Judge blocks possible redo of Rams-Saints playoff game in wake of blown call

/ CBS/AP

Roger Goodell admits missed call in Saints game

A quest by two New Orleans Saints ticketholders to force a full or partial do-over of this year's NFC championship game because of a blown "no-call" by game officials was rejected Thursday by a federal judge.

Officials failed to call interference or roughness penalties when a Rams player leveled a Saints receiver with a helmet-to-helmet hit at a crucial point in the final minutes of regulation time. The Rams won the January 20 game in overtime and are set to play the New England Patriots in Sunday's Super Bowl in Atlanta.

Fan reaction in New Orleans has included disbelief, anger and resignation, expressed in newspaper headlines, billboards ("They reffed up" said one), promises by some restaurants and bars they won't show the Super Bowl broadcast Sunday, and posters of blind referees.

Head coach Sean Payton of the New Orleans Saints reacts against the Los Angeles Rams during the fourth quarter in the NFC Championship game. Getty

There are also at least two lawsuits. One is a class-action lawsuit on behalf of ticketholders, still pending in state court as of Thursday.

The other was filed by season ticketholders Tommy Badeaux and Candis Lambert. Filed two days after the game, it says the NFL should be forced to implement a rule allowing Commissioner Roger Goodell to investigate "extraordinarily unfair acts" that affect the game. Remedies under that rule include rescheduling the game in full, or from the point at which the unfair act occurred.

U.S. District Judge Susie Morgan rejected arguments that Badeaux and Lambert were entitled to an order, known as a "writ of mandamus," forcing the NFL or Goodell to take action.

"None of the actions Plaintiffs might seek to compel Commissioner Goodell to do are the kinds of actions a writ of mandamus may address," Morgan said in a 17-page ruling in which she detailed the extraordinary circumstances in which Louisiana law allows a writ of mandamus to be issued.

In the same ruling, she also rejected arguments that the case should be in state court in New Orleans, where it was originally filed.

On Wednesday, Goodell held a pre-Super Bowl press conference where he broke his silence on the missed call in the Rams-Saints game.

"Whenever officiating is part of any kind of discussion postgame, it's never a good outcome for us. We know that, our clubs know that, our officials know that," he said. "But we also know our officials are humans. We also know that they are officiating a game that moves very quickly and have to make snap decisions under difficult circumstances and they are not going to get it right every time."

The Reuters news agency reported that NFL coaches are allowed to question a referee's decision, but aren't allowed on either penalties or uncalled penalties. Goodell said the NFL has worked hard to bring technology in to assist with officiating, but stressed it wasn't going to solve all the problems.

"We will look again at instant replay. There have been a variety of proposals over the last frankly 15 to 20 years of: should replay be expanded. It does not cover judgment calls … this was a judgment call," Goodell said.

Super Bowl 2019: Inside look at Atlanta's Mercedes-Benz Stadium

First published on January 31, 2019

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.

NFC Championship - Los Angeles Rams v New Orleans Saints

Federal judge blocks possible redo of Rams-Saints playoff game

A quest by two New Orleans Saints ticketholders to force a full or partial do-over of this year's NFC championship game has been rejected

updated 9M ago

Senate rebukes Trump's planned military drawdowns

In a rare move, a majority of the Republican-led Senate rebuked the president's planned drawdowns in Afghanistan and Syria

updated 27M ago

Trump optimistic on possible China trade deal

The administration has given a March 1 deadline for talks with China

updated 21M ago

Stocks post best January since 1987, as S&P 500 climbs 7.9%

Trading in the year's first month marks a sharp reversal from December, which was the worst month since 1931

updated 22M ago

U.S. border agency says it's made biggest-ever fentanyl bust

Border officials say they seized nearly 254 pounds of the deadly synthetic opioid with a street value of $3.5 million

updated 57M ago

Senate rebukes Trump's planned military drawdowns

In a rare move, a majority of the Republican-led Senate rebuked the president's planned drawdowns in Afghanistan and Syria

updated 27M ago

Trump optimistic on possible China trade deal

The administration has given a March 1 deadline for talks with China

updated 21M ago

Ralph Northam addresses controversial abortion comments

Northam has been under fire for his description of late-term abortions

1H ago

Elizabeth Warren blasts billionaire's bid for bankrupt Sears

Massachusetts senator calls out Eddie Lampert's commitment to workers, given his "history of slashing jobs"

updated 2M ago

Pence tells DEA border wall necessary to prevent trafficking

Mike Pence tells DEA employees "you fight for us every day" in speech at agency's headquarters

2H ago

29 children and babies die from cold as families seek shelter: Report

"Children are dying from hypothermia as their families flee to safety," said Elizabeth Hoff, WHO representative in Syria.

3H ago

"Disturbing" discovery: Giant hole found under Antarctica glacier

It is growing at an "explosive" rate that surprised researchers, NASA says

2H ago

Trump’s stance on Venezuela garners rare bipartisan support in Congress

"There are always going to be issues on which we agree," Democratic Rep. Donna Shalala told CBS News

4H ago

Europeans poised to roll out "vehicle" to dodge Iran sanctions

EU says it's "moving in the same direction" as U.S. on Iran's regional influence and military development, but it wants to keep the nuclear deal alive

6H ago

Venezuela power struggle hinges on Maduro's military

So far embattled president's commanders are standing by him, but pressure is mounting fast

2H ago

Mindfulness helped Kathy Bates lose 60 pounds

The 70-year-old actress said she learned about mindfulness from her niece – and has never felt better

3H ago

"Mobituaries": Who was the first African American major leaguer? Not Jackie Robinson

They made history. So, why don't we know their names?

5H ago

CBS All Access' "Twilight Zone" reboot gets premiere date

"Twilight Zone" fans can soon enter the fifth dimension all over again

21H ago

Persons of interest sought in alleged Jussie Smollett attack

Smollett told police he was attacked by two white men early Tuesday who allegedly yelled "this is MAGA country"

18H ago

The Beatles' historic final concert held on rooftop 50 years ago

By the time they performed, it had been more than two years since their last live show

21H ago

Climate change skeptics live where it hurts economy most: study

Americans who least believe in climate change live where its effects are forecast to hurt most, Brookings Institution says

2H ago

These states could move to 100% renewable power

They represent 42% of the U.S. population and a quarter of its economic output — and shift can happen within 25 years

1H ago

Dad: Hacker spoke to baby, taunted me, turned up thermostat

Hacker accessed Illinois family's Nest security cameras, father says

3H ago

"Disturbing" discovery: Giant hole found under Antarctica glacier

It is growing at an "explosive" rate that surprised researchers, NASA says

2H ago

Saturn spent billions of years without its rings, NASA says

Saturn's rings may have formed during the age of dinosaurs – but compared to the planet, that's not that old

6H ago

Mindfulness helped Kathy Bates lose 60 pounds

The 70-year-old actress said she learned about mindfulness from her niece – and has never felt better

3H ago

Woman with dementia dumped outside nursing home, family says

Security footage shows the elderly woman attempting to get inside in the middle of the night after being discharged from the hospital

2H ago

Drugmaker doubles recall of infant ibuprofen

Some batches found with overly high concentrations of the drug, with infants especially vulnerable to adverse effects

8H ago

Woman uses DNA test, finds sperm donor — and pays a "devastating" price

A sperm bank is threatening to sue an Oregon woman who contacted her daughter's biological father after using an at-home DNA test

updated 7M ago

Company accused of fueling opioid crisis wanted to capitalize on treatment: report

ProPublica specifically names Kathe Sackler as being involved with a secretive project called "Project Tango"

9H ago

Stocks post best January since 1987, as S&P 500 climbs 7.9%

Trading in the year's first month marks a sharp reversal from December, which was the worst month since 1931

updated 22M ago

Elizabeth Warren blasts billionaire's bid for bankrupt Sears

Massachusetts senator calls out Eddie Lampert's commitment to workers, given his "history of slashing jobs"

updated 2M ago

Climate change skeptics live where it hurts economy most: study

Americans who least believe in climate change live where its effects are forecast to hurt most, Brookings Institution says

2H ago

These states could move to 100% renewable power

They represent 42% of the U.S. population and a quarter of its economic output — and shift can happen within 25 years

1H ago

Dad: Hacker spoke to baby, taunted me, turned up thermostat

Hacker accessed Illinois family's Nest security cameras, father says

3H ago

Police show more video in shooting of boy with airsoft gun

14-year-old Antonio Arce was fatally shot as he ran away from a Tempe police officer responding to a vehicle burglary

2H ago

Nurse indicted on charges of raping incapacitated woman

Nathan Sutherland is expected to enter a plea to the charges at an arraignment hearing next week

1H ago

Phony pharmacist gave out 745,000 prescriptions, authorities say

She posed as a pharmacist and pharmacy manager for years in three California Walgreens stores, a state investigation finds

7H ago

Cleveland family says school should've flagged slain girl's absence sooner

Alianna DeFreeze, 14, was abducted on her way to school; her family is suing because they weren't notified about her absence quick enough

19H ago

"I hope y'all find peace," Texas inmate says before execution

Robert Jennings received lethal injection for killing Officer Elston Howard during a robbery part of a crime spree in July 1988

7H ago  Original Article