Oklahoma judge upholds 72-hour waiting period for women seeking abortions
By Kate Smith
/ CBS News
A judge in Oklahoma on Tuesday upheld a law that requires a 72-hour waiting period for women seeking abortions, the latest in a wave of state-level legislation that restricts access to abortion. Prior to the ruling, Oklahoma already had among the most restrictive laws for abortion access.
The nearly 70,000-square-mile state has only four abortion clinics, according to the Guttmacher Institute, a research organization focused on reproductive health. By comparison, there are 50 in Washington, a similarly sized state.
Women seeking an abortion in Oklahoma must undergo counseling with "information designed to discourage her from having an abortion," according to Guttmacher. After that, the 72-hour waiting period begins. Women under the age of 18 must also receive parental or guardian consent.
Because there are only four clinics in the state, women could have to travel up to four-and-a-half hours for their first appointment only to drive back home during the waiting period. Because of this, the law disproportionately impact low-income, rural families, said Elizabeth Nash, a senior states-issue manager at Guttmacher, in an email to CBS News.
"Waiting periods are designed to create delays," Nash said. "Patients may have to delay the appointment because of logistics such as getting time off of work, arranging travel and child care."
In November 2015, Oklahoma passed a measure that increased the mandatory wait time to 72 hours from 24. The legislation was immediately challenged by the Center for Reproductive Rights, an international women's advocacy group. Tuesday's ruling declined the Center's request.
"This patronizing law implies that women are not good decision makers," said Autumn Katz, a staff attorney at the Center for Reproductive Rights, in an email to CBS News. "Oklahoma politicians are telling women that they don't know what's best for themselves."
Oklahoma Attorney General Michael Hunter praised the judge's decision: "Studies have shown that women who have the benefit of a reflection period like this change their minds in a significant percentage of cases, saving precious unborn lives," Hunter wrote in a press release shared with CBS News.
"Waiting period laws are unnecessary because studies show that over 90% of patients have made up their mind before making the appointment for the abortion," Nash said, disagreeing with Hunter. "The idea that a patient hasn't thought through the decision and needs a period of reflection is simply false."
While other state-level measures aimed at limiting abortion access have been deemed unconstitutional, mandatory waiting periods have had success in the courts. In 1992, the United State Supreme Court upheld a 24-hour waiting period that Pennsylvania had enacted. Since that decision, 27 other states, including Oklahoma, have created similar laws, with wait periods ranging from 72 hours down to 18 hours, according to Nash. Lawmakers in Louisiana, Missouri, North Carolina, South Dakota and Utah have passed laws requiring 72-hour waiting periods for women seeking abortions, though a federal judge has blocked Louisiana's measure.
"[The Oklahoma] court and many others have failed to recognize the significant burdens that mandatory delay laws impose on women," said Katz. "While these laws may not succeed in preventing women from obtaining an abortion altogether, they impose a variety of harms by stigmatizing women who seek abortion care."
Even though abortion is federally protected by Roe v. Wade, many states have taken steps to regulate the procedure. In ballot measures during the recent midterm elections, Alabama and West Virginia voters agreed on laws banning abortion coverage on state-funded insurance plans. Constituents in both states also voted to clarify that their state constitutions banned abortion, readying themselves for a potential overturning of Roe v. Wade overturn.
This month, a state senator in Oklahoma introduced the Abolition of Abortion in Oklahoma Act, which would criminalize abortion, making it akin to homicide and punishable by life in prison. It is unlikely to pass, said Nash.
"Oklahoma seems hellbent on coming up with new ways to ban abortion," said Nash. "It is also one of the states that other states look to for ideas for abortion restrictions."
First published on December 12, 2018
© 2018 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Paradise Lost: Inside California's Camp Fire
"60 Minutes" reveals what firefighters saw as the deadliest wildfire in California history destroyed the town of Paradise
Dec 2 
Biggest stories of 2018, ranked
This year was a doozy. These were the top stories on CBSNews.com
55 photos 
Sinatra the husky reunites with family months after tragic event
Mystery swirls over how this "Ol' Blue Eyes" was found 1,100 miles away in Florida
Nov 26 
Mark Meadows out of running for chief of staff
U.S. Rep. Mark Meadows of North Carolina is out of the running to be President Trump's next chief of staff. Niall Stanage, White House columnist for The Hill, joins CBSN to discuss the latest developments and the rest of the day's political headlines.
54M ago 09:02 
Changing the strategy for 2020 primary elections
When it come to presidential primary elections, all eyes are usually on Iowa and New Hampshire, but in 2020, California and Texas could attract almost as much attention. Gromer Jeffers, a political writer for the Dallas Morning News, and Dave Bryan, a political reporter for KCBS and KCAL, join CBSN's "Red and Blue" to discuss.
55M ago 05:49 
Uncle accused of 3-year-old's murder
A Kentucky father heard his 3-year-old daughter scream on baby monitor as her uncle slit her throat, the sheriff said. Relatives say the man has mental health problems.
1H ago 01:02 
Breast cancer linked to childbirth
New research suggests women who bear children are more susceptible to breast cancer than women who do not. Dr. Lauren Cassell, chief of breast surgery at Lenox Hospital in New York City, joins CBSN to discuss the new study.
2H ago 03:19 
Mother of missing Colorado woman says she spoke to her the day she disappeared
Kelsey Berreth was last seen on Thanksgiving
4H ago 
Blind swim coach relies on his hearing to help team improve
"I have to listen to several strokes and where they're hitting in correlation to where you're breathing"
4H ago 
Nancy Pelosi secures votes to be speaker again with term-limit deal
The Democratic leader and former speaker announced Wednesday evening she would serve a maximum of four more years as speaker
4H ago 
Michigan protesters call out alleged power grab by Republicans
Demonstrators crowded the capitol Wednesday afternoon, opposing moves by GOP statehouse majorities to limit the authority of just-elected Democrats
4H ago 
Retirement out of reach for millions
Tom Coomer, 80, is just one of nearly 10 million Americans over 65 still working. He was working as a machinist when his plant closed down, just one year shy of getting his full pension. CBS News correspondent Mark Strassmann has his story.
5H ago 03:32 
"I blame myself": Millions of Americans forced to hold off on retirement
"If I had planned harder when I was younger and if things had went better, I wouldn't be going to work this morning"
5H ago 
"CBSN: On Assignment" ep. 4: Hate Rising; Cyber Soldiers; Deadliest Assignment; Climate Refugees
Aug 21, 2017 
"CBSN: On Assignment" ep. 3: The Nightmare Scenario; Inside Instagram; Disappearing Down's; Risky Business
Aug 11, 2017 
"CBSN: On Assignment" ep. 2: Guns of Chicago; Enemy of the State; Muslims Love Me
Aug 4, 2017 
"CBSN: On Assignment" ep. 1: Children of ISIS; iRobot; Made in America*
Jul 31, 2017
Mark Meadows out of running for chief of staff
U.S. Rep. Mark Meadows of North Carolina is out of the running to be President Trump's next chief of staff. Niall Stanage, White House columnist for The Hill, joins CBSN to discuss the latest developments and the rest of the day's political headlines.
54M ago 09:02
Changing the strategy for 2020 primary elections
When it come to presidential primary elections, all eyes are usually on Iowa and New Hampshire, but in 2020, California and Texas could attract almost as much attention. Gromer Jeffers, a political writer for the Dallas Morning News, and Dave Bryan, a political reporter for KCBS and KCAL, join CBSN's "Red and Blue" to discuss.
55M ago 05:49
Uncle accused of 3-year-old's murder
A Kentucky father heard his 3-year-old daughter scream on baby monitor as her uncle slit her throat, the sheriff said. Relatives say the man has mental health problems.
1H ago 01:02 
12/12/18: Red and Blue
Former Trump lawyer heading to prison; changing the strategy for 2020
2H ago 50:26
Breast cancer linked to childbirth
New research suggests women who bear children are more susceptible to breast cancer than women who do not. Dr. Lauren Cassell, chief of breast surgery at Lenox Hospital in New York City, joins CBSN to discuss the new study.
2H ago 03:19 
IRS budget cuts benefit rich, report finds
The IRS is deteriorating after eight years of budget cuts, according to a ProPublica investigation, which found the agency's decline benefits the wealthy while hurting the poor. Paul Kiel co-authored the report, "How the IRS Was Gutted." He joins CBSN to discuss his reporting.
4H ago 06:28 
Doctors say embassy workers in Cuba had ear damage
American diplomats affected by mysterious health incidents in Cuba showed damage in the inner ear shortly after they complained of weird noises and sensations, according to their earliest medical exams publicized Wednesday. CBS News' Steve Dorsey reports.
4H ago 01:39 
Missing Marines in midair collision presumed dead
The Pentagon has released the names of five Marines who are now presumed dead after their plane collided with a fighter jet midair. CBSN's Tanya Rivero has more.
4H ago 00:34 
Theresa May survives no-confidence vote
British Prime Minister Theresa May is keeping her job. She won a secret-ballot vote Wednesday among members of her party, meaning she'll continue to fight for her plan to leave the European Union. CBS News' Tina Kraus reports from London.
4H ago 01:33
Mother of missing Colorado woman says she spoke to her the day she disappeared
Kelsey Berreth was last seen on Thanksgiving
4H ago 
Michael Cohen sentenced to 3 years in prison
The president's former longtime attorney has been sentenced for campaign finance violations and lying to Congress
9H ago 
National Enquirer owner admits to paying off Playboy model to protect Trump
The announcement came hours after former Trump attorney Michael Cohen was sentenced to three years in prison
8H ago 
Earthquake strikes eastern Tennessee, felt in Atlanta
Light earthquake in Tennessee occurred in early morning hours, could be felt in Atlanta
13H ago 
In first public comments in 3 months, Blasey Ford lauds abuse survivor
"Rachael Denhollander, I am in awe of you, and I will always be inspired by you," she said
12H ago 
Witnesses say Christmas market killer on loose shouted "Allahu Akbar"
Motive still unclear but 29-year-old suspect identified as Cherif Chekatt, a local resident and native Frenchman radicalized in prison
18H ago 
Tesla CEO Elon Musk: The "60 Minutes" interview
Musk opens up to Lesley Stahl about Twitter, pot, the Securities and Exchange Commission, Model 3 and Tesla
Dec 9 
Study examines effects of screen time on kids
"60 Minutes" goes inside a landmark government study of young minds to see if phones, tablets and other screens are impacting adolescent brain development
Dec 9 
Ryan Speedo Green: From juvenile delinquency to opera stardom
After a childhood of anger and violence, the 32-year-old now commands the stage around the world
Dec 9 
Remembering President George H.W. Bush
Former presidents and others look back on the life of President George H.W. Bush, who passed away Friday
Dec 2
Paradise Lost: Inside California's Camp Fire
"60 Minutes" reveals what firefighters saw as the deadliest wildfire in California history destroyed the town of Paradise
Dec 2 
The chaos behind family separation at the border
A "60 Minutes" investigation has found the separations that dominated headlines this summer began earlier and were greater in number than the Trump administration admits
Nov 26 
Robots to the rescue after nuclear disaster
Seven years after a powerful earthquake and tsunami caused a massive nuclear meltdown in the Daiichi Power Plant, Lesley Stahl reports on the unprecedented cleanup effort
Nov 25 
"To Kill a Mockingbird" comes to Broadway
With Aaron Sorkin writing the adaptation and Jeff Daniels starring as Atticus Finch, the Harper Lee classic hits the stage
Nov 25 
Naloxone: The life-saving drug more Americans need
With over 115 Americans dying a day in the opioid epidemic, naloxone has become a necessity for first responders, doctors and everyday people
Nov 18 
Right Rail – Video Promo – Listing
Michael Cohen sentenced to 3 years in prison
President Trump's former attorney Michael Cohen once said he would take a bullet for the president. Instead, he turned on him and pleaded guilty to nine counts in federal court. On Wednesday, he was sentenced to three years in prison. CBS News Washington correspondent Paula Reid has the latest.
5H ago 03:14 
Tesla's Elon Musk: What's changed in a decade
"60 Minutes" first met the visionary CEO in 2008 for a report on the race to make the electric car. Producer Shachar Bar-On explains.
Dec 9 04:15 
Manhunt for France terror suspect
An intense manhunt continues in France and Germany for the terror suspect who opened fire near a Christmas markey in Strasbourg. At least two people were killed. CBS News correspondent Roxana Saberi reports.
5H ago 01:34 
Michigan protests over alleged power grab
There were loud protests in Michigan on Wednesday over what many say is a last-minute power grab by Republicans. They're accused off trying to limit the authority of newly elected Democrats. CBS News correspondent Dean Reynolds reports.
5H ago 02:07
Retirement out of reach for millions
Tom Coomer, 80, is just one of nearly 10 million Americans over 65 still working. He was working as a machinist when his plant closed down, just one year shy of getting his full pension. CBS News correspondent Mark Strassmann has his story.
5H ago 03:32 
Latest From CBS News
Mark Meadows out of running for chief of staff
U.S. Rep. Mark Meadows of North Carolina is out of the running to be President Trump's next chief of staff. Niall Stanage, White House columnist for The Hill, joins CBSN to discuss the latest developments and the rest of the day's political headlines.
54M ago 09:02
Changing the strategy for 2020 primary elections
When it come to presidential primary elections, all eyes are usually on Iowa and New Hampshire, but in 2020, California and Texas could attract almost as much attention. Gromer Jeffers, a political writer for the Dallas Morning News, and Dave Bryan, a political reporter for KCBS and KCAL, join CBSN's "Red and Blue" to discuss.
55M ago 05:49
Uncle accused of 3-year-old's murder
A Kentucky father heard his 3-year-old daughter scream on baby monitor as her uncle slit her throat, the sheriff said. Relatives say the man has mental health problems.
1H ago 01:02
12/12/18: Red and Blue
Former Trump lawyer heading to prison; changing the strategy for 2020
2H ago 50:26
Breast cancer linked to childbirth
New research suggests women who bear children are more susceptible to breast cancer than women who do not. Dr. Lauren Cassell, chief of breast surgery at Lenox Hospital in New York City, joins CBSN to discuss the new study.
2H ago 03:19
IRS budget cuts benefit rich, report finds
The IRS is deteriorating after eight years of budget cuts, according to a ProPublica investigation, which found the agency's decline benefits the wealthy while hurting the poor. Paul Kiel co-authored the report, "How the IRS Was Gutted." He joins CBSN to discuss his reporting.
4H ago 06:28 
2018 additions to the Library of Congress' National Film Registry
"The Shining," "Jurassic Park," "My Fair Lady" and "Brokeback Mountain" are among the classic films to be preserved for future generations by the Library of Congress
27 photos 
The timeless photojournalism of Chris Hondros and Tim Hetherington
"War and Peace in Liberia" is a new exhibition in New York City celebrating the work of two acclaimed war photographers, who were both killed in conflict zones
15 photos 
Yemen's humanitarian crisis
The nation's civil war has claimed at least 10,000 lives, and generated the world's worst humanitarian crisis
15 photos 
Notable deaths in 2018
A look back at the esteemed personalities who've left us this year, who touched us with their innovation, creativity and humanity
133 photos 
Biggest stories of 2018, ranked
This year was a doozy. These were the top stories on CBSNews.com
55 photos 
Army veteran saves 5-year-old girl with leukemia
Four years after Mike Laureano returned from serving his country in Iraq, he stumbled upon another way to serve
10H ago 
Thanks for the help of a loving neighbor
For many people flooded out of their homes in and around Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, the most welcoming port in the storm has been a total stranger. Jaret Hucks, who owns the Midtown Inn and Cottages, has given away almost a thousand free nights to this community's poorest and most vulnerable evacuees. Steve Hartman revisits the story he first reported earlier this fall, and about a new flood that followed.
Nov 25 02:13 
Quadriplegic student walks across graduation stage using exoskeleton
"I feel so blessed to have been able to accomplish that milestone," says new college grad Aldo Amenta
20H ago 
Baby dolls stir emotions in Alzheimer's patients
The gift of a baby doll "revives a part of their memory from when they were parents … a lot of them just start crying," said one organizer of the nonprofit
Dec 11 
Man takes ailing dog on cross-country road trip for one last adventure
To make their last months together happy, Paul Heroux decided to take his dog Mura on a road trip — all 8,500 miles, just the two of them
Dec 10 
Man gives up first class seat for mom and sick baby
The mom, who was taking her daughter to the hospital, has reconnected with the man who made their flight special
Dec 10
