Stock prices up more than 10 percent since U.S. shutdown began

By Irina Ivanova

/ MoneyWatch

NASA employees working without pay

Four weeks into a partial government shutdown that has gnarled air travel, threatened millions of tax refunds and stalled environmental protections, Wall Street seems to have a message for the feds: Stay shut.

Major U.S. stock indexes are up more than 12 percent since Dec. 24, the first day of the shutdown that markets were open.

News that the U.S. and China were considering dropping trade barriers sent the major market indexes even higher Friday afternoon, but stocks have been rising since the shutdown began. The S&P 500-stock index, now up for four weeks straight, was trading at 2,667 at 11:30 a.m. Eastern time on Friday, and was up 2.3 percent this week. The blue-chip Dow Jones industrial average was trading at 24,616, a spike of 3.2 percent since Monday, while the tech-heavy Nasdaq composite rose 3.9 percent this week to 7,164.

Apparent progress in U.S.-China trade talks, as well as limited economic data coming out that shows the U.S. economy remains on solid footing, seem to have persuaded investors the economy isn't turning south, as have assurances from Federal Reserve Chair Jay Powell that the central bank would be "patient" and listen to the markets.

"Past shutdowns have largely been a nonevent for the U.S. economy and stocks. Business and consumer confidence indicators usually decline and government spending drops during a shutdown, but any losses have typically been recouped quickly," John Lynch, research chief investment strategist at LPL Financial, said in a blog post.

Still, the S&P 500 has typically fallen in previous shutdowns, according to LPL. The fact that stocks are now rising makes the current shutdown unusual for more than its length. On average, the index drops by 0.4 percent in shutdowns, LPL found. Before the current shutdown, the biggest stock rise occurred during the shutdown of 2013. During the 17 days the federal government was closed, the S&P 500 rose 2.3 percent.

shutdown-stocks-2.png

It's worth remembering that stocks have been unusually volatile in the past half-year, and can turn on a dime. The current shutdown has also depressed consumer spending, and economists predict it could reduce GDP growth for the first quarter by as much as 0.3 percent.

Indeed, New York Federal Reserve President John Williams on Friday said he was "seeing some emerging headwinds to growth from the partial government shutdown."

Investors will have to wait a while for the shutdown's impact to be measured—the government agency that tracks the GDP is included in in the shutdown.

First published on January 18, 2019

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc.. All Rights Reserved.

shutdown-stocks.png shutdown-stocks-2.png

Stock prices up more than 10% since shutdown began

Four weeks into the longest shutdown in U.S. history, Wall Street seems to be saying: Stay shut

updated 2M ago

Will Washington pass the "10 Year Challenge"?

"CBS This Morning" co-host John Dickerson reflects on where we were a decade ago and poses a challenge to Washington

updated 28M ago

Pelosi says it was “very irresponsible” for Trump to cancel trip

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi responded to Trump's decision to ground her trip to Brussels and Afghanistan

updated 48M ago

Facility where comatose woman had baby faces new abuse allegations

The facility is facing scrutiny after another patient in a vegetative state unexpectedly gave birth

updated 58M ago

Saturn spent billions of years without its rings, NASA says

Saturn's rings may have formed during the age of dinosaurs – but compared to the planet, that's not that old

1H ago

Stock prices up more than 10% since shutdown began

Four weeks into the longest shutdown in U.S. history, Wall Street seems to be saying: Stay shut

updated 2M ago

Pelosi says it was “very irresponsible” for Trump to cancel trip

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi responded to Trump's decision to ground her trip to Brussels and Afghanistan

updated 48M ago

OMB shuts down all congressional travel until government reopens

All congressional travel using government transportation will be prohibited until the government reopens

updated 4M ago

Graham in Turkey after criticizing Trump's Syria withdrawal plans

Senior GOP senator has said Trump's move to pull out will embolden ISIS, as ex-U.S. envoy warns it's already happening

1H ago

GOP Rep. Will Hurd says wall is "least effective" border security measure

Hurd, from Texas, is the only Republican member representing a district along the southern border

2H ago

Graham in Turkey after criticizing Trump's Syria withdrawal plans

Senior GOP senator has said Trump's move to pull out will embolden ISIS, as ex-U.S. envoy warns it's already happening

1H ago

Trump meets with top North Korean official at White House — live updates

The meeting comes as President Trump hopes to set up a second summit with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un

updated 0M ago

Heavy machinery used in bid to reach toddler down 360-foot hole

Spanish boy Julen Rosello fell into the narrow waterhole five days ago and hasn't been heard, but there's still hope he's alive

2H ago

17-year-old from Jersey makes history at Australian Open

"I want to win this tournament," Amanda Anisimova said. "Right now."

2H ago

Car bomb kills 21 on Colombia police academy campus

Authorities say ELN, the only remaining active rebel group in the country, behind the deadliest attack in more than a decade

4H ago

17-year-old from Jersey makes history at Australian Open

"I want to win this tournament," Amanda Anisimova said. "Right now."

2H ago

How to watch "Star Trek: Discovery" season 2

New season of "Star Trek: Discovery" premieres Thursday on CBS All Access

14H ago

Netflix beats expectations for subscribers, undershoots revenue

The streaming service, which added 8.8 million new users in the last quarter, recently hiked its monthly fees

16H ago

"Star Trek: Discovery": Sonequa Martin-Green on her "complicated" Spock reunion

"Star Trek: Discovery" Season 2 premieres Thursday night on CBS All Access

18H ago

Gladys Knight to sing anthem at Super Bowl

"I am proud to use my voice to unite and represent our country in my hometown of Atlanta," Knight said

Jan 17

Saturn spent billions of years without its rings, NASA says

Saturn's rings may have formed during the age of dinosaurs – but compared to the planet, that's not that old

1H ago

Tens of thousands of embryos are stuck in limbo in fertility clinics

Some are outright abandoned by people who quit paying storage fees while some couples are struggling with tough decisions

Jan 17

Unpaid NASA workers protect missions during shutdown

NASA managers and engineers continue to oversee critical missions amid shutdown chaos

3H ago

Facebook shuts hundreds of pages linked to Russia's Sputnik

Facebook said it discovered two large disinformation operations as part of its fight against fake news

Jan 17

"Super blood wolf moon" will light up the sky Sunday

An unusual lunar eclipse will unfold Sunday night — and it will be hard to miss if you stay up

12H ago

Vaping has created teen nicotine addicts with few treatment options

The options for treating nicotine addiction in children is limited at a time when teen vaping is exploding in popularity.

4H ago

Perdue recalls chicken nuggets for possible wood contamination

Company reports customer complaints that wood was found in its gluten-free Organics Breaded Chicken Breast Nuggets

2H ago

Anti-vax movement among top 10 global health threats for 2019

Climate change also makes the World Health Organization's list of biggest health concerns

18H ago

The world needs a diet overhaul, expert panel says

New report concludes we need a major diet change to do what's best for our health and the planet

21H ago

Are intermittent fasting diets a good way to lose weight?

Fasting diets are growing in popularity, but Dr. David Agus says science doesn't back the trend

20H ago

Stock prices up more than 10% since shutdown began

Four weeks into the longest shutdown in U.S. history, Wall Street seems to be saying: Stay shut

updated 2M ago

Sears creditors allege Eddie Lampert lining "own pockets"

Legal challenge by committee pushing to liquidate retailer's remaining assets, including 425 stores that employ 45,000

2H ago

Furloughed? What to know about collecting unemployment

As more and more federal workers apply for unemployment to make ends meet, snags in the system are showing

updated 38M ago

Perdue recalls chicken nuggets for possible wood contamination

Company reports customer complaints that wood was found in its gluten-free Organics Breaded Chicken Breast Nuggets

2H ago

Obamacare premiums could increase slightly next year

A proposed rule change would result in a modest premium increase under the Affordable Care Act

4H ago

Facility where comatose woman had baby faces new abuse allegations

The facility is facing scrutiny after another patient in a vegetative state unexpectedly gave birth

updated 58M ago

Disabled woman, 23, raped, impregnated in health care facility: Suit

Lawsuit alleges she was living in facility in Pensacola, Florida when it happened, but authorities say they can't find DNA evidence of a rape

6H ago

Man sentenced in fatal stabbing of Morgan Freeman relative

Prosecutors say Lamar Davenport, 33, stabbed his girlfriend E'Dena Hines multiple times while under the influence of alcohol and drugs in August 2015

13H ago

El Chapo mistress describes "naked" drug lord's escape

"He took off running. He left us behind," Lucero Guadalupe Sanchez Lopez said Thursday in Joaquin Guzman's drug trafficking trial

13H ago

1 dead, 1 wounded in shooting outside Texas church

Harris County Sheriff's department said they're looking for a person in connection to Thursday night's incident

8H ago