Patients discharged from hospital at the holidays face higher risk of death, study finds

By Ashley Welch

/ CBS News

Higher death risk if discharged in holidays

Nobody wants to spend the holidays in the hospital. But patients who are discharged from the hospital during the holidays have a higher risk of death or readmission, according to new research.

The study, published in The BMJ medical journal, found that people tend to be discharged more quickly at this time of year so they can be home with their families. Reduced staffing and lack of follow-up care may also play a role, the researchers say.

Previous studies have found patients admitted to the hospital on Fridays or during the weekends may face an increased risk of death compared with those admitted on weekdays. Known as the "weekend effect," experts believe the phenomenon may be due to a variety of factors such as decreased levels of staffing, less experienced staff, and delays in testing, although the direct cause has not been proven.

But until now, little research existed looking at the potential effects of the December holiday season on patient outcomes.

Researchers from Canada analyzed more than 200,000 cases of adults and children discharged from hospitals in Ontario during the two-week December holiday period, between 2002 and 2016. They compared these to more than 450,000 cases of patients discharged during two periods in November and January.

The analysis showed that those discharged during the December holiday period had a higher risk of death or readmission within the next seven, 14 and 30 days.

Additionally, those discharged during the holidays were 39 percent less likely to have a follow-up appointment within a week, perhaps letting problems linger and worsen.

Specifically, the researchers found that for every 100,000 patients, there were 26 more deaths, 188 additional re-hospitalizations, 483 extra visits to an emergency department and 2,999 fewer follow-ups associated with being discharged during the Christmas holiday period.

However, there were some exceptions. Sicker patients, such as those with lung disease, had a lower holiday-related risk of readmission and death than those without a similar chronic condition. The researchers suggest that this could be because "in a setting of reduced resources over the holiday, clinicians [may] prioritize higher risk patients".

The study authors say several factors likely play a role in their findings, including limited access to care, difficulty in booking appointments, and reduced levels of hospital staffing.

They also note that holiday festivities are also often accompanied by excessive drinking and eating, heightened emotional stress, and lack of sleep.

"These altered circumstances could destabilize an acute medical condition," the authors write.

However, they acknowledge that the study is limited and other factors may be involved in the higher rates of death and readmission they observed.

"More detailed information on patient severity of illness would strengthen the argument for causation between discharge during the holiday period and health outcomes," they write.

First published on December 12, 2018

© 2018 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Ashley Welch

Ashley Welch covers health and wellness for


Pet care costs can top human medical bills

Pet health care bills can climb into the tens of thousands of dollars as new technologies and treatments drive up costs

Dec 1, 2016

7 bad habits that could be wrecking your diet

If you're having a hard time shedding pounds, try adjusting these common eating habits

Aug 21, 2015

New drug overtakes heroin as No. 1 opioid killer

New report says overdose deaths involving fentanyl have more than doubled each year since 2013

12H ago

Breast cancer linked to childbirth

New research suggests women who bear children are more susceptible to breast cancer than women who do not. Dr. Lauren Cassell, chief of breast surgery at Lenox Hospital in New York City, joins CBSN to discuss the new study.

2H ago 03:19

Viral tweets warn women their heart attacks can be different

"I almost died because I didn't call it chest pain," one woman tweeted after surviving a heart attack

7H ago

Kaiser cancels surgeries during mental health therapists' strike

Thousands of Kaiser Permanente mental health professionals started a weeklong strike Monday over staffing levels and pay

10H ago

Holidays may be hazardous time to leave hospital

Reduced staffing and lack of follow-up care may play a role in higher death rates, researchers say

10H ago

How Yemen's war is killing children — no weapons necessary

Yussuf Adel, 3, escaped some of the fiercest fighting in Yemen's civil war, but he's not out of danger

11H ago

Kimberly-Clark recalls Kotex tampons that can unravel inside body

Defective product produced over a two-year period and distributed broadly across the U.S. and Canada, company says

13H ago

Substance-free dorms at Univ. of Vermont

In our series What's Working, we look at innovations that are paying off in America, from education to infrastructure. About one-quarter of today's college students admit they suffer consequences from drinking too much. Nearly 700,000 people say they've been assaulted by another student who had too much alcohol. A major university is turning to neuroscience to encourage kids to tap into their books instead of kegs. Jim Axelrod reports.

15H ago 05:38

Tesla CEO Elon Musk: The "60 Minutes" interview

Musk opens up to Lesley Stahl about Twitter, pot, the Securities and Exchange Commission, Model 3 and Tesla

Dec 9

Study examines effects of screen time on kids

"60 Minutes" goes inside a landmark government study of young minds to see if phones, tablets and other screens are impacting adolescent brain development

Dec 9

Ryan Speedo Green: From juvenile delinquency to opera stardom

After a childhood of anger and violence, the 32-year-old now commands the stage around the world

Dec 9

Remembering President George H.W. Bush

Former presidents and others look back on the life of President George H.W. Bush, who passed away Friday

Dec 2

Paradise Lost: Inside California's Camp Fire

"60 Minutes" reveals what firefighters saw as the deadliest wildfire in California history destroyed the town of Paradise

Dec 2

The chaos behind family separation at the border

A "60 Minutes" investigation has found the separations that dominated headlines this summer began earlier and were greater in number than the Trump administration admits

Nov 26

Robots to the rescue after nuclear disaster

Seven years after a powerful earthquake and tsunami caused a massive nuclear meltdown in the Daiichi Power Plant, Lesley Stahl reports on the unprecedented cleanup effort

Nov 25

"To Kill a Mockingbird" comes to Broadway

With Aaron Sorkin writing the adaptation and Jeff Daniels starring as Atticus Finch, the Harper Lee classic hits the stage

Nov 25

Naloxone: The life-saving drug more Americans need

With over 115 Americans dying a day in the opioid epidemic, naloxone has become a necessity for first responders, doctors and everyday people

Nov 18

Right Rail – Video Promo – Listing

Michael Cohen sentenced to 3 years in prison

President Trump's former attorney Michael Cohen once said he would take a bullet for the president. Instead, he turned on him and pleaded guilty to nine counts in federal court. On Wednesday, he was sentenced to three years in prison. CBS News Washington correspondent Paula Reid has the latest.

5H ago 03:14

Tesla's Elon Musk: What's changed in a decade

"60 Minutes" first met the visionary CEO in 2008 for a report on the race to make the electric car. Producer Shachar Bar-On explains.

Dec 9 04:15

Manhunt for France terror suspect

An intense manhunt continues in France and Germany for the terror suspect who opened fire near a Christmas markey in Strasbourg. At least two people were killed. CBS News correspondent Roxana Saberi reports.

5H ago 01:34

Michigan protests over alleged power grab

There were loud protests in Michigan on Wednesday over what many say is a last-minute power grab by Republicans. They're accused off trying to limit the authority of newly elected Democrats. CBS News correspondent Dean Reynolds reports.

5H ago 02:07

Retirement out of reach for millions

Tom Coomer, 80, is just one of nearly 10 million Americans over 65 still working. He was working as a machinist when his plant closed down, just one year shy of getting his full pension. CBS News correspondent Mark Strassmann has his story.

5H ago 03:32

Michael Cohen sentenced to 3 years in prison

The president's former longtime attorney has been sentenced for campaign finance violations and lying to Congress

9H ago

National Enquirer owner admits to paying off Playboy model to protect Trump

The announcement came hours after former Trump attorney Michael Cohen was sentenced to three years in prison

8H ago

Earthquake strikes eastern Tennessee, felt in Atlanta

Light earthquake in Tennessee occurred in early morning hours, could be felt in Atlanta

13H ago

2018 additions to the Library of Congress' National Film Registry

"The Shining," "Jurassic Park," "My Fair Lady" and "Brokeback Mountain" are among the classic films to be preserved for future generations by the Library of Congress

27 photos

In first public comments in 3 months, Blasey Ford lauds abuse survivor

"Rachael Denhollander, I am in awe of you, and I will always be inspired by you," she said

12H ago

2018 additions to the Library of Congress' National Film Registry

"The Shining," "Jurassic Park," "My Fair Lady" and "Brokeback Mountain" are among the classic films to be preserved for future generations by the Library of Congress

27 photos

The timeless photojournalism of Chris Hondros and Tim Hetherington

"War and Peace in Liberia" is a new exhibition in New York City celebrating the work of two acclaimed war photographers, who were both killed in conflict zones

15 photos

Yemen's humanitarian crisis

The nation's civil war has claimed at least 10,000 lives, and generated the world's worst humanitarian crisis

15 photos

Notable deaths in 2018

A look back at the esteemed personalities who've left us this year, who touched us with their innovation, creativity and humanity

133 photos

Biggest stories of 2018, ranked

This year was a doozy. These were the top stories on

55 photos

Latest From CBS News

Mark Meadows out of running for chief of staff

U.S. Rep. Mark Meadows of North Carolina is out of the running to be President Trump's next chief of staff. Niall Stanage, White House columnist for The Hill, joins CBSN to discuss the latest developments and the rest of the day's political headlines.

55M ago 09:02

Changing the strategy for 2020 primary elections

When it come to presidential primary elections, all eyes are usually on Iowa and New Hampshire, but in 2020, California and Texas could attract almost as much attention. Gromer Jeffers, a political writer for the Dallas Morning News, and Dave Bryan, a political reporter for KCBS and KCAL, join CBSN's "Red and Blue" to discuss.

55M ago 05:49

Uncle accused of 3-year-old's murder

A Kentucky father heard his 3-year-old daughter scream on baby monitor as her uncle slit her throat, the sheriff said. Relatives say the man has mental health problems.

1H ago 01:02

12/12/18: Red and Blue

Former Trump lawyer heading to prison; changing the strategy for 2020

2H ago 50:26

Breast cancer linked to childbirth

New research suggests women who bear children are more susceptible to breast cancer than women who do not. Dr. Lauren Cassell, chief of breast surgery at Lenox Hospital in New York City, joins CBSN to discuss the new study.

2H ago 03:19

IRS budget cuts benefit rich, report finds

The IRS is deteriorating after eight years of budget cuts, according to a ProPublica investigation, which found the agency's decline benefits the wealthy while hurting the poor. Paul Kiel co-authored the report, "How the IRS Was Gutted." He joins CBSN to discuss his reporting.

4H ago 06:28