Super Bowl commercials: Who won and lost the biggest day in TV marketing

By Aimee Picchi

/ MoneyWatch

Super Bowl ads rated by USA Today's Ad Meter

The Super Bowl is the biggest single day in advertising, with companies this year reportedly spending more than $5 million to run a spot. And with the low-scoring game turning into a bit of a snore-fest, the focus on the ads was perhaps more intense than ever.

This year's Super Bowl commercials were a "solid bunch of ads," but lacked the pizzazz of some of the all-time greats, like Apple's "1984" ad or Volkswagen's ad featuring a little boy dressed as Darth Vader, said Derek D. Rucker, professor of entrepreneurial studies in marketing at the Kellogg School of Management at Northwestern University. The Kellogg School reviews Super Bowl ads each year for marketing effectiveness, grading the ads on a scale from "A" to "F."

Top Super Bowl ads need to be more than funny or eye-catching to be considered successful from a marketing standpoint, Rucker said. The best spots combine a top-notch creative component — like a flashy setting or a celebrity — as well as a strategic element that conveys the brand's message in a compelling way to viewers.

"You really want to know what a brand is hoping to accomplish," he said. "For some brands, it's to make sure my brand stays top of mind or that you are aware of a new product — and then the goal is, 'Will I see an increase in sales?'"

Six ads earned an "A" this year, according to Kellogg's yardstick. Only one earned a failing grade — Burger King's ad featuring the late artist Andy Warhol. These rankings don't always match up with USA Today's ranking of Super Bowl ads, which is based on consumer responses rather than marketers' assessment.

Best Super Bowl ads

This commercial earned an "A" from Kellogg because of its distinctiveness and emotional depth. The message was about how Microsoft is developing tools to help everyone win, such as a gaming device that helps people with disabilities play with more ease. That helps consumers "understand the brand's DNA," Rucker said.

Microsoft Super Bowl Commercial 2019: We All Win by Microsoft on YouTube

Another "A" for this compelling ad narrated by Tom Hanks and featuring journalists who have lost their lives, such as The Washington Post's Jamal Khashoggi. "We acquire and desire knowledge. That's something we want," Rucker said.

Washington Post Super Bowl message: Democracy Dies in Darkness by Washington Post on YouTube

The ad — the first-ever television ad for this company — used humor and flash to highlight the benefits of its service: providing an easy way to expense your receipts. "That ad didn't just entertain me — it made it relevant," Rucker said.

2 Chainz x Adam Scott | Expensify FULL Super Bowl Commercial 2019 by Expensify on YouTube

Featuring Serena Williams, this ad used emotion in a powerful way, Rucker said. Its message about empowering women was distinctive and tied back to the brand, he added.

Serena Williams: Bumble Commercial by Bumble on YouTube

This spot showed people using Google to translate words and phrases and connect with people from other cultures. Said Rucker, "They have figured out how to interface their brand with their life and emotions. The ad used emotions in a powerful and positive way."

100 Billion Words | Google Super Bowl Commercial 2019 by Google on YouTube

Amazon's second year in the Super Bowl again scored points. "They showed all these various amusing situations, with the idea of things they don't do well," Rucker said. "Then they showed everything they do do well, and it revealed why they are so good as a brand."

Not Everything Makes the Cut – Amazon Super Bowl LIII Commercial by amazon on YouTube

Worst Super Bowl ad

The ad had a number of problems and was the only spot to earn an "F," Rucker said. First, it wasn't clear that it was an ad for Burger King, with some viewers thinking it was advertising Heinz ketchup, since artist Andy Warhol is shown struggling to get the ketchup out of a bottle.

"There's an expectation you will do something interesting and engaging, and it fails on those core fundamentals," Rucker says. "It's uninteresting, and there isn't strong brand positioning behind it."

It's also unclear how many viewers will recognize Andy Warhol, who died in 1987, which limits the appeal of the commercial.

#EatLikeAndy | 02.03.2019 by BURGER KING on YouTube

First published on February 4, 2019

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc.. All Rights Reserved.

Who won and lost this year's Super Bowl commercials

A few advertisers scored points, expert says, while one company got sacked for a loss

updated 1M ago

Tech investor says Facebook is "terrible for America"

"Zucked" author Roger McNamee says Facebook is a threat to democracy, public health and privacy, and makes everyone vulnerable to bad actors

updated 13M ago

Kristoff St. John, "Young and the Restless" star, dies at 52

Kristoff St. John played Neil Winters on CBS' "The Young and the Restless"

updated 9M ago

Pregnant woman stabbed to death in NYC apartment lobby

Candle burned outside the apartment building where 35-year-old real estate agent Jennifer Irigoyen was savagely stabbed to death.

1H ago

What Super Bowl MVP told his mom after the game

Wide receiver was responsible for more than half of the Patriots' receiving yards in their 13-3 win over the Los Angeles Rams

2H ago

Northam meets with top aides amid pressure to resign

Northam met with administration officials of color Sunday as he faces mounting pressure to step down as governor

1H ago

Cory Booker urges "revival of civic grace," responds to Trump jab

Booker said that he's had a "very unique political path" which has forced him to run toward some of the "toughest problems" facing the country

2H ago

Trump says "only way" Democrats can win is to "bring out" impeachment

"The only thing I've done is created, maybe, the best economy we've had in the history of our country," Trump told CBS News

3H ago

Much of Trump's time is unstructured "executive time": Report

Schedules leaked to Axios show the president spending some 60 percent of his working hours in so-called "executive time" over the last three months

2H ago

Bill would eventually make Hawaii first state to ban cigarette sales

Measure would gradually raise minimum age of people allowed to buy them to 100

5H ago

Al-Shabab claims new carnage despite relentless U.S. air war

Bomb blast in Mogadishu comes weeks after brazen attack in Kenya, where U.S. warns of more attacks despite regular U.S. strikes targeting terrorists

1H ago

Body visible in undersea wreckage of soccer star's plane

Private search crew found small aircraft that was carrying Argentine striker Emiliano Sala and his pilot 2 weeks after it vanished

3H ago

Defiant Maduro warns Trump he'll stain his "hands with blood"

Pressure increases on embattled Venezuelan president as Europeans back opposition, global foes discuss sending aid in around him

3H ago

Using high-tech tools to recreate and preserve ancient treasures

In its Madrid workshop, Factum Arte uses scans of archaeological masterpieces to create exacting facsimiles that have both the look and feel of the originals

Feb 3

Venezuelan opposition holds rally amid first major army defection

A new polls showed 82 percent of Venezuelans want President Nicolas Maduro to quit

Feb 2

Who won and lost this year's Super Bowl commercials

A few advertisers scored points, expert says, while one company got sacked for a loss

updated 1M ago

Kristoff St. John, "Young and the Restless" star, dies at 52

Kristoff St. John played Neil Winters on CBS' "The Young and the Restless"

updated 9M ago

"Empire" actor says he fought back in alleged hate-crime attack

"Empire" star who was victim of hate crime makes first public appearance since attack in Chicago

1H ago

CBS All Access' "Twilight Zone" reboot gets premiere date

"Twilight Zone" fans can soon enter the fifth dimension all over again

15H ago

Super Bowl commercials 2019: Watch the ads

Check out our rundown of some of the most creative, entertaining and memorable commercials from the big game, as well as those that failed miserably

3H ago

Tech investor says Facebook is "terrible for America"

"Zucked" author Roger McNamee says Facebook is a threat to democracy, public health and privacy, and makes everyone vulnerable to bad actors

updated 13M ago

Meteorite appears to hit Cuba

In a tweet, the National Weather Service said its radar "may have detected the meteor" at 1:21 p.m. near Viñales, Cuba

Feb 1

"Lies spread faster than truth" on social media, journalist says

The CEO of Rappler alleged the online news website has been targeted by social media disinformation campaigns after its tough reporting on the government

Feb 1

Possum was living in unused, $1M taxpayer-funded bus

The zero-emission bus was never put into service

Feb 1

Steaming lakes and thundersnow: Weird winter weather explained

Extreme cold weather can produce some unusual phenomena, from sea smoke to slushy ocean waves

Feb 1

Bill would eventually make Hawaii first state to ban cigarette sales

Measure would gradually raise minimum age of people allowed to buy them to 100

5H ago

An end to food allergies?

26 million people, including 6 million kids, are allergic to one food or another, with peanuts producing one of the most severe reactions; might a reversal of medical advice slow or even eliminate the problem?

Feb 3

How a game-changing helmet design could prevent concussions

It's unbelievable to a Berkeley doctor that there's not a better way to protect players from the kind of head injuries he sees routinely

Feb 2

Critically ill football fans get their wish to attend Super Bowl LIII

Lucky Kelley, Brian Barrios and Gunter Garvin all love football and had the same wish to see the Super Bowl in person

Feb 1

Lawmaker: Measles vaccine is not about "parental rights"

As measles outbreak grows, a state lawmaker says requiring vaccines is "about the rights of other children and the rights of us to go around our community without getting sick"

Feb 1

Who won and lost this year's Super Bowl commercials

A few advertisers scored points, expert says, while one company got sacked for a loss

updated 1M ago

Tech investor says Facebook is "terrible for America"

"Zucked" author Roger McNamee says Facebook is a threat to democracy, public health and privacy, and makes everyone vulnerable to bad actors

updated 13M ago

Papa John's gets $200 million investment from Starboard

The activist investor, known for turning around Darden, said its CEO will become Papa John's board chairman

2H ago

A tricky IRA trap that retirees need to avoid

The rules for annual required minimum distributions can hit you with investment losses if you aren't careful

3H ago

These industries have the biggest labor shortages

Ten years into the economic expansion, blue-collar and lower-paid service workers finally seeing long-awaited gains

4H ago

Pregnant woman stabbed to death in NYC apartment lobby

Candle burned outside the apartment building where 35-year-old real estate agent Jennifer Irigoyen was savagely stabbed to death.

1H ago

Ex-MMA fighter facing murder charges is captured

Authorities spent hours searching for Cedric Joseph Marks after he fled a prisoner transport van at a McDonald's in Texas

9H ago

White officer demoted for Snapchat video taunting black woman

The officer had just impounded the woman's car and posted video of himself making derogatory comments as she walked away

Feb 1

Person investigating woman's death found dead inside home

Michelle O'Connell's 2010 death was ruled a suicide, but her family believed she was killed by her boyfriend

Feb 1

"Empire" actor after alleged hate-crime assault: "Justice will be served"

Smollett told police two white men shouting racial epithets and gay slurs attacked him in Chicago this week

Feb 1