Facebook co-founder Chris Hughes says it's time to break up the social media giant

By Aimee Picchi

/ MoneyWatch

FTC could impose restraints on Facebook

Facebook co-founder Chris Hughes, who started the social media giant 15 years ago with fellow Harvard student Mark Zuckerberg, says it's time to break up the company, arguing it has become a "powerful monopoly" that is harming innovation, reducing privacy and enabling hate speech and nationalist leaders.

"Mark's power is unprecedented and un-American," Hughes wrote Thursday in an editorial in The New York Times. "It is time to break up Facebook."

His suggestion: Regulators should force Facebook to spin off Instagram and WhatsApp into separate businesses, and bar Facebook from acquisitions for several years.

Trending News

"Facebook would have a brief period to spin off the Instagram and WhatsApp businesses, and the three would become distinct companies, most likely publicly traded," Hughes writes. "Facebook shareholders would initially hold stock in the new companies, although Mark and other executives would probably be required to divest their management shares."

The call to break up the social media giant comes after a year-long series of scandals and revelations about Facebook's privacy issues and shortfalls. The Cambridge Analytica scandal, in which the social network allowed the political consulting firm to collect data from millions of users without their knowledge, may result in a fine from U.S. regulators as large as $5 billion, although Hughes argues it isn't enough.

"AfterMark's congressional testimony last year, there should have been calls for him to truly reckon with his mistakes," Hughes writes. "We are a nation with a tradition of reining in monopolies, no matter how well intentioned the leaders of these companies may be."

Lack of innovation

Hughes argues Facebook's monopolistic control of social media is harming innovation and doesn't provide a benefit for the public good. Because Facebook secures $4 out of every $5 in social media revenue, by Hughes' reckoning, there's little incentive for investors to back other social media start-ups.

"Investors realize that if a company gets traction, Facebook will copy its innovations, shut it down or acquire it for a relatively modest sum," he points out. "No major social networking company has been founded since the fall of 2011."

Hughes likened Facebook's control of social media to AT&T's monopoly on the phone business — and its breakup in the 1980s. The end of the phone monopoly ushered in decades of innovation in the phone industry, spawning new companies and technologies.

"We would most likely not have iPhones or laptops without the competitive markets that antitrust action ushered in," Hughes writes.

Consumers would also benefit by having alternatives to Facebook, an issue that became apparent after the Cambridge Analytica scandal, when many consumers vowed to quit the social media service in protest. "They don't have any meaningful alternative," Hughes notes. "In the end people did not leave the company's platforms en masse. After all, where would they go?"

First published on May 9, 2019 / 9:15 AM

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc.. All Rights Reserved.

Katie Couric talks cancer program, #MeToo

The former anchor tells "CBS This Morning" what she thinks needs to happen for more diversity in media, and talks about the program she's partnered with to help people battling cancer

4M ago

Dallas Cowboys star to pay for funeral of teen football phenom

Cowboys running back Ezekiel Elliott will pay for Jaylon McKenzie's funeral

6M ago

A Facebook co-founder says it's time to break up the social media giant

Hughes argues the government should force the "powerful monopoly" to spin off Instagram and WhatsApp

14M ago

Tiny typo on cash a big embarrassment for Australian central bank

The Reserve Bank of Australia has taken "responsibilty" for the mistake – but about 46 million bills with the typo are out there

22M ago

Facebook auto-generates celebratory videos with extremist images

A whistleblower complaint points to major holes in the social media company's efforts to stymie terrorists and extremists

25M ago

A Facebook co-founder says it's time to break up the social media giant

Hughes argues the government should force the "powerful monopoly" to spin off Instagram and WhatsApp

14M ago

"Terrified" woman trapped in China pleads for help

In a video you'll see only on "CBS This Morning," Cynthia Liu describes the terrifying ordeal for her and her brother Victor

1H ago

Transcript: Mulvaney on Trump Jr. subpoena – on "The Takeout"

On "The Takeout" this week, acting White House chief of staff tells Major Garrett that he had no heads up that the president's son would be subpoenaed by GOP-led Senate Intel Committee.

10H ago

House Judiciary votes to hold Barr in contempt

House Judiciary Committee Chairman Jerry Nadler said the U.S. is in the midst of a "constitutional crisis"

13H ago

Trump slams Dems for wanting to give Puerto Rico "more and more"

"They complain, they want more money," the president said, referring to Puerto Rico's government. He also mocked a few of the Democrats running for president

3H ago

Tiny typo on cash a big embarrassment for Australian central bank

The Reserve Bank of Australia has taken "responsibilty" for the mistake – but about 46 million bills with the typo are out there

22M ago

"Terrified" woman trapped in China pleads for help

In a video you'll see only on "CBS This Morning," Cynthia Liu describes the terrifying ordeal for her and her brother Victor

1H ago

Pope issues broad new Vatican law on reporting sexual abuse

New document makes it mandatory for clergy everywhere to investigate reported abuse, and should make it easier for the public to level allegations

1H ago

Maduro regime arrests Venezuelan opposition leader's deputy

Edgar Zambrano, Juan Guaidó's right-hand man, refused to get out of his car when gov't agents surrounded it, so they towed it away with him inside it

4H ago

North Korea launches short-range missiles for 2nd time in 5 days

Kim Jong Un regime fired short-range missiles over the weekend, and may have just done so again during senior Trump envoy's visit to South Korea

updated 23M ago

Entertainment

David Gelb talks new series "Street Food"

The popular Netflix show "Chef's Table" takes viewers around the world to see the mouthwatering and innovative dishes served up by culinary stars. Now its creator, David Gelb, is shifting his focus to the streets of Asia. His new series, "Street Food" brings people to places like Singapore and Thailand to meet people who are perfecting dishes outside of a traditional restaurant setting.

updated 17M ago 04:05

New on Netflix, Hulu and Amazon

Shows and movies you'll want to stream in May

Apr 26 36 photos

Katie Couric talks cancer program, #MeToo

In her 40 years in television news, award-winning journalist Katie Couric has been a prominent voice on the national stage. In 2000, she had a colonoscopy on live TV to raise awareness about colon cancer after her husband Jay died of the disease. Couric lost her sister Emily in 2001 to pancreatic cancer. Now, she is partnering with a new program called "With Love, Me." It asks people, whose lives have been affected by cancer what they wish they had known when they first heard their diagnosis. Couric joins "CBS This Morning" to discuss her new partnership and how the media landscape has changed.

updated 12M ago 06:27

Met Gala 2019: Red carpet looks

See what all your favorite celebrities wore to fashion's biggest night

May 6 80 photos

Britain's royal great-grandchildren

Prince Harry's new baby Archie is the eighth great-grandchild for Queen Elizabeth and Prince Philip

12H ago 9 photos

A Facebook co-founder says it's time to break up the social media giant

Hughes argues the government should force the "powerful monopoly" to spin off Instagram and WhatsApp

14M ago

Facebook auto-generates celebratory videos with extremist images

A whistleblower complaint points to major holes in the social media company's efforts to stymie terrorists and extremists

25M ago

Facebook's CEO, COO face subpoena from Canadian Parliament

Facebook brass have ignored repeated requests to appear before a committee of officials from 10 nations, according to a Canadian Member of Parliament

3H ago

Putin trying to ring-fence Russia's internet, but it could backfire

New law could grant Kremlin new power to censor and block online content, but one official says "no one really knows how to make it work," and it could backfire

22H ago

4 biggest takeaways from Google's 2019 Developer Conference

With Android "Q," Google is finally introducing fan favorite "Dark Mode"

May 8

California bans pesticide blamed for harming children

Chlorpyrifos has already been banned in Hawaii and New York lawmakers recently sent a bill to the governor outlawing use of the pesticide

19H ago

Study finds contaminated drinking water in 43 states

An environmental non-profit and university researchers found PFAS chemical exposure in the water in 43 states

May 7

Tiny T. rex cousin identified 21 years after fossil discovery

Suskityrannus hazelae weighed between 45 and 90 pounds and roamed the earth 20 million years before the nine-ton T. rex

May 6

1 million species at risk of extinction, U.N. report warns

A new United Nations report presents some troubling predictions for the planet

May 6

SpaceX cargo ship reaches space station

SpaceX delivers 5,500 pounds of equipment and supplies to the space station

May 6

Measure to allow use of "magic mushrooms" approved in Denver

The measure would allow the use and possession of psilocybin mushrooms by adults 21 and older in Denver

14H ago

Drug prices must be revealed in TV ads under new Trump rule

TV ads will have to disclose the price of any drug that costs more than $35 a month

16H ago

Teen who sued after skipping vaccine now has chickenpox

Jerome Kunkel's lawyer admitted he told his unvaccinated teenage clients their best bet was to contract the chickenpox

17H ago

Bubonic plague kills couple who ate raw marmot

Bubonic plague did not entirely disappear after the "Black Death" outbreaks of the Middle Ages

19H ago

California bans pesticide blamed for harming children

Chlorpyrifos has already been banned in Hawaii and New York lawmakers recently sent a bill to the governor outlawing use of the pesticide

19H ago

A Facebook co-founder says it's time to break up the social media giant

Hughes argues the government should force the "powerful monopoly" to spin off Instagram and WhatsApp

14M ago

Facebook auto-generates celebratory videos with extremist images

A whistleblower complaint points to major holes in the social media company's efforts to stymie terrorists and extremists

25M ago

Higher China tariffs could cost Americans $767 per year

Consumers would likely see higher prices for luggage, phones and even food if the U.S. hikes duties on Chinese goods

1H ago

Credit bureaus draw the most consumer complaints to the CFPB

Equifax, Experian and TransUnion are the top culprits, but Americans can't just stop doing business with them

6H ago

Kraft will pay up to $100 for a Mother's Day babysitter

Skip the flowers and give mom what she really wants — a night off

15H ago

Justine Damond's fiancé describes conversation minutes before her death

Don Damond says he wants police to learn from his fiancee's death in his first interview since a former police officer was convicted of killing her

1H ago

Justine Damond's fiance calls for change

Don Damond says, "this is a policing issue" in his first interview since a former police officer was convicted last week of fatally shooting his unarmed fiancé, Justine. Jamie Yuccas reports.

updated 59M ago 04:25

Mollie Tibbetts' mom: She'd want us to live life to its fullest

Laura Calderwood grants first TV interview since arrest of man in University of Iowa student's slaying during July jog in her Iowa hometown

1H ago

Colorado shooting hero remembers the friend who acted first

Brendan Bialy says his longtime friend, the lone fatality in the attack, immediately took action when one of the gunmen walked into their classroom

2H ago

Shooting hero remembers friend who acted 1st

One of the students who helped end the Colorado school shooting is calling the attackers "cowards," and praising a friend who died confronting one of them. Hundreds gathered Wednesday to honor Kendrick Castillo, a senior at STEM School Highlands Ranch. Eight other students were wounded in Tuesday's attack. David Begnaud reports.

updated 6M ago 03:25

SpaceX cargo ship reaches space station

SpaceX delivers 5,500 pounds of equipment and supplies to the space station

May 6

SpaceX launches unpiloted cargo ship to space station

The Dragon is loaded with nearly 5,500 pounds of equipment

May 4

SpaceX confirms crew spacecraft destroyed in test mishap

Crew Dragon spacecraft was being prepared for in-flight test of emergency abort system when something went terribly wrong

May 2

Blue Origin launches rocket with NASA payloads

Company founded by Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos aims to send private citizens and scientists into space

May 2

SpaceX launch delayed by space station glitch

Faulty electronics box on the space station will be replaced using the lab's robot arm

Apr 30

Britain's royal great-grandchildren

Prince Harry's new baby Archie is the eighth great-grandchild for Queen Elizabeth and Prince Philip

12H ago 9 photos

Met Gala 2019: Red carpet looks

See what all your favorite celebrities wore to fashion's biggest night

May 6 80 photos

Dale Pike murder: Evidence photos in the case against Enrico Forti

In 1998, Dale Pike came to Miami to discuss a business deal with Enrico Forti — the next day he was dead, and Forti was the prime suspect

May 3 17 photos

Worst movie sequels since 2000, ranked

These are the lowest-rated sequels this century, according to Metacritic's rankings

Apr 30 51 photos

Private secrets shared via postcard

Since 2004, hundreds of thousands of anonymous contributors with something to get off their chest have sent postcards to the website PostSecret.com

Apr 28 32 photos

Popular

Trump laughs off "shoot them" remark at rally

While talking about migrants approaching the border, President Trump made a joke after a supporter appeared to yell out, "Shoot them." It happened during a rally in Florida on Wednesday.

updated 5M ago 00:33

David Gelb talks new series "Street Food"

The popular Netflix show "Chef's Table" takes viewers around the world to see the mouthwatering and innovative dishes served up by culinary stars. Now its creator, David Gelb, is shifting his focus to the streets of Asia. His new series, "Street Food" brings people to places like Singapore and Thailand to meet people who are perfecting dishes outside of a traditional restaurant setting.

updated 17M ago 04:05

Cello provides struggling teen an escape

In this installment of our continuing series, A More Perfect Union, we meet a young college student who's overcoming poverty and hardship with the help of a stringed instrument. Eddie Adams plays lead cello in the George Mason University orchestra. He says he discovered his talent by accident. Chip Reid reports.

updated 17M ago 03:55

How to successfully divide labor in the home

Research shows there is still inequality at home with women taking on most household responsibilities. One of the New York Times’ most shared articles this week is called “What ‘Good’ Dads Get Away With.” It unpacks why women still handle most of the childcare and chores. One study estimates it will be another 75 years before men do half the unpaid work at home. The article, by clinical psychologist Darcy Lockman, is based on her new book, "All the Rage: Mothers, Fathers, and the Myth of Equal Partnership."

updated 15M ago 04:38

Katie Couric talks cancer program, #MeToo

In her 40 years in television news, award-winning journalist Katie Couric has been a prominent voice on the national stage. In 2000, she had a colonoscopy on live TV to raise awareness about colon cancer after her husband Jay died of the disease. Couric lost her sister Emily in 2001 to pancreatic cancer. Now, she is partnering with a new program called "With Love, Me." It asks people, whose lives have been affected by cancer what they wish they had known when they first heard their diagnosis. Couric joins "CBS This Morning" to discuss her new partnership and how the media landscape has changed.

updated 12M ago 06:27