Supreme Court justices avoid saying F-word at heart of trademark case

/ AP

Washington – None of the Supreme Court's justices wanted to say the four-letter word. The high court was discussing a trademark case Monday involving a Los Angeles-based fashion brand "FUCT." But the justices did some verbal gymnastics to get through about an hour of arguments without saying the brand's name.

Chief Justice John Roberts described it as the "vulgar word at the heart of the case." Justice Samuel Alito called it "the word your client wants to use." And Justice Stephen Breyer called it "the word at issue."

The case has to do with a portion of federal law that says officials should not register trademarks that are "scandalous" or "immoral." Officials have refused to register the brand's name as a result.

Trending News

But the artist behind the brand, Erik Brunetti, argues that portion of law should be struck down as an unconstitutional restriction on speech. The government is defending the century-old provision, arguing it encourages trademarks that are appropriate for all audiences. Lawyer Malcolm Stewart, who was arguing for the Trump administration, said the law isn't a restriction on speech but rather the government declining to promote certain speech.

Stewart also went to great lengths not to say the brand's name, calling it "the equivalent of the profane past participle form of a well-known word of profanity and perhaps the paradigmatic word of profanity in our language."

Can use, but can't trademark

Brunetti and others like him who are denied trademark registration under the "scandalous" provision can still use the words they wanted to register for their business, nonprofit or brand, a point some justices underscored. They just don't get the benefits that come with registering a trademark. For Brunetti, that would largely mean a better ability to go after counterfeiters who knock off his designs.

Brunetti's lawyer, John R. Sommer, got the closest to saying the brand's name, using the phrase "the F word" and noting his client's brand "isn't exactly" a "dirty" word. "Oh, come on. You know, come on," responded Alito, adding: "Be serious. We know…what he's trying to say."

It wasn't clear from arguments how the case might ultimately come out, but Brunetti would seem to have a strong case. Two years ago, the justices unanimously invalidated a related provision of federal law that told officials not to register disparaging trademarks. In that case, an Asian-American rock band sued after the government refused to register its band name, "The Slants," because it was seen as offensive to Asians.

Inconsistent decisions

During Monday's argument, some of the justices seemed troubled by what they suggested are inconsistent decisions by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office about what gets tagged as scandalous or immoral. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg noted that the office has refused to register some trademarks both by saying they are scandalous and, ironically, too confusingly similar to something that is already registered. For example, the office refused to register "FUK!T" for being scandalous and immoral but also confusingly similar to the already registered "PHUKIT."

Justice Neil Gorsuch said, "There are shocking numbers of ones granted and ones refused" that "do look remarkably similar." Gorsuch suggested that the outcomes in such cases were as arbitrary as the "flip of a coin."

"I don't want to go through the examples," he said to laughter. "I really don't want to do that."

The case is 18-302, Iancu v. Brunetti.

First published on April 15, 2019 / 6:02 PM

© 2019 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

House Intel leaders demand "full visibility" into Mueller materials

Democrat Adam Schiff and Republican Devin Nunes say they want "all materials, regardless of form and classification" from Mueller

13M ago

Supreme Court justices avoid saying F-word at heart of trademark case

Los Angeles fashion brand "FUCT" argues that the legal ban on its trademarking of the word is unconstitutional

19M ago

Bernie Sanders releases 10 years of tax returns detailing millions in earnings

Facing mounting pressure, the Vermont senator and 2020 contender disclosed 10 years of his tax returns

21M ago

Best Buy names first woman CEO as Hubert Joly steps down

Corie Barry, who will take the helm in June, will face pressure to continue her predecessor's strong run

1H ago

YG pays tribute to slain friend Nipsey Hussle at Coachella

The Grammy-nominated Hussle was shot and killed outside his clothing store in South Los Angeles on March 31

1H ago

House Intel leaders demand "full visibility" into Mueller materials

Democrat Adam Schiff and Republican Devin Nunes say they want "all materials, regardless of form and classification" from Mueller

13M ago

Bernie Sanders releases 10 years of tax returns detailing millions in earnings

Facing mounting pressure, the Vermont senator and 2020 contender disclosed 10 years of his tax returns

21M ago

Judge denies bail for Chinese woman who entered Mar-a-Lago

Yujing Zhang had been indicted Friday on charges of lying to federal agent and illegal entering of a restricted area

3H ago

Trump to award Tiger Woods the Presidential Medal of Freedom

The president said he would be awarding Woods the nation's highest civilian honor

4H ago

Trump attorney calls Congress a "junior-varsity IRS"

Democratic lawmakers have given the Treasury Department an April 23 deadline to disclose six years of the president's tax returns

4H ago

Notre Dame Cathedral fire in Paris – live updates

A major fire engulfed the historic Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris

updated 1M ago

Ancient "human sacrifice" found by utility workers

More two dozen human skeletons believed to be nearly 3,000 years old were found as workers were laying down a new pipeline

1H ago

Notre Dame was undergoing major renovation before fire

Notre Dame Cathedral​ was undergoing $6.8 million in renovations on the church's spire and its 250 tons of lead

updated 3M ago

Climate change protests stop traffic in heart of London

"Brexit, none of it's going to matter if there's a climate apocalypse," a demonstrator says

5H ago

San Diego Zoo to say farewell to giant pandas

The most successful breeding program outside of China is coming to a close

5H ago

Will the GoT books end like the HBO series?

"I don't think Dan and Dave's ending is going to be that different from my ending," says author George R.R. Martin about the HBO series moving beyond his books

31M ago

YG pays tribute to slain friend Nipsey Hussle at Coachella

The Grammy-nominated Hussle was shot and killed outside his clothing store in South Los Angeles on March 31

1H ago

Jay-Z to headline Webster Hall reopening

Webster Hall closed its doors in 2017, and now a New York native is helping the iconic venue reopen

4H ago

Actress Lori Loughlin and husband plead not guilty in college scam

The couple is accused of paying $500,000 in bribes to get their daughters admitted to the University of Southern California as crew recruits, even though neither is a rower

6H ago

Why Abby Wambach felt "anger bubbling up" on stage with NBA, NFL stars

The retired soccer star speaks with Norah O'Donnell in the "CBS This Morning" podcast

11H ago

Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp back online after major outage

All three social media platforms were affected, particularly in the Northeast U.S., Europe and the Philippines

9H ago

5G gets boost from Trump administration

On Friday, the White House announced a new plan to accelerate the rollout of the super-fast network across the country and phone companies are racing to capitalize on the upgrade. Adriana Diaz reports.

7H ago 02:22

Is Grindr a threat to national security?

U.S. officials have ordered a Chinese company to sell the gay dating app Grindr over national security concerns. CBS News contributor Isaac Stone Fish joins CBSN to discuss.

21H ago 03:20

Off-duty tech workers help the homeless reconnect with loved ones

Databases, apps, and online searches are part of their arsenal to locate people who made a difference in a homeless person's past

Apr 13

Group connects homeless with lost loved ones

From Instagram postings to Snapchat messages, the world is communicating like never before. But that doesn't include much of America's homeless population – people who've stepped off the grid and into the shadows. For some homeless people in San Francisco a new service is using the tools we all take for granted to repair their broken bonds. Meg Oliver reports.

20H ago 04:44

Climate change protests stop traffic in heart of London

"Brexit, none of it's going to matter if there's a climate apocalypse," a demonstrator says

5H ago

Last known female of world's rare turtle dies in China zoo

Yangtze giant softshell turtle was about 90 years old, but scientists tried again for artificial insemination shortly before her death

13H ago

Arctic warming fuels blockbuster spring blizzard

What happens in the Arctic does not stay in the Arctic

Apr 12

Thousands of scientists back students demanding climate change action

"Without bold and focused action, their future is in critical danger. There is no time to wait until they are in power," scientists say.

Apr 12

Researchers reveal changes to astronaut's body

Retired astronaut Scott Kelly, who spent 340 days in space during an extended stay aboard the International Space Station in 2015-16, did not suffer any major long-term health effects that might raise warning signs for future long-duration flights, scientists reported Thursday. CBS News space consultant Bill Harwood joins CBSN with details.

Apr 11 01:08

Measles cases soar to second-highest level in 25 years

Since the beginning of the year, 555 cases of measles have been confirmed in the United States

3H ago

Students learn life-saving trauma techniques amid terror, shooting concerns

Boston Marathon bombing six years ago was "tipping point" for doctors who embraced the Stop the Bleed program

6H ago

Senator decries "poisons" as chemicals in cosmetics draw scrutiny

As lawmakers press for a Personal Care Product Safety Act, some companies are vowing never to use certain potentially dangerous chemicals found in everyday beauty products

10H ago

More regulation for chemicals in cosmetics?

A new bill aims to protect people from potentially dangerous chemicals found in everyday beauty products, like makeup, lotions, and shampoos. Women put an average of 168 chemicals on their face and body before they even walk out the door, while men put on an average of 85, according to the Environmental Working Group. Studies show some of those chemicals have been linked to health problems, including cancer and infertility. Anna Werner reports.

9H ago 05:47

Pre-cut melon recalled over link to salmonella outbreak

The fruit has been sold under various brands or labels at Kroger, Walmart, Trader Joe's, Target and Whole Foods

Apr 13

On Tax Day, many Americans don't think the tax cut helped them

President Trump touted "massive tax cuts," but only the richest Americans are likely to notice their new tax breaks

3H ago

Supreme Court justices avoid saying F-word at heart of trademark case

Los Angeles fashion brand "FUCT" argues that the legal ban on its trademarking of the word is unconstitutional

19M ago

Self-employed? Don't forget to claim these tax deductions

Taxes can put a big dent in your income, but you can offset that pain by taking advantage of these deductions

Apr 12

Bernie Sanders releases 10 years of tax returns detailing millions in earnings

Facing mounting pressure, the Vermont senator and 2020 contender disclosed 10 years of his tax returns

21M ago

60 of America's biggest companies paid no federal income tax in 2018

New analysis finds dozens of corporations, including Amazon and Netflix, paid no taxes despite billions in profits

Apr 12

YG pays tribute to slain friend Nipsey Hussle at Coachella

The Grammy-nominated Hussle was shot and killed outside his clothing store in South Los Angeles on March 31

1H ago

Suspect in church fires charged with hate crimes

Images on Holden Matthews' phone showed him "claiming responsibility" for the Louisiana churches burning, officials said

2H ago

Boy thrown from mall balcony in "courageous" fight as donations pour in

Donations and prayers for his recovery poured in around the country for a 5-year-old boy who is fighting a "courageous battle" after being thrown from a third-floor balcony at the Mall of America

3H ago

Arrest in brutal beating of Dallas transgender woman

Police calling attack in broad daylight in front of crowd a hate crime; it was caught on video

13H ago

Ambushed judge survives attack with a mission to protect others

Shot multiple times in front of her home and in front of her teenage son, the inspiring story of a woman who overcame incredible odds to survive and is now on a mission to stop future attacks on judges

Apr 13

Space

Researchers reveal changes to astronaut's body

Retired astronaut Scott Kelly, who spent 340 days in space during an extended stay aboard the International Space Station in 2015-16, did not suffer any major long-term health effects that might raise warning signs for future long-duration flights, scientists reported Thursday. CBS News space consultant Bill Harwood joins CBSN with details.

Apr 11 01:08

Israeli spacecraft fails to land on moon

CBS News space consultant Bill Harwood speaks to CBSN about the failed moon landing and Thursday's other headlines: SpaceX's second launch of their Falcon Heavy rocket and NASA's report that astronaut Scott Kelly experienced biological changes during his year-long orbit in space.

Apr 11 05:36

SpaceX Falcon Heavy rocket thunders into space

The second flight of SpaceX's Falcon Heavy is carrying a Saudi communications satellite into orbit

Apr 11

Meet the 29-year-old who helped create the black hole image

Dr. Katie Bouman led the creation of a new algorithm to produce the first-ever image of a black hole

Apr 11

Israel fails to land spacecraft on the moon

An Israeli spacecraft has failed in its attempt to make history as the first privately funded lunar mission. The SpaceIL spacecraft lost contact with Earth late Thursday, just moments before it was to land on the moon, and scientists declared the mission a failure. Watch their announcement here.

Apr 11 01:05

Photos: Fire burns Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris

On April 15, 2019 flames erupted at the landmark cathedral, the most-visited landmark in the French capital

1H ago 32 photos

Star Wars Celebration 2019

The four-day convention for fans of the Star Wars saga, held in Chicago, included cosplayers, panels with the filmmakers, and the debut of the trailer for Episode IX of the series

Apr 13 39 photos

Awkward Easter Bunny photos

Children love the Easter Bunny – until they meet him

Apr 12 35 photos

The folk art of Bill Traylor

Born into slavery, the self-taught painter who began his artistic life in his 80s is the focus of a retrospective at the Smithsonian American Art Museum

Apr 7 24 photos

America's surprising food recalls

What's in your fridge? Just maybe salmonella, E. coli – and a dead bat?

Apr 5 36 photos

Popular

How to get more time on your taxes

It's Tax Day, but don't fret if you're not ready — asking for more time to file your return is a pretty straightforward process. Yahoo News reporter and producer Jeanie Ahn joins CBSN to explain how to get a tax return extension and how you can prepare now for next year's tax season.

4H ago 04:13

Paris deputy mayor on Notre Dame fire

Christophe Girard, the deputy mayor of Paris in charge of culture, said the massive fire at the historic Notre Dame Cathedral is a "tragedy for the world," although some priceless paintings and artifacts have been saved. He spoke with CBSN as the fire continued to burn.

updated 58M ago 13:13

Why Notre Dame fire is so hard to fight

CBS News Radio correspondent Bill Rehkopf, a volunteer firefighter for 30 years, explains why church fires, including the one at Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris, are generally "really very hard to fight."

1H ago 06:38

(Un)Welcome: Sweden's rise of the right

In this installment of CBSN Originals’ ongoing examination at how migration is reshaping the world, Adam Yamaguchi travels to Sweden to examine how a record influx of migrants has coincided with the recently welcoming and politically progressive nation's swift shift to the right.

5H ago 23:06

Special Report: Notre Dame fire

A fire has caused extensive damage to the historic Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris. Jeff Glor anchors a CBS News special report.

2H ago 41:39