Brown University criticized for using live pigs in medical training

/ AP

Providence, R.I. — A prominent physicians' group has asked federal regulators to investigate Brown University's medical school, arguing it is violating the law by using live pigs for training in emergency medicine.

The Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine on Tuesday asked the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service to investigate animal use at the Warren Alpert Medical School at the Ivy League university.

A medical school spokeswoman said she didn't know about the complaint and didn't immediately respond to questions about the use of pigs. The school's website says its residency education includes hands-on animal labs.

The committee advocates for eliminating the use of live animals in any medical training and promotes the use of human-body simulators instead. Proponents of animal research argue it is crucial to scientific breakthroughs and for furthering medical science.

More than 90 percent of emergency medicine residency programs in the United States and Canada use only human-based training methods, such as medical simulation or cadavers, according to the committee. The nonprofit represents more than 12,000 doctors.

Brown, in Providence, violated the federal Animal Welfare Act because alternatives to animal use exist, so using pigs for emergency medicine training is not justified or unavoidable, said Dr. John Pippin, director of academic affairs for the Physicians Committee.

He also contends the school's animal care and use committee does not properly oversee the use of pigs for the training, which would also violate the act.

"The purpose of all of these training programs, including at Brown, is to produce the best possible physicians in the field of emergency medicine. Everyone agrees on that," said Pippin, a cardiologist in Dallas. "What I'm claiming, and I think I can prove, is the best way to do this does not include the use of animals."

Simulators allow repetition, so if residents err when putting a chest tube in, for instance, they can do it again, Pippin said.

The models also do a better job at representing human anatomy, he said. A pig's skin is thicker and the trachea far deeper than on a person, so a resident could not cut a hole for a blocked airway on a person in the same way they would on a pig, for example, Pippin said.

There are 16 programs the committee knows of that still use live animals, and most use pigs. Pippin said he has reached out to all 16.

When Pippin first contacted Brown's medical school in the fall, he said, he was told by the residency director she wouldn't have time to consider the matter for six months. He contacted her boss and the dean of medicine, he said, but got nowhere and drafted the letter.

Pippin said the committee is not looking for the university to be penalized in any way, rather they're hoping to motivate Brown to pay attention to the information the committee provided.

First published on January 30, 2019

© 2019 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Med school under fire for using live pigs in training

A physicians' group claims Brown University's medical school violates the law by using live pigs for training in emergency medicine

updated 1M ago

Deep freeze threatens millions, cancels flights in Midwest

Cities across the Midwest scrambling to protect people from historic cold

updated 16M ago

Sarah Sanders: "God wanted Trump to become president"

The White House press secretary told the Christian Broadcast Network in an interview that she believes God wanted Trump to win

updated 25M ago

Christine Blasey Ford nominated for Profile In Courage Award

"She is an inspiration to us all," tweeted Congresswoman Jackie Speier

updated 34M ago

Tesla reports much smaller profit this quarter than last

CEO Musk warned of a “very difficult” road ahead, and sure enough, electric-car maker's earnings reflect the sentiment

updated 47M ago

Sarah Sanders: "God wanted Trump to become president"

The White House press secretary told the Christian Broadcast Network in an interview that she believes God wanted Trump to win

updated 25M ago

Christine Blasey Ford nominated for Profile In Courage Award

"She is an inspiration to us all," tweeted Congresswoman Jackie Speier

updated 34M ago

Elliott Abrams says Iran-Contra history isn’t an issue

Abrams pleaded guilty in connection with the Iran-Contra scandal in 1991, but was pardoned by President George H.W. Bush

1H ago

The Takeout: A CBS News original political podcast

“The Takeout” is a weekly podcast about politics, policy and pop culture hosted by CBS News Chief White House correspondent Major Garrett

1H ago

Intelligence Matters: A CBS News original national security podcast

"Intelligence Matters" is a weekly podcast about national security and policy hosted by CBS News senior national security contributor Michael Morell

1H ago

Ariana Grande's Japanese tattoo is a fail

Hope she likes BBQ

3H ago

Trump suggests "intelligence people" should "go back to school"

The president's bristled at conclusions from his own intelligence agency leaders that don't match up with his own

3H ago

Dutch church's 97-day marathon Mass wins refugee family a home

Hundreds of clergy volunteered to keep the service going for months, using an obscure law to shield an Armenian family from deportation

4H ago

U.K.'s May needs to renegotiate Brexit, but the EU won't budge

Prime Minister Theresa May has just 58 days to strike a deal and avoid what one rival lawmaker warns could be a fall "into an abyss"

5H ago

Taliban talks reconciliation, ex-U.S envoy says don't trust them

U.S. envoy has said "draft" framework agreed with Taliban but former U.S. officials warn the group will say anything to bring about American withdrawal

8H ago

Ariana Grande's Japanese tattoo is a fail

Hope she likes BBQ

3H ago

"Empire" actor had noose around his neck, police say

He said he was beaten on a Chicago street by two masked men who shouted racist epithets, gay slurs and put a noose around his neck

9H ago

Grammy-winning R&B singer James Ingram dies at 66

James Ingram has been nominated for 14 Grammy Awards, winning for "100 Ways" in 1981 and for "Yah Mo B There" in 1984

21H ago

"Empire" actor assaulted in possible hate crime, police say

The actor told Chicago Police a group of men yelled racial and homophobic slurs and wrapped a rope around his neck

17H ago

Gwyneth Paltrow sued over alleged "hit and run ski crash"

A Utah man says the actress was "skiing out of control" when she knocked him down, leaving with with severe injuries

23H ago

Facebook paying teens for info on their phone activity

Facebook disputes report that practice has been "secret "and constitutes "spying" on participants

10H ago

Chicago is expected to be colder than Mount Everest base camp

It's also set to be colder than the South Pole

22H ago

NOAA responds to Trump's climate change skepticism with a cartoon

The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration tweeted increasing winter storms are a side effect of global warming

8H ago

Earnings week for Apple, Facebook, Microsoft, Amazon

High-tech giants in Wall Street spotlight as investors look for signs that explosive growth is holding up

Jan 29

What is the polar vortex and is global warming to blame?

Some scientists think the natural phenomenon bringing brutally cold weather to much of the nation has an unlikely helper

7H ago

Med school under fire for using live pigs in training

A physicians' group claims Brown University's medical school violates the law by using live pigs for training in emergency medicine

updated 1M ago

FDA "asleep at the switch" on vaping, report says

The FDA is failing to protect America's youth from the dangers of tobacco and e-cigarettes, a new report from the American Lung Association says

1H ago

Anti-vax movement fuels measles outbreaks, expert says

Dozens of children who weren't vaccinated have gotten sick, and the outbreak is spreading

3H ago

Drugmaker doubles recall of infant ibuprofen

Some batches found with overly high concentrations of the drug, with infants especially vulnerable to adverse effects

6H ago

Court to hear arguments over Ohio law banning abortions due to Down syndrome

The law's defenders argue it is a limited restriction intended as an anti-discrimination measure

9H ago

Tesla reports much smaller profit this quarter than last

CEO Musk warned of a “very difficult” road ahead, and sure enough, electric-car maker's earnings reflect the sentiment

updated 47M ago

Trump Organization says it will use E-Verify to check workers' status

A dozen immigrant workers at the Trump National Golf club were fired earlier this month, they claimed, after workers at another Trump club alleged that the club hired them knowing they were in the U.S. illegally

2H ago

Crafts retailer Michaels is closing Pat Catan's stores

Nation's biggest arts and crafts retailer shuttering 36 stores in Ohio, Pennsylvania, Michigan and West Virginia

2H ago

U.S. and China talk trade, but few expect any breakthroughs

The two countries have roughly a month to head off what would be a dramatic escalation in their trade war

2H ago

Jay Powell: "The case for raising rates has weakened"

The Federal Reserve chair pointed to low inflation and slower global growth as the Fed kept interest rates steady

1H ago

Video shows man punching 2 women in Los Angeles

The incident took place Saturday at a hot dog stand

updated 15M ago

"Empire" actor assaulted in possible hate crime, police say

The actor told Chicago Police a group of men yelled racial and homophobic slurs and wrapped a rope around his neck

17H ago

Cop rushed into gunbattle because "my guys were down"

Veteran Houston police officer among 4 shot in attempt to serve search warrant at drug house

22H ago

Cop charged in Russian roulette death appears injured in mugshot

Nathaniel Hendren is in custody three days after he was charged with involuntary manslaughter in the shooting death of Katlyn Alix

Jan 29

Passenger stabs, kills pregnant Lyft driver in Tempe, Ariz.

Police arrested suspect some 133 miles away after they say he stole her SUV, which they think was the motive for the attack

Jan 29