How guns sales and marketing have changed 20 years after Columbine massacre

By Kate Gibson, Sarah Min

/ MoneyWatch

Columbine survivors reflect 20 years later

Twenty years after Columbine, the U.S. guns and ammo business isn't exactly the same. But it is still thriving. That's the case, even though the most notorious school shooting of the modern era has been followed by seemingly nonstop gun-related bloodshed, with firearms used to kill nearly 40,000 Americans in 2017, the highest count in 50 years of tracking by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

As the rate of gun-related deaths, adjusted for population, hits highs not seen since the mid-1990s, 44 percent of Americans say they personally know someone who had been shot. That exposure has led to a complex shift in attitudes toward the gun industry, which is facing an even more volatile environment in today's polarized political climate.

It's believed about three-in-10 Americans own a gun, which is a decline from years past. Yet the rising number of guns being produced and a tally of background checks have researchers concluding that more guns are now concentrated in fewer hands.

Dave Cullen: America "did nothing" until the Parkland school shooting

A consolidating group of manufacturers produce firearms sold by more than 60,000 licensed dealers in the U.S. They operate out of storefronts, pawnshops and homes, according to the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives. The firearms and ammunition industry accounts for as much as $52.1 billion in economic activity in the U.S., according to the National Shooting Sports Foundation, an industry trade group.

Trending News

Yet as efforts to curb gun violence took hold in some state legislatures, companies that make and sell firearms have adapted in differing ways, some with increased marketing efforts and others by exiting the business. And while little has changed on the federal level, a slew of corporations have waded into this divisive issue, some by distancing themselves from working with gun manufacturers or the National Rifle Association.

Retail realities, from Walmart to Dick's Sporting Goods

One of the most powerful new dynamics is how certain corporate segments have rejected the gun industry. Take Blake Mycoskie, founder of Toms Shoes. The shooting rampage that killed 13 people at a bar and country music venue in Southern California last November prompted him to use his shoe company and brand to lobby for universal background checks. "With retail competition fiercer then ever, retailers are attempting to differentiate themselves by aligning their mission, product and marketing to convince consumers that they're a socially responsible brand," said Camilla Yanushevsky, an equities analyst with CFRA Research.

The mass shooting in Parkland, Florida,14 months ago prompted companies including Hertz and Delta Air Lines to sever ties with the NRA, the nation's largest gun-rights group. And two weeks after that Feb. 14, 2018, high school massacre left 17 dead, Walmart, the country's biggest seller of firearms and ammunition, said it would no longer sell guns or ammo to anyone under 21.

Walmart's move coincided with a more controversial one by Dick's Sporting Goods, another of the largest U.S. gun retailers, to halt sales of assault-style rifles and no longer sell guns or ammo to anyone 20 and younger.

Dick's decision was largely symbolic, given that it had already pulled the rifles from most of its 715 stores nationwide after the 2012 Sandy Hook elementary school massacre. But this time, CEO Edward Stack explicitly called for policy changes. "We hope others join us in this effort to let our kids know that their pleas are being taken seriously," he said on the company website.

Inside look at how police train to protect Columbine schools

The result: Dick's in March reported that same-store sales fell 3.1 percent in the 12 months ending Feb. 2 from the year-earlier period. Consumer reaction to the new gun policy was "a meaningful driver" in declining sales, Stack told analysts in an earnings conference call.

Still, Dick's efforts at downsizing its gun sales have continued. The retailer recently said it would remove firearms and other hunting products from 125 stores, and instead sell sports gear like ski apparel and batting cages.

"While guns are generally a lower-margin category, they drive foot traffic and purchases for other higher-margin sale items," said CFRA's Yanushevsky. However, Dick's decision could prove profitable as it shifts to higher-margin merchandise categories, she noted, adding: "In our view, Ed Stack's social activism has enhanced Dick's brand and reputation."

Sales shift: Up to 1.5 million gun purchases a month

Trending higher since 2005, gun sales "boomed" during the Obama administration and have since declined, said Jurgen Brauer, chief economist at Small Arms Analytics & Forecasting. He noted that overall trends are highly seasonal, with gun sales lowest in the second quarter — April, May and June — and highest in the year's final three months, which include the hunting season and the Thanksgiving and Christmas holidays.

In 1999, Brauer's research firm estimates nearly 8.8 million firearms sales required a background check, a tally that rose to 10 million in 2009, then hit a peak of 16.6 million in 2016. Last year, sales were estimated at 13.8 million. Monthly gun sales that in 2000 ranged from 500,000 to 1 million now tend to be between 1 million and 1.5 million each month, the economist said.

The share prices of two publicly held makers of AR-15-style weapons have fared far differently in recent months. American Outdoor Brands, which owns Smith & Wesson, has lost half its value during the past year, while Sturm Ruger has done far better, declining just a bit.

rgr-aobc.png

American Outdoor lost $5.7 million in its third quarter, compared with $114 million for the prior year's quarter, as CEO James Debney noted "ongoing weakness in the firearms market." Sturm Ruger, the nation's biggest supplier of hunting and assault rifles, in February reported $121 million in revenue for the fourth quarter, up from $118.2 million in the year-ago period.

At Sturm Ruger's annual meeting last May, a resolution calling for a report on the safety of its products was adopted, despite opposition from the weapons maker. Issued in February, the report included a strong rebuke of activists, saying the company's reputation as a "defender of the second amendment is not worth risking for a vague goal of improving the company's reputation among non-customers or special interest groups."

Law-abiding gun owners don't blame Smith & Wesson or other brands for the deeds of criminals or those mentally or emotionally impaired, said Sturm Ruger, which further argued that its products help defend against gun violence.

Gun makers' ad and marketing spending grows

Getting their message out is becoming more challenging for gun companies as Facebook and Google, which together account for about 60 percent of digital ad selling, have enacted restrictions. "There's still a lot of ways that firearm companies can market themselves, but they can't do everything that everyone else can," said Joshua Claflin, president of Garrison Everest, a Tennessee-based marketing firm that specializes in branding for firearms industries.

American Outdoor, for instance, spent about $56 million in marketing and public relations in 2018, about 78 percent more than it spent five years ago. The increase could be in response to the so-called "Trump slump," which operates on the theory that Americans are less likely to purchase guns when they have less fear their guns will be taken away.

Few industries have to deal with the level of variation seen in the gun industry, according to Brauer. "Industry executives really do face a challenging market environment in that the demand can zoom up 50 percent within a couple of years and then collapse by as much. This makes operations and labor force planning problematic."

Case in point is Remington Outdoor, the nation's oldest gunmaker. Facing a heavy debt load, falling sales and lawsuits tied to the Sandy Hook school shooting, Remington filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy two days before the shooting in Parkland. It emerged from bankruptcy last May, with JPMorgan among the institutions taking a stake in exchange for forgiving $775 million in debt. Investors in Cerberus Capital Management, Remington's previous owner, had urged the private equity fund to sell Remington after its Bushmaster rifle was used in the 2012 school shooting that killed 20 children in Connecticut.

Debating the roles that lenders play (or don't play) in gun sales

At a recent hearing on Capitol Hill, JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon defended his bank's lending to makers of weapons for police and the U.S. military, but said he would consider adopting a policy of curbing some lending to gunmakers and sellers.

In contrast, Bank of America's Brian Moynihan was criticized by Rep. Sean Duffy for his bank's recent shift in position on guns, which the Wisconsin Republican said "takes away the rights of law-abiding citizens where I live." Moynihan dismissed Duffy's assertion that his bank violates the Second Amendment by refusing to lend money to makers of assault-style weapons used for nonmilitary purposes. BofA cited 151 employees as being affected by mass shootings in its 2018 policy change.

America's favorite guns
America's favorite guns 26 photos

BofA's move followed Citigroup's decision to require clients to refrain from selling guns to those who haven't passed a background check or who aren't yet 21. The nation's largest privately owned bank, First National Bank of Omaha, in February 2018 said it would stop producing credit cards for NRA members, citing customer feedback. More than a dozen companies have ended discount programs for members of the gun trade group, which has lobbied against firearms restrictions.

Louisiana also provided a contrasting example of how the debate over guns is playing out in the business world. Its bond commission last August voted to bar Citigroup and Bank of America from taking part in a bond sale, citing their "restrictive gun policies."

First published on April 19, 2019 / 11:06 AM

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc.. All Rights Reserved.

guns-chart.png rgr-aobc.png America's favorite guns

Cop fired deadly shot before he could analyze threat, partner testifies

The partner of Mohamed Noor acknowledged under defense questioning he feared an ambush before the shooting

14M ago

Columbine shooting survivors reflect 20 years later

Craig Scott, Amanda Stair, Heather Martin, Michelle Wheeler and Frank DeAngelis spoke with Jeff Glor about their experiences since that day

16H ago

How guns sales have changed 20 years after Columbine

Infamous school shooting followed by more bloodshed, with firearms killing nearly 40,000 in 2017 even as fewer people own guns

14M ago

Trump declares some notes cited in Mueller report "total bullsh**"

President Trump is tweeting his grievances from West Palm Beach on Good Friday

updated 49M ago

"Text me $$$": Debt collectors want OK to text and email consumers

A federal agency wants to update rules about how debt collectors contact borrowers. Consumer advocates fear abuses

1H ago

Mayor Pete wants Phish at his inauguration

"It's worth a shot, maybe we should ask them," he said

13M ago

Trump declares some notes cited in Mueller report "total bullsh**"

President Trump is tweeting his grievances from West Palm Beach on Good Friday

updated 49M ago

"Text me $$$": Debt collectors want OK to text and email consumers

A federal agency wants to update rules about how debt collectors contact borrowers. Consumer advocates fear abuses

1H ago

"I'm f**ked": Trump said Mueller's appointment was "the end of my presidency"

"Oh my God. This is terrible. This is the end of my presidency. I'm f**ked," Mr. Trump told Sessions during an Oval Office meeting

1H ago

Chasten Buttigieg on husband Pete's presidential aspirations: "For real?"

Preview: John Dickerson talks with South Bend, Indiana Mayor Pete Buttigieg about his surprising decision to run for president

1H ago

"Computer glitch" may have caused Notre Dame Cathedral fire, rector says

Architects, construction workers trying to figure out how to stabilize Notre Dame, protect it from the elements

1H ago

Young journalist shot dead in Northern Ireland rioting

Lyra McKee wrote for the Atlantic and BuzzFeed; her death comes as police worry about a rise in dissident violence in Northern Ireland

2H ago

Family of renowned climber presumed dead in avalanche speaks out

Jess Roskelley, David Lama and Hansjoerg Auer were scaling a Banff summit that's a challenge for only the most extreme climbers

3H ago

Electrical short eyed as possible Notre Dame blaze cause: Report

Authorities say fire-weakened landmark is still very fragile but officials are in very beginning stages of mapping reconstruction

5H ago

16-year-old TV and film actress collapses and dies

She appeared in the 2013 movie "Cloud Atlas," alongside Tom Hanks and Halle Berry

10H ago

Mayor Pete wants Phish at his inauguration

"It's worth a shot, maybe we should ask them," he said

13M ago

Star-studded climate change music video drops

Even Leonardo DiCaprio makes a cameo

1H ago

Review: Terry Gilliam finally wrestles "The Man Who Killed Don Quixote" to the screen

The filmmaker's long-in the-works rendition of the Cervantes legend transforms contemporary times into an age of chivalry

1H ago

Judge allows sex-trafficking claim against Harvey Weinstein

In addition, the judge dramatically shrank scope of an action trying to treat the former movie producer and various companies like a mob organization

15H ago

16-year-old TV and film actress collapses and dies

She appeared in the 2013 movie "Cloud Atlas," alongside Tom Hanks and Halle Berry

10H ago

"Text me $$$": Debt collectors want OK to text and email consumers

A federal agency wants to update rules about how debt collectors contact borrowers. Consumer advocates fear abuses

1H ago

Debt collectors could soon text and email you

A federal agency says debt-collection regulations need to be updated to reflect new technology like smartphones.

1H ago 00:59

How to protect data when using health apps

Apps are being used for everything from tracking your diet to your daily steps and even your pregnancy. But that health-related data might not be as safe as you expect. Recent research published in BMJ, the British Medical Journal, found 79 percent of the top medication-related mobile apps shared user data in ways that may compromise sensitive information. Wired senior writer Issie Lapowsky joins "CBS This Morning" to discuss the latest research.

1H ago 04:26

Pinterest pinned hopes on big IPO. Looks like it got one

Stock price — trading under ticker symbol "PINS" — zoomed to nearly $25 a share from $19 opening bid within hours of NYSE debut

updated 3M ago

Pinterest shares soar on 1st day of trading

Shares in Pinterest soared 28 percent Thursday during the newly public company's first hours of trading under the New York Stock Exchange ticker symbol PINS.

14H ago 00:32

New York City slashes its biggest source of carbon emissions

In a first, America's largest city is moving to curb emissions by requiring buildings to become more energy-efficient

16H ago

12-foot, 1,600-lb shark being tracked in Gulf of Mexico

Researchers are OCEARCH are tracking the location of a giant great white shark

17H ago

"Green" buildings sprouting in record numbers

Buildings around the globe account for roughly 40 percent of the world's carbon emissions. In response, a growing number of cities are adapting old and new structures in ways that save energy and cut down on emissions.

17H ago 01:22

Evidence found for first molecule in the universe

"This molecule was lurking out there, but we needed the right instruments," a top NASA scientist said

Apr 17

Watch: Rocket launches cargo to space station

An Antares rocket blasted off from the Wallops Island Flight Facility in Virginia carrying a Cygnus cargo ship loaded with supplies for the International Space Station.

Apr 17 01:45

Listeria outbreak linked to deli meats turns deadly

The outbreak has sickened eight people and led to one death, the CDC reports

18H ago

McConnell proposes raising minimum age to buy tobacco to 21 nationwide

The bill will cover all tobacco products, including vaping devices

18H ago

Gene therapy may be cure for "bubble boy disease"

Eight babies with "bubble boy disease" have had it fixed by a gene therapy made from one of the immune system's worst enemies

22H ago

Deadly fungus is a problem, but don't freak out just yet

"This bug, this germ, raises the stakes in the issue of drug-resistant infections," says a reporter who uncovered the scope of the problem

22H ago

Flight attendant in coma after contracting measles

The 43-year-old woman, who was seemingly healthy before getting measles, has now been in a coma for 10 days

23H ago

How guns sales have changed 20 years after Columbine

Infamous school shooting followed by more bloodshed, with firearms killing nearly 40,000 in 2017 even as fewer people own guns

14M ago

"Text me $$$": Debt collectors want OK to text and email consumers

A federal agency wants to update rules about how debt collectors contact borrowers. Consumer advocates fear abuses

1H ago

Earth Day challenge for gardeners: Don't poison bees

To help, more garden centers are curbing, ending or labeling plants treated with potentially bee-harming pesticides

Apr 18

Debt collectors could soon text and email you

A federal agency says debt-collection regulations need to be updated to reflect new technology like smartphones.

1H ago 00:59

Stop & Shop is "not kosher" to shop at during strike, rabbis say

As Passover nears, rabbis in New England are cautioning against crossing the Stop & Shop picket lines

3H ago

Cop fired deadly shot before he could analyze threat, partner testifies

The partner of Mohamed Noor acknowledged under defense questioning he feared an ambush before the shooting

14M ago

How guns sales have changed 20 years after Columbine

Infamous school shooting followed by more bloodshed, with firearms killing nearly 40,000 in 2017 even as fewer people own guns

14M ago

"48 Hours" preview: "In Jason's Name"

A new episode of "48 Hours" investigates the case of a victim's sister fighting to clear her brother's name after his death. Correspondent Maureen Maher joined CBSN with more on "In Jason's Name." Watch it on CBS Saturday night at 10/9c.

updated 24M ago 05:34

Judge allows sex-trafficking claim against Harvey Weinstein

In addition, the judge dramatically shrank scope of an action trying to treat the former movie producer and various companies like a mob organization

15H ago

Old razor, new DNA technique tie suspect to 1970s murders

Familial searching of California's criminal database linked Arthur Rudy Martinez to two murders, miles apart

15H ago

Evidence found for first molecule in the universe

"This molecule was lurking out there, but we needed the right instruments," a top NASA scientist said

Apr 17

Watch: Rocket launches cargo to space station

An Antares rocket blasted off from the Wallops Island Flight Facility in Virginia carrying a Cygnus cargo ship loaded with supplies for the International Space Station.

Apr 17 01:45

Rocket launches with cargo for space station

Loaded with 3.8 tons of supplies and equipment, the Cygnus cargo ship will need two days to reach the space station

Apr 17

Researchers reveal changes to astronaut's body

Retired astronaut Scott Kelly, who spent 340 days in space during an extended stay aboard the International Space Station in 2015-16, did not suffer any major long-term health effects that might raise warning signs for future long-duration flights, scientists reported Thursday. CBS News space consultant Bill Harwood joins CBSN with details.

Apr 11 01:08

Israeli spacecraft fails to land on moon

CBS News space consultant Bill Harwood speaks to CBSN about the failed moon landing and Thursday's other headlines: SpaceX's second launch of their Falcon Heavy rocket and NASA's report that astronaut Scott Kelly experienced biological changes during his year-long orbit in space.

Apr 11 05:36

Photos: Fire burns Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris

On April 15, 2019 flames erupted at the landmark cathedral, the most-visited landmark in the French capital

Apr 16 46 photos

Star Wars Celebration 2019

The four-day convention for fans of the Star Wars saga, held in Chicago, included cosplayers, panels with the filmmakers, and the debut of the trailer for Episode IX of the series

Apr 13 39 photos

Awkward Easter Bunny photos

Children love the Easter Bunny – until they meet him

Apr 12 35 photos

The folk art of Bill Traylor

Born into slavery, the self-taught painter who began his artistic life in his 80s is the focus of a retrospective at the Smithsonian American Art Museum

Apr 7 24 photos

America's surprising food recalls

What's in your fridge? Just maybe salmonella, E. coli – and a dead bat?

Apr 5 38 photos

Popular

"48 Hours" preview: "In Jason's Name"

A new episode of "48 Hours" investigates the case of a victim's sister fighting to clear her brother's name after his death. Correspondent Maureen Maher joined CBSN with more on "In Jason's Name." Watch it on CBS Saturday night at 10/9c.

updated 24M ago 05:34

Journalist shot dead in Northern Ireland

29-year-old Lyra McKee, who wrote for the Atlantic and BuzzFeed, was shot and killed during unrest in Londonderry. Her death comes as police worry about a rise in dissident violence in Northern Ireland.

updated 24M ago 00:42

Debt collectors could soon text and email you

A federal agency says debt-collection regulations need to be updated to reflect new technology like smartphones.

1H ago 00:59

How to protect data when using health apps

Apps are being used for everything from tracking your diet to your daily steps and even your pregnancy. But that health-related data might not be as safe as you expect. Recent research published in BMJ, the British Medical Journal, found 79 percent of the top medication-related mobile apps shared user data in ways that may compromise sensitive information. Wired senior writer Issie Lapowsky joins "CBS This Morning" to discuss the latest research.

1H ago 04:26

(Un)Welcome: Sweden's rise of the right

In this installment of CBSN Originals’ ongoing examination at how migration is reshaping the world, Adam Yamaguchi travels to Sweden to examine how a record influx of migrants has coincided with the recently welcoming and politically progressive nation's swift shift to the right.

Apr 15 23:06