Public Citizen calls for FTC to probe Amazon over paid reviews

By Kate Gibson

/ MoneyWatch

Amazon Prime members a new U.S. majority

An estimated 100,000 — and as many as a million — people around the globe review Amazon products for pay that's based on the sales their writing generates. But consumer advocates allege that commission-based system isn't readily apparent to Amazon Prime subscribers, whose social-media feeds and email boxes were recently inundated with what amounts to undisclosed paid endorsements ahead of the retailer's Prime Day promotion last week.

That's the contention of Public Citizen, which on Tuesday called on the Federal Trade Commission to investigate whether the online retailer misled consumers in violation of the agency's rules.

"Amazon has colonized huge swaths of the internet and people's social media feeds, turning them into platforms for Amazon's disguised advertising, in violation of a core principle of fair advertising law," Public Citizen President Robert Weissman said in a statement. "When people see a recommendation for an Amazon Prime Day 'best buy,' they have a right to know if the person or company making that recommendation is getting a cut on the sales it is generating – but all too often that information is not disclosed."

Trending News

A substantial portion of Prime Day recommendations directed at consumers in the days before and during the two-day sales event last week were paid endorsements, yet in many cases that relationship was inadequately or not disclosed, according to Public Citizen. While Amazon instructs its reviewers to disclose that they are paid for the reviews through sales commissions and not a flat fee, the direction appears to be frequently and routinely ignored, Public Citizen said.

Prime Day protests: Amazon workers fight for better working conditions and pay

Amazon didn't immediately return requests for comment. An FTC spokesperson confirmed the agency had received the consumer group's complaint, but declined further comment.

In a letter to the FTC urging the agency to probe the matter, Public Citizen also took issue with Amazon's suggested disclosure phrase — "As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases" — calling it less than clear. Weissman wrote in a July 23 letter to the FTC that group favors a more explicit disclosure that would state: "This is a paid endorsement. I receive commissions on sales if you click on links in this story or use the code included in the review."

In reviewing Amazon Prime Day promotions, Public Citizen found 15 web-published articles that it said had no disclosure and eight that contained non-prominent disclosures. It also found 53 Instagram postings without any disclosure and 22 the group said were inadequate. The organization said it's possible that some of the reviews were independent and that no disclosure was required.

First published on July 23, 2019 / 2:25 PM

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc.. All Rights Reserved.

Consumer group wants FTC to probe Amazon over paid reviews

Consumer watchdog urges regulator to examine whether the online retailer failed to disclose paid product plugs

14M ago

Facility for migrant children in rented "man camp" to close

The facility cost $50 million and has been open for just over three weeks

18M ago

Uber tests $25 all-in-one pass for rides, eats, scooters and more

Uber is testing a new kind of subscription that encourages ride-hailing passengers to use its other services, too

21M ago

FDA launches TV ads featuring magician to fight teen vaping

The Centers for Disease Control says more than 1 in 5 high school students and nearly 1 in 20 middle school students vape

30M ago

Arrest made in death of 21-year-old college student

Brandon Theesfeld, 22, of Texas, was taken into custody Monday afternoon

1H ago

Facility for migrant children in rented "man camp" to close

The facility cost $50 million and has been open for just over three weeks

18M ago

Boris Johnson to become next prime minister of U.K.

Less than 200k members of the Conservative Party have picked ex-London Mayor to replace Brexit-battered Theresa May

1H ago

Mark Esper confirmed by Senate as defense secretary

The Pentagon has been without a Senate-confirmed leader since December when James Mattis resigned

1H ago

Trump speaks to conservative group Turning Point USA

The controversial and outspoken group has been embraced by President Trump

1H ago

U.S. downed more than one Iranian drone, commander suggests

In an interview with CBS News' David Martin, CENTCOM commander Gen. Kenneth McKenzie suggested there were possibly two drones downed in the incident

2H ago

Facility for migrant children in rented "man camp" to close

The facility cost $50 million and has been open for just over three weeks

18M ago

Meet Boris Johnson, the man who called Trump "unfit" to be president

Britain's next prime minister is known for an off-beat brand of charisma, political opportunism, and promoting a hard Brexit

1H ago

Boris Johnson to become next prime minister of U.K.

Less than 200k members of the Conservative Party have picked ex-London Mayor to replace Brexit-battered Theresa May

1H ago

Rare Amazon tribe captured on video

The clip filmed in the northern state of Maranhao shows members of the Awa tribe

1H ago

Journalist Maria Ressa goes on trial in the Philippines

Ressa is accused of criminal libel, but she and supporters say the case is just President Rodrigo Duterte's effort to silence a critical, free press

3H ago

American Wonders: California's glowing "Field of Light"

More than 58,000 solar-powered spheres now shimmer in Paso Robles' fields

3H ago

R. Kelly's crisis manager resigns

Just hours after appearing only on CBS This Morning, singer R. Kelly’s crisis manager resigned. In a statement to CBS News, Darrell Johnson said he is stepping down for “personal reasons.” He did not elaborate. on Monday, Johnson made headlines when he said he would not leave his daughter alone with anyone accused of being a pedophile. Kelly is charged with sexually abusing women and girls.

2H ago 01:24

New on Netflix, Hulu and Amazon

Shows and movies you'll want to stream soon

Jun 24 33 photos

Chelsea Clinton announces birth of 3rd child

"We are overflowing with love and gratitude and can't wait to introduce him to his big sister and brother," said Clinton in a tweet

15H ago

R. Kelly's crisis manager announces he's stepping down

"I step down as crisis manager for personal reasons," Darrell Johnson told CBS News hours after his appearance Monday on "CBS This Morning"

17H ago

Consumer group wants FTC to probe Amazon over paid reviews

Consumer watchdog urges regulator to examine whether the online retailer failed to disclose paid product plugs

14M ago

Uber tests $25 all-in-one pass for rides, eats, scooters and more

Uber is testing a new kind of subscription that encourages ride-hailing passengers to use its other services, too

21M ago

New satellite factory to focus on space-based internet

"OneWeb is doing for the satellite industry what Henry Ford did for cars," said FCC Chairman Ajit Pai

Jul 22

India launches spacecraft to far side of moon

It's designed to land on the lunar surface and send a rover around to explore water deposits

Jul 22

Extended transcript: SpaceX CEO Elon Musk on putting boots on the moon and Mars

The founder and CEO of SpaceX discusses the aerospace company's ambitions for flying humans to the moon and Mars, the importance of reusable in rockets, and the inspiration of Douglas Adams

Jul 21

"Corn sweat" makes heat wave even more dangerous

Late last week, Wisconsin was even more humid than Miami — and experts say corn sweat is to blame

Jul 22

New species of glow-in-the-dark shark identified

The small shark was first captured nearly a decade ago, but researchers recently determined it is a brand new species

Jul 22

Pence says moon, not Mars, remains near-term goal for NASA

In an interview on "The Takeout," Vice President Mike Pence reassured the space community with the administration's strong support for a "moon-first" policy

Jul 21

Extended transcript: SpaceX CEO Elon Musk on putting boots on the moon and Mars

The founder and CEO of SpaceX discusses the aerospace company's ambitions for flying humans to the moon and Mars, the importance of reusable in rockets, and the inspiration of Douglas Adams

Jul 21

SpaceX CEO Elon Musk on the next giant leap for mankind

The aerospace entrepreneur says we are only a few years away from employing reusable rockets to bring people to the moon and Mars, making humans a "multi-planet species"

Jul 21

FDA launches TV ads featuring magician to fight teen vaping

The Centers for Disease Control says more than 1 in 5 high school students and nearly 1 in 20 middle school students vape

30M ago

Millions take aspirin for heart health – but many shouldn't

People who take aspirin to prevent a heart attack​ may need to rethink the pill-popping, Harvard researchers report

4H ago

Tainted alcohol suspected of killing at least 19 in Costa Rica

The government has confiscated about 30,000 bottles of alcohol suspected to be poisoned with methanol

18H ago

Study finds colon cancer rates rising for patients under 50

Colon cancer is the third most common cancer in the U.S.

19H ago

Arkansas could go down to one abortion clinic

If the laws aren't blocked, women in Arkansas won't be able to access abortions after 10 weeks into pregnancy beginning this week

22H ago

Consumer group wants FTC to probe Amazon over paid reviews

Consumer watchdog urges regulator to examine whether the online retailer failed to disclose paid product plugs

14M ago

Uber tests $25 all-in-one pass for rides, eats, scooters and more

Uber is testing a new kind of subscription that encourages ride-hailing passengers to use its other services, too

21M ago

Macy's pulls plates with "mom jeans" and "skinny jeans" portions

Retailer's novelty plates sparked outrage, with some consumers complaining the design fostered body-shaming

2H ago

Trump plan would kick 3 million people off food stamps

Proposed rule would curb states' ability to provide nutrition assistance to many low-income families

2H ago

Elizabeth Warren warns Trump may trigger economic meltdown

In a blog post published Monday, the Democratic presidential candidate warns that the economy is on shakier footing than it seems

18H ago

Arrest made in death of 21-year-old college student

Brandon Theesfeld, 22, of Texas, was taken into custody Monday afternoon

1H ago

Investigation into murdered couple in Canada

Police in British Columbia are looking for a person of interest in the killings of American Chynna Deese and her Australian boyfriend Lucas Fowler. Another man's death may also be connected. CBS News correspondent Nikki Battiste joins CBSN to explain the latest.

4H ago 04:17

Man who killed mob boss allegedly thought he was helping Trump

Anthony Comello is facing murder charges in the shooting of Francesco "Franky Boy" Cali, an alleged leader in the Gambino crime family

6H ago

Video shows couple before being killed near notorious highway

Investigators are still looking for leads in the crime, which took place near Canada's notorious "Highway of Tears"

7H ago

Cops hunt for leads in Canada murders

Investigators have released a sketch of a person of interest in the murder of an American woman and her Australian boyfriend along a remote Canadian highway. Authorities in British Columbia are also searching for two missing teens. While looking for them, they found a man's body on the side of the road. Police are investigating whether any of these are connected, as families of the young couple are grieving. Nikki Battiste reports.

6H ago 02:24

Chris Kraft, legendary NASA flight director, has died at age 95

Kraft virtually invented the mission control concept behind NASA's greatest space triumphs

17H ago

New satellite factory to focus on space-based internet

"OneWeb is doing for the satellite industry what Henry Ford did for cars," said FCC Chairman Ajit Pai

Jul 22

Pence says moon, not Mars, remains near-term goal for NASA

In an interview on "The Takeout," Vice President Mike Pence reassured the space community with the administration's strong support for a "moon-first" policy

Jul 21

Extended transcript: SpaceX CEO Elon Musk on putting boots on the moon and Mars

The founder and CEO of SpaceX discusses the aerospace company's ambitions for flying humans to the moon and Mars, the importance of reusable in rockets, and the inspiration of Douglas Adams

Jul 21

SpaceX CEO Elon Musk on the next giant leap for mankind

The aerospace entrepreneur says we are only a few years away from employing reusable rockets to bring people to the moon and Mars, making humans a "multi-planet species"

Jul 21

The Oddities & Curiosities Expo

A traveling exhibition of gothic and occult art, sideshow performers, and bizarre specimens stopped outside Chicago, where CBS News photographer Jake Barlow took in the odd sights

Jul 22 24 photos

New York's Central Park

America's first major landscaped public park, the 840-acre park in Manhattan welcomes more than 37 million visitors every year

Jul 21 25 photos

Manson Family murders: The terrifying story in pictures

A look at the cult slayings that shocked – and scared – America

Jul 3 44 photos

New on Netflix, Hulu and Amazon

Shows and movies you'll want to stream soon

Jun 24 33 photos

Evidence photos from the police shooting of Danroy "DJ" Henry Jr.

Evidence from the scene of Pace University student DJ Henry’s fatal encounter with Officer Aaron Hess in Mount Pleasant, N.Y.

Jun 22 19 photos

Popular

Body cam video captures murder-for-hire suspect's arrest

On July 23, 2015, detectives with the Montgomery County Texas Constable's Office arrive at the Houston gym owned by Ramon Sosa and his wife, Lulu, to arrest Lulu on suspicion of plotting her husband's death.

Jul 20 03:29

Cell phone video shows aftermath of DJ Henry shooting

Video from Robert Coulombe who attended Pace University with DJ Henry shows the scene at a Westchester, N.Y., strip mall minutes after DJ was shot in his car by Officer Aaron Hess in October 2010.

Jun 22 00:37

Sneak peek: Hollywood Horror Story

A wealthy Hollywood producer is accused of murdering his girlfriend. Was he following the plot of his frightening novel? Correspondent Maureen Maher investigates Saturday, July 13 at 10/9c on CBS.

Jul 13 03:37

A mother's desperate 911 call

When Olga Kasian did not hear from her daughter Iana after several days, she began repeatedly calling 911. Concerned about Iana's well-being and her recent C-section, Kasian desperately asks police — through the help of an Russian interpreter — to enter the home her daughter shared with boyfriend Blake Leibel.

Jul 20 01:14

#BlazeItForward: Murder victim remembered for his generosity and spirit

Close friends of the slain college sophomore share stories about the chef, writer and aspiring doctor who left their lives too soon.

Jul 20 02:27