - Final Round

Pennsylvania teen wins $3 million at Fortnite World Cup

Kyle "Bugha" Giersdorf scored 26 more points than runner-up "psalm" to take home the title Sunday night in New York City

Jul 29 Fortnite World Cup Finals - Final Round siberia-wildfire-russia.jpg

Vast wildfires in Siberia a potential "disaster" for global climate

"The more fires affect the climate, the more conditions are created for new dangerous fires," environmental activist warns

5H ago siberia-wildfire-russia.jpg Nebraska man finds 2.12 carat diamond at Arkansas state park

Nebraska man finds 2.12 carat diamond at state park

John Lanik discovered the largest diamond found in the state park this year

20H ago Nebraska man finds 2.12 carat diamond at Arkansas state park perseids in night time

Double meteor showers will light up the sky tonight

The dueling showers will bring up to 25 meteors per hour

Jul 29 perseids in night time california-condor-409-zion-national-park-promo.jpg

Nature up close: Rescuing the California condor

Almost 40 years ago there were 22 birds left; today the species' population has increased dramatically

Jul 28 california-condor-409-zion-national-park-promo.jpg 0727-ctm-lasvegasgrasshoppers-1899263-640x360.jpg

Swarms of grasshoppers invade Vegas: "It was crazy"

A migration of mild-mannered grasshoppers sweeping through the Las Vegas area is being attributed to wet weather several months ago

Jul 27 0727-ctm-lasvegasgrasshoppers-1899263-640x360.jpg salmonellapoultry-456px.jpg

Biggest source of salmonella outbreaks? It's clucking in U.S. backyards

Raising poultry at home is the leading cause of sickness from salmonella, far exceeding infections from pre-cut melons

4H ago salmonellapoultry-456px.jpg d3-nod-farmers-neighbors-072919en-frame-13.jpg

Farmers harvest crop for neighbor battling cancer

The neighbors did three weeks worth of work in just six hours

22H ago d3-nod-farmers-neighbors-072919en-frame-13.jpg b3-lenghi-hot-car-death-072919en-cut-2-frame-861.jpg

Death of 1-year-old twins puts spotlight on hot car dangers

Father Juan Rodriguez is facing manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide charges in the deaths of his son and daughter

22H ago b3-lenghi-hot-car-death-072919en-cut-2-frame-861.jpg Modern building hallway, unfocused background

Nurse says people should be "scared" by private equity firms

Philadelphia's 171-year-old Hahnemann Hospital was sold to a private equity firm — now it may become luxury condos

Jul 29 Modern building hallway, unfocused background ctm-clean-8am-cr470c-20190729-frame-30651.jpg

Research links widely-used drugs to a nearly 50% higher risk of dementia

An estimated 1 in 4 older adults take anticholinergic drugs

Jul 29 ctm-clean-8am-cr470c-20190729-frame-30651.jpg Boeing 737 MAX 8

Consumers could see higher fares because of Boeing 737 woes

Global grounding of the aircraft is rippling through the travel sector and even denting the U.S. economy

28M ago Boeing 737 MAX 8 donald-trump-china-flag.jpg

Trump's China trade tweets dampen already low expectations for talks

Mr. Trump claimed China is "praying" for him to lose in 2020 as stalled trade and tariff talks resume in Shanghai

1H ago donald-trump-china-flag.jpg dahler-cape-cod-shark-attack-bulk-rem304-frame-21852.jpg

Sharks bite into Cape Cod summer rental market

Cape Cod shark sightings and new taxes on short-term home rentals keep would-be vacationers at bay this summer season

3H ago dahler-cape-cod-shark-attack-bulk-rem304-frame-21852.jpg salmonellapoultry-456px.jpg

Biggest source of salmonella outbreaks? It's clucking in U.S. backyards

Raising poultry at home is the leading cause of sickness from salmonella, far exceeding infections from pre-cut melons

4H ago salmonellapoultry-456px.jpg Women's World Cup trophy

U.S. Soccer: Women paid millions more than men

According to a letter released by U.S. Soccer President Carlos Cordeiro, the federation paid out more in salary and game bonuses to the women between 2010 and 2018

4H ago Women's World Cup trophy brazil-prison-riot-relatives.png

Relatives identifying victims of deadly prison riot in Brazil

Dozens of relatives of inmates killed during a riot in northern Brazil are gathering at a coroner's office Tuesday

1H ago brazil-prison-riot-relatives.png 015-rtr3gd2i.jpg

Boy charged with assault over dodgeball game

Months after the boy was suspended from his elementary school, his mom was notified he received a criminal charge

1H ago 015-rtr3gd2i.jpg 0730-cbsn-mcsallyabouthyten-1901044-640x360.jpg

Sen. Martha McSally defends Gen. Hyten

At Gen. John Hyten's confirmation hearing, Republican Senator Martha McSally, a survivor of military sexual assault, said Hyten was the right man for the job as vice chair of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.

2H ago 01:24 0730-cbsn-mcsallyabouthyten-1901044-640x360.jpg 0730-cbsn-hytendeniesallegations-1901000-640x360.jpg

Gen. Hyten denies misconduct allegations

At his confirmation hearing, Gen. John Hyten, President Trump's nominee for vice chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, categorically denied the sexual misconduct allegations against him, calling them false.

5H ago 00:26 0730-cbsn-hytendeniesallegations-1901000-640x360.jpg 0730-cbsn-policesearchformotivegilroy-1900994-640x360.jpg

Searching for motive in California shooting

Investigators are still working to determine the motive behind a deadly shooting at a California food festival on Sunday. Officials say Santino William Legan posted at least two photos on Instagram the day of the shooting, including one that referred to a book popular among white nationalist groups. CBS News correspondent Jamie Yuccas joined CBSN with the latest on the investigation.

5H ago 05:14 0730-cbsn-policesearchformotivegilroy-1900994-640x360.jpg 0430-en-asteroidpractice.jpg

"City killer" asteroid misses Earth – and scientists had no idea

Scientists revealed an asteroid dubbed by some as a "city killer" came closer to the Earth than the moon this week

19H ago 0430-en-asteroidpractice.jpg US-MEXICO-CINCO DE MAYO

New Mexico chiles to be grown in space

The "Española Improved" chile plant will be the first fruiting plant that the U.S. will grow aboard the Space Station

Jul 27 US-MEXICO-CINCO DE MAYO 072719-dragon2.jpg

SpaceX cargo ship reaches space station

SpaceX cargo ship brings 2.5 tons of supplies and equipment to space station

Jul 28 072719-dragon2.jpg cbsn-fusion-spacex-launches-falcon-9-rocket-today-2019-07-25-thumbnail-1898411-640x360.jpg

SpaceX launches Falcon 9 rocket

Thursday's launch marks SpaceX's 18th cargo run to the International Space Station. The Dragon supply ship atop the Falcon 9 was making its third trip to the lab complex, this time loaded with 5,000 pounds of crew supplies, equipment and high-tech science gear, including a low-tech container of bright green Nickelodeon "slime" for educational outreach. Watch the rocket launch here.

Jul 25 09:29 cbsn-fusion-spacex-launches-falcon-9-rocket-today-2019-07-25-thumbnail-1898411-640x360.jpg spacex-launch-today.png

SpaceX launches supplies — and slime — to space station

SpaceX Dragon cargo ship was loaded with 5,000 pounds of equipment and supplies — including a container of bright green Nickelodeon "slime"

Jul 25 spacex-launch-today.png jake-barlow-oddities-and-curiosities-expo-39.jpg

The Oddities & Curiosities Expo

A traveling exhibition of gothic and occult art, sideshow performers, and bizarre specimens stopped outside Chicago, where CBS News photographer Jake Barlow took in the odd sights

Jul 22 24 photos jake-barlow-oddities-and-curiosities-expo-39.jpg gettyimages-486106944.jpg

New York's Central Park

America's first major landscaped public park, the 840-acre park in Manhattan welcomes more than 37 million visitors every year

Jul 21 25 photos gettyimages-486106944.jpg Charles Manson

Manson Family murders: The terrifying story in pictures

A look at the cult slayings that shocked – and scared – America

Jul 3 44 photos Charles Manson star-trek.jpg

New on Netflix, Hulu and Amazon

Shows and movies you'll want to stream soon

Jun 24 30 photos star-trek.jpg danroy-dj-henry.jpg

Evidence photos from the police shooting of Danroy "DJ" Henry Jr.

Evidence from the scene of Pace University student DJ Henry’s fatal encounter with Officer Aaron Hess in Mount Pleasant, N.Y.

Jun 22 19 photos danroy-dj-henry.jpg wright-911-call-1567128-640x360.jpg

Popular

NBA star's desperate call for help

Listen to former NBA star Lorenzen Wright’s frantic 911 call made on the night in 2010 that he was murdered. Wright was unable to give his name or location as 11 gunshots are heard before the call cuts out. It took days for authorities to learn that it was Wright who made the call.

Jul 27 00:40 wright-911-call-1567128-640x360.jpg wright-murder-plot-1567134-640x360.jpg

The alleged plot to kill Lorenzen Wright

Prosecutor Paul Hagerman reads an affidavit about informant Jimmie Martin who claims he helped plan the murder of Lorenzen Wright. Martin is Sherra Wright’s cousin. Martin claims he wasn’t there the night of the murder, but says he did help clean up the crime scene.

Jul 27 01:37 wright-murder-plot-1567134-640x360.jpg lulu-arrest-1683015-640x360.jpg

Body cam video captures murder-for-hire suspect's arrest

On July 23, 2015, detectives with the Montgomery County Texas Constable's Office arrive at the Houston gym owned by Ramon Sosa and his wife, Lulu, to arrest Lulu on suspicion of plotting her husband's death.

Jul 20 03:29 lulu-arrest-1683015-640x360.jpg leibel-kasian-1674771-640x360.jpg

Sneak peek: Hollywood Horror Story

A wealthy Hollywood producer is accused of murdering his girlfriend. Was he following the plot of his frightening novel? Correspondent Maureen Maher investigates Saturday, July 13 at 10/9c on CBS.

Jul 13 03:37 leibel-kasian-1674771-640x360.jpg kasian-911-call-1674933-640x360.jpg

A mother's desperate 911 call

When Olga Kasian did not hear from her daughter Iana after several days, she began repeatedly calling 911. Concerned about Iana's well-being and her recent C-section, Kasian desperately asks police — through the help of an Russian interpreter — to enter the home her daughter shared with boyfriend Blake Leibel.

Jul 20 01:14 kasian-911-call-1674933-640x360.jpg