Trump's support of tariffs often includes dubious claims and misstatements

/ CBS/AP

Impact of tariff hike on Chinese goods

He's been contradicted by one of his top advisers, dinged in fact checks and called out by top economists. Still, President Donald Trump is sticking to dubious declarations about trade policy, raising questions among experts and even his allies about whether he either can't — or won't — grasp trade fundamentals.

This week, as he escalates a trade war with China, Mr. Trump has misstated how the tariffs are paid, who pays them and the significance and size of the trade deficit. His assertions came even as others in the White House worry about whether Trump's zeal for tariffs could have a political price.

In airing his grievances against China and promoting his administration's tariffs, Mr. Trump has exaggerated the size of the trade deficit, wrongly claiming the U.S. "loses" $500 billion in trade to China. He's also repeatedly misstated how tariffs working, saying that China pays the duties to the U.S. government — when, in fact, American consumers and businesses are paying the hefty import tax.

Trending News

It's not as if the U.S. is "losing" actual dollars in its trade deficit with China, or any other country, for that matter. The trade deficit refers to the gap between the value of imports and exports, and economists note that they aren't considered inherently "bad" or "good."

Tariff impact

The president's frequent claims provide a window into his long-held beliefs on trade and the difficulty of changing his economic worldview. They also signal that Trump may not back off the hawkish approach easily and is almost certain to continue to misrepresent the likely impact.

Trump's views on tariffs depart from conventional economics in at least three ways: He has repeatedly claimed that the Chinese — not Americans — are paying the 25% tariff he has imposed on $250 billion of Chinese imports. He has described the trade deficits that the United States runs with other individual countries as total economic losses. And he argues that the U.S. trade deficit with all other countries combined is a result of bad trade policy.

Here are the biggest U.S. companies hurt by China tariffs

On all three questions, trade experts fundamentally disagree.

Who pays Trump's China tariffs?

It is U.S. companies that import — retailers, wholesalers and manufacturers — that pay the duties that Trump has imposed, not Chinese companies. One of Trump's top economic advisers, Larry Kudlow, admitted as much in a television interview Sunday.

But Trump tweeted on Monday: "Tariffs are NOW being paid to the United States by China of 25% on 250 Billion Dollars worth of goods & products. These massive payments go directly to the Treasury of the U.S."

That's simply not true.

It's certainly possible that a huge retail chain, for example, could push its Chinese supplier to cut its prices to offset the tariffs. China's currency may also decline in value, which makes Chinese exports cheaper. And international corporations may decide to locate their plants elsewhere, such as in Mexico or Vietnam, depriving China of jobs and export revenue.

Impact of tariffs on Americans

But studies released in March found that those factors haven't made much difference, and that nearly the entire cost of the import taxes is falling on U.S. consumers and businesses. One of the studies , by economists at UCLA and the World Bank, found that American firms and shoppers lost $68.8 billion last year because of higher tariffs.

Trump made taking a tough line with China an animating feature of his underdog presidential campaign and some of his advisers believe that, even if the trade battle leads to short-term economic pain, it will have been worth it.

"This is an epic fail of the Wall Street junta to have President Trump accept a deal that was detrimental to the country. He rejected that," says Steve Bannon, Trump's chief strategist on the 2016 campaign. "He is not going to be tainted with a bad deal. He intuitively knows that this is the right thing to do."

Peter Navarro

There has long been division within the West Wing about tariffs' effectiveness. Trump has often sided with China hawk Peter Navarro, who argues that tariffs work. But Gary Cohn, the former director of the National Economic Council, argued strenuously against them.

"Tariffs don't work. If anything, they hurt the economy because if you're a typical American worker, you have a finite amount of income to spend. If you have to spend more on the necessity products that you need to live, you have less to spend on the services that you want to buy. And you definitely don't have anything left over to save," Cohn told the "Freakonomics" podcast in March.

His efforts to bring Trump around to that way of thinking were a failure.

"I was losing the war on tariffs every day with the president. I knew I wasn't convincing him I was right," Cohn said in the interview. "I was not going to take a 74-year-old man who's believed something since he was 30 and convince him that I was right."

GOP concerns

Some of Trump's fellow Republicans expressed weariness Tuesday about the standoff with China. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell declared, "Ultimately, nobody wins a trade war."

And Kansas Sen. Jerry Moran said: "It's been said if you don't like the tariffs just don't buy something from China. I understand that sentiment. But what we do in Kansas is we sell to China. Not dealing with China is not an option."

Economists also dispute Trump's portrayal of the U.S. trade deficit with China, which reached $378.7 billion last year, as evidence that Beijing is "ripping off" the United States. Mary Lovely, an economics professor at Syracuse University, says Trump is ignoring a simple point: The U.S. obtained goods and services for that money.

"It's like going to Walmart and you giving them money and they're giving you goods," she said. "There's an exchange."

Trade deficit: Does it matter?

Trade experts typically consider one nation's trade deficit with another as economically irrelevant. The United States also has a trade deficit with all other countries in the world combined, which reached $622.1 billion last year. Most economists aren't very concerned about that as long as so many nations are willing to finance that deficit by purchasing U.S. Treasury bonds and other assets.

Trump frequently blames the overall deficit on bad trade deals — he is in the midst of reworking several agreements, including one with Canada and Mexico — but that's not really the cause. A country runs a trade deficit when, like the United States, it consumes more than it produces. That's why the U.S. trade deficit typically falls sharply in a recession, when Americans spend less.

"We run deficits because we're a wealthy country that can buy things that it doesn't produce," said Joe Brusuelas, chief economist at RSM, a tax consulting firm. "Trade deficits fundamentally don't matter."

First published on May 15, 2019 / 8:52 AM

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Trump's support of tariffs often includes dubious claims and misstatements

The president's statements are raising questions about whether he can't — or won't — grasp trade basics

9M ago

Coca-Cola, Keurig cup makers vow to cut plastic pollution

Six big companies promise to reduce plastic waste by 10 million tons — but few are swearing off plastic completely

34M ago

Tiger Woods' restaurant accused of deleting video of employee before crash

Nick Immesberger was a bartender at Woods' flagship restaurant where his parents say he died after being served excessive amounts of alcohol by the staff

52M ago

Trampoline park injuries "like getting hit with a hammer," researcher says

The number of emergency room visits from trampoline park injuries soared to nearly 18,000 in 2017

1H ago

New congressional caucus to address needs of female vets

There are more than a dozen military related caucuses in the House, but none dedicated to the specific needs of women who serve

1H ago

Trump's support of tariffs often includes dubious claims and misstatements

The president's statements are raising questions about whether he can't — or won't — grasp trade basics

9M ago

2020 hopeful Steve Bullock says he can "bridge divides" with GOP

The two-term governor of Montana said it's his ability to reach across the aisle that separates him from his Democratic opponents

50M ago

New congressional caucus to address needs of female vets

There are more than a dozen military related caucuses in the House, but none dedicated to the specific needs of women who serve

1H ago

DHS to allow border wall to go through national monument, wildlife refuge

The Department of Homeland Security waived environmental and dozens of other laws to build more barriers along the U.S.-Mexico border

1H ago

Maine's ranked choice ballot amendment lacks necessary votes

Voters rank candidates on the ballot, and a candidate garnering a majority of first-place votes is the winner

1H ago

Sherpa breaks his own record for number of Mt. Everest ascents

Kami Rita has scaled the world's highest peak 23 times since first reaching the summit in 1994

52M ago

U.S. officials say Iran's military likely behind tanker attacks

State Department orders most personnel out of neighboring Iraq citing "serious" threat, one that a senior British commander said doesn't exist

updated 30M ago

Vandals throw paint on Athens home of U.S. ambassador to Greece

Geoffrey Pyatt called the attack "childish vandalism"; anarchists and far-left groups frequently vandalize diplomatic missions in Greece

5H ago

China tariffs a big problem for small businesses in U.S.

Toy company owner asks: "Who is going to want to paint the eyeballs onto a Marvel action figure or Barbie doll here?"

14H ago

Sanders says war with Iran would be "many times worse than the Iraq War"

Sanders posted a live video in reaction to a report that the Trump administration is reviewing a plan that could send up to 120,000 troops to the Middle East

15H ago

"Game Of Thrones" creators to helm upcoming "Star Wars" movie

Disney CEO Bob Iger announced the pair will be at the helm of the next "Star Wars" film after 2019's "The Rise of Skywalker"

8H ago

New on Netflix, Hulu and Amazon

Shows and movies you'll want to stream in May

Apr 26 36 photos

New "CBS This Morning" co-hosts tell Stephen Colbert: "It's a new chapter"

Colbert told King, Mason and Dokoupil that he watches "CBS This Morning" every morning and he is "happy" if he makes it into the Eye Opener

8H ago

Met Gala 2019: Red carpet looks

See what all your favorite celebrities wore to fashion's biggest night

May 6 80 photos

Remembering Tim Conway

Comedian Tim Conway, best known for his role in "The Carol Burnett Show," has died. Conway also starred in "McHale's Navy" and voiced the role of Barnacle Boy for "Spongebob Squarepants." Lee Cowan takes a look back at his life.

13H ago 01:48

Facebook to bar some rules breakers from livestreaming

One-strike-you're-out policy follows the livestreamed massacre in Christchurch, New Zealand

3H ago

San Francisco bans facial recognition technology

The face ID ban will apply to San Francisco city departments, but not to personal, business or federal use

11H ago

U.S. says Uber drivers are independent contractors, not employees

The National Labor Relations Board released its opinion on the controversial matter of Uber drivers' classification

16H ago

Disney gets control of Hulu in deal with Comcast

Entertainment giant, which also plans to launch Disney Plus in the fall, pushes deeper into streaming video

22H ago

WhatsApp flaw let hackers install spyware on cellphones

Signs point to Israeli company NSO, which works with governments, often to spy on human rights activists; spyware kicked in when people made or got calls

21H ago

Coca-Cola, Keurig cup makers vow to cut plastic pollution

Six big companies promise to reduce plastic waste by 10 million tons — but few are swearing off plastic completely

34M ago

American says record-breaking dive "opening the door for science"

Victor Vescovo dove 35,853 feet beneath the waves in a submarine to the lowest part of the ocean in the Pacific's Mariana Trench

21H ago

NASA vows to make ambitious plan to return to the moon "a reality"

The newly announced Artemis program, named after the Greek goddess of the moon, intends to land astronauts on the South Pole of the moon by 2024

May 14

The moon is shrinking — and may be generating "moonquakes"

As the lunar interior ever-so-slowly contracts, "moonquakes" are produced, NASA data suggests.

May 14

"The planet's on f***ing fire!" Bill Nye's climate rant goes viral

He's not the same kid-friendly "Science Guy" millennials grew up with

22H ago

These are the best — and worst — states in the U.S.

Is your state in the bottom or the top of the rankings? U.S. News & World Report's annual list has the answers

10H ago

Alabama just passed a near-total abortion ban

The legislation is the most restrictive anti-abortion measure passed since Roe v. Wade was decided in 1973

9H ago

Protesters rally as lawmakers consider ending religious vaccine exemptions

A measles outbreak in New York has taken place in Orthodox Jewish communities, where a pamphlet questioning vaccines has been circulating

14H ago

Philadelphia soda sales drop after tax on sugary drinks

Health groups say sweetened drinks pose real — and preventable — health risks, including tooth decay and diabetes

16H ago

Proposed law seeks to increase access to rape kits

Bipartisan bill would establish national standards of care for survivors of sexual assault and expand access to services, including the specialized nurses who administer rape examinations

17H ago

Trump's support of tariffs often includes dubious claims and misstatements

The president's statements are raising questions about whether he can't — or won't — grasp trade basics

9M ago

Coca-Cola, Keurig cup makers vow to cut plastic pollution

Six big companies promise to reduce plastic waste by 10 million tons — but few are swearing off plastic completely

34M ago

The oddities on Trump's latest China products tariff list

Forget paying more for a T-shirt — the price of a pet parrot (and many other things you didn't know) will also climb

3H ago

Facebook to bar some rules breakers from livestreaming

One-strike-you're-out policy follows the livestreamed massacre in Christchurch, New Zealand

3H ago

These are the best — and worst — states in the U.S.

Is your state in the bottom or the top of the rankings? U.S. News & World Report's annual list has the answers

10H ago

A slain professor, 2 naked men and a suicide: "One of the strangest cases"

Man charged in the death of a University of Georgia professor at a home where authorities say the homeowner apparently killed himself after investigators arrived

updated 36M ago

Anthony Weiner leaves NYC halfway house

"It's good to be out," the former Democratic representative said Tuesday; "I hope to be able to live a life of integrity and service. I'm glad this chapter of my life is behind me"

11H ago

San Francisco bans facial recognition technology

The face ID ban will apply to San Francisco city departments, but not to personal, business or federal use

11H ago

Officer fatally shoots woman heard on video claiming she's pregnant

Police on Tuesday said Pamela Turner was not pregnant; family said she suffered from mental health issues

12H ago

Poway synagogue shooting suspect pleads not guilty

John Earnest is charged with opening fire at the Chabad of Poway synagogue on April 27, killing one and injuring three

13H ago

Space

NASA wants to send first woman to the moon

NASA is gearing up to send American astronauts back to the moon by 2024, and it hopes to include a woman for the first time. The Trump administration has asked Congress to approve an additional $1.6 billion for NASA's budget. CBS News space consultant Bill Harwood joined CBSN to discuss the ambitious plans.

16H ago 04:35

NASA vows to make ambitious plan to return to the moon "a reality"

The newly announced Artemis program, named after the Greek goddess of the moon, intends to land astronauts on the South Pole of the moon by 2024

May 14

Trump backs early moon landing with funding request

Trump administration asks Congress to kick-start NASA moon mission with $1.6 billion in additional 2020 funding

16H ago

Shrinking moon may be causing "moonquakes"

NASA says the moon is shrinking and it may be creating so-called "moonquakes." Scientists say the moon's interior is cooling and causing it to shrivel up like a raisin. The shrinking has caused ridges on the moon's surface called "thrust faults" — where one section of crust is pushed up over a neighboring part. Scientists now believe those faults are to blame for the tremors.

May 14 00:44

Virgin Galactic announces new steps toward offering thrill rides to space

New Mexico officials have eagerly anticipated the arrival of space tourism by Virgin Galactic for more than a decade

May 10

Britain's royal great-grandchildren

Prince Harry's new baby Archie is the eighth great-grandchild for Queen Elizabeth and Prince Philip

May 8 9 photos

Met Gala 2019: Red carpet looks

See what all your favorite celebrities wore to fashion's biggest night

May 6 80 photos

Dale Pike murder: Evidence photos in the case against Enrico Forti

In 1998, Dale Pike came to Miami to discuss a business deal with Enrico Forti — the next day he was dead, and Forti was the prime suspect

May 3 17 photos

Worst movie sequels since 2000, ranked

These are the lowest-rated sequels this century, according to Metacritic's rankings

Apr 30 51 photos

Private secrets shared via postcard

Since 2004, hundreds of thousands of anonymous contributors with something to get off their chest have sent postcards to the website PostSecret.com

Apr 28 32 photos

Popular

First look at Scotty, largest T-Rex on earth

First on “CBS This Morning,” we get a glimpse of the largest Tyrannosaurus Rex ever to have roamed the earth. The massive creature named Scotty weighed an estimated 20,000 pounds. It will soon go on display at the Royal Saskatchewan Museum in Canada. Jamie Yuccas reports.

updated 13M ago 04:59

Tiger Woods lawsuit: Restaurant deleted video

The parents of a drunk driver who crashed his car and died last December are suing Tiger Woods and his girlfriend over their son's death. Nick Immesberger was a bartender at Woods' flagship restaurant in Jupiter, Florida. His parents say he died after being served excessive amounts of alcohol by the staff there. Jim Axelrod reports.

updated 3M ago 02:49

Montana Gov. Bullock enters 2020 race

Montana Gov. Steve Bullock is running for president, becoming the 23rd candidate to enter the race for the Democratic nomination. In his first TV interview since announcing his candidacy, Bullock tells CBS News' Ed O'Keefe what sets him apart in a crowded field.

updated 13M ago 04:04

All that matters in 90 seconds

A look back at what we've been covering on "CBS This Morning."

updated 18M ago 01:21

New research on trampoline park injuries

For the first time, we're learning about test results showing why some trampoline parks can be so dangerous. A Virginia engineer says the way many trampolines are bound together in the parks can create an unsafe transfer of energy. The number of emergency room visits from trampoline park injuries soared to nearly 18,000 in 2017. Meg Oliver reports.

updated 29M ago 05:58