Former DHS chief: There’s no security crisis near the southern border

By Olivia Gazis

/ CBS News

To the extent there is an emergency on the U.S. southern border, it is the result of a humanitarian crisis, not a security crisis, according to former Department of Homeland Security (DHS) Secretary Jeh Johnson.

He spoke in reference to recent statements made by President Trump and members of his administration, many of which blamed a supposed influx of illegal immigration for creating a "humanitarian and security crisis" near the U.S.-Mexico border. Mr. Trump has demanded "urgent action" from Congress, mainly in the form of billions in additional funding to support, among other things, the construction of miles of physical barriers along the frontier.

"There is so much emotion, politics and misinformation about immigration and about our southern border," said Johnson, who ran the U.S. government's third-largest department from 2013 to 2017 during the Obama administration. "So here are the facts: the facts are that illegal migration on our southern border is a fraction of what it used to be."

Johnson said that apprehensions of migrants attempting to cross the border into the United States had fallen to an annual level of between 300,000-400,000 – down significantly from a high of 1.6 million in fiscal year 2000.

Meanwhile, Johnson said, "There's a humanitarian crisis in Central America that leads to the circumstances on our southern border today. And during a spike, you see local communities in, say, McAllen or Laredo or El Paso or in Southern California that are flooded with migrants."

Increasing levels of violence and poverty in Central American countries like Guatemala, Honduras and El Salvador, Johnson said, have propelled entire families to seek safety in the United States. "That itself presents unique challenges," he said, "because our system is really not equipped to deal with a lot of women and children and families. And this administration is seeing that now."

"But a security crisis per se? No. I would not characterize it that way," Johnson said. "I think there is some fear-mongering going on."

In an interview with Intelligence Matters host and CBS News senior national security contributor Michael Morell, Johnson, who also served as general counsel at the Pentagon, said the topic of immigration had been, in his experience, "the most difficult, intractable, emotional, politicized" issue with which he has dealt. He added that its highly-charged complexities make it unlikely for politicians of either party to risk seeking the middle ground.

Last month, the government was partially shut down for a record 35 days amid a failure by lawmakers and the White House to reach a mutually acceptable political solution. Though he had previously threatened a second shutdown, Mr. Trump indicated on Tuesday afternoon that he was close to accepting a bipartisan compromise brokered by congressional leaders late Monday.

Johnson thinks the first one had already taken a toll, saying it had done "a level of damage to our federal government and our security efforts that will last months, if not years, in terms of morale, recruitment, retention, re-enlistment."

And the administration has a litany of other national security priorities to address, he said, including deterring increasingly sophisticated cyber attacks, mitigating terrorist-inspired attacks on U.S. soil, and protecting the integrity of upcoming elections. Boosting security at the southern border is also within the administration's reach, he said, with a few, potentially less contentious, policy choices.

"We have to make a long-term investment in addressing the poverty and violence in Central America," Johnson said. "It has been done before – like the so-called Plan Colombia," he said, referring to a multifaceted aid initiative conceived during the Clinton administration to combat Colombian drug cartels.

"That is not a political quick fix," Johnson said. "And here in Washington, so often people want political quick fixes."

For much more from Michael Morell's conversation with Jeh Johnson, you can listen to the new episode and subscribe to Intelligence Matters here.

First published on February 13, 2019

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Mom of 3 arrested during ICE check-in, set for deportation

Ilsa Guzman, who's married and has been in the U.S. since entering illegally in 1999 and being denied asylum, was whisked away without warning

updated 10M ago

Former DHS chief: No security crisis near southern border

On "Intelligence Matters" this week, former DHS Secretary Jeh Johnson tells host Michael Morell there's too much fear-mongering in today's political discourse

updated 11M ago

Transcript: Michael Rogers on "Intelligence Matters"

The former DHS chief says there’s no security crisis near the southern border

updated 11M ago

2 kids found in dog cages, 2 more covered in waste in barn

All appeared malnourished; the local sheriff near Rhome, Texas, outside Dallas, called it the worst case of child abuse he's ever seen

updated 51M ago

King the wire fox terrier wins Westminster Dog Show

King beat out 2,800 competitors who represented 203 breeds and varieties in the two-day event

6H ago

Former DHS chief: No security crisis near southern border

On "Intelligence Matters" this week, former DHS Secretary Jeh Johnson tells host Michael Morell there's too much fear-mongering in today's political discourse

updated 11M ago

Transcript: Michael Rogers on "Intelligence Matters"

The former DHS chief says there’s no security crisis near the southern border

updated 11M ago

Fairfax accuser Vanessa Tyson speaks at #MeToo-related event

Tyson, an associate professor at Scripps College, was expected to attend before her accusations against Virginia Lt. Gov. became public

8H ago

Intelligence Matters: A CBS News original national security podcast

"Intelligence Matters" is a weekly podcast about national security and policy hosted by CBS News senior national security contributor Michael Morell

9H ago

Transcript: Vicki Huddleston on "Intelligence Matters"

Venezuela showdown could lead to U.S. confrontation with Cuba, says former top U.S. diplomat

9H ago

Venezuelan opposition sets date for showdown with Maduro's forces

"Allow in the humanitarian aid. That's an order," U.S.-backed Juan Guaidó tells military, announcing date for aid caravans to challenge blocked border

updated 13M ago

Instagram kills account depicting abuse of gay Muslims in Indonesia

The account was removed for being "pornographic" following widespread "moral" outrage

1H ago

Transcript: Vicki Huddleston on "Intelligence Matters"

Venezuela showdown could lead to U.S. confrontation with Cuba, says former top U.S. diplomat

9H ago

George Clooney defends Meghan Markle after treatment by press

"I believe she cried more to do with the press intrusion than anything else in her life," Prince William has said about their mother, Diana, Princess of Wales

9H ago

21 Savage granted release on bond from ICE custody, lawyers say

The Atlanta-based rapper was arrested by ICE on Feb. 3

11H ago

George Clooney defends Meghan Markle after treatment by press

"I believe she cried more to do with the press intrusion than anything else in her life," Prince William has said about their mother, Diana, Princess of Wales

9H ago

21 Savage granted release on bond from ICE custody, lawyers say

The Atlanta-based rapper was arrested by ICE on Feb. 3

11H ago

Police use pepper balls to disperse Travis Scott fans

"Astroworld" was not the fantasyland fans hoped it would be

18H ago

The 2019 Grammy Awards: Winners and highlights

Female performers dominated the 61st Annual Grammy Awards

Feb 11

Alicia Keys shares story about John Mayer splitting his Grammy award with her 15 years ago

Mayer surprised Keys with the same award he split with her in 2004 — after he felt she deserved the trophy, too

Feb 11

Tesla self-driving car gets confused and crashes on highway

"The driver was shaken. He was panicked by the accident," police said

8H ago

Senator calls for Google, Apple to drop Saudi app that monitors women

Oregon's Ron Wyden says U.S. tech companies shouldn't facilitate "abhorrent surveillance and control of women"

14H ago

Russian region declares emergency over polar bear "invasion"

It is illegal to hunt the species, already endangered thanks to climate change shrinking their habitat, but a cull has not been ruled out

Feb 11

Crew hunts for fabled U.S. carrier in a graveyard for WWII ships

The explorers who located the wreck of the USS Indianapolis are searching for an aircraft carrier sunk by the Japanese 77 years ago

Feb 11

Hurricanes are intensifying more rapidly and it may be our fault

Storms that quickly strengthen are often the most challenging to predict, and they can cause more damage

Feb 10

How to confront rising anxiety among young girls

Psychologist Lisa Damour offers practical advise on how adults can help address the "unique pressures" girls face

updated 7M ago

Teen defies mom, gets vaccinated after turning to strangers online

"I question her judgment, but not her care," says Ethan Lindenberger of his mother

22H ago

FDA announces crackdown on illegal dietary supplements

In one case, the FDA found a company claimed its product reduced "symptoms of cognitive decline"

Feb 11

Medicare patients face surging costs for some life-saving drugs

Participants in the federal health program often struggle to afford treatments for cancer and other diseases

Feb 11

CBD fans want edibles, but some states are cracking down

States are cracking down on cannabidiol-infused food over safety concerns — some in the industry say it's warranted

Feb 11

Katy Perry accused of evoking blackface imagery in shoe designs

Reactions to the shoes, released last summer, are a measure of the charge around imagery perceived as racist today

9H ago

Toys R Us plots a 2nd act with new look, new name

Richard Barry started his career at the toy seller pushing shopping carts — now he's planning its comeback

11H ago

Paul Volcker calls out Trump on trade and taxes

The former Federal Reserve chair laments the president's approach as divisive, "all threats and demands"

11H ago

REI CEO leaves over an undisclosed relationship

Jerry Stritzke is resigning after violating the outdoor retailer's policy regarding conflicts of interest

7H ago

National debt tops $22 trillion for first time in U.S. history

The debt has ballooned by more than $2 trillion in the two years since President Trump took office

12H ago

2 kids found in dog cages, 2 more covered in waste in barn

All appeared malnourished; the local sheriff near Rhome, Texas, outside Dallas, called it the worst case of child abuse he's ever seen

updated 51M ago

NYPD officer killed by apparent friendly fire

Police recovered an imitation firearm at the scene

6H ago

4 former firefighters charged for "racist, lewd" prank

Lt. Robert Webster discovered a hangman's noose during his shift; there were also sexual images drawn on his family photos

3H ago

The craziest details from the "El Chapo" trial

Shooting bazookas, burying a rival alive, a naked escape — just to name a few of the twisted revelations

11H ago

Porch pirate steals boy's cancer meds

The teen has been battling the disease since he was six months old, and in a matter of minutes, his cancer fight got harder

12H ago  Original Article