Obamacare battle continues in New Orleans court

/ AP

The fate of former President Barack Obama's signature health care law, and its coverage and insurance protections for millions of Americans, is again being argued before a panel of judges — this time a federal appeals court in New Orleans.

At issue in a hearing scheduled Tuesday by a three-judge panel of the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals is whether Congress effectively rendered it unconstitutional in 2017 when it zeroed out the tax imposed on those who chose not to buy insurance. Texas-based U.S. District Judge Reed O'Connor declared in December that it did. The law's supporters appealed.

It's unclear when the panel will rule in a case that appears destined for the Supreme Court, which has reviewed the law before. The ultimate outcome will affect protections for people with pre-existing conditions; Medicaid expansions covering roughly 12 million people; and subsidies that help about 10 million others afford health insurance.

Trending News

Tuesday's arguments are the latest in a lawsuit filed by Republican officials in 18 states, led by the Texas Attorney General's Office. It was filed after Congress — which didn't repeal the law, despite pressure from President Donald Trump — reduced to zero the unpopular tax imposed on those without insurance.

In challenging the law anew, "Obamacare" opponents noted the 2012 ruling of a divided Supreme Court that upheld the law. Conservative justices had rejected the argument that Congress could require everyone to buy insurance under the Constitution's interstate commerce clause. But Chief Justice John Roberts, joining four liberal justices, said Congress did have the power to impose a tax on those without insurance.

With no tax penalty now in effect, the Texas lawsuit argues, the individual mandate is unconstitutional and the entire law must fall without it. O'Connor, the federal judge in Texas, agreed in a December ruling.

In addition to the 18 states, two individual taxpayers are part of the lawsuit. The Trump administration is not defending the law and has filed arguments in favor of O'Connor's ruling.

California's attorney general represents a coalition of mostly Democratic-led states and the District of Columbia seeking to overturn O'Connor's ruling and uphold the law. The House of Representatives has joined them. Among the arguments by the law's supporters: Those who filed suit have no case because they aren't harmed by a penalty that doesn't exist; the reduction of the tax penalty to zero could be read as a suspension of the tax, but the tax's legal structure still exists; and that, even if the individual mandate is now unconstitutional, that does not affect the rest of the law known as the Affordable Care Act.

When the law was proposed, friends and foes of "Obamacare" agreed that the tax was essential to persuade healthy people to get insured, thereby keeping premiums in check. But this year — the first time no fines will be collected — the number of people signing up for subsidized private insurance through the Affordable Care Act slipped only slightly.

The government said in March that a total of 11.4 million people signed up during open enrollment season, a dip of about 300,000 from last year.

Scheduled to hear Tuesday's arguments were 5th Circuit Judges Carolyn Dineen King, Jennifer Walker Elrod and Kurt Engelhardt. King was nominated to the appeals court by President Jimmy Carter in 1979. Elrod was nominated by President George W. Bush in 2007. Engelhardt was nominated by President Donald Trump last year.

Democrats in the Senate said Monday that Republicans will pay a political price if the case results in the loss of popular "Obamacare."

"If they are successful in striking down the Affordable Care Act, Republicans will own all of the consequences," Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer of New York said on a call Monday with reporters.

First published on July 9, 2019 / 7:48 AM

© 2019 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Obamacare battle continues in New Orleans court

A panel of judges will decide whether Congress rendered it unconstitutional in 2017 when it zeroed out the tax imposed on those who chose not to buy insurance

2M ago

How modified stretch limos sacrifice safety for amenities

The custom-built vehicles don't undergo crash testing — and are not required to meet the same federal safety standards as other vehicles

3M ago

McConnell gets challenger in retired fighter pilot Amy McGrath

"Everything that's wrong in Washington had to start some place," McGrath says of McConnell

5M ago

23 governors back pledge to oppose Trump mileage freeze

The stand comes as the Trump administration moves to freeze tougher mileage standards laid out by former President Barack Obama

6M ago

Judge blocks Trump rule requiring drug ads to reveal prices

The DC-based judge struck down a requirement that was set to go into effect within hours, on Tuesday

22M ago

Obamacare battle continues in New Orleans court

A panel of judges will decide whether Congress rendered it unconstitutional in 2017 when it zeroed out the tax imposed on those who chose not to buy insurance

2M ago

McConnell gets challenger in retired fighter pilot Amy McGrath

"Everything that's wrong in Washington had to start some place," McGrath says of McConnell

5M ago

23 governors back pledge to oppose Trump mileage freeze

The stand comes as the Trump administration moves to freeze tougher mileage standards laid out by former President Barack Obama

6M ago

Judge blocks Trump rule requiring drug ads to reveal prices

The DC-based judge struck down a requirement that was set to go into effect within hours, on Tuesday

22M ago

Trump's threats of ICE raids keep immigrants on edge

"I'm scared to go outside," one Guatemalan mother said. "If they take my kids away from me, what's going to happen to them?"

1H ago

U.K. PM May stands by ambassador after leaked cables bash Trump

The cables revealed Sir. Kim Darroch's opinion that the Trump administration is "dysfunctional," "clumsy" and "inept"

36M ago

Saudi princess faces verdict in workman's beating at Paris home

Tradesman says sister of powerful Saudi heir Mohammed bin Salman shouted, "Kill him, the dog, he doesn't deserve to live," as he was beaten

47M ago

American scientist's body found in Greece

Suzanne Eaton was last seen a week ago, when colleagues said she went for a run on the Greek island of Crete

updated 13M ago

U.S. draws China's ire with proposed $2.2B arms sale to Taiwan

Beijing claims Taiwan as its territory, and has been making more overt military threats and trying to isolate the tiny, self-ruled island

2H ago

Activists: Hong Kong leader dubbing disputed bill "dead" falls short

Opposition groups want Carrie Lam to totally withdraw extradition measure that's sparked massive protests – and they plan more demonstrations

6H ago

"Stranger Things" season 3 breaks Netflix streaming records

The show has already turned the platform's ratings record upside down

9H ago

Streisand duets with "A Star is Born" co-star Kristofferson

"Here's a song that we sang together, in the movie, right?" Streisand said as music for "Lost Inside of You" began to play

10H ago

New on Netflix, Hulu and Amazon

Shows and movies you'll want to stream soon

Jun 24 33 photos

"Stranger Things" star Dacre Montgomery on humanizing a villain

The Australian actor plays a major antagonist in season three of the popular show

20H ago

Artur Brauner, producer and Holocaust survivor, has died at age 100

Brauner produced hundreds of films, including several 1960s revivals of the "Dr. Mabuse" crime movies and other hits such as "Girls in Uniform"

Jul 7

Activists warn about potential abuse of facial scans for ICE

At least three states have scanned millions of driver's license photos on behalf of Immigration and Customs Enforcement without drivers' knowledge or consent

9H ago

Zuckerberg's security chief out over sexual harassment accusations

Liam Booth is accused of sexual misconduct and slurs that included racist remarks about Mark Zuckerberg's wife, Priscilla Chan

10H ago

Amazon warehouse workers plan Prime Day protest

Employees at Minnesota center plan a job walkout on July 15, the first frenzied day of Amazon's annual summer sale

13H ago

Amazon's competitors primed for Prime Day

Retailers from eBay to Walmart want a piece of the summer shopping-holiday action that Amazon successfully created

14H ago

8 Frank Lloyd Wright buildings recognized for "organic architecture"

Guggenheim Museum​ in New York City, Los Angeles' Hollyhock House​ and the Unity Temple​ in suburban Chicago were among those added to to UNESCO World Heritage list

Jul 7

American scientist's body found in Greece

Suzanne Eaton was last seen a week ago, when colleagues said she went for a run on the Greek island of Crete

updated 13M ago

California earthquakes a stark warning for L.A.

Seismologist Lucy Jones estimates a similar quake in LA could cause $200 billion in damage

13H ago

Scientists studying brains of altruistic organ donors

There were more than 20,000 kidney transplants in the United States last year, with just a few hundred coming from altruistic donors

15H ago

Bright orange bird turns out to be seagull covered in curry

The bird, which was later named Vinny after Vindaloo curry, had a pungent smell and couldn't fly

17H ago

Trump avoids climate change in speech on environmentalism

A White House fact sheet provided to CBS News ahead of his speech didn't mention climate change, and the president stuck to that

15H ago

After earthquakes rattle California, expert shares tips to cope

A clinical and forensic neuropsychologist tells CBS Los Angeles that natural disasters are classified as traumatic experiences

Jul 7

All of Mississippi's beaches have closed due to toxic algae bloom

The bloom is caused by the opening of the Bonnet Carre spillway in Louisiana, which has brought an "excessive amount of freshwater to the coastline"

Jul 7

Where's the beef? Hamburger patties made from plants

It tastes like the real thing, but it's just a little different. Allison Aubrey reports on hamburgers that are made from plants instead of beef

Jul 7

Pig ears as dog treats linked to salmonella in 13 states

At least 45 people have been sickened by bacteria in dog product being recalled by retailer Pet Supplies Plus

Jul 5

Former Patriots star recovering after suffering stroke

"Tedy and his family thank you for your ongoing encouragement, and kindly ask for privacy at this time," his charity said

Jul 5

Amazon warehouse workers plan Prime Day protest

Employees at Minnesota center plan a job walkout on July 15, the first frenzied day of Amazon's annual summer sale

13H ago

Weary from standing, American Airlines ticket agents beg for stools

On their feet for up to 12 hours a day, thousands have signed a petition asking the carrier for some relief

14H ago

Amazon's competitors primed for Prime Day

Retailers from eBay to Walmart want a piece of the summer shopping-holiday action that Amazon successfully created

14H ago

Hiking minimum wage to $15 would boost pay for up to 27 million, CBO says

The increase would affect more people than work in the entire manufacturing sector, but it could also cause job losses

14H ago

Boeing loses first big 737 Max order to rival Airbus

Saudi Arabia's flyadeal will buy 50 A320neos from Airbus, reversing its plan to buy $5.9 billion of 737 Max planes

9H ago

Accusers speak out after Jeffrey Epstein charged and jailed

Billionaire financier was charged Monday with sexually abusing dozens of underage girls

33M ago

Why Alex Acosta is "public enemy No. 2"

Billionaire financier Jeffrey Epstein is behind bars for underage sex trafficking charges. His lawyers say it's illegal double jeopardy because of a controversial plea bargain more than a decade ago. CBS News legal analyst Rikki Klieman joins "CBS This Morning" to discuss that 2008 plea deal and now-Labor Secretary Alex Acosta's role in keeping it under wraps.

updated 2M ago 02:49

Jeffrey Epstein charged with sex trafficking

Prosecutors are urging more women to come forward and accuse Jeffrey Epstein, the well-connected billionaire financier charged with sexually abusing underage girls. The 66-year-old is charged with sex trafficking and conspiracy. He pleaded not guilty Monday in New York City, 11 years after accepting a secret plea bargain for similar charges in Florida. Mola Lenghi reports.

updated 9M ago 03:55

Kevin Spacey accuser testifies

The young man accusing actor Kevin Spacey of groping him testified in court on Monday. Spacey's lawyers say they need the accuser's cellphone for their defense, but the accuser has pleaded the Fifth. Dean Reynolds reports.

12H ago 01:35

Jeffrey Epstein pleads not guilty

Wealthy financier Jeffrey Epstein is facing sex trafficking charges and is accused of abusing underage girls. He has pleaded not guilty. The indictment comes years after he cut a deal with attorneys in Florida amid similar accusations. Mola Lenghi reports.

12H ago 03:02

Space

NASA successfully tests abort system

NASA completed a successful test of its launch abort system Tuesday morning from Cape Canaveral, Florida. That puts the U.S. space program one step closer to sending astronauts back to the moon, and eventually to Mars. CBS News space consultant Bill Harwood joined CBSN with details.

Jul 2 04:49

Solar eclipse boom-time for small cities in the sweet spot

One Chilean city was flooded with more than 300,000 visitors to see the moon completely hide the sun for just a few fleeting minutes

Jul 2

NASA launches capsule to test abort system for moonship

The launch abort system would pull a moon-bound crew to safety in a booster failure

Jul 2

Welcome to July 1969: Inside NASA's restored Mission Control

"CBS This Morning" got an exclusive look inside the three-year, multimillion-dollar renovation

Jun 28

SpaceX launches Falcon Heavy rocket

SpaceX launched a Falcon Heavy rocket for its third flight, carrying 24 small science and technology satellites into multiple orbits for the Pentagon, NASA and a variety of other agencies. CBS News space consultant Bill Harwood joins "CBSN AM" to explain the goals of the complex mission and what happened.

Jun 25 08:08

Manson Family murders: The terrifying story in pictures

A look at the cult slayings that shocked – and scared – America

Jul 3 44 photos

New on Netflix, Hulu and Amazon

Shows and movies you'll want to stream soon

Jun 24 33 photos

Evidence photos from the police shooting of Danroy "DJ" Henry Jr.

Evidence from the scene of Pace University student DJ Henry’s fatal encounter with Officer Aaron Hess in Mount Pleasant, N.Y.

Jun 22 19 photos

Apollo 11 50th anniversary: 50 photos from the moon

50 photos to celebrate the 50th anniversary of the moon landing

Jun 21 50 photos

Deadliest highway in every state

These are the highways with the highest rate of fatal crashes

Jun 20 50 photos

Popular

Man could face charges for cruise ship death

An investigation is underway into the death of an Indiana toddler who fell from a Royal Caribbean cruise ship in Puerto Rico. It appears to have been a tragic accident. The 1-year-old girl's grandfather apparently lost his grip while holding her near a window on the ship. Don Dahler reports.

updated 17M ago 02:01

Elizabeth Warren raises $19M in 3 months

The crowded field of 2020 Democratic candidates is getting a shakeup. There's also a surprising candidate among the fundraising leaders who has pulled in money in an unconventional way. Ed O'Keefe reports.

updated 14M ago 02:03

May stands by Kim Darroch after leaked cables

The diplomatic rift between the U.S. and Britain is growing wider over embarrassing leaked cables critical of President Trump. British ambassador Kim Darroch was uninvited from a dinner the president attended last night. Mr. Trump said earlier the U.S. would "no longer deal" with Darroch. The ambassador called the Trump administration "inept" in the cables. Ben Tracy reports.

updated 20M ago 02:23

Why Alex Acosta is "public enemy No. 2"

Billionaire financier Jeffrey Epstein is behind bars for underage sex trafficking charges. His lawyers say it's illegal double jeopardy because of a controversial plea bargain more than a decade ago. CBS News legal analyst Rikki Klieman joins "CBS This Morning" to discuss that 2008 plea deal and now-Labor Secretary Alex Acosta's role in keeping it under wraps.

updated 2M ago 02:49

Jeffrey Epstein charged with sex trafficking

Prosecutors are urging more women to come forward and accuse Jeffrey Epstein, the well-connected billionaire financier charged with sexually abusing underage girls. The 66-year-old is charged with sex trafficking and conspiracy. He pleaded not guilty Monday in New York City, 11 years after accepting a secret plea bargain for similar charges in Florida. Mola Lenghi reports.

updated 9M ago 03:55