Rising interest rates? Not for savers
By Kathy Kristof
The Federal Reserve has been hiking interest rates for the past two years, but Americans who have been anxiously waiting for higher returns on their savings deposits have been left high and dry.
Even though the Fed's benchmark interest rate — the so-called fed funds rate, the rate at which banks borrow from other banks — has risen from near zero to 2.5 percent, average savings rates remain in the basement. Traditional banks are paying roughly 0.22 percent on savings and money market deposit accounts, said Greg McBride, chief financial analyst for BankRate.com, a consumer information and rate-shopping site.
Normally, consumer deposits command about 50 percent of the fed funds rate, according to G. Michael Moebs, economist and chief executive of bank consulting firm Moebs Services. That would mean rates in the 1.25 percent range today — about 80 percent more than consumers are actually getting for deposits at big banks, he said.
Blame it on scant loan demand
Why are savers locked out? Supply and demand. And in this case, it's because loan demand simply isn't strong enough for banks — at least big banks — to push lending rates higher, which in turn would boost deposit rates as bank profits climb from lending, said Moebs. Internet-based banks are an exception. Many are paying more than the industry norm.
To make sense of it all, let's take a step back.
Remember the scene in "It's a Wonderful Life" where George Bailey tries to quell a run on the Bailey Brothers Building and Loan by explaining where depositors' money has gone? That is, indeed, how banks and thrifts operate: They take in deposits at one rate of interest, and turn around and loan out that cash at a higher rate, making a profit on the margin between the two.
However, Bailey's Building and Loan was loaning money largely to homeowners who needed mortgages, but big banks typically use their deposits to finance commercial loans to businesses.
Demand for commercial loans is currently tepid. Experts cite several reasons. First, when interest rates were at record lows, many big companies issued long-term bonds. Bonds are essentially IOUs — you invest a set amount, and the bond issuer promises to pay you interest at a set annual rate and pay back the principal at some point in the future.
But because interest rates were so low, even companies that didn't have an immediate need for the cash issued bonds to create a pool of funds to finance future growth rather than borrow the money from banks.
Burned by the Great Recession
Smaller companies didn't do that, but they also aren't spending fast enough to push up loan demand. Why? The lessons of the Great Recession are still fresh in their minds, McBride said.
"Most companies aren't comfortable sticking their necks out and taking risk because the scars of 2008 are still visible," he said. "No one wants to be sitting on a warehouse full of inventory that they can't move."
Meanwhile, gathering sufficient deposits to finance existing loan demand is easy for big, national banks because their ubiquitous branch systems and automated teller systems act as giant catcher's mitts, gathering up trillions in consumer deposits, McBride said.
Internet-based banks are another story. Without massive branch systems and ATM networks, these banks have both lower costs (fewer offices and employees to pay) and a greater need to woo depositors. Consequently, many pay as much as 10 times more for deposits than traditional banks that support expensive branch networks.
"You've got to be very selective about where you put your savings to get the best return," said McBride. "Most banks are very stingy with their payouts."
First published on December 20, 2018
© 2018 CBS Interactive Inc.. All Rights Reserved.
View all articles by Kathy Kristof on CBS MoneyWatch»
Kathy Kristof, editor of SideHusl.com, is an award-winning financial journalist and the author of Investing 101.
Rising interest rates? Not for savers
Even as the Fed keeps hiking, rates on savings accounts at big banks remain in the basement
updated 3M ago
Dow falls below 23,000 for first time in 14 months
After years of easy money, investors are spooked by rising interest rates and slowing U.S. growth
updated 5M ago
Experts: Don't send sensitive info on Facebook Messenger
"I would not trust Facebook with any of my information in a million years," one cybersecurity expert told CBS News
updated 18M ago
Holiday spending leaves many renters in the red
New Yorkers wind up in a $4,200 hole on average, while Seattle renters still have $1,700 after Santa is long gone
Counting on a tax refund? You may owe this year, IRS says
The tax bill signed by Donald Trump last year may create an unwelcome surprise for some taxpayers in April
Apple reveals new, bigger, pricier iPhones and Apple Watch
World's most valuable company unveiled three iPhones, an updated Apple Watch and a new "giveback" program
5 great new car deals you can get now
As the 2018 model year nears its end, big rebates and good lease deals are plentiful — here are some of the best
6 of the safest cars on the road
These are the latest new cars to earn the highest rating from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety
Mark Zuckerberg grilled over data scandal
EU lawmakers question Mark Zuckerberg about Facebook's role in Cambridge Analytica scandal
Russian trolls' standout Facebook ads
Lawmakers released all 3,000-plus ads connected to the Russian Internet Agency, some of which ran through the summer of 2017