Wildfires may soon be uninsurable risks for homeowners
By Ed Leefeldt
updated / MoneyWatch
Homeowners in wildfire-prone areas of California and other Western states now have yet another worry: Insurers have issued an ominous warning that they could be facing a "wildfire deductible" in coming years or, even worse, the prospect of having their home insurance canceled altogether.
The surprising scenario came in part from Aon, the largest insurance broker in the U.S., where meteorologist Steve Bowen pointed out that fire losses have exceeded $10 billion for the second year running. In California, the Camp Fire alone has killed 86 people and damaged or destroyed nearly 20,000 homes.
House fires of almost any kind have traditionally been covered under home insurance policies — no questions asked. But "risks that were once insurable … will become uninsurable," said Birny Birnbaum, executive director of the Center for Economic Justice. "Insurers have long excluded wind in coastal states and earthquake and flood everywhere from homeowners' policies."
Perils such as hurricanes, earthquakes and flooding are what insurers consider "primary" risks, which puts them in a category of being insurable only under special circumstances. Earthquakes generally require a separate policy or a separate endorsement. Flood insurance is handled by the federal government (although surplus carriers will insure above the federal minimum). But home fires have always been "secondary" risks.
"The standard assumption of wildfire being a 'secondary' peril may evolve in the future," Aon's Bowen said. He added that this "may lead to a shift in mindset that causes industries [like insurers] to alter their view of fire risk."
Consumer advocates such as Bob Hunter, director of insurance for the Consumer Federation of America, said the intent is clear. With wildfires now graduating to the highest level of peril for insurers, they're going to react accordingly — by running away, raising rates whenever possible or inserting "deductibles" in their contracts so they pay out less and put more burden on policyholders.
Worldwide, fires and explosions account for nearly a quarter of the value of all insurance claims, according to Allianz Global.
Are insurers' current losses from conflagrations like the Camp Fire bad enough to cause serious economic losses for insurers? No, said Amy Bach, executive director of San Francisco-based United Policyholders. Property-casualty insurers now have a huge "policyholders' surplus," the amount of money available to pay claims, of nearly $760 billion, the highest in history.
But that doesn't mean they want to lose money in the future, especially as the wildfire danger from climate change, drought and unmanaged forests increases in states like California. If the current problems continue and grow, "there will be a strain on both public and private insurance," predicted Birnbaum.
Penalized for not clearing brush
"Insurers have been very aggressive in limiting coverage in the past, and I see what Aon is doing as trying to get out in front of this problem in the future," said Bach. Some insurers appear to be not waiting even for a month to go by before taking action.
One letter from a Woodland Hills, California, insurance agency informed a homeowner earlier this year that his insurer was adding "a 20 percent wildfire deductible" to his policy based on a survey showing that he hadn't cleared brush 150 feet from his house.
Allstate, the second-largest home insurer, sparked concern when it said on its website that some policies may exclude coverage for wildfire. "Coverage may vary by geographic location and by policy," Allstate said.
Farmers, also a major home insurer, issued an "Amendatory Endorsement" limiting liability for "Wild Fire Smoke, Soot, Char, Ash, Odor Damage," particularly if it was "not visible to the unaided human eye."
Will more restrictions appear in the future? Probably. Home insurers are likely to take several approaches to limiting coverage.
Desirable — but vulnerable — areas
Advocates for the industry are quick to point out that this won't affect all 40 million Californians, such as those who live in urban areas. But it will cost people who live in rural or "wildlife-urban interface areas," where tree lines and brush meet development and tract homes in hilly areas. These are the very areas where many city-dwelling Californians want to escape to and live.
One insurance solution is to simply abandon areas that have already seen a major fire, like the ill-named town of Paradise in Butte County and also in Ventura County, where the Woolsey fire destroyed 2,000 homes and killed three people at almost the same time as Paradise went up in flames.
By law, insurers are required to write one renewal after a declared disaster, according to Madison Voss, deputy press secretary for the California Department of Insurance. After that, however, "the Department doesn't have the authority to require insurance companies to write … in a particular area," Voss said.
That would throw hundreds of thousands, perhaps millions, of Californians onto the state's FAIR plan, a "last resort" insurance vehicle for the otherwise uninsurable. An alternative, although not always a good one, is to get home insurance with a "non-admitted carrier." That's an insurer who isn't licensed in California but can still sell there. The downside: If the carrier goes bankrupt, homeowners can't get a bailout from the state, as they did when Merced Property & Casualty recently became insolvent.
Adding wildfire deductibles
Given their huge resources, insurers seldom declare bankruptcy. Far more likely is that others will follow the lead of carriers who have already started to add wildfire deductibles. Wind deductibles are common in hurricane-prone areas such as New York and New Jersey, and since California fires are often wind-driven, that's a likely course of action for insurers there.
They're also likely to insist that anyone in a fire-prone area such as Hidden Valley Lake, California, join with neighbors in a community cleanup effort to remove brush from their surroundings. "We clean our lots by June 15," said resident Janet Ruiz. "The homeowners association checks, and if not, they hire someone and charge the homeowner."
A wildfire there in 2015 damaged or destroyed 100 homes, but it could have been a lot worse, Ruiz said. Building codes governing fire resistance for new housing, already strict in the state, are likely to be enforced to the letter, she said.
Ruiz, who works for the Insurance Information Institute, a group that represents property insurers, said insurers don't necessarily want to charge more. But they will, if California and other dry Western states continue catching fire. It's partly a matter of education and the hard work of cutting down dead trees and clearing brush.
Some of that may be in the control of homeowners and insurers. "But chronic climate risk is the creeping change" that worries all companies, warned Greg Lowe, global head of resilience at Aon. And that goes far beyond what happens in anyone's immediate surroundings.
First published on December 13, 2018
© 2018 CBS Interactive Inc.. All Rights Reserved.
Ed Leefeldt is an award-winning investigative and business journalist who has worked for Reuters, Bloomberg and Dow Jones, and contributed to the Wall Street Journal and the New York Times. He is also the author of The Woman Who Rode the Wind, a novel about early flight.
How much did the 2008 financial crisis cost you in dollars?
A decade after the Great Recession, the U.S. economy still hasn't made up the ground it lost
America's highest-paying jobs
The top-paying jobs tend to cluster in two industries — and may prove less vulnerable automation
Parasailers recount dramatic rescue of pilot after fighter jet crashes
A group of parasailers in a nearby boat witnessed the chaos unfold and immediately took action
Teen fatally shoots himself inside Indiana middle school
Tipster credited with helping police prevent students, teachers from being harmed during shooting at Indiana middle school
Officer sucker punches man in video released by whistleblower cop
The Miami Beach police department has called the Dec. 3 incident "very serious" and says it's investigating
Human heart left on Southwest plane forces pilot to turn around
According to Southwest, the "life-critical cargo shipment" was for a hospital
Sneak peek: FindJodi
More than two decades after an Iowa TV anchor disappeared, "48 Hours" reveals new information into the investigation. Jim Axelrod investigates Saturday, Dec. 15 at 10/9c on CBS.
6H ago 03:46
Embattled deputy claims he had no duty to confront school gunman
Video shows Scot Peterson, the only armed officer at the Parkland high school, remained outside while shots rang out
Remains found in basement solve decades-old mystery of missing dad
Michael Carroll said he was a baby when his father disappeared in 1961
9 killed, dozens hurt as train hits locomotive, overpass in Turkey
High-speed train was traveling through station in Turkey's capital, Ankara; at least 2 cars derailed and parts of overpass fell onto train
Tariffs cast a shadow on U.S. solar industry
It says around $8 billion in utility-scale projects have been frozen or canceled, costing some 9,000 American jobs
Waymo's self-driving cars have faced slashed tires, thrown rocks
Autonomous vehicles in Arizona have been involved in incidents including slashed tires and thrown rocks
Boy Scouts, facing sexual abuse suits, may declare bankruptcy
Organization considering "all options" as it grapples with declining membership and rising legal costs
Half of America hasn't recovered from the recession
All of the businesses created in the U.S. since 2007 can fit in five counties, a sign of the nation's widening geographic gap
Del Monte recalls canned corn for botulism risk
Walmart and Target among retailers that sold incompletely sterilized food that could cause life-threatening illness
Apple reveals new, bigger, pricier iPhones and Apple Watch
World's most valuable company unveiled three iPhones, an updated Apple Watch and a new "giveback" program
5 great new car deals you can get now
As the 2018 model year nears its end, big rebates and good lease deals are plentiful — here are some of the best
6 of the safest cars on the road
These are the latest new cars to earn the highest rating from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety
Mark Zuckerberg grilled over data scandal
EU lawmakers question Mark Zuckerberg about Facebook's role in Cambridge Analytica scandal
Russian trolls' standout Facebook ads
Lawmakers released all 3,000-plus ads connected to the Russian Internet Agency, some of which ran through the summer of 2017