Could diet soda raise a woman's stroke risk?

By Alan Mozes

/ HealthDay

Older women, beware: New research warns that drinking a lot of diet sodas or artificially sweetened fruit juices may increase your risk for stroke.

In a study that tracked nearly 82,000 postmenopausal women, those who drank two or more diet drinks per day saw their overall stroke risk rise by 23 percent, compared with those who consumed diet drinks less than once a week.

Blocked arteries were often the main culprit, with heavy diet drink consumption linked to a 31 percent greater risk for an ischemic stroke, which is triggered by a clot, the study findings showed.

Study author Yasmin Mossavar-Rahmani acknowledged that an "association does not imply causation." But she stressed that the findings held up even after taking into account the nutritional value of each participant's overall diet.

So, "we can't assume these diet drinks are harmless, particularly when consumed at high levels," Mossavar-Rahmani said.

"The take-home message is that these findings give us pause," she added. "We need to do more research on why we are seeing these associations. What are the scientific mechanisms? Is there something about the artificial sweeteners, for example, that affect the bacteria in the gut and lead to health issues?"

New study looks at diet soda's link to dementia

Mossavar-Rahmani is an associate professor in the department of epidemiology and population health's division of health promotion and nutrition research at Albert Einstein College of Medicine, in New York City.

The study authors pointed out that the American Heart Association (AHA) has recently underscored the lack of sufficient research into the cardiovascular impact of diet sodas. Until more work is done, the AHA says the jury remains out on whether artificially sweetened beverages do or do not hasten heart disease.

Women in the latest study were between 50 and 79 when they first enrolled in the Women's Health Initiative trial between 1993 and 1998.

Investigators tracked the general health of all the enrollees for an average of nearly 12 years. During that time — at the three-year mark — all the women were asked to indicate how frequently they consumed diet sodas and diet fruit drinks over a three-month period.

The researchers did not take note of which brands of artificially sweetened drinks the women drank, and so did not know which artificial sweeteners were being consumed.

That said, nearly two-thirds of the women consumed diet sodas or drinks very infrequently, meaning less than once a week or never. Only about 5 percent were found to be "heavy" consumers of artificially sweetened drinks.

After taking into consideration a variety of stroke risk factors — including blood pressure status, smoking history and age — the study team concluded that heavy consumption of diet drinks did appear to be tied to cardiovascular risks in a number of ways.

For example, those women who drank two or more diet beverages a day saw their overall risk for developing heart disease increase by 29 percent. They were also 16 percent more likely to die prematurely from any cause.

Certain groups fared even worse: Among obese women and black women with no history of heart disease or diabetes, a diet drink habit pushed clot-driven stroke risk up by roughly twofold and fourfold, respectively, the researchers reported.

Whether or not the findings would apply to either men or younger women remains unclear, the study authors noted.

The findings were published online Feb. 14 in the journal Stroke.

Lona Sandon is program director of the department of clinical nutrition at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center in Dallas.

She agreed that more research is needed to further explore a possible diet drink-heart disease connection. But for now Sandon offered simple advice: diet or regular, sodas offer no nutritional value other than calories.

"If they replace other drinks, such as milk and 100 percent fruit or vegetable drinks, then these women miss out on valuable nutrition for protecting the heart and vascular system," Sandon warned.

"The nutrition you are missing because you are drinking artificially sweetened beverages instead may be the real problem," she said.

A group representing the artificial sweetener industry offered another caveat about the findings — that many women who drink diet drinks are already struggling with weight issues.

"It is likely study subjects were already at a greater health risk and chose low-calorie sweetened beverages to manage their calorie and sugar intake as these products are proven safe and beneficial for those managing their weight and blood glucose levels," said Robert Rankin, president of the Calorie Control Council.

"The contribution of reverse causality, meaning that individuals already at a greater risk of stroke and cardiovascular events chose low-calorie sweetened beverages, is very likely the cause of the associations presented by these researchers," the council added in a statement.

First published on February 14, 2019

© 2019 HealthDay. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

How to watch the Daytona 500 this Sunday

The Great American Race kicks of the NASCAR season

updated 4M ago

Shutdown watch: Senate passes border bill, Trump to declare emergency – live updates

The Senate passed the bill Thursday afternoon, and the House is expected to pass it in the evening

updated 9M ago

El Niño has arrived. What does it mean for the weather?

After several months on the edge, we're officially under an El Niño advisory

updated 13M ago

"Since Parkland" profiles 1,200 kids killed by guns

More than 200 teen reporters told the stories of young lives lost to bullets

updated 22M ago

Senate passes bill to fund government, avert shutdown

The measure is also expected to pass in the House and signed into law by President Trump

updated 45M ago

Shutdown watch: Senate passes border bill, Trump to declare emergency – live updates

The Senate passed the bill Thursday afternoon, and the House is expected to pass it in the evening

updated 9M ago

Senate passes bill to fund government, avert shutdown

The measure is also expected to pass in the House and signed into law by President Trump

updated 45M ago

GOP lawmakers blast McCabe for comments in "60 Minutes" interview

Republicans balked at fired former FBI deputy director Andrew McCabe after his explosive interview with CBS News

1H ago

Immigration advocates sue DHS and others over "Remain in Mexico" policy

The initiative is possibly the biggest change to immigration policy implemented by the Trump administration

1H ago

Trump to declare a national emergency for border wall

The Senate majority leader says the president will move ahead with his long-threatened move to declare a national emergency

updated 6M ago

Immigration advocates sue DHS and others over "Remain in Mexico" policy

The initiative is possibly the biggest change to immigration policy implemented by the Trump administration

1H ago

Pompeo: Trump administration doing "everything" it can to free Americans in Iran

"We're having conversations with all the people who have the ability to help get them back," Pompeo said

1H ago

Duchess shines light on dangers of osteoporosis

Camilla, 71, opened up about her late mother Rosalind, who died of the bone disease in 1994

3H ago

Human foot found on Canadian coastline — the 15th since 2007

Authorities are seeking help identifying a foot found inside a Nike sneaker

1H ago

Pompeo refuses to say if he believes CIA on Khashoggi killing

Dismissing the question as "ridiculous," Pompeo says U.S. will hold "each individual accountable" for the murder, but current "fact sets" don't implicate crown prince

8H ago

Alfonso Cuarón on the personal trauma he channeled into "Roma"

The black and white foreign film with a largely unknown cast has become an unlikely Oscar front-runner.

4H ago

Ryan Adams accused of emotional abuse, sexual misconduct

In one allegation, a 20-year-old female musician said Ryan Adams, 44, had inappropriate conversations with her while she was 15 and 16

1H ago

These A-listers are the most stylish stars, according to People

Ahead of the Academy Awards, People has released its list that also includes Emma Stone, Nicole Kidman, Donald Glover

22H ago

Disney reveals first look at "Frozen 2"

Fans get their first look at the highly-anticipated "Frozen 2," and it appears the cast is far from where they started

Feb 13

3 women share role of Cher on Broadway. They call it "Cherapy."

The lead role is played by three actresses who represent the different stages of Cher's life

Feb 13

El Niño has arrived. What does it mean for the weather?

After several months on the edge, we're officially under an El Niño advisory

updated 13M ago

Dating apps expose lovebirds to scams and hackers

Mobile apps have transformed the dating experience but they can also expose sensitive information to fraudsters

5H ago

Solar jobs are on the decline — the industry blames Trump

U.S. tariffs have cast a shadow on what until recently had been one of the country's hottest job sectors

6H ago

California governor: Consumers should get paid a "digital dividend"

The idea is sparking debate about a tax on tech companies or a refund to customers who share their data with Facebook and others

7H ago

Hackers are stealing medical records – and selling them on the dark web

How easy is it for criminals to get hold of these patient files? It only took a few seconds

8H ago

Could diet soda raise a woman's stroke risk?

New research looks at the possible connection between diet sodas​ or artificially sweetened fruit juices and heart health

updated 9M ago

Duchess shines light on dangers of osteoporosis

Camilla, 71, opened up about her late mother Rosalind, who died of the bone disease in 1994

3H ago

Hackers are stealing medical records – and selling them on the dark web

How easy is it for criminals to get hold of these patient files? It only took a few seconds

8H ago

CDC warns about potentially contaminated raw milk

A dangerous drug-resistant bacteria is connected the consumption of raw milk​ in 19 states

Feb 13

Eating these kinds of foods may cut your life short

New research suggests certain foods high in salt, sugar and other additives may increase the risk of early death

Feb 13

Tax refunds are lower for second week in a row

Returns are being processed more slowly, and the average refund is about $185 below its level last year

updated 36M ago

Federal revenue fell in first year after U.S. tax overhaul

The government is taking in less money from businesses and individuals even as the economy is expanding

2H ago

Virgin founder Richard Branson says the rich may need "heavy taxes"

If wealthy can't make capitalism work for more people, "we deserve to have very heavy taxes," philanthropist says

4H ago

Amazon cancels New York City headquarters

E-commerce giant had faced fierce opposition for a planned New York location projected to cost $3 billion in incentives

updated 43M ago

Romance scams break hearts and bust bank accounts

"I was just ready to be in love" — music to the ears of a swindler looking to con someone out of her cash

5H ago

"Since Parkland" profiles 1,200 kids killed by guns

More than 200 teen reporters told the stories of young lives lost to bullets

updated 22M ago

Persons of interest ID'd in alleged attack on "Empire" actor

The "Empire" actor gives a detailed account to "Good Morning America," says attack left him "forever changed"

3H ago

Apple lawyer who oversaw insider trading policy charged with insider trading

Former attorney at the tech giant allegedly drew on non-public earnings information to cash in

Feb 13

Gunman kills wife at dentist's office, gets shot by bystander

Armed bystander shoots gunman, detains him, waits for police to arrive, police say

Feb 13

White supremacist gang in Arkansas accused of brutal tactics

Group called "reprehensible in its admiration for Nazi imagery and racist views, but even more alarming are the crimes and violence perpetrated by these defendants"

Feb 13