Most cancer doctors don't know enough about LGBTQ patient care, study finds
By Ashley Welch
/ CBS News
Cancer cells don't discriminate. But when a patient who identifies as lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, or queer/questioning (LGBTQ) is diagnosed, they may have health needs or concerns their doctors aren't expecting.
When it comes to cancer care, a new study finds many doctors are lacking in knowledge about treating members of the .
The research, published in the Journal of Clinical Oncology, found that the majority of oncologists say they're comfortable treating individuals who identify as LGBTQ. But only half of them expressed confidence in their knowledge of these patients' health needs.
"There's both overt and covert discrimination that happens that we've heard again and again especially for transgender patients but across the LBGTQ spectrum," study author Megan Sutter, PhD, postdoctoral research fellow at NYU Langone Health, told CBS News. "With this research, we're really interested in looking at how discrimination affects not only patient health but also how can we intervene at the provider level to have an impact on quality of care."
The researchers surveyed 450 oncologists from the 45 National Cancer Institute (NCI) designated cancer centers in the United States.
"These are the best of the best. If things are not happening at NCI centers, they're probably not happening at smaller community centers," said Gwendolyn Quinn, PhD, professor of population health and obstetrics and gynecology at NYU Langone Health and also an author of the study.
The questions were designed to assess the doctors' knowledge, attitudes, behaviors, and willingness to be educated about LGBTQ cancer patients. Most of the oncologists surveyed were heterosexual males.
Health needs of LGBTQ patients
Care for LGBTQ patients was incorporated in med school curriculums around 2010, Quinn explained. "If you went to school before then, you probably didn't get a lot of that training. And even still if you did get it, you got it as a med student before you identified your subspecialty as oncology," she said.
The results of the study revealed that a big gap in care comes from doctors not being able to appropriately assess cancer risk for members of the LGBTQ community.
For example, the survey asked doctors if they were aware that the LGBTQ population is, overall, more likely to spend time in the sun, use tobacco, and have substance abuse issues. The doctors were also asked whether or not women who have never had sex with a man are still at risk for HPV, or the human papillomavirus, which is linked to several types of cancer.
"The answer to these questions is that they're true, but many of the doctors in the survey didn't think that," Quinn said.
The research also found a lack of understanding of some of the personal and family issues LGBTQ patients may face.
"Some of them focus on end-of-life care issues," Quinn said. "People who are members of this community tend to sometimes be estranged from family of origin. There are all different types of patterns for who may be caregivers or health surrogates. It may be someone who's formally a married partner or a friend."
She said it's also important for doctors not to assume that patients of child-bearing age are not interested in fertility preservation methods because they are LGBTQ. They may still want to have children.
Gaps in transgender care
While 83 percent of oncologists surveyed said they were comfortable treating transgender individuals, only 37 percent reported feeling that they knew enough to do so.
Previous research has found that transgender people often postpone medical care due to discrimination or concern about how they'll be treated, and many say they've needed to teach their health care providers about transgender care. Some have even been refused treatment because of their transgender or gender non-conforming status.
A 2015 report from the New York Academy of Medicine on access to quality health care for transgender people describes how harrowing the experience can be. "We've gotten calls from people who have gotten thrown out of gynecologists' offices because they'll say we don't see men… then they have to explain that they have female anatomy and the doctors are so uninformed," a trans woman and LGBTQ care provider said.
Medical experts say it's always important to ask a patient how they would like to be addressed and to use the proper pronouns to which he or she identifies.
More training needed
As a result of their findings, the researchers recommend cancer centers create a safe environment for patients to disclose their sexual orientation and gender identity, as well as establish protocols for treating LGBTQ cancer patients.
"It's not a patient issue. We should not expect people who identify as LGBTQ to train us about what their needs are," Quinn said. "It is our obligation as institutions and providers of care to figure out how we can best serve them."
Although the survey revealed most oncologists lack awareness in key health issues facing LGBTQ patients, it also found a high interest in receiving more education on the subject.
Sutter says she hopes this can happen in consultation with the LGBTQ community. "We want to make sure we're not dictating what we think is best for them but rather make sure we're doing it as partners and equals," she said.
Finally, the study authors say workers at every level of the health care industry should receive training to provide better care for LGBTQ patients.
"It's one thing to train practicing oncologists, and they're obviously the place to start, but members of the LGBTQ community are not going to get great care if the whole team and the institution are also not trained," Quinn said. "There needs to be policies at the institution level from nurses to intake to schedulers, all workers need to have this cultural competency in order for the patient to have a good experience."
First published on January 16, 2019
© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Ashley Welch covers health and wellness for CBSNews.com
Elijah Cummings' new power for investigating Trump
House Democrats have been stonewalled over the last two years when it came to subpoenas on various Trump administration dealings. But now Democrats have the majority, and Elijah Cummings plans to make the most of it
How advanced is AI today?
Scott Pelley reports on the developments in artificial intelligence brought about by venture capitalist Kai-Fu Lee's investments and China's effort to dominate the AI field
Architect still designing, 10 years after going blind
A social worker tried to tell him about "career alternatives" after he lost his sight, but Chris Downey wasn't about to stop being an architect
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez: The "60 Minutes" interview
The youngest woman ever elected to Congress tells "60 Minutes" she thinks President Trump is racist and responds to criticisms she could be pushing the Democratic Party too far to the left
President El-Sisi: The interview Egypt didn't want aired
Abdel Fattah el-Sisi seized control of Egypt in the wake of an uprising against Mohamed Morsi's autocratic regime. Since then, Sisi's regime has imprisoned opponents and killed protesters
The inventor turning plant life into biofuel
Marshall Medoff unveils to "60 Minutes" his innovative method of turning plant life into fuel and other useful products
Ocasio-Cortez calls President Trump a racist
The congresswoman says the president uses words "which are historic dog whistles of white supremacy"
Cleaning up the plastic in the ocean
Discarded plastic is piling up around the world and pooling in the ocean. Sharyn Alfonsi reports on the problem's deadly consequences for wildlife and what can be done to stop it
The return of wolves to Yellowstone Park
The reintroduction of the predator has led to more visitors and a shift in the ecological makeup of the park
Dec 24, 2018
Chef Massimo Bottura: The Pavarotti of pasta
"60 Minutes" travels to Italy to meet the chef whose kitchen creations are works of art
Dec 30, 2018
Right Rail – Video Promo – Listing
Barr vows transparency with Mueller findings
William Barr, President Trump's nominee for attorney general, is defending Robert Mueller's Russia investigation, saying he will let it finish. Barr repeatedly promised senators during Tuesday's confirmation hearing that he will be independent. Nancy Cordes reports.
8H ago 01:24
When Sully met the passengers he saved
Capt. "Sully" Sullenberger saved all 155 people on board US Airways Flight 1549. Ten years ago, 60 Minutes was there when he reunited with them
Jan 15 02:31
Shutdown impact felt beyond federal workers
The partial government shutdown is in its 26th day, with no negotiations planned to end it. A new White House analysis shows the deadlock is hurting U.S. economic growth at twice the rate previously estimated. The administration is recalling some 50,000 federal employees to work without pay, including nearly 46,000 of IRS staff. Carter Evans reports from Ogden, Utah, the city that has the highest concentration of federal workers in the West.
8H ago 03:18
Calif. winter storm triggers rivers of mud
A powerful winter storm hitting the West Coast forced hundreds of people from their homes across Southern California. But the worst is still to come. Two more days of heavy rain and blizzard conditions are expected in California before that storm takes aim at the East Coast later this weekend. WCBS weathercaster Lonnie Quinn is tracking the storm's latest path.
8H ago 02:22
New details on Jayme Closs' accused kidnapper
Jake Patterson, the suspect in the kidnapping of Jayme Closs and the killing of her parents, was moved Tuesday from Wisconsin's Barron County Jail to the jail in Polk County about 30 miles away. The 21-year-old is being held on $5 million bail. Jamie Yuccas reports.
8H ago 02:32
U.S. troops killed in Syria suicide attack claimed by ISIS
Shortly after the military said service members were killed, Vice President Pence said ISIS "has been defeated"
Why Theresa May's Brexit defeat matters to the U.S.
With just 72 days until the U.K. is scheduled to leave the EU, economic uncertainty caused by the landslide vote could ripple across the Atlantic
U.S. businessman among those killed in Kenya terror attack
Friend says Jason Spindler was "one of those rare men who was loved by pretty much anyone" as Kenyan leader puts toll from al-Shabab attack at 14
Pelosi asks Trump to postpone State of the Union
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi wrote a letter to President Trump suggesting he find another date or location
Jailed model who claimed she has dirt on Russian oligarch speaks out
Anastasia Vashukevich has told Russian media she can't wait to be released
Golden Globes red carpet 2018
See all the stars at the 76th annual Golden Globe Awards ceremony in Beverly Hills, Calif.
Jan 6 77 photos
New on Netflix, Hulu and Amazon
Shows and movies you'll want to stream soon
Dec 26, 2018 35 photos
A look at the career of the Oscar-winning film legend
Jan 5 33 photos
50 best movies of the century (so far)
"Gravity," "Moonlight," "The Social Network" and more
Jan 4 50 photos
Notable deaths in 2018
A look back at the esteemed personalities who've left us this year, who touched us with their innovation, creativity and humanity
Jan 6 141 photos
What cancer doctors don't know about LGBTQ patients
New research reveals most oncologists lack awareness about key health issues facing gay, bisexual or transgender patients
updated 2M ago
PG&E bankruptcy shows we don't know how to pay for climate change
As weather gets more extreme, corporations, citizens and politicians fight over who should pay for the damages
updated 7M ago
Senate rejects bill to stop sanctions relief for Russian oligarch
The procedural vote to move forward on the issue failed with just under 60 votes
updated 15M ago
World Economic Forum warns of worsening global relations
The group behind annual Davos conference cites U.S.-China trade tensions, Brexit and nationalism as top concerns
updated 30M ago
Karen Pence to teach at Christian school that bans LGBTQ students, faculty
The vice president's wife returns to a Virginia Christian school that bars students and employees from homosexual activity and from condoning transgender identity
updated 54M ago
Hyundai, Kia recall 168,000 vehicles at risk for fires
The carmakers moved even though the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, which normally oversees recalls, is closed due to the shutdown
updated 0M ago