Fact-checking claims by Trump and Barr against Mueller's report

/ AP

Trump claims victory after Mueller report released

WASHINGTON — President Trump and his attorney general aren't giving the whole picture when it comes to special counsel Robert Mueller's report in the Russia investigation.

The president and his team continue to insist that he was exonerated by the two-year investigation. Bu the report specifically declines to clear the president on possible charges of obstruction of justice.

And in remarks Thursday at the Justice Department, Attorney General William Barr made a series of misleading claims, suggesting that Mueller did not want Congress to decide whether Trump obstructed justice. Barr also indicated that he was not really supposed to be publicly releasing the two-volume report , but, on the other hand, it was "long-standing" practice to share such types of confidential information with the White House.

Trending News

A look at the claims:

Barr, asked if Mueller intended for Congress, not the attorney general, to decide whether Mr. Trump obstructed justice: "Well, special counsel Mueller did not indicate that his purpose was to leave the decision to Congress. I hope that was not his view. … I didn't talk to him directly about the fact that we were making the decision, but I am told that his reaction to that was that it was my prerogative as attorney general to make that decision."

The report states that no person is above the law, including the president, and that the Constitution "does not categorically and permanently immunize a president for obstructing justice."

In his four-page memo released last month, Barr said while Mueller left open the question of whether Trump broke the law and obstructed the investigation, he was ultimately deciding as attorney general that the evidence developed by Mueller was "not sufficient" to establish, for the purposes of prosecution, that Mr. Trump obstructed justice.

But the special counsel's report specifies that Congress can also render a judgment on that question.

Mueller's report says: "The conclusion that Congress may apply obstruction laws to the President's corrupt exercise of the powers of office accords with our constitutional system of checks and balances and the principle that no person is above the law."

___

TRUMP: "As I have been saying all along, NO COLLUSION – NO OBSTRUCTION!" the president tweeted Thursday.

VICE PRESIDENT MIKE PENCE: "Today's release of the special counsel's report confirms what the president and I have said since day one: there was no collusion between the Trump campaign and Russia and there was no obstruction of justice."

KELLYANNE CONWAY, White House counselor: "What matters is what the Department of Justice and special counsel concluded here, which is no collusion, no obstruction, and complete exoneration, as the president says."

THE FACTS: The special counsel specifically leaves open the question of whether the president obstructed justice.

"If we had confidence after a thorough investigation of the facts that the President clearly did not commit obstruction of justice, we would so state. Based on the facts and the applicable legal standards, however, we are unable to reach that judgment," the report states.

The report identifies 10 instances of possible obstruction by Mr. Trump and said he might have "had a motive" to impede the investigation because of what it could find on a multitude of personal matters, such as his proposal to build a Trump Tower in Moscow.

"The evidence does indicate that a thorough FBI investigation would uncover facts about the campaign and the president personally that the President could have understood to be crimes or that would give rise to personal and political concerns," the report states.

In explaining its decision, Mueller's team said reaching a conclusion on whether Mr. Trump committed crimes would be inappropriate because of Justice Department guidelines indicating that a sitting president should not be prosecuted. It nevertheless left open at least the theoretical possibility that Mr. Trump could be charged after he leaves office, noting that its factual investigation was conducted "in order to preserve the evidence when memories were fresh and documentary material were available."

"Accordingly, while this report does not conclude that the president committed a crime, it also does not exonerate him," the report states.

___

BARR: "These reports are not supposed to be made public."

THE FACTS: He's not going out on a limb for public disclosure.

Justice Department regulations give Barr wide authority to release a special counsel's report in situations it "would be in the public interest." Barr had made clear during his Senate confirmation hearing in January that he believed in transparency with the report on Mueller's investigation into Russian election interference during the 2016 campaign, "consistent with regulations and the law."

___

BARR, saying it was "consistent with long-standing practice" for him to share a copy of the redacted report with the White House and president's attorneys before its release: "Earlier this week, the president's personal counsel requested and were given the opportunity to read a final version of the redacted report before it was publicly released. That request was consistent with the practice followed under the Ethics in Government Act, which permitted individuals named in a report prepared by an independent counsel the opportunity to read the report before publication."

THE FACTS: Barr's decision, citing the Ethics in Government Act, is inconsistent with independent counsel Ken Starr's handling of his report into whether President Bill Clinton obstructed and lied in Starr's probe.

On Sept. 7, 1998, Clinton's attorney David Kendall requested that Starr provide him an opportunity to review the report before it was sent to Congress. Starr quickly turned him down.

"As a matter of legal interpretation, I respectfully disagree with your analysis," Starr wrote to Kendall two days later. Starr called Kendall "mistaken" regarding the rights of the president's attorneys to "review a 'report' before it is transmitted to Congress."

Starr's report was governed by the ethics act cited by Barr as his justification for showing the report to the president's team. It has since expired. Current regulations governing Mueller's work don't specify how confidential information should be shared with the White House.

Starr's report led to the impeachment trial of Clinton in 1999.

First published on April 19, 2019 / 7:33 AM

© 2019 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Family of renowned climber presumed dead in avalanche speaks out

Jess Roskelley, David Lama, and Hansjoerg Auer were scaling a Banff summit that's a challenge for only the most extreme climbers

5M ago

Columbine shooting survivors reflect 20 years later

Craig Scott, Amanda Stair, Heather Martin, Michelle Wheeler and Frank DeAngelis spoke with Jeff Glor about their experiences since that day

13H ago

Fact-checking claims by Trump and Barr against Mueller's report

Some of the claims made by the president and attorney general miss the picture presented by special counsel Robert Mueller

7M ago

The many ways "green buildings" save

Retrofitted and newly built structures that meet a varied set of energy-efficiency standards yield many payoffs

40M ago

Support for marijuana legalization hits new high, CBS News poll finds

Sixty-five percent of Americans now think marijuana should be legal — a record high in CBS News polling

40M ago

Fact-checking claims by Trump and Barr against Mueller's report

Some of the claims made by the president and attorney general miss the picture presented by special counsel Robert Mueller

7M ago

Support for marijuana legalization hits new high, CBS News poll finds

Sixty-five percent of Americans now think marijuana should be legal — a record high in CBS News polling

40M ago

VA Secretary Wilkie won't "get into" Trump's feud with McCain

Robert Wilkie says that his department is committed to combating suicide, drug addiction and homelessness among veterans

1H ago

Burr may have told White House about FBI probe

The report says that the White House counsel appeared "to have received information about the status of the FBI investigation"

5H ago

2020 Democratic candidates' reaction to Mueller report

Democratic presidential hopefuls on Thursday criticized Attorney General William Barr and called for voters to remove President Trump

7H ago

Electrical short eyed as possible Notre Dame blaze cause: Report

Authorities say fire-weakened landmark is still very fragile but officials are in very beginning stages of mapping reconstruction

1H ago

16-year-old TV and film actress collapses and dies

She appeared in the 2013 movie "Cloud Atlas," alongside Tom Hanks and Halle Berry

6H ago

American among 3 climbers presumed dead after avalanche

Recovery efforts are on hold because of dangerous conditions and additional avalanches at Alberta's Banff National Park

14H ago

CIA Director Gina Haspel praises Trump's "wisdom" on North Korea

"I am very proud that we've been able to support this administration's effort to engage the North Koreans in a dialogue"

13H ago

Petition seeks to make Earth Day a national holiday

The North Face wants people to be able to celebrate Earth Day outside, rather than in front of screens

15H ago

Judge allows sex-trafficking claim against Harvey Weinstein

In addition, the judge dramatically shrank scope of an action trying to treat the former movie producer and various companies like a mob organization

11H ago

16-year-old TV and film actress collapses and dies

She appeared in the 2013 movie "Cloud Atlas," alongside Tom Hanks and Halle Berry

6H ago

Jason Momoa shaved off signature beard for a good cause

While promoting canned water, the actor is seen cutting off his facial hair in a 4-minute video

16H ago

The National Enquirer is being sold to Hudson News' CEO

The tabloid publisher is embroiled in a dispute with Amazon and Washington Post owner Jeff Bezos

10H ago

Preview: Behind the scenes with K-Pop sensation BTS

"Sunday Morning" goes backstage as the Korean pop phenomenon prepares to launch a world tour

17H ago

Pinterest pinned hopes on big IPO. Looks like it got one

Stock price — trading under ticker symbol "PINS" — zoomed to nearly $25 a share from $19 opening bid within hours of NYSE debut

11H ago

Pinterest shares soar on 1st day of trading

Shares in Pinterest soared 28 percent Thursday during the newly public company's first hours of trading under the New York Stock Exchange ticker symbol PINS.

11H ago 00:32

Uber to roll out new safety push notification feature

Ride-share app Uber is taking measure to improve safety for its passengers. Users will not receive a push notification reminding them to check they have the right driver when getting picked up. CBSN New York has the details.

11H ago 00:24

NYC acts to cut carbon emissions

The New York City Council has passed a far-reaching plan to cut building emissions by up to 80%, and other cities could follow.

11H ago 01:05

Zoom's stock soared 54,000% — for a very bad reason

A tiny Chinese company seems to have hitched a profitable ride on Zoom Video Communications' hot IPO

14H ago

New York City slashes its biggest source of carbon emissions

In a first, America's largest city is moving to curb emissions by requiring buildings to become more energy-efficient

12H ago

12-foot, 1,600-lb shark being tracked in Gulf of Mexico

Researchers are OCEARCH are tracking the location of a giant great white shark

14H ago

"Green" buildings sprouting in record numbers

Buildings around the globe account for roughly 40 percent of the world's carbon emissions. In response, a growing number of cities are adapting old and new structures in ways that save energy and cut down on emissions.

13H ago 01:22

Evidence found for first molecule in the universe

"This molecule was lurking out there, but we needed the right instruments," a top NASA scientist said

Apr 17

Watch: Rocket launches cargo to space station

An Antares rocket blasted off from the Wallops Island Flight Facility in Virginia carrying a Cygnus cargo ship loaded with supplies for the International Space Station.

Apr 17 01:45

Listeria outbreak linked to deli meats turns deadly

The outbreak has sickened eight people and led to one death, the CDC reports

14H ago

McConnell proposes raising minimum age to buy tobacco to 21 nationwide

The bill will cover all tobacco products, including vaping devices

15H ago

Gene therapy may be cure for "bubble boy disease"

Eight babies with "bubble boy disease" have had it fixed by a gene therapy made from one of the immune system's worst enemies

18H ago

Deadly fungus is a problem, but don't freak out just yet

"This bug, this germ, raises the stakes in the issue of drug-resistant infections," says a reporter who uncovered the scope of the problem

18H ago

Flight attendant in coma after contracting measles

The 43-year-old woman, who was seemingly healthy before getting measles, has now been in a coma for 10 days

19H ago

The many ways "green buildings" save

Retrofitted and newly built structures that meet a varied set of energy-efficiency standards yield many payoffs

40M ago

Hail damage costs this year could hit new annual high in U.S.

While baseball-sized hail stones are common, the biggest this year was the size of a grapefruit and weighed more than half a pound

2H ago

Earth Day challenge for gardeners: Don't poison bees

To help, more garden centers are curbing, ending or labeling plants treated with potentially bee-harming pesticides

Apr 18

Pinterest pinned hopes on big IPO. Looks like it got one

Stock price — trading under ticker symbol "PINS" — zoomed to nearly $25 a share from $19 opening bid within hours of NYSE debut

11H ago

NYC acts to cut carbon emissions

The New York City Council has passed a far-reaching plan to cut building emissions by up to 80%, and other cities could follow.

11H ago 01:05

Judge allows sex-trafficking claim against Harvey Weinstein

In addition, the judge dramatically shrank scope of an action trying to treat the former movie producer and various companies like a mob organization

11H ago

Old razor, new DNA technique tie suspect to 1970s murders

Familial searching of California's criminal database linked Arthur Rudy Martinez to two murders, miles apart

12H ago

Columbine survivors share their stories

It's been 20 years since the Columbine massacre. Two teenagers murdered 12 schoolmates and a teacher and wounded 20 others. Five survivors sat down with "CBS Evening News" anchor Jeff Glor to share their stories.

11H ago 04:54

Details emerge about NYC cathedral suspect

Marc Lamparello, 37, was arrested Wednesday after entering St. Patrick's Cathedral carrying two cans of gasoline, lighter fluid and butane lighters. He has been charged with attempted arson, reckless endangerment and trespassing, according to police. CBSN New York's Natalie Duddrige reports.

11H ago 02:59

Columbine survivors reflect 20 years later

Saturday will mark 20 years since the shooting at Columbine High School. CBS News brought together five survivors, each with their own story. Each has their own powerful lesson they are passing on. They spoke with "CBS Evening News" anchor Jeff Glor.

13H ago 05:25

Evidence found for first molecule in the universe

"This molecule was lurking out there, but we needed the right instruments," a top NASA scientist said

Apr 17

Watch: Rocket launches cargo to space station

An Antares rocket blasted off from the Wallops Island Flight Facility in Virginia carrying a Cygnus cargo ship loaded with supplies for the International Space Station.

Apr 17 01:45

Rocket launches with cargo for space station

Loaded with 3.8 tons of supplies and equipment, the Cygnus cargo ship will need two days to reach the space station

Apr 17

Researchers reveal changes to astronaut's body

Retired astronaut Scott Kelly, who spent 340 days in space during an extended stay aboard the International Space Station in 2015-16, did not suffer any major long-term health effects that might raise warning signs for future long-duration flights, scientists reported Thursday. CBS News space consultant Bill Harwood joins CBSN with details.

Apr 11 01:08

Israeli spacecraft fails to land on moon

CBS News space consultant Bill Harwood speaks to CBSN about the failed moon landing and Thursday's other headlines: SpaceX's second launch of their Falcon Heavy rocket and NASA's report that astronaut Scott Kelly experienced biological changes during his year-long orbit in space.

Apr 11 05:36

Photos: Fire burns Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris

On April 15, 2019 flames erupted at the landmark cathedral, the most-visited landmark in the French capital

Apr 16 46 photos

Star Wars Celebration 2019

The four-day convention for fans of the Star Wars saga, held in Chicago, included cosplayers, panels with the filmmakers, and the debut of the trailer for Episode IX of the series

Apr 13 39 photos

Awkward Easter Bunny photos

Children love the Easter Bunny – until they meet him

Apr 12 35 photos

The folk art of Bill Traylor

Born into slavery, the self-taught painter who began his artistic life in his 80s is the focus of a retrospective at the Smithsonian American Art Museum

Apr 7 24 photos

America's surprising food recalls

What's in your fridge? Just maybe salmonella, E. coli – and a dead bat?

Apr 5 38 photos

Popular

A new twist on the button-down

Bryan Davis, founder of Teddy Stratford, designs shirts that zip instead of button. In an effort to get rid of the "pec gap," Bryan reverse-engineered how to create the traditional button-down. In this small business spotlight, Bryan explains what inspired him to create the shirt and how selling online helps his brand.

Apr 17 02:15

Press secretary Sanders on Mueller report

Robert Mueller’s special counsel investigation notes several instances where President Trump pressured his top aides to lie or mislead. White House press secretary Sarah Sanders joins "CBS This Morning" to discuss her comments on the firing of FBI Director James Comey and whether President Trump has ever asked her to say something she knew not to be true.

updated 5M ago 04:52

Dems vow to pick up where Mueller let off

Attorney General William Barr denied Thursday that the special counsel intended to let Congress decide the unresolved issue of obstruction in the Russia investigation. But the Mueller report clearly acknowledges lawmakers have the authority to determine whether the president’s actions represent an obstruction of Justice. Nancy Cordes reports.

updated 3M ago 02:03

Mueller report on Trump efforts to foil probe

Republicans say it is time to put the Russia investigation in the past. Democrats have a different plan now that Robert Mueller’s report is out in public. President Trump claims total exoneration, but the special counsel’s 448-page report details the president’s repeated efforts to stymie the investigation – and how he was stopped by the people around him. Paula Reid reports.

updated 2M ago 04:19

(Un)Welcome: Sweden's rise of the right

In this installment of CBSN Originals’ ongoing examination at how migration is reshaping the world, Adam Yamaguchi travels to Sweden to examine how a record influx of migrants has coincided with the recently welcoming and politically progressive nation's swift shift to the right.

Apr 15 23:06