Mnuchin calls Democrats' request for Trump's tax returns "unprecedented"

By Camilo Montoya-Galvez

/ CBS News

Washington — Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin called the request by Congressional Democrats for the disclosure of President Trump's tax returns an "unprecedented" move that raises questions about the scope of Congress' "investigative authority" and lawmakers' "legislative purpose."

In a letter that is likely to intensify the latest showdown between the White House and Democrats in the House, Mnuchin said his department, which oversees the Internal Revenue Services (IRS), will not be able to review the request for the president's tax returns by Friday, the deadline set by the chairman of the House Committee on Ways and Means, Rep. Richard Neal, a Democrat from Massachusetts.

"The Committee's request raises serious issues concerning the constitutional scope of Congressional investigative authority, the legitimacy of the asserted legislative purpose, and the constitutional rights of American citizens," Mnuchin wrote in the letter addressed to Neal on Friday.

Last week, Neal sent a formal request to the IRS for six years of Mr. Trump's tax returns, arguing the committee "has a responsibility to conduct oversight of our voluntary Federal tax system and determine how Americans — including those elected to our highest office — are complying with those laws."

Trending News

The president responded by saying he's under audit — a pretext he has often cited — and "would not be inclined" to release his returns until the audit is completed. No federal statute bars individuals under audit from releasing their tax returns. Mr. Trump's lawyer in the matter, Will Consovoy, also asked the IRS not to hand over the president's tax returns until it receives a legal opinion from the Justice Department.

Over the weekend, Mick Mulvaney, who is the acting White House chief of staff, told Fox News that Democrats would "never" see Mr. Trump's tax returns.

Referring to Neal's request as a "long-planned inquiry," Mnuchin cited concerns raised by the House Ways and Means Committee when it was controlled by Republicans during the last session of Congress, as well as comments made by GOP lawmakers when Democrats made the request last week. He said a report issued by House Republicans in 2017 suggested the request by Democrats was politically-motivated and not for the purposes of congressional oversight.

"The Committee determined that such a request would be an 'abuse of authority and set a dangerous precedent by targeting a single individual's confidential tax returns and associated financial documents for disclosure' for political reasons," Mnuchin wrote.

He said his agency is consulting with the Justice Department to determine whether the request for Mr. Trump's tax returns is legal and constitutional. "The legal implications of this request could affect protections for all Americans against politically-motivated disclosures of personal tax information, regardless of which party is in power," he added.

Mnuchin pledged to review the request "carefully," but did not provide a timeline for doing so.

First published on April 10, 2019 / 8:18 PM

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Mnuchin calls request for Trump's tax returns "unprecedented"

Treasury Secretary said the move raises questions about the scope of Congress' "investigative authority" and lawmakers' "legislative purpose"

2M ago

SpaceX Falcon Heavy launch scrubbed due to high winds

A year after its maiden flight, the Falcon Heavy is carrying an Arabsat communications satelllite

updated 21M ago

Deadly gas explosion levels building in Durham, North Carolina

Firefighters responding to a natural gas leak were evacuating people from building when it exploded Wednesday morning

58M ago

7-Eleven owner caught a teen thief. Here's why he didn't call 911

When Jay Singh confronted a young thief, he decided he wanted to help him

1H ago

7-Eleven owner treats thief with kindness

When 7-Eleven owner Jay Singh say a young thief in his store, he confronted him. Then he responded with kindness. Dean Reynolds explains.

updated 10M ago 01:46

Mnuchin calls request for Trump's tax returns "unprecedented"

Treasury Secretary said the move raises questions about the scope of Congress' "investigative authority" and lawmakers' "legislative purpose"

2M ago

Migrant families left waiting as the border crisis escalates

Last month, U.S. Customs and Border Protection reported 103,000 people were apprehended

1H ago

Families left waiting at the border

President Trump flew to Texas Wednesday, and said he plans to send more troops to the southern border after hearing complaints about the surge of migrants crossing into the U.S. Mireya Villarreal traveled to Bronwsville, Texas to see the crisis firsthand.

updated 28M ago 02:52

Barr says spying occurred on Trump campaign

Attorney General William Barr got plenty of attention Wednesday when he told Congress he believes the government spied on the Trump campaign in 2016. He also wants to examine how the Russia investigation began. Nancy Cordes has the latest.

updated 46M ago 02:24

Bernie Sanders' "Medicare for All" plan

Vermont Senator and presidential candidate Bernie Sanders released an updated version of his universal health care plan, known as "Medicare for All," Wednesday. CBS News political correspondent Ed O'Keefe sat down with Sanders to talk about his bill, which has the backing of several of his Democratic primary opponents.

updated 10M ago 08:40

Migrant families left waiting as the border crisis escalates

Last month, U.S. Customs and Border Protection reported 103,000 people were apprehended

1H ago

First black hole picture revealed

Scientists on Wednesday showed off the first picture of a black hole. Its gravity is so powerful, nothing escapes, not even light. Mark Strassmann explains.

updated 30M ago 02:25

Families left waiting at the border

President Trump flew to Texas Wednesday, and said he plans to send more troops to the southern border after hearing complaints about the surge of migrants crossing into the U.S. Mireya Villarreal traveled to Bronwsville, Texas to see the crisis firsthand.

updated 28M ago 02:52

Barr says spying occurred on Trump campaign

Attorney General William Barr got plenty of attention Wednesday when he told Congress he believes the government spied on the Trump campaign in 2016. He also wants to examine how the Russia investigation began. Nancy Cordes has the latest.

updated 46M ago 02:24

"Meghan and Harry Plus One" to look back on whirlwind year for royal couple

Gayle King to anchor one-hour special marking the one-year anniversary of the royal couple's marriage and the birth of their first child

2H ago

"Meghan and Harry Plus One" to look back on whirlwind year for royal couple

Gayle King to anchor one-hour special marking the one-year anniversary of the royal couple's marriage and the birth of their first child

2H ago

Full-length trailer for "The Lion King" is released

The trailer reveals the astonishing CGI remake of the classic 1994 Disney movie

2H ago

Memorial service for Nipsey Hussle to be held in L.A.

The Grammy-nominated rapper will be honored on Thursday in Los Angeles

1H ago

Kim Kardashian-West preparing to take bar exam

The reality star and beauty mogul is now a law apprentice at a San Francisco firm

1H ago

"Killing Eve" stars on their characters' "absolutely obsessive" relationship

The hit show is at once a psychological thriller, a cat-and-mouse spy game and a workplace comedy

11H ago

Facebook to combat false and harmful info with new features

It's limiting visibility of links that are more prominent on Facebook than elsewhere and adding more expert fact checkers

4H ago

Ethical challenges of artificial intelligence

CNET senior producer Dan Patterson reports on some of the technological and ethical challenges facing the rapidly growing field of artificial intelligence.

3H ago 03:08

New app aspires to be the Airbnb of parking

ParkStash connects drivers looking for a parking spot with homeowners and businesses with space for their wheels

14H ago

YouTube had to disable "hateful" comments during hate crimes hearing

One of the channels streaming the hearing was a white nationalist account that raised money from users

Apr 9

Facebook's AI helping block or remove 1 million accounts a day

Ahead of elections in India, the social media company is purging accounts that violate its rules against misinformation, hate speech and voter suppression

Apr 8

SpaceX Falcon Heavy launch scrubbed due to high winds

A year after its maiden flight, the Falcon Heavy is carrying an Arabsat communications satelllite

updated 21M ago

First black hole picture revealed

Scientists on Wednesday showed off the first picture of a black hole. Its gravity is so powerful, nothing escapes, not even light. Mark Strassmann explains.

updated 30M ago 02:25

Scientists unveil first image of black hole in all its dark glory

In an historic observation, a globe-spanning virtual telescope has directly imaged a black hole's shadow

3H ago

First image of black hole ever seen

The first image of a black hole has been released by scientists. Telescopes captured the image from 55 million light-years away. CBS News space consultant Bill Harwood joins CBSN to discuss the significance of this discovery.

3H ago 03:26

"Our Planet" explores climate & wildlife

The new Netflix series, "Our Planet," takes a look at the impact humans have on wildlife. Filmmakers Keith Scholey, Jamie McPherson and Sophie Lanfear speaks to CBSN about the series and the steps all of us can take to help protect and preserve nature.

Apr 9 07:43

"People are dying": Insulin being rationed as drug prices rise

A recent study found one in four patients reported "cost-related underuse"

1H ago

Patients rationing insulin amid rising prices

Drug industry executives faced tough questions Wednesday from Congress over the rising cost of insulin. It's nearly doubled in the last five years, forcing some diabetics to ration the drug. Anna Werner reports.

updated 15M ago 02:10

Ohio heartbeat abortion ban heads to governor, who plans to sign it

Ohio would join five other states that have passed such restrictive abortion measures; Opponents vow to sue

updated 43M ago

New Jersey dad dies after donating bone marrow to teen stranger

Derrick Nelson went into a coma after he donated bone marrow to a teenage boy in France

4H ago

Mysterious E. coli outbreak expands in 5 states

The CDC has not yet identified a source of the outbreak

8H ago

What taxpayers should know about the new IRS Form 1040

New "postcard-size" form now has just 23 lines, but many taxpayers must complete one or more of six new schedules

3H ago

Yahoo reaches $117.5 million settlement in huge data breach

Some 200 million people who had sensitive information stolen will share restitution and get free credit monitoring

3H ago

In wealthy countries, a shrinking middle class

Half of all middle-income households in wealthier nations now struggle to make ends meet, with millennials especially struggling to maintain their foothold.

3H ago 01:24

Facebook to combat false and harmful info with new features

It's limiting visibility of links that are more prominent on Facebook than elsewhere and adding more expert fact checkers

4H ago

Millennials are falling out of the U.S. middle class

Half of all middle-income households in wealthier countries around the world now struggle to make ends meet

5H ago

Man who found his long-missing mom's remains testifies

Aaron Fraser was 3 when his mother, Bonnie Haim, vanished in 1993; he told a detective, "Daddy hurt Mommy"

2H ago

Man who found missing mom's remains testifies

A Florida man who found the remains of his mother, missing since 1993, during a 2014 home renovation took the stand Tuesday in his father’s murder trial. Christy Turner reporters for CBS affiliate WJAX.

2H ago 01:22

Man fatally shot after buying meals for Waffle House customers

"This should have never happened," a family member said

4H ago

Arrests in botched hit that killed intended victim's sister

Alisha Canales-McGuire was gunned down at her sister's home in 2017 as she was caring for her young nieces and nephew

5H ago

NYC man, 80, charged in 1973 murders of teens in Virginia Beach

Virginia Beach police said their cold-case unit began to pursue a "strong lead" last year and sought out "advanced forensic technology"

12H ago

SpaceX Falcon Heavy launch scrubbed due to high winds

A year after its maiden flight, the Falcon Heavy is carrying an Arabsat communications satelllite

updated 21M ago

Cargo ship completes express flight to space station

For only the second time, the Russians launched a cargo ship on a two-orbit flight to space station

Apr 4

Astronauts excited to return to the moon

Three U.S. astronauts aboard the International Space Station said Monday that they're ready to sign up for a trip to the moon if NASA can meet the Trump administration's newly stated goal of returning Americans to the lunar surface within the next five years.

Apr 2 00:59

NASA astronauts "super excited" about moon mission

Three space station crew members say they'll be ready for a trip to the moon if NASA can pull it off

Apr 1

U.S. planning to return to the moon

Vice President Mike Pence says the United States will return to the moon within the next five years. It would be the first trip to the moon in nearly 50 years. CBS News space analyst Bill Harwood joins CBSN with the latest.

Mar 27 05:30

The folk art of Bill Traylor

Born into slavery, the self-taught painter who began his artistic life in his 80s is the focus of a retrospective at the Smithsonian American Art Museum

Apr 7 24 photos

America's surprising food recalls

What's in your fridge? Just maybe salmonella, E. coli – and a dead bat?

Apr 5 36 photos

The highest-paid U.S. athletes in 2019, ranked

Here's the definitive list of the athletes who earn the most money in the NBA, NFL and MLB

Apr 2 49 photos

New on Netflix, Hulu and Amazon

Shows and movies you'll want to stream soon

Mar 26 35 photos

Anti-Brexit march: Hundreds of thousands in London demand new vote

EU supporters hold a "People's Vote" march demanding a new referendum, as Prime Minister Theresa May faces increasing pressure to resign

Mar 23 22 photos

Popular

7-Eleven owner treats thief with kindness

When 7-Eleven owner Jay Singh say a young thief in his store, he confronted him. Then he responded with kindness. Dean Reynolds explains.

updated 10M ago 01:46

Border business: Inside immigration

CBSN Originals presents a documentary special about the cottage industry that's built up across Central America to get migrants to the U.S. border.

Mar 29 38:03

Patients rationing insulin amid rising prices

Drug industry executives faced tough questions Wednesday from Congress over the rising cost of insulin. It's nearly doubled in the last five years, forcing some diabetics to ration the drug. Anna Werner reports.

updated 15M ago 02:10

First black hole picture revealed

Scientists on Wednesday showed off the first picture of a black hole. Its gravity is so powerful, nothing escapes, not even light. Mark Strassmann explains.

updated 30M ago 02:25

Families left waiting at the border

President Trump flew to Texas Wednesday, and said he plans to send more troops to the southern border after hearing complaints about the surge of migrants crossing into the U.S. Mireya Villarreal traveled to Bronwsville, Texas to see the crisis firsthand.

updated 28M ago 02:52