Boeing didn't tell airlines that safety alert wasn't working until after crash

/ CBS/AP

Boeing surprises with warning light admission

Boeing said Sunday that it discovered after airlines had been flying its 737 Max plane for several months that a safety alert in the cockpit was not working as intended, yet it didn't disclose that fact to airlines or federal regulators until after one of the planes crashed. The feature was designed to warn pilots when a key sensor might be providing incorrect information about the pitch of the plane's nose.

But within months of the plane's debut in 2017, Boeing said, its engineers realized that the sensor warning light only worked when airlines also bought a separate, optional feature.

The sensors malfunctioned during an October flight in Indonesia and another in March in Ethiopia, causing software on the plane to push the nose down. Pilots were unable to regain control of either plane, and both crashed, killing 346 people.

Trending News

It is not clear whether having the warning light would have prevented either the Lion Air crash or the March 10 crash of an Ethiopian Airlines Max near Addis Ababa. Boeing's disclosure on Sunday, however, raised fresh questions about the company's candor with regulators and airline customers.

Boeing said again that the plane was safe to fly without the sensor alert, called an angle-of-attack disagree light. Other gauges tell pilots enough about the plane's speed, altitude, engine performance and other factors to fly safely, the company said.

A spokesman for the Federal Aviation Administration said the agency was notified of the non-working warning light in November, after a Lion Air 737 Max crashed on Oct. 29 in Indonesia. He said FAA experts determined that the non-working cockpit indicator presented a low risk.

"However, Boeing's timely or earlier communication with (airlines) would have helped to reduce or eliminate possible confusion," the spokesman said in an emailed statement. He declined to give more details.

In manuals that Boeing gave to Southwest Airlines, the biggest operator of both the Max and 737s in general, the warning light was depicted as a standard feature just as it is on older 737s, according to Southwest spokeswoman Brandy King.

After the Lion Air crash, King said, Boeing notified Southwest that it had discovered the lights didn't work without the optional angle-of-attack indicators, so Southwest began adding the optional feature too. That allowed the airline to activate the sensor-disagree warning lights on its 34 Max jets earlier this year, she said.

King described both features as "supplemental" and "advisory" to other information provided to pilots during flights.

The indicator was supposed to tell pilots when sensors that measure the pitch of the plane's nose appear to conflict, a sign that the sensor information is unreliable. Boeing told airlines that the warning light was standard equipment on all Max jets.

Boeing engineers quickly learned, however, that the warning light only worked if airlines also bought an optional gauge that told pilots how the plane's nose was aimed in relation to the onrushing air. Boeing said the problem stemmed from software delivered to the company. A Boeing spokesman declined to name the software vendor.

Boeing said Sunday that because in-house experts decided that the non-working light didn't affect safety, the company decided to fix the problem by disconnecting the alert from the optional indicators at the next planned update of cockpit display software.

Boeing didn't tell airlines or the FAA about this decision.

Boenig's statement comes as engine maker CFM instructed several airlines including American and Southwest to inspect a total of 25 engines on their grounded 737 Max fleets.

Boeing hopes to win approval from the FAA and foreign regulators to get the Max flying again before summer is over. When it does, the company said, the sensor warning light will be standard. CEO Dennis Muilenburg, speaking at Boeing's annual shareholder meeting in Chicago last week, said that the aerospace giant is making "steady progress" in implementing a software update that will enable the FAA to certify the aircraft as safe.

Nearly 400 Max jets were grounded at airlines worldwide in mid-March after the Ethiopia crash. Boeing is working to fix the software that pitched the planes' noses down based on faulty sensor readings, and to provide pilots with more information about the plane's automation.

The Justice Department is conducting a criminal investigation into whether Boeing misled regulators about features on the plane including flight-control software at the heart of the crash investigations. The company is also under scrutiny by congressional committees and the Transportation Department's inspector general, and it faces a growing number of lawsuits by families of the dead passengers.

First published on May 6, 2019 / 8:03 AM

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Boeing didn't tell airlines about safety alert failure until after crash

The feature was designed to warn pilots when a key sensor might be providing incorrect information about the pitch of the plane's nose

7M ago

Why moving to find work is a lot harder than it used to be

A less dynamic economy means Americans are less likely to relocate in search of employment opportunity

44M ago

Cory Booker unveils "bold" plan to curb gun violence

Booker's proposal is the most extensive gun violence prevention proposal of any presidential candidate to date

1H ago

Rep. Dan Crenshaw stands by criticism of Ilhan Omar's 9/11 comments

Asked about deaths threats against Omar, Crenshaw told CBSN, "It's unfortunately part of the nature of this job"

updated 49M ago

CBS News announces anchor changes at "CBS This Morning" and "CBS Evening News"

Gayle King will be joined by Anthony Mason and Tony Dokoupil as co-hosts of "CBS This Morning," and Norah O'Donnell has been named anchor and managing editor of "CBS Evening News"

1H ago

Cory Booker unveils "bold" plan to curb gun violence

Booker's proposal is the most extensive gun violence prevention proposal of any presidential candidate to date

1H ago

Rep. Dan Crenshaw stands by criticism of Ilhan Omar's 9/11 comments

Asked about deaths threats against Omar, Crenshaw told CBSN, "It's unfortunately part of the nature of this job"

updated 49M ago

Trump taps Obama-era Border Patrol chief as ICE director

Mark Morgan was named the head of the U.S. Border Patrol in 2016, but was ousted early in Mr. Trump's presidency. Since he left, he's defended the administration's immigration policies

9H ago

Trump threatens to hit China with $200 billion in tariffs

Mr. Trump's comments, delivered on Twitter, came as a Chinese delegation was scheduled to resume talks in Washington on Wednesday

6H ago

Trump says Robert Mueller shouldn't testify before Congress

Trump said just days ago that he would let his attorney general decide if Mueller should testify

7H ago

Brunei says it will not enforce gay sex death penalty after worldwide protests

"This announcement does nothing to address the many other human rights concerns about the (sharia code)," rights activist says

46M ago

U.S. sending forces to Mideast to warn Iran

U.S. deploying the USS Abraham Lincoln Carrier Strike Group and a bomber task force; sources say U.S. tracking preps for attack by Iran or allied fighters

4H ago

New Israeli-Palestinian cease-fire in effect, for now

Hostilities that erupted over the weekend suddenly ceased; deaths reported by both sides

2H ago

Trump threatens to hit China with $200 billion in tariffs

Mr. Trump's comments, delivered on Twitter, came as a Chinese delegation was scheduled to resume talks in Washington on Wednesday

6H ago

Venezuelan opposition in contact with Russia "on several levels," leader says

Yon Goicoechea said the opposition's communications with Russia occurred for at least a year "on several levels"

13H ago

Adam Sandler performs tribute to Chris Farley on "Saturday Night Live"

"Give it up for the great Chris Farley," Sandler said on the May 4 broadcast

10H ago

New on Netflix, Hulu and Amazon

Shows and movies you'll want to stream in May

Apr 26 36 photos

"Avengers: Endgame" surpasses $2 billion in ticket sales

"Endgame" is one of five movies to ever reach that threshold and, not accounting for inflation, is now second worldwide only to "Avatar's" $2.8 billion

11H ago

Singing the praises of karaoke

Daisuke Inoue, a Japanese musician who couldn't read music, invented a machine that would help teach the world to sing in perfect harmony

21H ago

Let's all sing the praises of karaoke

Nancy Giles meets the inventor of karaoke, Daisuke Inoue, a Japanese musician who couldn't read music, but who created a machine that would help the world to sing in perfect harmony. She also picks up a mic with Joshua Baron, Seattle's "Karaoke Baron."

21H ago 03:53

Boeing didn't tell airlines about safety alert failure until after crash

The feature was designed to warn pilots when a key sensor might be providing incorrect information about the pitch of the plane's nose

7M ago

Inside Silicon Valley's surprising push to help people unplug

This week at its annual F8 Conference, Facebook announced new features for Instagram, including a de-emphasis on "likes"

May 4

SpaceX launches unpiloted cargo ship to space station

The Dragon is loaded with nearly 5,500 pounds of equipment

May 4

Warren Buffett: I was an "idiot" for not buying Amazon shares sooner

Storied investor says a money manager at Berkshire Hathaway decided to invest in the ecommerce giant

May 3

Pornhub wants to make Tumblr NSFW again

Pornhub said it's interested in restoring the adult content that blogging platform Tumblr had banned last year

May 3

Nature up close: A red fox family in Yellowstone

A pair of foxes and their kits provide photographers with a surprisingly up-close-and-personal view of fox life, and death

May 3

Gravity wave detectors spot more black hole mergers

After upgrades, gravitational wave detectors haul in rich bounty of observations

May 2

SpaceX confirms crew spacecraft destroyed in test mishap

Crew Dragon spacecraft was being prepared for in-flight test of emergency abort system when something went terribly wrong

May 2

Blue Origin launches rocket with NASA payloads

Company founded by Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos aims to send private citizens and scientists into space

May 2

States declare war on Styrofoam — "People think it breaks down"

Maine is the first U.S. state to ban polystyrene food containers, which are hard to recycle and often end up in oceans

May 1

CBD: On a real market high

Cannabidiol, a chemical compound extracted from hemp, is now at the center of a swiftly-growing industry which last year derived about $600 million in U.S. sales

22H ago

Facebook bans breast cancer ad campaign

Facebook is facing backlash for banning an ad campaign that aims to highlight "the reality of a breast cancer diagnosis"

May 3

Girl could be first to have "air pollution" listed as cause of death

"There is a real prospect that without unlawful levels of air pollution Ella would not have died," report says

3H ago

FDA warns that French cheese may be tainted with listeria

Product made with pasteurized cow's milk was distributed throughout the United States

May 3

Man suffers stroke after cracking neck

"Right after I heard a pop, everything on my left side went numb," Josh Hader told CBS News

May 3

Why moving to find work is a lot harder than it used to be

A less dynamic economy means Americans are less likely to relocate in search of employment opportunity

44M ago

Trump threatens to hit China with $200 billion in tariffs

Mr. Trump's comments, delivered on Twitter, came as a Chinese delegation was scheduled to resume talks in Washington on Wednesday

6H ago

Is this record-setting stock market setting up investors for a fall?

If you're worried that stock prices can't get much higher, you might want to review this list of market indicators

Apr 30

Celebrity Edge, Celebrity Cruises' brand-new, billion-dollar cruise ship

In an industry in which passenger traffic has increased exponentially over the past decade, Royal Caribbean is sinking millions into innovation, both above and below deck

22H ago

The rise of female gun ownership and fashionable "carrywear"

Alexo Athletica designed a pair of Lulelemon-like leggings with pockets for guns — and women gun owners took notice

Apr 26

The case against Enrico Forti: Is he the Italian Amanda Knox?

Two decades after Dale Pike was shot dead on a Miami beach, questions still swirl around the man convicted for the murder

May 4

YouTuber Austin Jones gets 10 years in prison in child porn case

He was sentenced "for enticing several underage girls … to produce sexually explicit videos"

May 4

Family who paid $6.5 million in admissions scandal claims innocence

Unlike other parents indicted so far, the Zhous have not been charged

May 3

40 charges filed against truck driver in fiery interstate crash

Four people were killed in the April 25 crash on Colorado's Interstate 70

May 3

Footage released of fatal Connecticut police shooting

Connecticut officials have taken the unusual step of releasing video of a police shooting soon after it occurred, for the second time in two weeks

May 3

SpaceX confirms crew spacecraft destroyed in test mishap

Crew Dragon spacecraft was being prepared for in-flight test of emergency abort system when something went terribly wrong

May 2

Blue Origin launches rocket with NASA payloads

Company founded by Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos aims to send private citizens and scientists into space

May 2

SpaceX launch delayed by space station glitch

Faulty electronics box on the space station will be replaced using the lab's robot arm

Apr 30

NASA troubleshoots space station power glitch

Upcoming SpaceX cargo launch could be delayed if space station power glitch isn't quickly resolved

Apr 29

NASA just detected the first "marsquake"

For the first time since its mission began, NASA's InSight lander has detected what scientists believe to be a marsquake

Apr 23

Dale Pike murder: Evidence photos in the case against Enrico Forti

In 1998, Dale Pike came to Miami to discuss a business deal with Enrico Forti — the next day he was dead, and Forti was the prime suspect

May 3 17 photos

Worst movie sequels since 2000, ranked

These are the lowest-rated sequels this century, according to Metacritic's rankings

Apr 30 51 photos

Private secrets shared via postcard

Since 2004, hundreds of thousands of anonymous contributors with something to get off their chest have sent postcards to the website PostSecret.com

Apr 28 32 photos

Met Gala: Craziest looks of all time

The bigger the tiara – or pope hat – the better! (Just ask Rihanna, Katy Perry or Sarah Jessica Parker… )

Apr 26 47 photos

New on Netflix, Hulu and Amazon

Shows and movies you'll want to stream soon

Apr 26 36 photos

Popular

At least 41 people killed on Russian jet

Russian investigators said they've recovered the black boxes from the jetliner that made a deadly emergency landing in Moscow. Forty-one people were killed when the plane burst into flames during a hard landing in Moscow Sunday. Roxana Saberi reports.

updated 4M ago 02:30

Cease-fire ends Israeli-Palestinian fight

A cease-fire appears to be holding between Israel and Palestinian militants in Gaza after one of the worst outbreaks of violence there in five years. Both sides have launched hundreds of rockets and missiles at one another since Friday. More than 20 people have been killed in Gaza, and four more were killed in Israel. Seth Doane reports from Ashkelon, Israel.

updated 21M ago 02:23

U.S. sending forces to Mideast to warn Iran

The U.S. is making a new military move to challenge Iran, sending more forces to the Middle East in response to potential threats against American troops in the region. The Trump administration announced Sunday that a U.S. aircraft carrier and a bomber task force are being sent to areas closer to Iran. David Martin reports.

updated 19M ago 03:06

CBS News announces anchor changes

We're announcing some major changes at CBS News. Gayle King will be joined by Anthony Mason and Tony Dokoupil as co-hosts of "CBS This Morning," and Norah O'Donnell has been named anchor and managing editor of "CBS Evening News."

updated 18M ago 06:47

Full interview: Rep. Dan Crenshaw

In an interview with CBSN political reporter Caitlin Huey-Burns, Republican Rep. Dan Crenshaw of Texas discusses the Mueller report, his controversial comments about fellow Rep. Ilhan Omar and more.

updated 53M ago 13:02