Gillette ad challenging images of masculinity rubs some men's rights activists the wrong way

By Kate Gibson

/ MoneyWatch

Gillette ad sparks controversy

After three decades of touting Gillette razors as part of being an alpha male, Procter & Gamble is doing an about-face with an ad that has the consumer-products company jumping into into the cultural wars with both feet.

A play on its 30-year tagline "The Best A Man Can Get," Gillette's new "The Best Men Can Be" campaign features a nearly two-minute ad showing men intervening to stop fights between boys, and berating others of their gender for saying sexually inappropriate things to females in public.

While there are plenty of "issue-based, ideologically-grounded, cultural branding type" of ads out there, Gillette's is unusual in terms of how direct the messaging is, Robert Kozinets, a scholar of marketing and consumer culture at the University of Southern California's Annenberg School for Communication and Journalism, told CBS MoneyWatch.

We Believe: The Best Men Can Be | Gillette (Short Film) by Gillette on YouTube

Gillette said in a news release announcing the campaign that the company has a "responsibility to make sure we are promoting positive, attainable, inclusive and healthy versions on what it means to be a man." Gillette included a pledge to donate $1 million annually for the next three years to a nonprofit devoted to helping men "achieve their personal 'best.'" The Boys and Girls Club of America will be the first recipient, according to Adweek.

As with Nike's controversial advertising campaign featuring former NFL star Colin Kaepernick, Gillette's "The Best Men Can Be" campaign inspired backlash on social media and calls for a boycott of its products.

British TV personality Piers Morgan was among the higher-profile objectors to the ad, posting, "this absurd virtue-signalling PC guff may drive me away to a company less eager to fuel the current pathetic global assault on masculinity."

Christina Sommers, a scholar at the right-wing American Enterprise Institute, took to Twitter to slam both the ad and a prominent liberal arts college in Ohio.

Help! Police! Gillette has been hijacked by the Oberlin College Gender Studies Collective. https://t.co/lCMNQ3ofii

— Christina Sommers (@CHSommers) January 15, 2019

Released on Sunday, the video's YouTube page as of Tuesday afternoon had 343,000 dislikes and 83,000 likes.

Still, it remains to be seen whether that negative outpouring will impact sales for a conglomerate that generated $66.8 billion in revenue in 2018.

If Nike's decision to feature an athlete known for kneeling during the national anthem to protest police brutality is any guide, Gillette may not have much to worry about, as Nike's stock and sales surged in the wake of its September ad campaign featuring Kaepernick.

Kozinets agreed, saying even negative reviews can be a positive when it comes to drawing interest.

"Given that most advertising is ignored, or about some boring functionality such as shaving cream that makes your skin 17 percent softer, this is already a win for P&G," he said.

First published on January 15, 2019

© 2019 CBS Interactive Inc.. All Rights Reserved.

Gillette ad challenging images of masculinity rubs some the wrong way

Men's rights activists call for boycott of Proctor & Gamble after razor commercial highlights bad behavior by their gender

updated 4M ago

William Barr confirmation hearing: "I will not be bullied"

The president's nominee for attorney general is making his case on Capitol Hill that he will serve as an independent leader of the Justice Department, if confirmed

updated 6M ago

Carbonated water has become a multibillion-dollar industry

Sales of seltzer, club soda and sparkling water are up by double digits as more Americans turn away from soda and other sugary drinks

updated 51M ago

As shutdown drags on, federal workers flock to food pantries

Furloughed government workers are lining up at food banks and calling help hotlines across U.S. after missing paychecks

updated 49M ago

GOP leaders step up pressure on Steve King

The number three Republican leader in the House, Liz Cheney, says Steve King should find another line of work. The House GOP has barred him from serving on any committees

1H ago

William Barr confirmation hearing: "I will not be bullied"

The president's nominee for attorney general is making his case on Capitol Hill that he will serve as an independent leader of the Justice Department, if confirmed

updated 6M ago

As shutdown drags on, federal workers flock to food pantries

Furloughed government workers are lining up at food banks and calling help hotlines across U.S. after missing paychecks

updated 49M ago

GOP leaders step up pressure on Steve King

The number three Republican leader in the House, Liz Cheney, says Steve King should find another line of work. The House GOP has barred him from serving on any committees

1H ago

Judge bars Trump administration from adding citizenship question to 2020 census

Critics believe the Commerce Department's proposal would lead to low response rates among immigrants and distort congressional apportionment to favor the GOP

2H ago

EPA criminal action against polluters hits 30-year low

"We're reaching levels where the enforcement program is lacking a pulse," said Jeff Ruch, PEER's executive director

2H ago

Rescuers struggle to find toddler in 330-foot well

A robotic camera found a bag of candy along with a cup that belongs to the missing child

updated 15M ago

Brexit deal faces key vote in Parliament – then what?

Theresa May's plan faces almost certain defeat, and Brits may be left with little more understanding of how, when or even if they are to leave the EU

1H ago

Saudi woman who fled family: "We are treated as an object, like a slave"

"It's daily oppression," the 18-year-old reportedly said

1H ago

Antarctica's ice is melting faster, raising risk of sea level rise

The yearly loss of Antarctic ice mass has increased six-fold since 1979, scientists report

2H ago

"McJesus" sculpture sparks outrage in Israel

Israel's Christian minority, and a gov't minister, protesting the piece, intended to criticize worship of capitalism, but museum director standing firm

4H ago

Kim Kardashian reveals gender of baby No. 4

Kardashian revealed the news to Andy Cohen, who is also expecting a baby boy with a surrogate

updated 4M ago

Netflix hikes prices on all subscription plans

On the heels of a blowout success with "Bird Box," the streaming service is raising monthly prices by $1 or $2

3H ago

Alicia Keys named Grammy Awards host

CBS will broadcast Grammy Awards show on Sunday, Feb. 10

2H ago

"Mobituaries": Mo Rocca's irreverent podcast to debut with intriguing stories of past lives

CBS News and Simon & Schuster partner on podcast and book that offer obituaries celebrating the famous, the un-famous, the fictional, and the inanimate who have bitten the dust

3H ago

Broadway legend Carol Channing dead at 97

Iconic actress, singer and comedian who starred in the Broadway hit "Hello, Dolly!" has died

5H ago

Antarctica's ice is melting faster, raising risk of sea level rise

The yearly loss of Antarctic ice mass has increased six-fold since 1979, scientists report

2H ago

Netflix hikes prices on all subscription plans

On the heels of a blowout success with "Bird Box," the streaming service is raising monthly prices by $1 or $2

3H ago

Iran admits failed launch of satellite U.S. worries about

Tehran plans to put at least two into orbit that Washington says use tech that could be used to deliver nuclear weapons

7H ago

"Marty" the robot ready to roll at some grocery stores

Fully autonomous robotic assistants will cruise the aisles looking for potential safety hazards

19H ago

Texas canines contain DNA of red wolves declared extinct in 1980

The animal was declared extinct in the wild nearly 40 years ago

Jan 14

Poor sleep may take a toll on your heart

New research finds not getting enough good sleep could affect your risk of heart disease

20H ago

Americans more likely to die from opioids than a car crash

A new report from the National Safety Council sheds light on the most common causes of accidental death in the U.S.

3H ago

Parents charged after 3-year-old girl with 17-pound tumor dies

The parents of an Oklahoma girl, 3, who died from cancer with a 17-pound tumor are accused of failing to provide medical care

Jan 14

New school lunch rules could mean more salt, sugar and fat

The Trump administration begins rollbacks on Obama-era initiatives for healthier school lunches, giving the dairy industry a bigger presence in U.S. cafeterias

Jan 14

Judge blocks Trump birth control coverage rules in 13 states, D.C.

Issues preliminary injunction against rules that would let more employers opt out of providing women with free birth control

Jan 14

Gillette ad challenging images of masculinity rubs some the wrong way

Men's rights activists call for boycott of Proctor & Gamble after razor commercial highlights bad behavior by their gender

updated 4M ago

Carbonated water has become a multibillion-dollar industry

Sales of seltzer, club soda and sparkling water are up by double digits as more Americans turn away from soda and other sugary drinks

updated 51M ago

As shutdown drags on, federal workers flock to food pantries

Furloughed government workers are lining up at food banks and calling help hotlines across U.S. after missing paychecks

updated 49M ago

Netflix hikes prices on all subscription plans

On the heels of a blowout success with "Bird Box," the streaming service is raising monthly prices by $1 or $2

3H ago

PG&E bankruptcy: California's tough choices for nation's biggest utility

Gov. Gavin Newsom and state lawmakers confront nothing less than the fate of California's energy future

4H ago

"Dine-and-Dash Dater" surrenders to serve jail sentence in California

Paul Guadalupe Gonzales, 45, went on numerous first dates with women at restaurants in SoCal and would walk out — leaving the victim to foot the bill

11H ago

Gunman gets 84 years for murdering teen who performed at Obama's inauguration

Micheail Ward, 24, was sentenced in the 2013 shooting of the young honors student

18H ago

Suspect shot and killed after taking 2 women hostage at UPS facility

Officials said William Owens died of a gunshot wound after an incident Monday morning in Logan Township, N.J.

18H ago

El Chapo lawyer suggested hiring belly dancer to visit accused drug lord in jail

Lawyer Jeffrey Lichtman allegedly suggested he was planning to hire a belly dancer to visit the accused Mexican drug lord in jail

20H ago

Complaint reveals chilling details of Jayme Closs' abduction, captivity

The complaint says Jake Patterson told investigators: "He knew that was the girl he was going to take"

19H ago