NASA works to revive Mars rover Opportunity, but hopes are fading

By William Harwood

/ CBS News

NASA's Opportunity rover landed on Mars 15 years ago this week, but the long-lived robot remains out of action in the wake of a global dust storm last summer that caused it to lose power. Engineers are still trying to contact the spacecraft, sending commands and listening for any sort of response, but hopes are fading, a senior manager said Friday.

"We're getting close to the end," said John Callas, the Mars Exploration Rover project manager at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory in Pasadena, Calif. "At some point, in an emotional sense, you have to say 'enough' and move on, to say goodbye."

For many of the engineers and scientists that built and nurtured Opportunity over the years, the six-wheeled robot is almost a member of the family, and no one wants to say that final goodbye until every possible rescue option has been exercised. But seven months after contact was lost, that moment is approaching barring a sudden reversal of fortune.

"It's just like a loved one missing in action, a pet that goes missing," Callas said. "You spend several days searching the neighborhood, posting pictures on telephone poles, but then after six months, you say OK, we did all we could."

But not quite yet.

It's the windy season on Mars, and there remains a chance gusty breezes might blow off enough accumulated dust from Opportunity's solar cells to allow its batteries to charge up enough for the spacecraft to phone home.

An artist's impression of a Mars Exploration Rover on the surface of the red planet. Opportunity, one of two MER robots that landed on Mars in 2004, remains out of contact with Earth in the wake of a global dust storm last year. NASA

At the same time, flight controllers at JPL continue to send commands "in the blind" in an attempt to coax Opportunity back into action if it ever does wake up while NASA's Deep Space Network antennas regularly listen for a response.

"We've been doing this strategy of listening with the DSN antennas as well as commanding to try to elicit a response from the vehicle," Callas said. "The expectation was once the storm passed, that sunlight on the solar arrays would charge the rover back up and it would autonomously talk to us."

But if the batteries were fully depleted, as now appears likely, the spacecraft's internal clock would reset and "the rover won't know what time it is," Callas said. "And so, it'll attempt to wake up at these odd hours of the day or night, so we might not hear from it when it is powered up because it's got the wrong time.

"That's part of the reason we were sending these commands. If the rover was ever awake, and it gets one of these commands, then it knows to respond right away."

But so far, flight controllers have heard nothing.

Opportunity landed on Mars, on a plain known as Meridiani Planum, on Jan. 24, 2004, 15 years ago Thursday. The design specifications called for a minimum 90-martian-day mission and an ability to rove at least 1,100 yards.

But Opportunity and its twin rover, Spirit, far exceeded expectations, chalking up year after year of slow-but-steady exploration, looking for signs of past habitability and confirming a warmer, wetter environment in the distant past.

Mars rover Curiosity: Images from the Red Planet
Mars rover Curiosity: Images from the Red Planet 57 photos

Spirit got stuck in deep sand and ceased operations in 2011, but Opportunity pressed ahead, showing signs of wear and tear over the years but remaining in remarkably good health. Instead of the 1,100-yard design goal, the rover has covered more than 28 miles, marking its 5,000th day on the red planet last February.

But last June, a record dust storm boiled up, becoming a global event that shrouded the red planet in a thick haze, sharply reducing the amount of sunlight reaching Opportunity's solar cells. Flight controllers last contacted the spacecraft on June 10.

"This was a historic dust storm," Callas said. "Never since humans have been observing Mars and measuring the atmospheric opacity have we ever seen a dust storm this intense. … Essentially it was nighttime during the day on Mars."

The storm persisted for weeks before finally dissipating. Relatively clear skies returned, but JPL has not been able to restore contact with Opportunity. In the meantime, the planet's seasons are changing, temperatures are dropping and the amount of sunlight reaching Opportunity is decreasing.

"There are still some techniques we want to try to account for multiple failure scenarios on the vehicle," Callas said. "We're trying to look at all the possible things that could explain why we haven't heard from the rover that are potentially recoverable. Things like if both transmitter amplifiers failed, could we use just the UHF (radio)? Those are the kinds of things we're looking at. We'd like to give those a try."

JPL is operated for NASA by the California Institute of Technology as a Federally Funded Research and Development Center, or FFRDC. As such, it receives payments from NASA in advance and currently remains in operation despite the ongoing partial government shutdown.

Callas said his small team will continue efforts to contact Opportunity until NASA is back in operation and able to provide guidance.

"NASA makes the decision about this," he said. "Until they tell us otherwise, we'll keep going."

First published on January 25, 2019

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.

William Harwood

Bill Harwood has been covering the U.S. space program full-time since 1984, first as Cape Canaveral bureau chief for United Press International and now as a consultant for CBS News. He covered 129 space shuttle missions, every interplanetary flight since Voyager 2's flyby of Neptune and scores of commercial and military launches. Based at the Kennedy Space Center in Florida, Harwood is a devoted amateur astronomer and co-author of "Comm Check: The Final Flight of Shuttle Columbia."

012519-opportunity.jpg Mars rover Curiosity: Images from the Red Planet

Trump says he'll sign bill to reopen government for 3 weeks

He's expected to announce this development on the government shutdown at the White House Friday afternoon, although some details are still being worked out

updated 1M ago

Hope fading for Mars Opportunity rover

NASA engineers have not given up trying to revive the Opportunity Mars rover in the wake of a dust storm last year – but "we're getting close to the end"

updated 2M ago

FBI's Wray sends video to agents amid shutdown struggle

Wray acknowledged it may seem as though the FBI has been silent on the shutdown, which affects many of its agents, but said that it has been working on the problem on every level — outside the view of the press

updated 45M ago

Federal workers speak out about the shutdown: "We're being used as pawns"

"This has been incredibly stressful," said Sarah Pinter, who didn't expect to be furloughed from her first "real" job after graduating from college

1H ago

"The Happiness Project" author on how to combat loneliness

One in 10 Americans say they feel lonely or isolated from those around them all or most of the time, according to a Pew Research Center survey

1H ago

Trump says he'll sign bill to reopen government for 3 weeks

He's expected to announce this development on the government shutdown at the White House Friday afternoon, although some details are still being worked out

updated 1M ago

FBI's Wray sends video to agents amid shutdown struggle

Wray acknowledged it may seem as though the FBI has been silent on the shutdown, which affects many of its agents, but said that it has been working on the problem on every level — outside the view of the press

updated 45M ago

Federal workers speak out about the shutdown: "We're being used as pawns"

"This has been incredibly stressful," said Sarah Pinter, who didn't expect to be furloughed from her first "real" job after graduating from college

1H ago

Roger Stone leaves court to chants of "lock him up"

Roger Stone, arrested and indicted on seven charges, was released on $250,000 bond Friday

updated 30M ago

Air traffic controllers union sounds alarm

"Each hour that goes by that the shutdown continues makes the situation worse"

1H ago

Australians suffer as heatwave knocks out power, fuels fires

Dizzying temps well over 110 degrees are setting records across the country as drought parched lands are scorched by wildfire

3H ago

U.K. lawmakers' Brexit standoff appears to irk Queen Elizabeth

Monarch barred from voicing political opinions, but call for Britain to seek "common ground" seen as rebuke of feuding British lawmakers

4H ago

Iran says U.S. Navy veteran jailed on "private complaint"

Tehran had previously given no info on detention of Michael White, whose family fear for his wellbeing as he was undergoing cancer treatment

6H ago

How could Trump's Venezuela policy impact the U.S.?

Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro severed ties with the U.S. after President Trump endorsed an opposition leader as interim president

7H ago

U.S. orders some diplomats to leave Venezuela

After U.S. President Trump recognized Venezuela's chief opposition leader, Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro severed ties with the U.S.

14H ago

"Princess Diaries 3" in the works

In the words of Mia Thermopolis: "Shut. Up."

2H ago

Special edition of "CBS Sunday Morning" celebrates its 40th birthday

The January 27 broadcast looks at the people, the moments, and the milestones from the series' first four decades

3H ago

Kate Hudson on her "genderless" approach to raising kids

Hudson and Danny Fujikawa's daughter, Rani, is named after Fujikawa's father, Ron

5H ago

Meek Mill, Jay-Z and others launch initiative for criminal justice reform

According to the Reform Alliance, 4.5 million people are currently on parole or probation for unreasonable terms

Jan 24

Dad and son dance to "Frozen" in viral video

When his son wanted to dance to "Frozen" songs, this dad put on an Elsa costume – because it's important to just "let it go" and be yourself

Jan 24

Hope fading for Mars Opportunity rover

NASA engineers have not given up trying to revive the Opportunity Mars rover in the wake of a dust storm last year – but "we're getting close to the end"

updated 2M ago

Instagram, Messenger, WhatsApp functions may merge

Don't worry — your favorite apps aren't going anywhere

updated 37M ago

Alligators freeze with noses above water

The Swamp Park manager said 18 alligators froze Monday night and stayed frozen all day Tuesday

3H ago

New Horizons beams back best image yet of Ultima Thule

NASA's New Horizons probe has sent back more photos from the far side of the solar system, a billion miles past Pluto

21H ago

15 senators demand FCC, FTC investigate carriers selling location data

The demand comes after a report found carriers such as AT&T were selling data to buyers such as bounty hunters

21H ago

"The Happiness Project" author on how to combat loneliness

One in 10 Americans say they feel lonely or isolated from those around them all or most of the time, according to a Pew Research Center survey

1H ago

Whole Foods recalls wraps, other products with spinach due to salmonella risk

Ready-to-eat products sold at the grocery chain's stores in eight states may be contaminated by bacterial infection

2H ago

Sackler family, tied to prestigious institutions, quiet on opioid crisis accusations

Their name is attached to the Guggenheim and the Met, among others, but what you don't often find it publicly tied to is the pharmaceutical company it built

5H ago

Superintendent charged with fraud for helping teen speaks out

Casey Smitherman was arrested after using her own insurance to help a sick student

19H ago

Study links gum disease bacteria to Alzheimer's

Scientists found the key pathogen of gum disease in the brains of people with Alzheimer's, but other experts caution more research is needed to understand the connection

18H ago

Instagram, Messenger, WhatsApp functions may merge

Don't worry — your favorite apps aren't going anywhere

updated 37M ago

Whole Foods recalls wraps, other products with spinach due to salmonella risk

Ready-to-eat products sold at the grocery chain's stores in eight states may be contaminated by bacterial infection

2H ago

Shutdown's drag to worsen, economists warn

The negative impact on GDP will double for every week the impasse continues, Bank of America economists warn

1H ago

Wells Fargo CEO: Not paying fed workers is "completely embarrassing"

The government shutdown hit day 35 on Friday, marking the second missed paycheck for federal workers

4H ago

Tubbs Fire report complicates PG&E's bankruptcy decision

A state report finding the utility's equipment wasn't to blame could hamper lawsuits and complicate a planned bankruptcy

6H ago

Roger Stone leaves court to chants of "lock him up"

Roger Stone, arrested and indicted on seven charges, was released on $250,000 bond Friday

updated 30M ago

Former Trump campaign chair Paul Manafort appears in federal court

The president's former campaign chairman appeared in federal court the same day as Trump associate Roger Stone

2H ago

Judge OK's high-profile new defense team for Weinstein

One of Harvey Weinstein's new lawyers is Jose Baez, best known for representing Casey Anthony, Florida mom acquitted in daughter's death

3H ago

Mueller indicts Trump associate Roger Stone

White House press secretary Sarah Sanders said this has "nothing to do with the president and certainly nothing to do with the White House"

1H ago

Florida bank shooting: Newlywed among the dead

Names of 4 of the 5 victims have been made public; authorities say the accused gunman didn't appear to know any of them

8H ago  Original Article