Yikes: 1 in 4 millennials raiding 401(k)s early to pay down debt

By Sarah Min

/ MoneyWatch

Some millennials tap 401(k)s to pay down debt

When her husband asked for her signature to withdraw the $11,000 in his 401(k) to pay off credit card debt and a medical bill, Marissa Sanders, 30, tried to talk him out of it. Sanders, who runs a financial advice blog, tried to explain the importance of compounding interest over future decades, but her husband decided against the advice.

"I didn't know what to do, really, he was intent on taking it out," Sanders said.

For a generation often defined by unprecedented levels of debt, the idea of financial independence has become so important that one in four young adults with 401(k)s are choosing to drain their retirement savings to pay down loans, according to a new report from Merrill Lynch and Age Wave. The top reasons for adults under the age of 34 tapping their 401(k)s? Paying off credit card and student loan debt, the survey found.

Trending News

Tax penalties and long-term consequences

The decision to raid your retirement savings can come with long-term consequences. Most financial advisers consider it a cardinal sin to withdraw funds early from your 401(k), as it borrows against your future wealth and comes with heavy tax penalties. Experts feel that the last-resort option can be avoided by coordinating an emergency fund, a Roth IRA and other, better forms of borrowing.

"Many [millennials] will not explore all options while things are still manageable," said Mark Struthers, financial adviser at Sona Financial. "They wait until things are desperate and options are few. When things are bad, it is easy to put off making a plan."

Any amount withdrawn early from a 401(k) is subject to a 10 percent IRS penalty. Because 401(k) contributions are made with pre-tax dollars, the withdrawal will be taxed as extra income during tax season.

The setback also means workers have less time to raise money to retire, or will have to settle for a lower quality of life in retirement. Sanders, who personally set a $2 million retirement goal, already feels behind on her progress. "I'm worried that we'll have to work much longer," Sanders said. She hopes to save enough to live comfortably and also go traveling.

"It's very, very expensive money, so you might be better off going to mom and dad for a loan," said Chris Chen, financial adviser at Insight Financial Strategists.

Why are Americans forced to work longer?

$1.6 trillion in student loan debt

Only 68 percent of 20-somethings are even eligible to contribute to a 401(k) plan, according to the Center for Retirement Research at Boston College. While people in their 20s and 30s today are more educated, more diverse and more technologically savvy than their parents and grandparents, they're also carrying exorbitantly high levels of debt at a time when wages are stagnant and the cost of living is rising.

Americans collectively carry about $1.6 trillion in student loan debt today. They're graduating with nearly $37,000 in student loan debt and paying monthly installments of $371 for 10 years, according to the Merrill Lynch report. They're also averaging $3,700 in credit card debt.

"That debt has a ripple effect," said Lisa Margeson, head of retirement client experience and communications at Bank of America, parent of Merrill Lynch.

Anxiety around financial independence

Debt is making "adulthood" prove so elusive for many adults that financial independence is increasingly becoming the top priority. The study found that 60 percent of today's young adults define "financial success" as being debt-free, as opposed to 19 percent who equate success with being rich.

It's understandable when you consider how debt is reshaping priorities: Some early adults are assessing whether they can afford to have children. Fewer adults are buying homes than they were just 10 years ago. Still others with debt are contributing only half the amount of those without debt into their 401(k)s, Merrill Lynch reported.

Meanwhile, 75 percent of young adults defined success as financial independence from their parents. Nearly 60 percent of early adults said they could not afford to get by without financial support from their parents, and 70 percent said they received some form of help in the last year.

While both parents and children are happy for the intergenerational support, children are wary of over relying on their parents, especially as they get older past 25, as it can add to their anxiety that they are falling behind.

"That's sort of the target for when they'll feel like an adult," Bank of America's Margeson said.

First published on April 19, 2019 / 5:18 PM

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc.. All Rights Reserved.

Star-studded climate change music video drops

The song and video were created to raise awareness and money for environmental causes

7M ago

Columbine shooting survivors reflect 20 years later

Craig Scott, Amanda Stair, Heather Martin, Michelle Wheeler and Frank DeAngelis spoke with Jeff Glor about their experiences since that day

1H ago

1 in 4 millennials raiding 401(k)s early to pay debt

A generation defined by high levels of debt often thinks paying off credit cards and student loans trumps saving for retirement

22M ago

Rapper Cardi B rejects plea deal in strip club fight

Cardi B has rejected a plea deal in a case stemming from a New York strip club melee last August

49M ago

Fiat Chrysler recalls 320,000 cars due to rollaway risk

Transmission problem in Dodge Dart compact cars made from 2013 through 2016, when company stopped producing them.

1H ago

Romney "sickened" by "dishonesty" in the White House

Romney also said it was "good news" that the president was not charged with obstruction of justice

1H ago

Warren calls on Congress to begin impeachment proceedings

Warren became the first Democratic presidential candidate to call for impeachment in the wake of the Mueller report's release

updated 6M ago

Pompeo dismisses North Korea's call for him to be replaced

The secretary of state spoke after a meeting with the acting defense secretary and their Japanese counterparts

2H ago

2020 Dems sidestep impeachment talk after Mueller report release

Sen. Elizabeth Warren said Friday that "the House should initiate impeachment proceedings" against President Trump

1H ago

Preview: Pete Buttigieg's thoughts on the presidency

In an interview for "Sunday Morning" the South Bend, Ind. mayor also talks about his marriage, and why the presidency should be a "moral office"

4H ago

Fashion industry's carbon impact is bigger than airline industry's

As consumers learn of toll fast fashion can take on the environment, they're embracing less wasteful alternatives

4H ago

Teen burned to death after refusing to drop sex harassment charges

Protesters demand justice for Nusrat Jahan Rafi in Bangladesh's capital of Dhaka

5H ago

Russia mocks Mueller probe for finding "caviar" but no collusion

"There is nothing in it that would be worth paying attention to," Russia's Foreign Ministry tells state-run media

6H ago

Bees atop Notre Dame Cathedral survive fire

European bees don't flee their hives in danger; they stayed put and got drunk on smoke

6H ago

"Computer glitch" may be behind Notre Dame fire, rector says

Fire burned through network of oak beams supporting Notre Dame's vaulted stone ceiling, dangerously weakening it

1H ago

Star-studded climate change music video drops

The song and video were created to raise awareness and money for environmental causes

7M ago

Rapper Cardi B rejects plea deal in strip club fight

Cardi B has rejected a plea deal in a case stemming from a New York strip club melee last August

49M ago

Mayor Pete wants Phish at his inauguration

"It's worth a shot, maybe we should ask them," he said

6H ago

Review: Terry Gilliam finally wrestles "The Man Who Killed Don Quixote" to the screen

The filmmaker's long-in the-works rendition of the Cervantes legend transforms contemporary times into an age of chivalry

8H ago

Judge allows sex-trafficking claim against Harvey Weinstein

In addition, the judge dramatically shrank scope of an action trying to treat the former movie producer and various companies like a mob organization

21H ago

"Text me $$$": Debt collectors want OK to text and email consumers

A federal agency wants to update rules about how debt collectors contact borrowers. Consumer advocates fear abuses

7H ago

Debt collectors could soon text and email you

A federal agency says debt-collection regulations need to be updated to reflect new technology like smartphones.

7H ago 00:59

How to protect data when using health apps

Apps are being used for everything from tracking your diet to your daily steps and even your pregnancy. But that health-related data might not be as safe as you expect. Recent research published in BMJ, the British Medical Journal, found 79 percent of the top medication-related mobile apps shared user data in ways that may compromise sensitive information. Wired senior writer Issie Lapowsky joins "CBS This Morning" to discuss the latest research.

7H ago 04:26

Pinterest pinned hopes on big IPO. Looks like it got one

Stock price — trading under ticker symbol "PINS" — zoomed to nearly $25 a share from $19 opening bid within hours of NYSE debut

6H ago

Pinterest shares soar on 1st day of trading

Shares in Pinterest soared 28 percent Thursday during the newly public company's first hours of trading under the New York Stock Exchange ticker symbol PINS.

21H ago 00:32

New York City slashes its biggest source of carbon emissions

In a first, America's largest city is moving to curb emissions by requiring buildings to become more energy-efficient

22H ago

12-foot, 1,600-lb shark being tracked in Gulf of Mexico

Researchers are OCEARCH are tracking the location of a giant great white shark

Apr 18

"Green" buildings sprouting in record numbers

Buildings around the globe account for roughly 40 percent of the world's carbon emissions. In response, a growing number of cities are adapting old and new structures in ways that save energy and cut down on emissions.

Apr 18 01:22

Evidence found for first molecule in the universe

"This molecule was lurking out there, but we needed the right instruments," a top NASA scientist said

Apr 17

Watch: Rocket launches cargo to space station

An Antares rocket blasted off from the Wallops Island Flight Facility in Virginia carrying a Cygnus cargo ship loaded with supplies for the International Space Station.

Apr 17 01:45

If my measles shot was years ago, am I still protected?

An expert answers 5 common questions about the measles vaccine

2H ago

Corporate America embraces 420 as pot legalization grows

April 20 marijuana holiday now a mainstream marketing gimmick, from Lyft's $4.20 credits to Carl's Jr.'s CBD burgers

2H ago

Blood pressure medication recall expanded

It's the latest in a string of recalls over concerns of potential cancer-causing impurities

4H ago

Girl died of congenital condition, not school fight injuries, prosecutor says

A family attorney, however, says the girl was bullied for years and they still have questions about how she died

5H ago

Amid measles outbreak, anti-vax mom defends "medical freedom"

There are at least 555 confirmed cases in 20 states, according to the CDC

9H ago

1 in 4 millennials raiding 401(k)s early to pay debt

A generation defined by high levels of debt often thinks paying off credit cards and student loans trumps saving for retirement

22M ago

Fiat Chrysler recalls 320,000 cars due to rollaway risk

Transmission problem in Dodge Dart compact cars made from 2013 through 2016, when company stopped producing them.

1H ago

Earth Day challenge for gardeners: Don't poison bees

To help, more garden centers are curbing, ending or labeling plants treated with potentially bee-harming pesticides

Apr 18

Some millennials tap 401(k)s to pay down debt

For a generation defined by unprecedented levels of debt, paying down credit card and student loan bills trumps saving for retirement.

2H ago 01:11

Corporate America embraces 420 as pot legalization grows

April 20 marijuana holiday now a mainstream marketing gimmick, from Lyft's $4.20 credits to Carl's Jr.'s CBD burgers

2H ago

Rapper Cardi B rejects plea deal in strip club fight

Cardi B has rejected a plea deal in a case stemming from a New York strip club melee last August

49M ago

"House of horrors" parents sentenced

A California couple has been sentenced to 25 years to life in prison for torturing and holding their 13 children captive for years. David and Louise Turpin pleaded guilty in February to torture and other abuse and neglect. Alex Denis has more.

1H ago 01:19

"House of horrors" parents get 25 years to life as kids speak out

The horrific plight of the 13 siblings was revealed in January 2018 when a girl escaped captivity and called 911

updated 48M ago

Girl died of congenital condition, not school fight injuries, prosecutor says

A family attorney, however, says the girl was bullied for years and they still have questions about how she died

5H ago

Cop fired deadly shot before he could analyze threat, partner testifies

The partner of Mohamed Noor acknowledged under defense questioning he feared an ambush before the shooting

6H ago

Evidence found for first molecule in the universe

"This molecule was lurking out there, but we needed the right instruments," a top NASA scientist said

Apr 17

Watch: Rocket launches cargo to space station

An Antares rocket blasted off from the Wallops Island Flight Facility in Virginia carrying a Cygnus cargo ship loaded with supplies for the International Space Station.

Apr 17 01:45

Rocket launches with cargo for space station

Loaded with 3.8 tons of supplies and equipment, the Cygnus cargo ship will need two days to reach the space station

Apr 17

Researchers reveal changes to astronaut's body

Retired astronaut Scott Kelly, who spent 340 days in space during an extended stay aboard the International Space Station in 2015-16, did not suffer any major long-term health effects that might raise warning signs for future long-duration flights, scientists reported Thursday. CBS News space consultant Bill Harwood joins CBSN with details.

Apr 11 01:08

Israeli spacecraft fails to land on moon

CBS News space consultant Bill Harwood speaks to CBSN about the failed moon landing and Thursday's other headlines: SpaceX's second launch of their Falcon Heavy rocket and NASA's report that astronaut Scott Kelly experienced biological changes during his year-long orbit in space.

Apr 11 05:36

Photos: Fire burns Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris

On April 15, 2019 flames erupted at the landmark cathedral, the most-visited landmark in the French capital

Apr 16 46 photos

Star Wars Celebration 2019

The four-day convention for fans of the Star Wars saga, held in Chicago, included cosplayers, panels with the filmmakers, and the debut of the trailer for Episode IX of the series

Apr 13 39 photos

Awkward Easter Bunny photos

Children love the Easter Bunny – until they meet him

Apr 12 35 photos

The folk art of Bill Traylor

Born into slavery, the self-taught painter who began his artistic life in his 80s is the focus of a retrospective at the Smithsonian American Art Museum

Apr 7 24 photos

America's surprising food recalls

What's in your fridge? Just maybe salmonella, E. coli – and a dead bat?

Apr 5 38 photos

Popular

Some millennials tap 401(k)s to pay down debt

For a generation defined by unprecedented levels of debt, paying down credit card and student loan bills trumps saving for retirement.

2H ago 01:11

"House of horrors" parents sentenced

A California couple has been sentenced to 25 years to life in prison for torturing and holding their 13 children captive for years. David and Louise Turpin pleaded guilty in February to torture and other abuse and neglect. Alex Denis has more.

1H ago 01:19

Warriors take series lead on Clippers

The Golden State Warriors rebounded from a blown lead in Game 2 to win Game 3 against the Los Angeles Clippers. Bill Reiter of CBS Sports HQ joined CBSN to break down the week's headlines in sports.

3H ago 05:26

Ex-FBI agent to 911: "I may have killed him"

Listen as a 911 dispatcher in Davidson County, N.C., directs Tom Martens and his daughter Molly Corbett how to perform CPR after Martens called for help the night of Aug. 2, 2015. Martens says he had to intervene in self-defense after his son-in-law Jason Corbett got into fight with his daughter.

3H ago 01:53

(Un)Welcome: Sweden's rise of the right

In this installment of CBSN Originals’ ongoing examination at how migration is reshaping the world, Adam Yamaguchi travels to Sweden to examine how a record influx of migrants has coincided with the recently welcoming and politically progressive nation's swift shift to the right.

Apr 15 23:06