Trump EPA orders rollback of Obama mercury regulations

/ AP

WASHINGTON — The Trump administration has targeted an Obama-era regulation credited with helping dramatically reduce toxic mercury pollution from coal-fired power plants, saying the benefits to human health and the environment may not be worth the cost of the regulation.

The 2011 Obama administration rule, called the Mercury and Air Toxics Standards, led to what electric utilities say was an $18 billion clean-up of mercury and other toxins from the smokestacks of coal-fired power plants.

Overall, environmental groups say, federal and state efforts have cut mercury emissions from coal-fired power plants by 85 percent in roughly the last decade.

Mercury causes brain damage, learning disabilities and other birth defects in children, among other harm. Coal power plants in this country are the largest single manmade source of mercury pollutants, which enters the food chain through fish and other items that people consume.

The proposal Friday from the Environmental Protection Agency challenges the basis for the Obama regulation. It calculates that the crackdown on mercury and other toxins from coal plants produced only a few million dollars a year in measurable health benefits and was not "appropriate and necessary" — a legal benchmark under the country's landmark Clean Air Act.

The proposal, which now goes up for public comment before any final administration approval, would leave the current mercury regulation in place.

However, the EPA said it will seek comment during a 60-day public-review period on whether "we would be obligated to rescind" the Obama-era rule if the agency adopts Friday's finding that the regulation was not appropriate and necessary. Any such change would trigger new rounds in what have already been years of court battles over regulating mercury pollution from coal plants.

This move is the latest by the Trump administration that changes estimates of the costs and payoffs of regulations as part of an overhaul of Obama-era environmental protections.

It's also the administration's latest proposed move on behalf of the U.S. coal industry, which has been struggling in the face of competition from natural gas and other cheaper, cleaner forms of energy. The Trump administration in August proposed an overhaul for another Obama-era regulation that would have prodded electricity providers to get less of their energy from dirtier-burning coal plants.

In a statement, the EPA said Friday the administration was "providing regulatory certainty" by more accurately estimating the costs and benefits of the Obama administration crackdown on mercury and other toxic emissions from smokestacks.

Hal Quinn, head of the National Mining Association, charged in a statement Friday that the Obama administration had carried out "perhaps the largest regulatory accounting fraud perpetrated on American consumers" when it calculated that the broad health benefits to Americans would outweigh the cost of equipment upgrades by power providers.

Sen. Tom Carper of Delaware, the top Democrat on the Senate's Environment and Public Works Committee, condemned the Trump administration's move. He said the EPA has "decided to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory" after the successful clean-up of toxins from the country's coal-plant smokestacks.

He and other opponents of the move said the Trump administration was playing with numbers, ignoring what Carper said were clear health, environmental and economic benefits to come up with a bottom line that suited the administration's deregulatory aims.

Janet McCabe, a former air-quality official in the Obama administration's EPA, called the proposal part of "the quiet dismantling of the regulatory framework" for the federal government's environmental protections.

Coming one week into a government shutdown, and in the lull between Christmas and New Year, "this low-key announcement shouldn't fool anyone — it is a big deal, with significant implications," McCabe said.

First published on December 29, 2018

© 2018 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Trump EPA orders rollback of Obama mercury regulations

"It is a big deal, with significant implications," said a former air-quality official in the Obama administration's EPA

updated 9M ago

Top trending health questions of 2018

This year, people turned to Google to answer their questions about the keto diet, ALS, endometriosis, and more

updated 31M ago

Mega Millions winning numbers for $370M jackpot

There hasn't been a winner since the massive $1.5 billion jackpot in October

6H ago

Strong undersea quake reported near Philippines

The Pacific Tsunami Warning Center lifted its warning for a potential tsunami that could hit coastal areas of the southern Philippine and Indonesia

5H ago

Washington EMS says 911 capabilities restored throughout state

A number of police and fire agencies said earlier that callers dialing 911 received a fast busy signal

8H ago

How a former CIA officer was caught betraying his country

The officials who investigated and convicted Kevin Mallory for conspiracy to commit espionage tell 60 Minutes how their case came together

Dec 23

Inside the corruption allegations plaguing Malta

The smallest nation in the European Union is earning an unsavory reputation, with a series of scandals involving allegations of bribery, cronyism and money laundering

Dec 23

The lawsuits that could bankrupt the opioid industry

The attorney behind a multibillion-dollar tobacco settlement in 1998 has turned his attention to the opioid epidemic. And he wants drug companies to pay

Dec 17

Cleaning up the plastic in the ocean

Discarded plastic is piling up around the world and pooling in the ocean. Sharyn Alfonsi reports on the problem's deadly consequences for wildlife and what can be done to stop it

Dec 16

Tesla CEO Elon Musk: The "60 Minutes" interview

Musk opens up to Lesley Stahl about Twitter, pot, the Securities and Exchange Commission, Model 3 and Tesla

Dec 9

Study examines effects of screen time on kids

"60 Minutes" goes inside a landmark government study of young minds to see if phones, tablets and other screens are impacting adolescent brain development

Dec 10

Ryan Speedo Green: From juvenile delinquency to opera stardom

After a childhood of anger and violence, the 32-year-old now commands the stage around the world

Dec 9

Remembering President George H.W. Bush

Former presidents and others look back on the life of President George H.W. Bush, who passed away Friday

Dec 2

Right Rail – Video Promo – Listing

Suspected cop killer caught after manhunt

The accused gunman in the fatal shooting of a police officer in California surrendered on Friday nearly 200 miles from the scene of the crime, according to authorities. Investigators say the suspect, in the country illegally, was trying to escape back to Mexico. Mireya Villarreal reports.

12H ago 02:52

At least 2 deaths blamed on dangerous weather

Millions in the Midwest and Southwest are digging out, while people in the rain-drenched South are mopping up from flooding. The dangerous weather is blamed for at least two deaths in Kansas and Louisiana. Mark Strassmann reports.

9H ago 01:58

Trump threatens to close U.S.-Mexico border

On the seventh day of the partial government shutdown, President Trump threatened to shut down the border with Mexico if Democrats refuse his demands for money to build a long-promised wall. We learned, however, that the president has lowered his asking price. Paula Reid reports.

9H ago 02:16

Report on Parkland finds failures to warn

Ten months after the massacre at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Florida, we're seeing for the first time video from the school's interior security cameras. The Sun Sentinel newspaper obtained the video as part of its investigation into the shooting that killed 17 people. Manuel Bojorquez reports.

9H ago 01:57

America's oldest veteran dies at 112

Born in 1906, Richard Overton lived to be 112 years old. Although he received many honors, he didn't consider himself a hero. He attributed his longevity to whiskey and cigars. James Brown reports.

11H ago 01:41

Trump EPA orders rollback of Obama mercury regulations

"It is a big deal, with significant implications," said a former air-quality official in the Obama administration's EPA

updated 9M ago

Drones to surveil Times Square on New Year's

With New Year’s Eve just two days away, police in New York City are beefing up security to prepare for the annual celebration. Officials say as many as two million people could pack into Times Square to ring in 2019 for the famous New Year’s ball drop. Kenneth Craig reports.

updated 1M ago 02:17

Sheriff blames sanctuary laws for cop's death

A California sheriff is blaming immigration laws for the murder of a police officer. Gustavo Perez Arriaga, who was in the country illegally, was arrested Friday following a two-day manhunt. He's accused of killing a police officer during a DUI stop. Mireya Villarreal reports.

updated 4M ago 02:18

Trump lowers his ask for border wall funding

As more agencies run out of funding, President Trump is now also threatening to close the border with Mexico if Democrats refuse his demand for money to build a wall along the southern border. Mr. Trump has lowered his asking price. Democrats plan to pass legislation to try to restore the government when they take control of the House on Thursday. Nikole Killion reports.

updated 5M ago 02:34

Eye Opener

Why the sheriff in the case is blaming immigration laws for the heartbreaking murder. Also, a series of deadly winter storms cross the country, hitting millions of Americans with everything from heavy snow to flooding rains. All that and all that matters in today's Eye Opener. Your world in 90 seconds. <a href="" target="_blank"><u>Get the Eye Opener delivered straight to your inbox.</u></a>

updated 6M ago 02:05

Top trending health questions of 2018

This year, people turned to Google to answer their questions about the keto diet, ALS, endometriosis, and more

updated 31M ago

Notable deaths in 2018

A look back at the esteemed personalities who've left us this year, who touched us with their innovation, creativity and humanity

Dec 27 140 photos

Biggest stories of 2018, ranked

This year was a doozy. These were the top stories on

Dec 6 55 photos

Yemen's humanitarian crisis

The nation's civil war has claimed at least 10,000 lives, and generated the world's worst humanitarian crisis

Dec 17 24 photos

The timeless photojournalism of Chris Hondros and Tim Hetherington

"War and Peace in Liberia" is a new exhibition in New York City celebrating the work of two acclaimed war photographers, who were both killed in conflict zones

Dec 9 15 photos

2018 additions to the Library of Congress' National Film Registry

"The Shining," "Jurassic Park," "My Fair Lady" and "Brokeback Mountain" are among the classic films to be preserved for future generations by the Library of Congress

Dec 12 27 photos

Social worker known for being frugal left $11 million to charities

He repaired his shoes with duct tape and bought clothes from the grocery story

11H ago

Thanks for the help of a loving neighbor

For many people flooded out of their homes in and around Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, the most welcoming port in the storm has been a total stranger. Jaret Hucks, who owns the Midtown Inn and Cottages, has given away almost a thousand free nights to this community's poorest and most vulnerable evacuees. Steve Hartman revisits the story he first reported earlier this fall, and about a new flood that followed.

Nov 25 02:13

Mom in labor walks across graduation stage

After completing her midterms and finals in the hospital, she wanted to walk across stage in person to "show people it could be done"

15H ago