Cardinal on trial in France's biggest Catholic sex abuse case to date

/ AP

Lyon archbishop, Cardinal Philippe Barbarin, sits in a Lyon court to attend his trial, Jan. 7, 2019, charged with failing to report a priest who abused Boy Scouts. Getty

Lyon, France — A Catholic cardinal and five other people went on trial Monday accused of covering up for a pedophile priest who abused Boy Scouts — France's most important church sex abuse case to date. The case poses a new challenge to the Vatican, amid growing demands in overwhelmingly Catholic France for a reckoning with decades of sexual abuse by the clergy.

Cardinal Philippe Barbarin, 68, appeared in a Lyon court Monday along with other senior church officials accused of failing to protect children from alleged abuse by the Rev. Bernard Preynat. The top Vatican official in charge of sex abuse cases, Cardinal Luis Ladaria, is among the accused – but won't appear in court because the Vatican invoked his diplomatic immunity.

After taking his seat in the front row, Barbarin held his hands together and closed his eyes, as if in prayer.

The judge then read out the lengthy accusations against the defendants, and the defense used procedural arguments to try to get the case thrown out.

Nine people who said Preynat abused them in the 1970s and 1980s brought the case to court, and hope it marks a turning point in efforts to hold the French church hierarchy accountable for hushing up abuse. The victims say top clergy were aware of Preynat's actions for years, but allowed him to be in contact with children until his 2015 retirement.

Catholic nuns accused of sexual misconduct

Despite nationwide attention to the case, it may fall apart for legal reasons. Prosecutors initially threw out it out for insufficient evidence, and Barbarin maintains his innocence. His lawyer says his client never obstructed justice because the statute of limitations had passed on the acts in question by the time Barbarin was informed.

"Accusing an innocent man doesn't advance a cause," lawyer Jean-Felix Luciani said.

If found guilty of failing to report the priest's actions, the defendants could face up to three years in prison and a 45,000-euro ($51,300) fine. Barbarin and some other defendants are also charged with failing to assist a person in peril.

The case is a new test for Pope Francis, whose handling of clergy sex abuse cases has threatened his legacy and thrown the Catholic hierarchy into a credibility crisis. Francis has praised Barbarin as "brave" and said French justice should take its course.

Pope Francis will hold summit in 2019 on sexual abuse controversy

The priest Preynat, now in his 70s, wrote letters to some families confessing the abuse, and is to be tried separately on sexual violence charges involving 10 children.

One of his alleged victims, Alexandre Hezez, hailed the trial as an effort to "move justice forward." Hezez, 44, spoke to the cardinal directly about Preynat and is among those who brought the case to trial.

Barbarin sought counsel on how to handle abuse accusations against Preynat from the Vatican official, Cardinal Ladaria, who recommended disciplinary measures while "avoiding a public scandal."

Numerous child sex abuse claims have been made against Catholic clergy in France since the 1990s, but there hasn't been a huge wave like those seen in the U.S., Ireland or some other countries.

Barbarin is the highest-level French church figure accused of covering up abuse, and his case has cast a shadow over the diocese and the French Catholic Church. As a result, the Bishops of France last year created an ambitious commission aimed at shedding light on sexual abuse of minors in the church since 1950. A report is due in 2020.

FRANCE-RELIGION-ABUSE
French priest Pierre Vignon sits outside his church as he speaks in Saint-Martin-en-Vercors, southeastern France, Aug. 22, 2018. Getty

But the issue is divisive. An outspoken French priest, the Rev. Pierre Vignon, started a petition urging Barbarin to resign that garnered more than 100,000 signatures last year – and Vignon says the effort has damaged his church career.

Barbarin is among the most powerful figures in the Catholic Church, one of some 200 cardinals worldwide and archbishop of Lyon since 2002. Multiple cardinals have been accused in recent years of shielding abusers or committing abuse themselves, from Pennsylvania to Australia to Chile.

First published on January 7, 2019

© 2019 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

TOPSHOT-FRANCE-JUSTICE-RELIGION-CHILDREN-ABUSE FRANCE-RELIGION-ABUSE

Joy, grief and a handwritten letter bring 2 La. families together

Two parents were undecided on a middle name for their new baby boy until inspiration arrived in the form of a handwritten letter

Jan 1

Cardinal on trial in France's biggest Catholic sex abuse case to date

Cardinal Philippe Barbarin stands accused of covering up for an alleged pedophile priest accused of abusing Boy Scouts for decades

updated 1M ago

Golden Globe Awards 2019: Full list of winners

Glenn Close won best film actress in a drama for "The Wife;" Christian Bale won best comedy actor for "Vice"

updated 3M ago

NYC firefighter falls 52 feet to his death during emergency call

Steven Pollard is the 1,151st member of the FDNY to die in the line of duty, and comes from a family of firefighters

updated 36M ago

Luxury Hawaii resort evacuated due to fast-moving brush fire

Guests, workers at 5-star Hotel Wailsea were cleared out after flames jumped a highway

1H ago

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez: The "60 Minutes" interview

The youngest woman ever elected to Congress tells "60 Minutes" she thinks President Trump is racist and responds to criticisms she could be pushing the Democratic Party too far to the left

8H ago

President El-Sisi: The interview Egypt didn't want aired

Abdel Fattah el-Sisi seized control of Egypt in the wake of an uprising against Mohamed Morsi's autocratic regime. Since then, Sisi's regime has imprisoned opponents and killed protesters

9H ago

The inventor turning plant life into biofuel

Marshall Medoff unveils to "60 Minutes" his innovative method of turning plant life into fuel and other useful products

9H ago

Ocasio-Cortez calls President Trump a racist

The congresswoman says the president uses words "which are historic dog whistles of white supremacy"

8H ago

Cleaning up the plastic in the ocean

Discarded plastic is piling up around the world and pooling in the ocean. Sharyn Alfonsi reports on the problem's deadly consequences for wildlife and what can be done to stop it

Jan 3

The return of wolves to Yellowstone Park

The reintroduction of the predator has led to more visitors and a shift in the ecological makeup of the park

Dec 24, 2018

Chef Massimo Bottura: The Pavarotti of pasta

"60 Minutes" travels to Italy to meet the chef whose kitchen creations are works of art

Dec 30, 2018

The Young American

The 19-year-old from Pennsylvania is already a millionaire pro-soccer player in Germany, but his U.S. coach says he could be the sport's "first American superstar"

Jan 2

Paul McCartney speaks to "60 Minutes"

In his first profile on "60 Minutes," McCartney walks down memory lane while looking through old pictures and videos and talks about how he still feels the need to prove himself with his music

Dec 30, 2018

Whisky Island

Steve Kroft and Bob Simon report on the Scottish Island of Islay, home to some of the world's premium single-malt scotch whiskies

Dec 30, 2018

How a former CIA officer was caught betraying his country

The officials who investigated and convicted Kevin Mallory for conspiracy to commit espionage tell 60 Minutes how their case came together

Dec 23, 2018

Inside the corruption allegations plaguing Malta

The smallest nation in the European Union is earning an unsavory reputation, with a series of scandals involving allegations of bribery, cronyism and money laundering

Dec 23, 2018

Right Rail – Video Promo – Listing

Suspect charged in killing of 7-year-old Texas girl

Police in Texas have arrested a man suspected of driving the getaway car in the drive-by killing of 7-year-old Jazmine Barnes. Eric Black Jr. was captured during a traffic stop for not using his turn signal. Police say he then identified the suspected shooter and called the slaying a mistake. Janet Shamlian reports.

9H ago 02:17

Is Ocasio-Cortez afraid of making enemies?

The freshman congresswoman is often at odds with her own party. She told "60 Minutes" she focuses on goals, not allies.

12H ago 04:29

Federal employees work without pay during shutdown

President Trump said Sunday he can relate to federal employees required to work without pay during the partial government shutdown. It's day 16 of the standoff, with Democrats standing firm that no taxpayer dollars be used to build a wall. But in new comments and bold letters, Mr. Trump says, "The wall is coming." Errol Barnett reports.

9H ago 02:49

Top Pentagon official resigns

Department of Defense chief of staff Ret. Rear Adm. Kevin Sweeney resigned Saturday without giving a reason. Sweeney is the third top Pentagon official to step down since President Trump's controversial plan to withdraw U.S. troops from Syria. Jonathan Vigliotti reports.

9H ago 01:51

West hit with winter weather

Large parts of the western U.S. were dealing with some miserable winter weather Sunday. But it was warmer than normal from the Rockies to the Appalachians. The bad news is that it will not last. Ileana Diaz reports.

9H ago 01:33

20-year-old man charged with murder in shooting death of Texas girl

Eric Black Jr. appeared in court to face a capital murder charge in the death of Jazmine Barnes

12H ago

Ocasio-Cortez calls President Trump a racist

The congresswoman says the president uses words "which are historic dog whistles of white supremacy"

8H ago

Sanders repeats claim on terrorists at the border refuted by administration's own data

White House press secretary Sarah Sanders on Sunday repeated a false claim put forth by her and other Trump administration officials

12H ago

More from Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez on 60 Minutes

The rookie congresswoman talks with Anderson Cooper about being branded a "flamethrower" and getting into a social media spat with Donald Trump Jr.

9H ago

Highway in California closed by mudslides, more rain in the forecast

Pacific Coast Highway was expected to remain closed in both directions until Monday while crews tow away stuck vehicles and clear lanes

8H ago

Golden Globes red carpet 2018

See all the stars at the 76th annual Golden Globe Awards ceremony in Beverly Hills, Calif.

10H ago 77 photos

Michael Caine

A look at the career of the Oscar-winning film legend

Jan 5 33 photos

New on Netflix, Hulu and Amazon

Shows and movies you'll want to stream soon

Dec 26, 2018 35 photos

50 best movies of the century (so far)

"Gravity," "Moonlight," "The Social Network" and more

Jan 4 50 photos

Notable deaths in 2018

A look back at the esteemed personalities who've left us this year, who touched us with their innovation, creativity and humanity

18H ago 141 photos

Cardinal on trial in France's biggest Catholic sex abuse case to date

Cardinal Philippe Barbarin stands accused of covering up for an alleged pedophile priest accused of abusing Boy Scouts for decades

updated 1M ago

Golden Globe Awards 2019: Full list of winners

Glenn Close won best film actress in a drama for "The Wife;" Christian Bale won best comedy actor for "Vice"

updated 3M ago

Eye Opener

President Trump may try to bypass Democrats to secure billions for a border wall after weekend talks failed to break the deadlock. Also, the Golden Globe Awards turned into a night of diversity, inclusion and surprise winners. All that and all that matters in today's Eye Opener. Your world in 90 seconds. <a href="http://www.cbsnews.com/newsletters/" target="_blank"><u>Get the Eye Opener delivered straight to your inbox.</u></a>

updated 0M ago 02:06

NYC firefighter falls 52 feet to his death during emergency call

Steven Pollard is the 1,151st member of the FDNY to die in the line of duty, and comes from a family of firefighters

updated 36M ago

Luxury Hawaii resort evacuated due to fast-moving brush fire

Guests, workers at 5-star Hotel Wailsea were cleared out after flames jumped a highway

1H ago

Saudi woman barricades herself in Thai airport hotel, begs for asylum

Rahaf al-Qunun, 18, barricaded herself in her hotel room to avoid a flight back to her family, whom she says abuses her and now would kill her

updated 35M ago