El Chapo trial shows why a wall won’t stop drugs from crossing the U.S.-Mexico border

By Luis Gómez Romero

/ The Conversation

DEA agent reveals how El Chapo was caught

Luis Gómez Romero is senior lecturer in Human Rights, Constitutional Law and Legal Theory at the University of Wollongong in Australia.

The trial of Mexican drug kingpin Joaquín "El Chapo" Guzmán Loera has exposed just how powerful Mexico's cartels really are.

The trial has now run for two months. On Jan. 15, a Colombian drug trafficker who worked for Guzmán's Sinaloa Cartel from 2007 to 2013 testified that Guzmán paid former Mexican president Enrique Peña Nieto a $100 million bribe while he was in power, a charge Peña Nieto' office denies.

It was just the latest allegation of the cartels paying off high-ranking politicians in Mexico, presumably to exert influence over the government.

Guzmán is charged with drug trafficking, murder, kidnapping and money laundering – crimes he allegedly committed over the past quarter-century as head of the Sinaloa cartel, the Western Hemisphere's most powerful organized crime syndicate.

With its witness accounts of extreme violence, political corruption, international intrigue and entrepreneurial innovation, Guzmán's trial is a telenovela-style explainer on why a wall is unlikely to stop the lucrative U.S.-Mexico drug trade.

The Sinaloa cartel

Founded in Mexico's Sinaloa state in the 1990s, the Sinaloa cartel now distributes drugs to some 50 countries, including Argentina, the Philippines and Russia.

Determining the scale of Guzmán's global empire is difficult, since gangsters usually don't keep books and charts of accounts. But his 2016 indictment in the U.S. sought forfeiture of more than $14 billion in proceeds and illicit profits from decades of narcotics sales in the U.S. and Canada.

The Sinaloa cartel controls perhaps half of Mexico's drug market, with annual earnings of around $3 billion. Mexican estimates suggest that each month it moves two tons of cocaine and 10,000 tons of marijuana – plus heroin, methamphetamine and other substances.

The drug business

Illegal drugs are a highly lucrative business.

In 2016, the year El Chapo was captured in Mexico, the wholesale price for a gram of cocaine was approximately $2.30 in Colombia and $12.50 in Mexico. The same gram had a wholesale cost of $28 by the time it got to the United States. In Australia, that same gram of cocaine fetched $176.50 wholesale.

Drug prices rise significantly during transit as intermediaries demand compensation for the risk they assume in getting the product to consumers.

Retail prices per gram of cocaine are even higher, reflecting the addition of even more middlemen: $82 in the U.S. in 2016 and $400 in Australia.

This liability markup is one reason why some prominent policy experts and even conservative economists call for legalizing and regulating illicit narcotics. Keeping drugs illegal is what makes them so profitable for the people who traffick them.

Bribes, violence and threats

Illegality is also what makes the drug business so violent.

Running an illicit operation, cartel leaders must both enforce their own business agreements and protect themselves from authorities and competitors.

They do so using a combination of violence, threats and bribes.

At least eight armed groups worked under Guzmán's command in Mexico, according to Mexican government reports, attacking competitors and killing defectors.

Guzmán also bribed as many politicians, police officers and prison guards to stay in business.

El Chapo trial: Former Mexican president accused of corruption

His elaborate disappearances from Mexican high-security prisons are the stuff of legend. In 2015, Guzmán escaped jail by riding a motorcycle through a lit, ventilated mile-long tunnel constructed underneath his cell.

American demand

The Sinaloa cartel didn't become the world's biggest supplier of illicit drugs by coincidence. It has flourished because the United States is the world's biggest consumer of illicit drugs.

Mexican cartels serve Americans' "insatiable demand for illegal drugs," as Hillary Clinton once said.

Despite President Donald Trump's focus on Mexican drug traffickers, his former chief of staff, John Kelly, has admitted that the U.S. is part of the problem.

"We're not even trying," he told Congress in 2017, calling for more drug-demand reduction programs.

Kelly added that Latin American countries chide American authorities for "lecturing [them] about not doing enough to stop the drug flow" while the U.S. does nothing to "stop the demand."

Trump's wall

Trump's continued insistence on securing the southern border with a wall seems to disregard the economic forces driving the drug trade and diminish Mexican cartels' innovative distribution strategies.

A high-tech border fence constructed in Arizona long before Trump's inauguration has proven virtually useless in stopping drugs from crossing into the U.S.: Mexican smugglers just use a catapult to fling hundred-pound bales of marijuana over to the American side.

"We've got the best fence money can buy," former DEA chief Michael Brown said to The New York Times in 2012, "and they counter us with a 2,500-year-old technology."

Then there's the other ancient technology perfected by Guzmán: the tunnel.

Officials have discovered about 180 cleverly disguised illicit passages under the U.S.-Mexico border. Many, like the one Guzmán used to escape prison, are equipped with electricity, ventilation and elevators.

Recapturing "El Chapo" 38 photos

Trump has admitted that anyone could use "a rope" to climb over his wall, but believes that more border guards and drone technology would prevent infiltration.

Corruption in the US

Corruption is not an exclusively Mexican trait.

Over the past decade some 200 employees and contractors from the Department of Homeland Security have accepted nearly $15 million in bribes to look the other way as drugs were smuggled across the border into the United States, The New York Times has reported.

Some U.S. officials have also given sensitive law enforcement information to cartels members, according to the Times.

"Almost no evidence about corrupt American officials has been allowed at [El Chapo's] trial," New York Times reporter Alan Feuer said recently on Twitter.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. This article is an updated version of a story originally published on Feb. 19, 2017.

First published on January 17, 2019

Recapturing "El Chapo"

El Chapo trial shows why a wall won’t stop drugs at border

With witness accounts of violence, corruption, and entrepreneurial innovation, the trial is a telenovela-style explainer on why a wall is unlikely to stop​ the lucrative U.S.-Mexico drug trade

updated 5M ago

Nancy Pelosi speaks at weekly news conference

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi is speaking at her weekly news conference amid a government shutdown

updated 22M ago

Early Facebook backer Roger McNamee wants to break it up

McNamee, once a mentor to Mark Zuckerberg, now says the tech CEO's success has blinded him to Facebook's problems

updated 24M ago

Moonves to fight CBS Corp. for $120 million severance in arbitration

On December 17, the CBS board of directors determined Moonves was fired "for cause." He had 30 days to say whether he would fight the decision.

updated 43M ago

Kids of federal workers turn shutdown anxiety into business savvy

As hundreds of thousands of parents are missing paychecks children are feeling the trickle-down effects and stress of their parents

1H ago

Nancy Pelosi speaks at weekly news conference

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi is speaking at her weekly news conference amid a government shutdown

updated 22M ago

Trump visits Pentagon as U.S. ramps up space-based missile defense strategy

The Trump administration is rolling out the results of its missile defense review

updated 17M ago

Giuliani: "I never said there was no collusion" between Trump campaign and Russia

Trump lawyer Rudy Giuliani says in interview that he never said there was no collusion between people on Trump campaign and Russia

1H ago

Facebook shuts hundreds of pages linked to Russia's Sputnik

Facebook said it discovered two large disinformation operations as part of its fight against fake news

2H ago

Senators debate Cardi B video

"Trying to decide whether or not to retweet the Cardi B video," one senator wrote, sparking a debate between colleagues

2H ago

El Chapo trial shows why a wall won’t stop drugs at border

With witness accounts of violence, corruption, and entrepreneurial innovation, the trial is a telenovela-style explainer on why a wall is unlikely to stop​ the lucrative U.S.-Mexico drug trade

updated 5M ago

U.S. refuses to discuss Iranian TV anchorwoman's detention

Son says U.S. national being held on a law that one expert says feds resorts to, "when they need a reason to arrest somebody but they don't have one"

updated 58M ago

ISIS is morphing in Syria, but it's not beaten yet

CBS News visits the front line in the ongoing fight by Kurdish forces, and their American allies, against a persistent enemy Trump insists is defeated

3H ago

American killed in Kenya terror attack survived 9/11

Jason Spindler gave up a high-powered Wall Street career for the chance to make a difference, a passion for change that led him to Kenya

4H ago

California man killed in Taliban truck bombing in Afghanistan

Manoharan "Paul" Kamaleson, 55, was in the country working alongside an NGO on development when the blast tore through compound in Kabul

7H ago

Betty White turns 97: Here's how she stays hip

Betty White celebrated her birthday on Thursday, and after seven decades in show business, she's still making us laugh

1H ago

Senators debate Cardi B video

"Trying to decide whether or not to retweet the Cardi B video," one senator wrote, sparking a debate between colleagues

2H ago

Steve Carell to star in Netflix comedy "Space Force"

It's not an "Office" reboot — but it's probably the next best thing

15H ago

New "Star Trek" season tells "untold chapter of Spock"

"Star Trek: Discovery" season 2 premieres Thursday on CBS All Access

19H ago

Fortnite flaw exposed millions of users to hacks

Hackers could take over accounts, make purchases and even eavesdrop on players

19H ago

Facebook shuts hundreds of pages linked to Russia's Sputnik

Facebook said it discovered two large disinformation operations as part of its fight against fake news

2H ago

"Super blood wolf moon" will light up the sky Sunday

An unusual lunar eclipse will unfold Sunday night — and it will be hard to miss if you stay up

5H ago

PG&E bankruptcy shows we don't know how to pay for climate change

As weather gets more extreme, corporations, citizens and politicians fight over who should pay for the damages

19H ago

Is "10 Year Challenge" helping Facebook mine data?

The simple meme that's taking over your Facebook feed might not be so simple

2H ago

Fortnite flaw exposed millions of users to hacks

Hackers could take over accounts, make purchases and even eavesdrop on players

19H ago

Recalls of hazardous meat and poultry up 83 percent, report finds

"Something is rotten in our slaughterhouses and our fields"

1H ago

Fashion model poses with her ostomy bags to inspire other cancer survivors

Jearlean Taylor has learned to embrace her ostomy bags — and now wants to inspire others to do the same

12H ago

Cats test positive for bubonic plague

No human cases have been identified, but health officials warn the disease can be passed to people from infected animals

17H ago

What cancer doctors don't know about LGBTQ patients

New research reveals most oncologists lack awareness about key health issues facing gay, bisexual or transgender patients

17H ago

Experimental patch could offer once-a-month contraception

Microneedle patch would be placed on the skin for a few seconds each month and would slowly release contraceptive drugs over time

Jan 15

Early Facebook backer Roger McNamee wants to break it up

McNamee, once a mentor to Mark Zuckerberg, now says the tech CEO's success has blinded him to Facebook's problems

updated 24M ago

Moonves to fight CBS Corp. for $120 million severance in arbitration

On December 17, the CBS board of directors determined Moonves was fired "for cause." He had 30 days to say whether he would fight the decision.

updated 43M ago

Hyundai, Kia recall 168,000 vehicles at risk for fires

The carmakers moved even though the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, which normally oversees recalls, is closed due to the shutdown

1H ago

Facebook shuts hundreds of pages linked to Russia's Sputnik

Facebook said it discovered two large disinformation operations as part of its fight against fake news

2H ago

TSA workers, federal employees relying on donations during shutdown

GoFundMe pages and food donations are helping government workers make ends meet as the shutdown continues

2H ago

Wisconsin girl's accused kidnapper applied for job on day she escaped

Jake Patterson, charged with abducting Jayme Closs after killing her parents, described himself as "an honest and hardworking guy"

1H ago

Officer shoots, kills boy, 14, who had airsoft gun, not real one

Tempe, Arizona police say officer caught teen burglarizing car, teen got gun from car, officer chased teen, felt threatened, shot him

9H ago

Teacher who fled with student sentenced to 20 years in prison

At Wednesday's sentencing, a statement from the victim called the 52-year-old "disgusting" and effects of his actions "devastating and permanent"

12H ago

TV host Chris Hansen arrested over bad checks, police say

Chris Hansen confronted alleged child predators during sting operations on NBC's "To Catch a Predator"

16H ago

"Innocent black man" who died behind bars exonerated by governor

Grover Thompson, who died in 1996, was convicted for a stabbing that a serial killer later confessed to committing

21H ago