Researchers claim world record for longest life a case of ID fraud

/ AFP

A record held by a Frenchwoman as the world's longest living person could be fraudulent and involve an identity swap, Russian researchers have claimed in a report that has sparked widespread controversy.

Jeanne Calment died at the age of 122 years and 164 days in 1997, setting a record as the world's most long-lived person that is still unsurpassed.

The elderly woman used to joke that God must have forgotten about her.

But Russian mathematician Nikolai Zak is not convinced by her story.

The oldest living person ever documented, Jeanne Calment of France, holding a certificate from the Guinness Book of Records in 1995. Calment died in 1997 at age 122. Getty

In collaboration with gerontologist Valery Novoselov, he spent months analysing biographies of Jeanne Calment as well as her interviews and photos, witness testimony and the public records of the city of Arles in southern France where she lived.

"Analysing all these materials led me to conclude that Jeanne Calment's daughter Yvonne assumed her mother's identity," Zak told AFP.

Zak, a member of the Moscow Society of Naturalists at Moscow State University, recently published his report called "Jeanne Calment: the Secret of Longevity" on ResearchGate, a portal connecting scientists around the world.

While opponents have slammed the report, some scientists have welcomed it and stressed the need for closer checks into longevity records.

Zak suggests that in 1934 it was not Calment's daughter Yvonne who died of pleurisy, as official records say, but Jeanne Calment herself. Yvonne then took on her mother's identity in order to avoid paying inheritance tax.

If that is so, the woman who died in 1997 was in fact Yvonne, and she was aged just 99.

Wacky Guinness World Records (2017 edition)
Wacky Guinness World Records (2017 edition) 12 photos

The Russian researcher points to discrepancies between physical characteristics listed on Calment's identity card from the 1930s and her appearance in later years.

The card gives her eye colour as dark and her height as 1 metre, 52 centimetres and describes her forehead as low — all details that jar with her later appearance.

"As a doctor I always had doubts about her age," said Novoselov, who heads the gerontology section of the Moscow Society of Naturalists.

"The state of her muscle system was different from that of her contemporaries. She could sit up without any support. She had no signs of dementia."

After Calment's death, scientists expressed regret that no autopsy was held to find the reasons for her exceptional longevity.

She used to talk of enjoying chocolate and port and would smoke an occasional cigarette before her health deteriorated.

Fuelling suspicions, Calment ordered some of her old photos to be burnt when she became famous, the Russian researchers say.

Interviewed by AFP, French demographer and gerontologist Jean-Marie Robine, who took part in authenticating Calment's age for Guinness World Records, said he "never had any doubt over the authenticity of the documents" of the woman.

He slammed the Russian report, saying it "never examines the facts in favour of the authenticity of the longevity of Madame Calment" and "appears to me to be defamatory against her family."

The mayor of Arles at the time of Calment's death, Michel Vauzelle, said that the Russians' theory was "completely impossible and ridiculous" since Calment was monitored by a number of doctors.

But others welcomed the research.

"The idea of assumed identity had already been considered by those validating (the claim) and I regularly invited demographers to hold onto this hypothesis," said Nicolas Brouard, research director at France's Institut National d'Etudes Demographiques (INED).

"It's good that Nikolai Zak has carried out research that is independent and covers the same area of investigation. It's a very good piece of work and an argument in favour of exhuming the bodies of Jeanne and Yvonne Calment," he said.

DNA testing would be able to finally settle the debate, he said.

Belgian demographer Michel Poulain, of the University of Louvain, welcomed what he called "quite a detailed investigation" that he said shows the need for further scientific research "to validate the exceptional age of these supercentenarians" — those older than 110.

"The probability of an erroneous age increases exponentially with presumed age," he said.

Zak came up with the idea of investigating Calment's life while creating a mathematical model of the lifespan of supercentenarians.

"The more I searched, the more contradictions I found," he said.

In a book published in 1997 titled "Insurance and its Secrets", he found a short passage about Calment that supported the idea that her daughter took on her identity.

The book's author, Jean-Pierre Daniel, wrote that an insurance investigator looking into a life annuity taken out by Jeanne Calment had already concluded that fraud took place.

"But at the time Jeanne Calment was already considered a national heroine. That official asked his bosses about it and they told him to keep on paying out the annuity. There was no question of creating a scandal over the doyenne of the French," he told AFP.

Gerontologist Novoselov argues that question marks over Calment's true age are damaging to his field since "for gerontologists, Jeanne Calment is a symbol. Her name is cited in all the studies… For research to advance, we need to show the true boundaries of the chessboard".

Members of Calment's extended family did not respond to requests for comment from AFP.

If Calment's record were to be cancelled, the new record-holder would be American Sarah Knauss, who died at 119 in 1999.

First published on January 2, 2019

© 2019 AFP. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

gettyimages-51992530.jpg Wacky Guinness World Records (2017 edition)

U.S. fires tear gas across border to stop migrants, including children

Customs and Border Protection says agents saw "toddler sized children" being passed over concertina wire with difficulty

updated 15M ago

Intelligence Matters: A CBS News original national security podcast

"Intelligence Matters" is a weekly podcast about national security and policy hosted by CBS News senior national security contributor Michael Morell

1H ago

Transcript: Lisa Monaco with Michael Morell on "Intelligence Matters"

Former White House counterterrorism chief Lisa Monaco talks with Morell about terror threat that's "getting worse"

1H ago

Terror threat is "getting worse" says Lisa Monaco

On the "Intelligence Matters" podcast this week, former White House counterterrorism chief Lisa Monaco warns risks of radicalization for potential domestic terrorists may be increasing

1H ago

Haitian girl, suspected migrant smuggler missing off Florida coast

9-year-old was among 11 people on an inflatable boat that capsized about 50 miles from the coast during an apparent smuggling effort

2H ago

Intelligence Matters: A CBS News original national security podcast

"Intelligence Matters" is a weekly podcast about national security and policy hosted by CBS News senior national security contributor Michael Morell

1H ago

Transcript: Lisa Monaco with Michael Morell on "Intelligence Matters"

Former White House counterterrorism chief Lisa Monaco talks with Morell about terror threat that's "getting worse"

1H ago

Terror threat is "getting worse" says Lisa Monaco

On the "Intelligence Matters" podcast this week, former White House counterterrorism chief Lisa Monaco warns risks of radicalization for potential domestic terrorists may be increasing

1H ago

Mitt Romney slams Trump days before being sworn into Senate

Although Romney is critical of Mr. Trump in the editorial, he also writes that he will follow the leadership of Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell

6H ago

Trump invites congressional leaders to White House

Democratic congressional aides expressed skepticism about the briefing, saying the agenda for the session is unclear

16H ago

New details on former U.S. Marine accused of spying in Russia

Paul Whelan's brother is rejecting the claim that the Michigan man detained in Russia is a spy

updated 3M ago

Researchers claim world record for longest life a case of ID fraud

Russian mathematician says Frenchwoman was dead long before she supposedly passed away in 1997 at the age of 122

updated 19M ago

U.S. fires tear gas across border to stop migrants, including children

Customs and Border Protection says agents saw "toddler sized children" being passed over concertina wire with difficulty

updated 15M ago

Chinese leader vows to stop "any sort of Taiwan independence"

But Taiwan's president rejects China's insistence on "one country, two systems" unification

1H ago

Netflix nixes U.S. satire in Saudi Arabia "to comply with local law"

Streaming giant takes heat for removal of "Patriot Act with Hasan Minhaj" episode in which comedian lashes crown prince over journalist's murder

4H ago

Netflix nixes U.S. satire in Saudi Arabia "to comply with local law"

Streaming giant takes heat for removal of "Patriot Act with Hasan Minhaj" episode in which comedian lashes crown prince over journalist's murder

4H ago

Madonna gives surprise New Year's Eve concert at historic Stonewall Inn

Madonna performed with "Can't Help Falling in Love" and "Like a Prayer" with her son, David Banda, playing guitar

12H ago

Jimmy Osmond suffers stroke after U.K. performance

Osmond was playing Captain Hook in a performance of Peter Pan

18H ago

"Nervous" Roger Federer faces Serena Williams for 1st time

"People talk about her serve so much and I see why it is such a wonderful serve because you just can't read it," Federer said

20H ago

Jon Batiste: "You can't sit on the sidelines"

The "Late Show" band leader says his response to the current times is not anger or disappointment, but to find true joy in music

23H ago

NASA spacecraft survives historic trip to world 4 billion miles away

New Horizons zooms past the celestial object known as Ultima Thule 3 ½ years after its spectacular brush with Pluto

17H ago

Report: China completes antenna 5 times the size of NYC

The Wireless Electromagnetic Method project was built on a site nearly five times the size of New York City

Dec 31, 2018

Retail revolution brings robot restaurants, car vending machines to China

Companies are re-engineering their businesses to cater to consumers who rely on smartphones for pretty much everything

Dec 31, 2018

New Horizons space probe closes in for historic encounter

NASA's New Horizons probe is racing toward the most distant space object ever explored, 4.1 billion miles from Earth

Dec 31, 2018

New augmented reality technology could help firefighters save lives

Operating in pitch-black, smoke-filled rooms may become less dangerous with the help of special cameras and computer programs built into the C-Thru firefighter's mask

Dec 31, 2018

Pets burned in California's Camp Fire get relief with fish-skin treatments

The skin has been used to treat bears and mountain lions in the past

12H ago

Top health stories to watch for in 2019

From a mysterious polio-like illness affecting kids to 3D-printing human organs, here are some medical stories to keep an eye on

19H ago

5 popular hangover cures, reviewed by experts

From black coffee to a hair of the dog – here's the science behind popular hangover remedies

Jan 1

Judge lets Obamacare stand during appeal process

Judge Reed O'Connor said he stands by his conclusion that the law is invalidated by congressional repeal of its fines on people who remain uninsured

Dec 30, 2018

Doctor possibly exposed to Ebola brought to U.S. for treatment

The doctor had been providing medical assistance in the Democratic Republic of Congo, where over 300 people have died in the latest Ebola outbreak

Dec 29, 2018

Stocks end the year down in worst decline since 2008

Investors endured the worst year for stocks since the recession — here's what experts say is in store for 2019

Dec 31, 2018

Opportunity in America, 10 years after the financial crisis

This week's "Where Did You Get This Number?" podcast explores the impact of the financial crisis on how people deal with money, plus opportunity in the digital economy and income in America

Dec 31, 2018

Stocks climb amid renewed hopes for U.S.-China trade deal

Despite President Trump's optimism over trade dispute, stocks are limping into 2019 amid growth fears

Dec 31, 2018

5 New Year’s resolutions for working boomers

Here are critical steps that will improve your retirement prospects and — best part — can be easy to achieve

Dec 31, 2018

Retail revolution brings robot restaurants, car vending machines to China

Companies are re-engineering their businesses to cater to consumers who rely on smartphones for pretty much everything

Dec 31, 2018

"He fired at us for no reason": Mother of slain 7-year-old recalls shooting

Jazmine Barnes was killed after a gunman in a pickup truck pulled up next to the car she was in and started shooting

12H ago

Kids in 2 states wounded by possible New Year's "celebratory" gunfire

A nine-year-old boy in Georgia and a six-year-old girl in California were both wounded by stray bullets overnight

17H ago

Mother killed over $35 manicure at Las Vegas nail salon

Las Vegas police search for a woman accused of using a stolen car to run over and kill a nail salon worker after failing to pay for a $35 manicure

22H ago

Elizabeth Smart responds to news her kidnapper lives near school

Wanda Barzee, who helped kidnap Smart, is listed in sex-offender registry as living near Parkview Elementary School in Utah

22H ago

Search for gunman who killed 7-year-old girl riding in car with family

Jazmine Barnes was killed when a man in a red pickup truck pulled up next to her family's car and opened fire Sunday

Dec 31, 2018