Parents indicted in Illinois boy's slaying amid increasing scrutiny of state child welfare agency

/ CBS/AP

Couple charged with killing 5-year-old son

An Illinois mother and father have pleaded not guilty to murder charges in the beating death of their 5-year-old son amid increasing scrutiny of the state's child welfare agency, which had a long history of contact with the family. JoAnn Cunningham and Andrew Freund Sr. of Crystal Lake appeared in McHenry County court Friday, the day after a 30-page grand jury indictment was handed down in the case.

Andrew "AJ" Freund Handout

Police found Andrew "AJ" Freund's body wrapped in plastic last month in a shallow grave, nine days after authorities say he was beaten to death and a week after his parents reported him missing.

McHenry County Judge Robert Wilbrandt granted a defense request for a psychological exam of Freund. The judge also said a gag order request from both parents' attorneys was too broad.

Court records show the parents allegedly forced AJ to take a cold shower and beat him as punishment for lying about soiling his underwear.

Trending News

The disturbing and high-profile case has ramped up public and legislative scrutiny for the state's Department of Children and Family Services, which has been haunted for decades by deaths wrought of abuse and neglect. On Tuesday, Rep. Sara Feigenholtz stood with more than a dozen House and Senate members of a new child welfare reform caucus to propose legislation that would bolster checks and balances in the child welfare agency.

Even before AJ's death, Gov. J.B. Pritzker ordered a review of the agency to recommend improvements following the deaths of two toddlers. The mother of a 2-year-old Decatur girl has been charged with her murder after the girl was returned to her from foster care, and a 2-year-old Chicago boy 's autopsy showed bruises and rib fractures never reported despite numerous DCFS visits.

cunningham-freund.jpg
JoAnn Cunningham, left, and Andrew Freund Sr., right Crystal Lake police via CBS Chicago

Also Tuesday, Auditor General Frank Mautino issued a review of the agency's investigative practices from 2015 to 2017. It found that while abuse and neglect complaints jumped 11%, the DCFS hotline put callers into voicemail more than half the time, caseloads of investigators regularly exceeded limits set by a federal consent decree, and in more than three of five cases in which a child stayed with a family after an investigation, documentation did not exist to show proper social services were provided.

DCFS acting director Marc Smith has described an agency plagued by underfunding and a lack of resources, but has pledged reforms. He pointed to a proposed budget appropriation that would fund 126 extra workers, reduce caseload for investigators and improve oversight.

Feigenholtz's measure would set up a review of allegations of neglect or abuse in which DCFS investigators concluded there was insufficient evidence to sustain the claim, to make sure all the boxes were checked.

It was a key missed piece in AJ's case. According to DCFS records, in December of 2018, police responded to the home after a child welfare hotline call alleging "environmental neglect" to AJ and his younger brother as well as cuts, welts and bruises to AJ. When an emergency room doctor examined a bruise on AJ's hip, the boy confided to the physician: "Maybe someone hit me with a belt. Maybe mommy didn't mean to hurt me."

1asketch.jpg
Andrew Freund, Sr., left, and JoAnn Cunningham, the parents of slain boy AJ Cunningham, depicted in a sketch from a Thursday court appearance Sheryl Cook

The doctor was concerned, the records show, but couldn't determine how AJ was injured. He said the bruise could have been caused by a dog, as the family claimed, a football, or a belt. The children were returned home, and the next month the agency ruled the hotline report unfounded "due to lack of evidence for cuts, welts and bruises allegation."

Representatives on the Illinois house appropriations human services committee blasted that finding during a hearing last month, questioning DCFS leaders as to why the case wasn't referred to the judicial system.

A DCFS official admitted missteps in the case, saying the DCFS investigators should have further interviewed the boy, and the case should have been referred to a child abuse specialist for a second opinion because the doctor couldn't determine the nature of the injury.

Smith said last month a full review of the agency's interactions with the family is underway and that the investigator and supervisor involved in the case have been placed on administrative duties.

First published on May 10, 2019 / 9:19 PM

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.

AJ cunningham-freund.jpg 1asketch.jpg

Parents indicted in boy's death amid scrutiny of state DCFS

Police found Andrew "AJ" Freund's body wrapped in plastic in a shallow grave after his parents reported him missing

11M ago

Barges and oil tanker collide in Houston Ship Channel

An estimated 25,000 tons of gasoline stock were on each barge and an unknown amount had been released, the Coast Guard sai

34M ago

A 4-year-old made a promise to his sister after she died. He kept it for 13 years.

Alex Kunda turned down a trip to Disney World to get perfect attendance

2H ago

Pentagon to reallocate $1.5 billion for border fencing

The funds will be spent on four fence replacement four projects in two states. Along with $1 billion the department announced in April, spending on border barriers adds up to $2.5 billion

3H ago

2 French troops killed freeing hostages in West Africa

The troops freed four people from the U.S., France and South Korea who were kidnapped in neighboring Benin

1H ago

Pentagon to reallocate $1.5 billion for border fencing

The funds will be spent on four fence replacement four projects in two states. Along with $1 billion the department announced in April, spending on border barriers adds up to $2.5 billion

3H ago

Senators request documents related to Christopher Steele

Republicans have expressed concern about Steele's role in the origin of the Russia investigation

3H ago

Democratic lawmaker subpoenas Mnuchin for Trump tax returns

Mnuchin has refused the committee's request for six years of President Trump's tax returns

4H ago

Trump celebrates nation's military mothers at White House — live stream

The White House is also continuing its annual tradition of honoring military spouses

5H ago

Could Pete Buttigieg make history in LGBTQ-friendly Nevada?

The openly gay South Bend mayor is headlining on Saturday a key gathering of LGBTQ leaders in an important early caucus state

5H ago

2 French troops killed freeing hostages in West Africa

The troops freed four people from the U.S., France and South Korea who were kidnapped in neighboring Benin

1H ago

An extinct bird species has evolved back into existence, study says

It's an example of iterative evolution — when the same ancestral lineage leads to repeated evolution of a species at different points in time

4H ago

Four kids in one New Zealand family all have royal names, including Archie

"It's a royal flush – what are the chances?" the kids' mother told a local paper

5H ago

Investors shrug off mounting U.S.-China trade tensions

Yet while stocks rebounded, Wall Street analysts say new tariffs could hit U.S. consumers and companies

5H ago

Dozens missing as migrant boat sinks in Mediterranean

While the number of migrants trying to make the perilous journey from war-torn Libya has fallen, people still try, and fail

11H ago

Kim Kardashian and Kanye West welcome fourth child

Kardashian didn't announce the baby's name, but she did reveal one detail about the way he looks

1H ago

New on Netflix, Hulu and Amazon

Shows and movies you'll want to stream in May

Apr 26 36 photos

Book excerpt: Howard Stern on how therapy changed him

In "Howard Stern Comes Again" the radio giant explains what it took for him to treat his guests as collaborators in an interview, rather than as foils for his on-air antics

6H ago

Met Gala 2019: Red carpet looks

See what all your favorite celebrities wore to fashion's biggest night

May 6 80 photos

What to stream this weekend

"TV Guide editor Krutika Mallikarjuna joins CBSN to talk about the best things to stream this weekend: ""State of the Union,"" Wine Country"" and ""The Society.""

9H ago 05:59

Wall Street to Uber: Is that all there is?

Disappointing debut for one of the most-anticipated IPOs in years — but not for investors in it for the long haul

4H ago

Most downloaded app on planet? Hint: It's not Facebook or Instagram

TikTok is wildly popular among kids everywhere, but data-privacy concerns in the U.S., U.K. and India are a challenge

5H ago

Uber IPO: The "dumb money" usually loses

If you didn't have access to IPO pricing, experts say it's best to wait when considering investing in a newly public stock

9H ago

How the dating app Bumble is making online dating safer

The dating app has grown to more than 55 million users in 150 countries since it was created in 2014

10H ago

Jeff Bezos says lunar lander can carry crews to the moon by 2024

Lunar lander unveiled as NASA puts finishing touches on plans to return astronauts to the moon by 2024

13H ago

An extinct bird species has evolved back into existence, study says

It's an example of iterative evolution — when the same ancestral lineage leads to repeated evolution of a species at different points in time

4H ago

Virgin Galactic announces new steps toward offering thrill rides to space

New Mexico officials have eagerly anticipated the arrival of space tourism by Virgin Galactic for more than a decade

5H ago

Jeff Bezos says lunar lander can carry crews to the moon by 2024

Lunar lander unveiled as NASA puts finishing touches on plans to return astronauts to the moon by 2024

13H ago

California bans pesticide blamed for harming children

Chlorpyrifos has already been banned in Hawaii and New York lawmakers recently sent a bill to the governor outlawing use of the pesticide

May 8

Study finds contaminated drinking water in 43 states

An environmental non-profit and university researchers found PFAS chemical exposure in the water in 43 states

May 7

New vaccine offers new hope for pancreatic cancer patients

When cancer develops in the pancreas, the diagnosis often comes after the cancer has already spread

1H ago

Can surprise medical bills be stopped?

Trump urging Congress to offer consumers relief from hospital sticker shock. How best to do that? There's much to debate

6H ago

Teacher who uses "mood notes" says she's seen an impact on grades

"They're believing in themselves," Erin Castillo said about her students

10H ago

Questions raised about the safety of generic drugs made overseas

A man's body rejected his new heart. Then his doctor looked into his anti-rejection drugs.

13H ago

Campaign raises awareness of "epidemic" killing moms

"An American mom today is 50 percent more likely to die in childbirth than her own mother was," a Harvard Medical School obstetrician said

20H ago

Wall Street to Uber: Is that all there is?

Disappointing debut for one of the most-anticipated IPOs in years — but not for investors in it for the long haul

4H ago

More millennials are living at home than at any other point this century

Experts blame the unaffordable housing market, rather than a failure by millennials to "adult"

4H ago

Most downloaded app on planet? Hint: It's not Facebook or Instagram

TikTok is wildly popular among kids everywhere, but data-privacy concerns in the U.S., U.K. and India are a challenge

5H ago

Virgin Galactic announces new steps toward offering thrill rides to space

New Mexico officials have eagerly anticipated the arrival of space tourism by Virgin Galactic for more than a decade

5H ago

How the China tariffs could affect consumers and businesses

Experts fear that ratcheting up the cost of importing Chinese goods will drive up prices and sap confidence

5H ago

Parents indicted in boy's death amid scrutiny of state DCFS

Police found Andrew "AJ" Freund's body wrapped in plastic in a shallow grave after his parents reported him missing

11M ago

2 French troops killed freeing hostages in West Africa

The troops freed four people from the U.S., France and South Korea who were kidnapped in neighboring Benin

1H ago

Mom arrested after kidnapping story unravels

Henderson County Sheriff Lowell Griffin said North Carolina mom Krista Madden threw her 7-week-old baby down a ravine and made up a kidnapping claim. Griffin said the child survived "by the grace of God." Madden was charged with attempted murder.

4H ago 01:01

Mom's story about a kidnapping unravels after baby found alive in ravine

A sheriff in North Carolina said the baby girl survived "by the grace of a merciful God"

3H ago

Hollywood murder mystery: Arrest made in TV director's 1985 killing

When asked whether he killed Barry Crane, Edwin Hiatt told WSOC: "Anything's possible back then–I was big into drugs"

8H ago

Virgin Galactic announces new steps toward offering thrill rides to space

New Mexico officials have eagerly anticipated the arrival of space tourism by Virgin Galactic for more than a decade

5H ago

SpaceX cargo ship reaches space station

SpaceX delivers 5,500 pounds of equipment and supplies to the space station

May 6

SpaceX launches unpiloted cargo ship to space station

The Dragon is loaded with nearly 5,500 pounds of equipment

May 4

SpaceX confirms crew spacecraft destroyed in test mishap

Crew Dragon spacecraft was being prepared for in-flight test of emergency abort system when something went terribly wrong

May 2

Blue Origin launches rocket with NASA payloads

Company founded by Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos aims to send private citizens and scientists into space

May 2

Britain's royal great-grandchildren

Prince Harry's new baby Archie is the eighth great-grandchild for Queen Elizabeth and Prince Philip

May 8 9 photos

Met Gala 2019: Red carpet looks

See what all your favorite celebrities wore to fashion's biggest night

May 6 80 photos

Dale Pike murder: Evidence photos in the case against Enrico Forti

In 1998, Dale Pike came to Miami to discuss a business deal with Enrico Forti — the next day he was dead, and Forti was the prime suspect

May 3 17 photos

Worst movie sequels since 2000, ranked

These are the lowest-rated sequels this century, according to Metacritic's rankings

Apr 30 51 photos

Private secrets shared via postcard

Since 2004, hundreds of thousands of anonymous contributors with something to get off their chest have sent postcards to the website PostSecret.com

Apr 28 32 photos

Popular

CBSN Originals Preview

In the newest installment of CBSN Originals, Adam Yamaguchi travels to West Virginia to investigate the how the growing market for renewable energy has impacted the states coal industry. CBSN Originals Supervising Producer Matt Morrison sat down to discuss "Clinging To Coal: West Virginia's Fight Over Green Jobs," which will air this weekend.

updated 17M ago 09:26

Former Defense Sec. Robert Gates on Trump admin's strategy on China

Former Defense Secretary Robert Gates spoke with "Face the Nation" moderator Margaret Brennan on the Trump administration's strategy on China.

1H ago 04:26

Jeff Glor signs off "CBS Evening News"

Jeff Glor anchored his final "CBS Evening News" broadcast on Friday. Watch his final remarks.

1H ago 02:14

Why a student vowed to never miss a day of school

A promise is a promise. Even when you’re just 4 years old. Why a student vowed to never miss a day of school. Here’s Steve Hartman, “On The Road.”

1H ago 02:26

Teacher with cancer forced to pay for substitute

A California teacher who's battling breast cancer isn't just facing mounting medical fees, she's also being forced to pay for her own replacement. Turns out, it's the law. Jamie Yuccas reports.

1H ago 01:31