Emanuela Orlandi mystery: Vatican to open 2 graves in hunt for missing girl after cryptic clue

By Anna Matranga

/ CBS News

Demonstrators hold posters of Emanuela Orlandi reading "Missing" during Pope Benedict XVI's Regina Coeli noon prayer in St. Peter's square, at the Vatican, in a May 27, 2012 file photo. Getty

Rome — The tiny, 1,200-year-old Teutonic Cemetery is the only graveyard inside the walls of Vatican City. The cemetery just behind St. Peter's Basilica is the final resting place of royals, cardinals, artists — and, just maybe, a teenage girl who disappeared 36 years ago without a trace.

The Vatican will open two 19th century graves in the cemetery on Thursday morning to let forensic experts look for the remains of Emanuela Orlandi. She was the 15 year-old-daughter of a Vatican bank employee whose family lived inside Vatican City. Orlandi was last seen at a bus stop in central Rome after leaving a flute lesson on June 22, 1983.

The mystery of her disappearance has gripped Italy ever since.

Trending News

One of the tombs to be opened, known as the "Tomb of the Angel" contains the remains of Princess Sophie von Hohenlohe, who died in 1836. The other is the resting place of Princess Carlotta Federica of Mecklemburg, who died in 1840. Members of their families, Orlandi's, and forensics scientists and Vatican police will all be present when the tombs are unsealed.

Orlandi's mother still lives in Vatican City, close to the Teutonic Cemetery. After searching for Emanuela incessantly for three decades, "the family won't be happy if they find Emanuela's corpse just 200 yards from their home," Orlandi family lawyer Laura Sgro told CBS News.

Giovanni Arcudi, a forensics expert and professor at Rome's Tor Vergata University, will lead the team tasked with exhuming the skeletons and then, bone by bone, examining them to assess the years of death, age, sex and stature — all to verify who they belong to.

VATICAN-RELIGION-ITALY-MISSING
A Feb. 13, 2013 file photo shows the Teutonic Cemetery in the courtyard of the Collegio Teutonico, as seen from atop St. Peter's Basilica at the Vatican. Getty

Arcudi's team will also take samples for DNA testing, which will take place later.

In a statement issued by the Vatican, Arcudi said it could take five hours to open the two tombs and remove the remains, barring unforeseen circumstances.

"The state of conservation of the bones is what will determine how much time is needed," he said. "Obviously that is not predictable before the tombs are opened."

But he said he'd know fairly quickly whether the tombs contained the bones of anyone other than the two German princesses.

Human bones discovered in building attached to Vatican embassy

"We can distinguish whether a bone is 10 years old or if it's been there 50 years, or 150 years," he said. "After this first initial examination, we may even be able to exclude the hypothesis that the skeletal remains belong to people other than the two who were buried there."

But he said the DNA tests would be carried out regardless of what the skeletal examinations revealed, in order to definitively exclude the presence of Orlandi's remains. The DNA results could take up to several months to come back.

Orlandi's family has been chasing clues on her disappearance for decades, and conspiracy theories abound. Because the family lived inside the Vatican walls, many of the rumors involve the Vatican itself: that she was murdered in connection to the Vatican bank scandals of the 1980s; that she was kidnapped to barter for the freedom of a man who attempted to kill Pope John Paul II; that she was kidnapped as part of a sex slavery ring inside the Vatican. So far there has been no solid evidence in the case at all.

Rome_tAP120514010095.jpg
Forensic police unload equipment in the courtyard of Sant'Apollinare Basilica in Rome, May 14, 2012. The tomb of reputed mobster Enrico De Pedis was opened inside the basilica as part of an investigation into the disappearance of Emanuela Orlandi. AP

Thursday won't be the first time a grave is opened to search for the teenager's remains. After persistent rumors that her body was concealed in the grave of a Roman mobster, police opened his tomb in 2012. They found nothing that didn't belong there.

Last summer, the family received yet another anonymous tip.

"I received a letter with a picture in it," Sgro, the family's attorney, told CBS News. "The letter said: 'If you want to find Emanuela, search where the angel is looking.'" The photo was of a marble statue of an angel that looks down on the German princesses' tombs in the Teutonic Cemetery.

Sgro said the family went to the Teutonic Cemetery and quickly found the "Tomb of the Angel," and they noticed something that seemed to be amiss.

"The tomb had obviously been recently opened, there was new cement on it, but we didn't know why or when, we were given no information," Sgro told CBS News.

In February, they petitioned the Vatican Secretary of State to permit the tombs to be opened. Last week a Vatican tribunal granted the request.

First published on July 10, 2019 / 11:36 AM

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Demonstrators hold posters of Emanuela O VATICAN-RELIGION-ITALY-MISSING Rome_tAP120514010095.jpg

"Florida Girls" creator on inspiration behind new series

Comedy series follows four young women as they "navigate life's curveballs while living below the poverty line"

37M ago

Trump speaks and signs executive order to advance kidney health

The president is giving a speech Wednesday in Washington

updated 13M ago

Epstein had "well in excess of 50" victims, accusers' lawyer says

Epstein faces federal child sex trafficking charges in New York City, where prosecutors say a raid of his home turned up hundreds of lewd photos

1H ago

AFM still a "bit of a mystery" amid peak season for polio-like illness

It's not yet clear exactly how the virus works, or how to treat it

1H ago

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez suggests dissolving DHS

"I think we need to undo a lot of the egregious mistakes that the Bush administration did" said Ocasio-Cortez

1H ago

Trump speaks and signs executive order to advance kidney health

The president is giving a speech Wednesday in Washington

updated 13M ago

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez suggests dissolving DHS

"I think we need to undo a lot of the egregious mistakes that the Bush administration did" said Ocasio-Cortez

1H ago

Appeals court appears ready to rule Obamacare unconstitutional

Setting up a potential legal showdown in the middle of the 2020 presidential race

3H ago

U.K. Ambassador to U.S. resigns over leaked cables bashing Trump

Britain's government kept backing him, but with Trump fuming on Twitter, Sir Kim Darroch said the "current situation" made it "impossible" to do his job

1H ago

Ivory Coast passes legislation encouraged by Ivanka Trump

The country is in the process of updating its family code to make it more equitable to women

4H ago

Vatican to open 2 graves in hunt for missing girl after cryptic clue

Emanuela Orlandi vanished without a trace 36 years ago, but a mysterious letter suggests she may be buried in a 19th century tomb inside Vatican City

5M ago

U.S. argues its case against Iran to a divided world

Trump admin. called a special session of atomic agency over Iran's nuclear deal breaches, but Iran and Russia say it's the U.S. that broke its promise

2H ago

Germany's Angela Merkel seen shaking again at public event

It is the 3rd such incident in less than a month, but Chancellor Merkel continues to insist that she is "fine"

3H ago

Family blames cruise line for girl's deadly fall, seeks video

A lawyer for the family claims a window was left open in the children's play area

4H ago

U.K. Ambassador to U.S. resigns over leaked cables bashing Trump

Britain's government kept backing him, but with Trump fuming on Twitter, Sir Kim Darroch said the "current situation" made it "impossible" to do his job

1H ago

"Florida Girls" creator on inspiration behind new series

Comedy series follows four young women as they "navigate life's curveballs while living below the poverty line"

37M ago

Beyonce's new single for "The Lion King" released

"Spirit" is the first full song Disney has unveiled – two full star-studded albums will soon follow

2H ago

New on Netflix, Hulu and Amazon

Shows and movies you'll want to stream soon

Jun 24 33 photos

Rip Torn, a star of "The Larry Sanders Show," has died at age 88

Emmy-winning actor's career spanned 60 years and also included appearances in films and on- and off-Broadway

9H ago

Nicki Minaj pulls out of Saudi Arabia concert to support human rights

Nicki Minaj was originally scheduled to headline Jeddah World Fest on July 18

18H ago

Activists warn about potential abuse of facial scans for ICE

At least three states have scanned millions of driver's license photos on behalf of Immigration and Customs Enforcement without drivers' knowledge or consent

Jul 8

Zuckerberg's security chief out over sexual harassment accusations

Liam Booth is accused of sexual misconduct and slurs that included racist remarks about Mark Zuckerberg's wife, Priscilla Chan

Jul 8

Amazon warehouse workers plan Prime Day protest

Employees at Minnesota center plan a job walkout on July 15, the first frenzied day of Amazon's annual summer sale

Jul 8

Amazon's competitors primed for Prime Day

Retailers from eBay to Walmart want a piece of the summer shopping-holiday action that Amazon successfully created

Jul 8

8 Frank Lloyd Wright buildings recognized for "organic architecture"

Guggenheim Museum​ in New York City, Los Angeles' Hollyhock House​ and the Unity Temple​ in suburban Chicago were among those added to to UNESCO World Heritage list

Jul 7

Toxic algae affecting Miss. beaches is eating into local businesses

Algae blooms can cause a host of ailments including rashes, nausea and diarrhea

16H ago

Saturn's rings will be visible from Earth

You could see it with your eyes only, or you can look into a telescope and see the ringed planet's signature feature

21H ago

American scientist's body found in Greece

Suzanne Eaton was last seen a week ago, when colleagues said she went for a run on the Greek island of Crete

Jul 9

California earthquakes a stark warning for L.A.

Seismologist Lucy Jones estimates a similar quake in LA could cause $200 billion in damage

Jul 8

Scientists studying brains of altruistic organ donors

There were more than 20,000 kidney transplants in the United States last year, with just a few hundred coming from altruistic donors

Jul 8

AFM still a "bit of a mystery" amid peak season for polio-like illness

It's not yet clear exactly how the virus works, or how to treat it

1H ago

First baby born in U.S. from dead donor's transplanted womb

Cleveland Clinic says it has delivered the first baby in North America after a womb transplant from a dead donor.

2H ago

American dies during plastic surgery in the Dominican Republic

"Women are going over there for these surgeries, these elective surgeries, and not coming out alive," victim's sister said

13H ago

Toxic algae affecting Miss. beaches is eating into local businesses

Algae blooms can cause a host of ailments including rashes, nausea and diarrhea

16H ago

After earthquakes rattle California, expert shares tips to cope

A clinical and forensic neuropsychologist tells CBS Los Angeles that natural disasters are classified as traumatic experiences

Jul 7

Fed rate cut appears likely in Jay Powell's speech to Congress

With Powell facing Congress for two days, the direction of interest rate policy will be the key takeaway

1H ago

Marriott sued by DC alleging fraudulent resort fees

It's the first lawsuit to come out of an ongoing multi-state investigation into pricing practices in hotel chains

16H ago

Toxic algae affecting Miss. beaches is eating into local businesses

Algae blooms can cause a host of ailments including rashes, nausea and diarrhea

16H ago

The U.S. Women's National Team's next goal: Equal pay

As they parade up New York City's Canyon of Heroes Wednesday, these pro athletes know what they want to happen now

15H ago

Walmart will stop selling guns in New Mexico

The state's new expanded background check law would require Walmart to conduct checks on guns it doesn't sell

19H ago

Crime

Teen migrant claims CBP officer assaulted her

Customs and Border Protection confirms it is investigating allegations of sexual assault on a 15-year-old migrant girl by a border officer. The alleged assault, first reported by NBC News, took place at a facility in Yuma, Arizona. The teenager from Honduras said the officer put his hands inside her bra, pulled down her underwear and groped her, during what was supposed to be a routine pat down.

4H ago 00:54

Alan Dershowitz speaks after Epstein arrest

Alan Dershowitz, one of Jeffrey Epstein's former lawyers, talks about the new accusations against his former client in his first TV interview since Epstein's indictment. Dershowitz defended Epstein against sex abuse allegations in Florida more than a decade ago. One of Epstein's accusers, Virginia Roberts Giuffre, claims she was forced to have sex with Dershowitz as part of Epstein's alleged sex trafficking operation. Dershowitz says Giuffre and her lawyer, David Boies, falsely accused him as part of an elaborate extortion scheme. Giuffre is suing him for defamation. Mola Lenghi reports.

3H ago 04:38

California teen fatally shot by officer

A 17-year-old girl's family is demanding action and answers after the teen was shot and killed by a Southern California police officer. Orange County prosecutors said the Fullerton officer fatally shot Hannah Linn Williams after their vehicles "made physical contact" on a freeway. CBSN Los Angeles has more.

1H ago 01:16

Family demands answers after 17-year-old girl fatally shot by officer

The circumstances of Hannah Williams' death Friday on a Southern California freeway remain unclear

1H ago

Russia helped spread political conspiracy

CBS News confirmed a Russian disinformation campaign helped push a bogus theory about the murder of a Democratic National Committee staffer. The story even caught the attention of conservative commentators. Ed O'Keefe has more.

16H ago 02:00

Saturn's rings will be visible from Earth

You could see it with your eyes only, or you can look into a telescope and see the ringed planet's signature feature

21H ago

NASA successfully tests abort system

NASA completed a successful test of its launch abort system Tuesday morning from Cape Canaveral, Florida. That puts the U.S. space program one step closer to sending astronauts back to the moon, and eventually to Mars. CBS News space consultant Bill Harwood joined CBSN with details.

Jul 2 04:49

Solar eclipse boom-time for small cities in the sweet spot

One Chilean city was flooded with more than 300,000 visitors to see the moon completely hide the sun for just a few fleeting minutes

Jul 2

NASA launches capsule to test abort system for moonship

The launch abort system would pull a moon-bound crew to safety in a booster failure

Jul 2

Welcome to July 1969: Inside NASA's restored Mission Control

"CBS This Morning" got an exclusive look inside the three-year, multimillion-dollar renovation

Jun 28

Manson Family murders: The terrifying story in pictures

A look at the cult slayings that shocked – and scared – America

Jul 3 44 photos

New on Netflix, Hulu and Amazon

Shows and movies you'll want to stream soon

Jun 24 33 photos

Evidence photos from the police shooting of Danroy "DJ" Henry Jr.

Evidence from the scene of Pace University student DJ Henry’s fatal encounter with Officer Aaron Hess in Mount Pleasant, N.Y.

Jun 22 19 photos

Apollo 11 50th anniversary: 50 photos from the moon

50 photos to celebrate the 50th anniversary of the moon landing

Jun 21 50 photos

Deadliest highway in every state

These are the highways with the highest rate of fatal crashes

Jun 20 50 photos

Popular

Royal baby Archie's christening

In this week's Royals Report, we're learning new details of baby Archie's private christening service. BBC royals correspondent Jonny Dymond joined CBSN from London with more.

updated 9M ago 06:59

Report: Refugees from Africa coming to U.S.

A new report by the Los Angeles Times is highlighting refugees from Africa who are traveling to seek asylum in the U.S. Los Angeles Times immigration reporter Molly O'Toole joined CBSN with more on her report.

1H ago 06:55

Mission to save South Africa's flamingos

Severe drought has cost South Africa an estimated half a billion dollars, and it's forced an unprecedented rescue mission. Thousands of flamingos were forced to abandon their eggs and newborn chicks earlier this year because of the lack of water. Specialists from the Dallas Zoo traveled to South Africa to try to save the baby birds. Debora Patta reports.

updated 23M ago 04:57

Family turns injury into business plan

Megan Ross turned her kid's injury into a business, GooseEgged, that creates ice packs to make bumps and bruises more bearable for kids.

1H ago 03:20

"Three Women" author on female desire

The book “Three Women” is one of this summer’s most anticipated debuts. Author Lisa Taddeo spent eight years traveling across the country to share the stories of three different women’s sexual desires. Lisa Taddeo joins “CBS This Morning” in her first television interview to talk about her new book.

2H ago 06:25